|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|Commander 2013 (C13)||Common|
|Shards of Alara (ALA)||Common|
Combos Browse all
: Add to your mana pool.
, , Sacrifice Naya Panorama: Search your library for a basic Mountain, Forest, or Plains card and put it into play tapped. Then shuffle your library.
Price & Acquistion Set Price Alerts
|Have (3)||releasethedogs , CAPTAINxCOOKIES , Unjust_DiabIo|
|Want (13)||mango_channel , Georgez96 , Maliande , absciss , 2gherkins , afeuling , Artius , Njc12345 , Raw_fishFood , awfulNeutral , CaptianClueless , 1337_Nerd , Unjust_DiabIo|
Naya Panorama Discussion
2 weeks ago
I think your deck relies too heavily on Omnath’s Landfall ability to make elementals, so I would recommend taking out some of the ramp spells and artifacts and putting in a few more elemental creatures and elemental generators. I would suggest:
Additionally, these would increase the or enable the damage dealt by Omnath’s abilities:
You have a lot of ramp spells, but there are defiantly some better ones you might want put in instead of the some of the ones you have are:
Bounce lands and sac lands would work really well here as well:
I would also recommend:
1 month ago
You cannot include lands such as Jungle Shrine and Seaside Citadel because they include mana symbols outside your commander's. I would consider replacing them with Bant Panorama and Naya Panorama. Also you have quite a few lands that come in tapped, which can slow you down, I'd consider finding utility lands which come in untapped or add more basics.
Also Karametra's competitive edge is casting creatures to trigger her. 21 is not low but you may not be taking advantage of her as much as you could be. I'd consider more enchantment creatures to have your cake and eat it too.
1 month ago
Hey, I saw you comment on my deck (Tetsuko & Doran's Assault Formation!), and I'd love to see if I can give you any tips for this deck.
As you already said in your description for this deck, Arcades, the Strategist might be a very good card for this deck, especially if you like control decks. White-Green-Blue is a very nice color combination for a control deck, and the defender creatures you are running just add onto that. Furthermore, this deck as it is now can only make your creatures with defender attack if you happen to draw Assault Formation, which means there are gonna be some games were you won't be able to get it. However, you can play around this with your big creatures.
Arcades, the Strategist also lets you draw more cards, which together with Lead the Stampede and your creatures that make mana allow you to build up a very strong board, However, you do already have Soul of the Harvest, which kinda does the same, but just costs 2 more. For that reason, even if you don't play Arcades, the Strategist, I really like your Lead the Stampedes, If you want to stay mono green you could even play something like Commune with Nature to fetch another creature.
If you're wondering what kind of creatures with defender you get access to when also going into blue and white, here are some nice options: Ludevic's Test Subject Flip can work with your mana ramping, Wall of Frost, Wall of Denial, Stalwart Shield-Bearers, Wall of Omens I really love this card together with your Carven Caryatid and Soul of the Harvest (and Arcades, the Strategist if you want to run it) since it just make you fly through your deck, Dragon's Eye Sentry, Perimeter Captain, and you get access to Rolling Stone, however between Assualt Formation and Arcades, the Strategist, you wont need it. Also you get access to some metagame staples like Path to Exile.
Perhaps a Tower Defense or Shape the Sands (or Aegis of the Heavens (its a new m19 card so tappedout wont let me link it) when playing white) could also make this deck more explosive if you want to go that route, but since you are not reliant on making your creatures with defender attack, Carnage Tyrant is a nice beater, when going into white you also get access to angels which are great late game creatures, you might even think about running card with in their mana costs, like Entreat the Angels, Quarantine Field, Secure the Wastes, Animist's Awakening, Chord of Calling, Enshrined Memories, Genesis Wave, Nissa, Steward of Elements.
