|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|Ravnica Allegiance (RNA)||Uncommon|
Combos Browse all
Creature — Vedalken Rogue Mutant
: Adapt 2. (If this creature has no +1/+1 counters on it, put two +1/+1 counters on it.)
Each creature you control with a +1/+1 counter on it has flying.
Skatewing Spy Discussion
2 months ago
I don't really see the point of the +1/+1 subtheme here. I think more flicker effects could be better instead. Think cards like Conjurer's Closet , Deadeye Navigator , Displace , Essence Flux , Ghostly Flicker , Illusionist's Stratagem , Teferi's Time Twist , Voidwalk . Heck, even Identity Thief kinda fits this bill. Otherwise, just add more ETB effects. I notice there's no Coiling Oracle in here and I'm pretty shocked. Maybe some more removal would be prudent. Putrefy at the very least, more (3-5 instant speed removal spells) is probably better.
So cards I think are worth cutting are most things that have to do w/ +1/+1 counters. Winding Constrictor Skatewing Spy , Ivy Lane Denizen , Bred for the Hunt , Hardened Scales , potentially Evolution Sage . There's a few other counters cards that could be considered for cuts but have enough synergy with the rest of the deck to be fine. I'd also think about cutting down on the token subtheme as well. I don't see Verdant Force being that helpful. There's not enough cards that trigger on "whenever a creature ETB" in here for tokens to be really worth it, I think. Speaking of cards that trigger "when creature ETB" I don't really like Death Match or Season of Growth (or for that matter Hedonist's Trove ) in here. These cards don't really do enough for you or let your opponents do something bad to you, potentially. Once again, I'd look to put in more ETB effects or I'd look to add in a few instants and sorceries that do things you want to do in any deck (removal, board wipe, card draw, ramp, tutors, etc.)
Overall, this deck looks really fun. I hope to play against it someday.
3 months ago
I just get the feeling that you are trying to do too much and will lose out on consistency. Frilled Mystic has a great effect, but is expensive and difficult to play, while Siren Stormtamer might do just as well. Skatewing Spy can give all your powerful creatures flying, but also becomes playable only later in the game, when you could already be in a losing position. I don't like Hydroid Krasis unless you have 6, 8 or 10 spare mana, which is not going to happen too early in the game. I would tend to drop some of these fancy 'game-enders' in favour of a few 'game-starters'.
Simic Ascendency provides a viable win-con, but you want to start getting +1/+1 counters out from turn 1 or 2. This is about the only deck where Pelt Collector is a strong card. An extra turn 1 landfall from Arboreal Grazer , Adventurous Impulse etc. can really kick-start your game. See what you think of WAR PAW
7 months ago
Thanks for another comment. I do like your idea of adding in some "+1/+1 counter lords" and I already have some in the form of Skatewing Spy , Zegana, Utopian Speaker and Herald of Secret Streams . I have considered the ones that you talked about before. I'll playtest once I get a chance, but for now, they'll be in the maybeboard.
7 months ago
Thanks for your suggestions and upvote. I think I agree with you on adding some more mana ramp. My deck is pretty slow, and getting that creature out one turn earlier may help with that. I am going to add a Talisman that you suggested and an Incubation Druid and take out the Hideaway lands. I found that I couldn't activate them as much as I wanted and that they slowed down my game occasionally.
Thanks for your suggestions. I'm not a big fan of Mycoloth as it might be a bit too slow and my deck doesn't have many things it can sacrifice. I'm not a big fan of the Hydras again because they're a bit too slow. I am a fan of Incubation Druid , that that will take up a ramp slot that was provided with the cutting of two lands. The Mending of Dominaria seemed good at first, but I just didn't have anything to do with it, so I think I'll cut it for Skatewing Spy . While I can't disagree that Rhystic Study is a bad card, I think that Bred for the Hunt is better for a +1/+1 counter deck. I'll playtest it and see how it goes and keep you updated.
7 months ago
Primordial Hydra , Kalonian Hydra , Avatar of the Resolute and Mycoloth , Incubation Druid , and Skatewing Spy all seem like good cards for this deck. Rhystic Study is also a good card draw enchantment.
8 months ago
Consider adding Skatewing Spy to deal with flyers
8 months ago
This looks great! I like the addition of white for Shalai, Voice of Plenty and Unbreakable Formation , though I wonder what Lyra Dawnbringer has to offer. She seems a bit out of place to me. If you'd like some more flyers, maybe Skatewing Spy would be a nice addition to the deck. I'm really digging this rotation of standard, and this is a great deck! If you wouldn't mind, I'd appreciate it if yoy'd check out my standard deck, Boros Strike, and maybe comment a suggestion or two! Thanks :)
8 months ago
Thanks for all the sideboard suggestions. For now, the deck will only exist on Arena, and I'd like to use it in the new BO3 format.
I definitely need some protection against flying in the sideboard. Definitely Arbor Armament and Skatewing Spy . I wonder if it's worth mainboarding the red aggro hate cards, since it's so dominant in the arena meta that I'd likely lose half of my game 1s in BO3 without them.
Also thinking it's probably worth sideboarding-- or even mainboarding-- counterspells and/or enchantment removal. Ravnica Allegiance is stocked with great enchantments, and so that could help me disrupt the slower decks in the meta, especially the Wilderness Reclamation gate stuff, which I see a lot of. And for the same reasons a lot of people are mainboarding enchantment removal (I see a lot of Mortify ), so Negate could be a big help.
All that said, I haven't been able to do any testing, since I'm still building up the wildcards to actually put the deck together.
Skatewing Spy occurrence in decks from the last year
Commander / EDH:
All decks: 0.0%