legendofa on Meek’s Inheritance

1 hour ago

The thing here is that as soon as a creature gains landwalk, it has an ability, so it can't get anything from Ruxa, Patient Professor, or Jasmine Boreal of the Seven, or Muraganda Petroglyphs, which are the biggest reasons to use vanilla creatures. If you want these bonuses to be usable together, they can't actually be granted abilities.

May I suggest rewarding casting vanilla creature spells, or giving them some benefit? Something like "Whenever a nontoken creature with no abilities enters, draw a card." or "Creature spells with no abilities cost less." or something.

Danutercisd updated Ertai the Corrupted

1 hour ago

Replaced Pemmins aura for Near Death Experience

legendofa on ideas about formats

1 hour ago

My biggest concern here is what to do with promos and Secret Lair cards, which have given a lot of cards rare printings without changing their actual quality or function. Are Evolving Wilds and Terramorphic Expanse qualified to be rares? Is Ornithopter mythic? If cards are restricted in Podium or banned in Format 2 based on their highest or most recent rarity, these products create a huge amount of variance as Secret Lairs or promo pieces are given thematic rarities high above their actual value. Because of this pretty much by itself, I think the least rare print of a card should be the defining factor. Using the Expeditions and Inventions as a baseline, most of those would already be restricted to two copies each. Cards like Strip Mine or Mana Crypt can be further restricted or banned on a case-by-case basis.

Is there a gameplay reason for 80-card decks?

KibaAlpha on Toxic Feminism

1 hour ago

Profet93

Yawgmoth hasn’t been performing since making the switch to turn the deck in to a spell slinger style. I knew I was going to have to swap him out. Took me a while to do so. He was solid flavor for the deck as it had once been.

I’m sure Evolution Sage will be a far better performer in this type of deck.

philias on Card creation challenge

3 hours ago

Do I just reskin Breaker of Armies, or do I have to build a whole new creature?

Pearl-Skin Beast

Creature: Beast Horror

All creatures able to block ~ must do so

10/8

Make a commander that doesn’t fit a particular niche

DarkKiridon on What Card Should Replace Otherworld …

3 hours ago

I also recommend Vraska, Betrayal's Sting.

My other picks are:

Oko, Thief of Crowns

Ajani, Sleeper Agent

Teferi, Hero of Dominaria

Lae'zel, Vlaakith's Champion is good.

I'm a personal fan of Managorger Hydra.

CaveBoy on JUST DIE ALREADY

3 hours ago

Have you considered these two cards: Molten Vortex or Forgotten Cave?

Molten vortex is a good outlet for late game land draws, and it can help kill mana dorks without using the spells that do more damage. Increases the odds that you can use Skewer and Light up the Stage a little also.

Forgotten Cave is good when you draw it and don’t need the land. If you are running 20 lands in a burn deck, I recommend some of these because it’s likely you will draw lands when you don’t need them.

FormOverFunction on Why Do Soul Warden-Type Effects …

5 hours ago

Crow_Umbra is spot-on for what I was thinking. There’s still a lot of interaction in magic, but narrowing the scope of cards (only your creatures, only at sorcery speed, only once per turn, etc) makes it harder to accidentally make an infinite loop or whatever because you don’t have to expand your concerns exponentially out to include whatever the other players are doing.

DemonDragonJ on Battle Hymn of the Seraphim

6 hours ago

I have replaced Crystal Ball with Loran of the Third Path, because directly drawing a card is usually better than scrying, she requires no additional investment of mana after her initial cost, she can destroy a permanent, and she provides an additional creature for this deck, which focuses heavily on combat.

Danutercisd updated Ertai the Corrupted

6 hours ago

Update 3

The_Undead_King on Bloomburrow set still missing quite …

6 hours ago

As of today, the Bloomburrow precon cards, save for the face cards, are still not showing up in the search feature. Do we know any particular reason for this? It's abnormal for edhrec to have cards up and running before Tappedout has them even added

haki2022 on Kroxa cedh - Fast Supper

8 hours ago

• how u want to discard your Worldgorger with "Necropotence" on battlefield ? o.0 Your deck is kind a weird, i guess u dont have too much experience playing with "Discard Kroxa" cEDH ?

• how your "Sire Of Insanity" works with necropotence ? o.0 u should replace them by enchanment "Oppresion"

• i rly dont see any kind of speed here... Night's Whisper is too weak and slow... yes u draw 2 cards but u lost 2 mana on sorcery speed it's great card but too slow and expensive in cEDH.

• Thrill of Posibility replace by "Cathartic Pyre" - if u need to remove opponents Dauthi / Dranith u deal 3 damage, i u need discard Worldgorger u chose second option.

Best speed for Kroxa is:

turn 1) land, cast entomb (put Vilis on grave), mox diamond or lotus petal cast reanimate, put Vilis on battlefield, lose 8 life, draw 8 cards , cast enother 0 mana ramp for example chrome mox, cast burnt offering, sac Villis add 8 mana in any combination red/black cast your combo from hands, tutor , stax, draw engine etc <-- this could happen in turn 1 or u can cast "Yawgmoth's Will" and again reanimate Villis, draw additional 8 card, cast additional stax / tutor and win on next turn with counterspell on hand etc.

this is scenario when u draw in first turn 17 cards... this is how it should work on cEDH

• u should consider to add in your deck new cards in cEDH meta like: "Tinybones Joins Up", "Chthonian Nightmare" (which combo with Dockside to generate infinite mana) or "Tinybones, the Pickpocket" wich can steal "Mystic Remora"

Necramus on Alela, Artful Provocateur

8 hours ago

Roaming Throne has been an absolute haymaker for me for this deck!

Always happy to find a fae friend.