Finally, I don't really like Trolls of Tel-Jilad, Terastodon, and Naya Panorama since they don't really do much. I would also up your land count to at least 20, even with all the mana acceleration. Maybe even 22-24. As for your current maybeboard, I like the Axebane Guardian, and all the other card are also good beaters except for Silklash Spider, Prey Upon your defender creatures have no power, even with Assault Formation, not 100% sure on this interaction though, and Elixir of Immortality, If you want lifegain, perhaps a Jaddi Offshoot is better?
I hope this helps you a little! I like the deck and its versatility a lot!
3 months ago
Hello! You asked me to take a look and comment about your deck. I think you already have a good understanding of what you can do with slivers when you can tutor them at will. You can pull of pretty much any combo out of nowhere with Quick Sliver and enough mana.
The first thing I want to point out is if you're sure you're reaching your lands running this little ramp spells or mana rocks (I'm always happy when I draw Boundless Realms ).
The second thing is that I noticed you're also being economic on lands like me. In my environment experience and personal taste I dislike lands that come into play tapped, specially the Vivid lands and the three-colored tapped lands. I utterly hate them. I don't know if you'll agree but I prefer using the Panorama lands cycle (like Naya Panorama ) because, if you draw them when you need mana, you can instantly use them for (1). If you can wait you sac and search for a basic among three types.
Opposite of popular belief, I see no necessity at all to run fetch lands or pain lands like Hallowed Fountain, they just make the deck expensive. Obviously untapped five-color lands are a better investment (like Exotic Orchard, Forbidden Orchard and Reflecting Pool.
Well, that's just my opinion. May slivers dominate in every game you play!
4 months ago
As far as your mana base is concerned, add Plateau, Flooded Strand, Bloodstained Mire, Wooded Foothills, Windswept Heath, Scalding Tarn and Marsh Flats.
Take out Evolving Wilds, Terramorphic Expanse, Naya Panorama and basics.
That would solve your tapped lands problem. If you still want faster mana, Mox Diamond, Chrome Mox and Ancient Tomb could speed you up.
4 months ago
Some improvements for the decks after messing with it. Noticed that the biggest counter to the deck is control. Currently takes quite a lot to get the deck going, and having stuff blow up sucks. Definitely turn 4 (or earlier if you can ramp) get Tana out, and next turn play Sidar and start swinging with Tana to start getting saprolings out ASAP.Early game needs to focus on ramping and getting both commanders out and pumping out Saprolings ASAP. I noticed that hydras were a bit of dead draws. I never really wanted to play them over buffing on Tana.
Card Draw:Skullclamp Can use a few saprolings for good card drawHunter's Insight Play this on Tana. Worst case 2 cards, best case a lot more (if she's buffed)Keen Sense While only one card, 1 mana for guaranteed card draw per turn is nice.Regal Force Luckily Saprolings are green, so this can be a juicy card drawer.Fecundity With skullclamp = lots of cards. Otherwise a board wipe isn't an issue eitherSlate of Ancestry Gets rid of that bad hand for more cards, especially if hand is getting empty.
Buff Cards (replacing some blood rush could be helpful):
Chorus of Might
Intangible Virtue Can be beneficial if you only apply 1 buff to saprolings (so they cant be blocked)Might of the Masses Give Tana a huge buff for 1 mana
Triumph of the Hordes Can easily win with infect, or kill people with it
Brave the Sands Have an army of blockers and attackers constantlyGratuitous Violence Double damage without double strike
More Saprolings:Second Harvest
Parallel LivesPrimal Vigor
Verdant Force This one is amazing
Selesnya Evangel Helps get the early saprolings out.
Growing Ranks Again 1 saproling per turnSecure the Wastes While not saprolings, you can just make some soldiers instantly
More removal:Aura Shards This will shit on Zur so hard.
More ramp (Accelerates game, mana fixes, and reduces chance of annoying land draw):Harvest Season Swing in with saprolings and Tana and double landObelisk of Naya Fixes mana a bit since it is 3 colorsExplore
Nature's Lore Pair this with one of those dual color cards that have Forest type for good mana fixing
Land:Getting some more dual colored lands can be helpful. Especially those scry lands.Also potentially Naya Panorama if you think mana fixing could be useful (green has good ramp to do the fixing you would want anyway).
Infinite Combats and win:Breath of Fury
5 months ago
Looks pretty tasty, and it's a great start!
I would take out Quest for the Holy Relic, Open the Armory, and Strength of Arm due to not really having that much equipment. I would add 3 more Plains (I would also try to balance your mana better, try less Mountains and more Plains). If that mana fixing becomes an issue, add in Evolving Wilds, Myriad Landscape, Warped Landscape, Terminal Moraine, Arid Mesa, Naya Panorama, or Terramorphic Expanse. I would recommend adding at least 3-5 fetch lands to help mana fixing.
If you take out Armory of Iroas, Murder Investigation, and Coat of Arms, you could free up the last two spots for the 38 lands.
I did notice that a lot of your soldiers have a synergy with equipment cards, yet you only run 2 equipment cards. I was a bit confused by this. I would recommend taking them all out and replacing them. I would also recommend trying to run 2 more soldiers (you are at that tribal sweet spot with all the soldier creatures, but Boros is known for being aggressive with instant/sorcery AND creatures). 30 creatures is great aggro. Here are some creatures I would recommend: Brimaz, King of Oreskos, Blaze Commando, Sunhome Guildmage, Preeminent Captain, Field Marshal, Daru Warchief, Ballyrush Banneret, Veteran Swordsmith, Rhox Pikemaster, or Catapult Squad. The cards I'd recommend to take out are Auriok Steelshaper, Auriok Survivors, Auriok Windwalker, Conclave Phalanx, Kalemne, Disciple of Iroas, Relic Seeker, Fated Conflagration, Arrows of Justice.
You already have a lot of key cards. I do see that your mana is very unbalanced. I would add more Plains. If you just take out one Mountain at a time and switch it for a Plains until your Pie Chart for your mana is "perfectly" aligned. It won't always be there, but the closer the better. With this being a tribal deck, it would help to have cards like Cavern of Souls, but that's a make-or-break card for you wallet. I actually don't even have one (it's one of the last 9 cards I WANT for my Gishath deck). Soldiers won't really get a lot of heat at any of my play groups, so getting countered shouldn't be that big of an issue.
Here is what I would take out and add:
- Quest for the Holy Relic - Open the Armory - Strength of Arm - Armory of Iroas - Coat of Arms - Murder Investigation - Auriok Steelshaper - Auriok Survivors - Auriok Windwalker - Conclave Phalanx - Kalemne, Disciple of Iroas - Relic Seeker - Fated Conflagration - Arrows of Justice + Evolving Wilds + Terramorphic Expanse + Naya Panorama + 3x Plains + Sunhome Guildmage + Brimaz, King of Oreskos + Daru Warchief + Rhox Pikemaster + Ballyrush Banneret + Field Marshal + Veteran Swordsmith + Preeminent Captain Rebalance Mountains and Plains to match the Pie Chart
Sorry for the ranty post. I get a bit into it.
6 months ago
Id take out Parallel Lives and Anointed Procession you arnt running enough token effects to make them worth while. You could even just replace both these cards with other things that make more tokens and get more value. Id also take out Tamiyo's Journal, its a heavy mana cost to pay for something that is very slow. I like the rest of this deck but it may due to have one or two more card draw effects. Looking at your lands, there is an obvious suggestion I have to make - Terramorphic Expanse, Evolving Wilds, Naya Panorama (these are cheep cards and will all work well with Omnath, Locus of Rage). There are a bunch more double color lands, mana rocks and mana creatures I could recomend but... Ill just send you to this website instead http://manabasecrafter.com/r/peVp8 - there you will find everything you need for mana.