pie chart

Mr. Arcades, tear down this wall!

Commander / EDH Defender GWU (Bant) Wall

youareatrex


Maybeboard


Ever since the oldschool Living Wall, Wall of Water, Wall of Ice, etc. days I'd wanted to build a wall deck.

Arcades, the Strategist existence finally pushed me to do it.

This has been through a bunch of tweaks, and is never going to be the most powerful deck, but ultimately I've found it works best when:

  1. You can double up on Arcades' "Whenever a creature with defender enters the battlefield under your control, draw a card." trigger. Hence the inclusion of Guardian Project, Beast Whisperer, Panharmonicon, and the newly added Teferi's Ageless Insight. If one of those is down, plus Arcades, dropping an innocent Wall of Omens can draw you 3 cards, keep your hand filled with gas, and flood the board with an army of defenders.

  2. You use lower-costed walls to cantrip through your deck: Shield Sphere, Perimeter Captain, etc. - just keep playing and drawing.

I usually try to play as many walls as I can in a turn with Arcades down, drawing as many cards as possible, leaving up a bit of mana for protection if I've got it. And you are indeed going to need to protect him - the path of least resistance is just to kill Arcades so the walls aren't a threat anymore. Lightning Greaves + Swiftfoot Boots, Heroic Intervention, Resolute Watchdog, Jeskai Barricade, Eerie Interlude, Swan Song + Arcane Denial, etc.

To deal with your opponents creatures, you can lock them down Meekstone or one-sided board wipes: Wave of Reckoning, Slaughter the Strong, Fell the Mighty

We have a handful of fun win conditions here. We can pump our walls with Tower Defense or the unexpected Triumph of the Hordes. Or make them unblockable in a variety of ways with Tetsuko Umezawa, Fugitive or Archetype of Imagination. Also > just added Akroma's Will which serves as a win condition on my turn or speed protection if needed on someone else's.

Have fun, let me know any suggestions.

Record: 13-19, 41%


October 2021 Deck Changes

First changes in a while - this deck is really optimized

In Overgrown Farmland - 35 lands is making me nervous. want to pump it up to 36 for consistency despite the low avg cmc of the deck Deserted Beach - pulling for an island. i really think these new dual lands are spectacular. turn 1 - tapped lands are often the move anyway. by turn 3 - its an OG dual land. so really you only don't want to play it one turn of the entire game

Out Wall of Vines - This and Fortified Rampart are JUST on the vanilla wall bubble.


November 2021 Deck Changes

In

Dreamroot Cascade - see above, these new duals are amazing - cut a forest for it Nimbus Maze - I think this makes the cut? I need a certain amount of Plains and Islands to make it worthwhile. Cut a plains for it. Nature's Claim - 1) realizing the efficiency of this card is top notch 2) a bit light on targeted removal in the deck Nature's Lore - one of the last upgrades i can make to this deck - swapping out rocks for the good green ramp spells Three Visits - see above Breeding Pool - wanted another forest X dual land with the two new ramp additions. believe this is one of the only forest <> island combos, so figure it is worth the cash. cutting a forest for it. Larder Zombie - i think this ability may be surprisingly relevant if i flood the board with walls - i can scry 1 or two before my turn. and more importantly - 1 cmc wall Secret Door - i'll take all the 1 cmc 0/4 walls i can get. i'll never use the dungeon ability Portcullis Vine - loading up on these 1 cmc walls Spark Double - the deck works much better when my walls net me cards vs. just replace themselves. adding another one of these effects. drawback - arcades needs to be on the field when i cast it. positive - i can copy a different creature of mine in a pinch if the ability is relevant. if this works out - sakashima of a thousand faces functions the same way. i almost added chulane too - but decided to retaion my integrity Bala Ged Recovery   - realizing i have no recursion in the deck - cheap way to get it in

Out Wall of Denial - cutting all 3 cmc walls - i want the efficiency of the 1-2 mana ones Azorius Signet - rocks can get blown up - lands rarely do Fellwar Stone - rocks can get blown up - lands rarely do Wall of Tanglecord - cuttable 2 cmc vanilla wall Wall of Mulch - cuttable 2 cmc vanilla wall Carven Caryatid - cutting all 3 cmc walls - i want the efficiency of the 1-2 mana ones Axebane Guardian - cutting all 3 cmc walls - i want the efficiency of the 1-2 mana ones


December 2021 Deck Changes

In Into the North - decided to get this into all my green decks. Added two snow basics of each bant color.

Out Arcane Signet - taking advantage of all the green 2 cmc land ramp


January 2022 Deck Changes

In

Rejuvenating Springs - these lands are great and affordable at the moment. cut a forest Sejiri Shelter   - another way to squeeze protection in here Ghostway - whoa. i didn't realize this card existed. it is even better than eerie interlude as it doesn't target. instantly one of the best cards in the deck. if i hold up the mana for protection and dont need it - it becomes a super draw spell.

Out Nimbus Maze - card makes me nervous Negate - i have 24 walls in the deck, dont really want to go below that, so ill cut negate. plus just added sejiri shelter so still 'up' on protection


February 2022 Deck Changes

In Wall of Hope - think this is a pretty intimidating blocker actually Dovin's Veto - missing a counterspell after i cut negate for ghostway. easier to cast this than in breya where id been considering it for a while Glasspool Mimic   - MDFCs are great in this deck as i can get flooded. this is a tapped land or a wall clone when i need it. pull an island Otawara, Soaring City - see above, lands with more value are great in arcades. pull an island High Alert - probably should have been playing this all along - arcades redundancy

Out

Fell the Mighty - 5 cmc plus i could get two for oned Meekstone - doesnt do enough Wall of Shards - between this and wall of junk to cut


May 2022 Deck Changes

In An Offer You Can't Refuse - another copy of swan song. i always max out my mana in this deck so 1 cmc is key Errant, Street Artist - 1 cmc flash defender. yes please! i dont believe i have any synergy with the other ability. oh wow it has haste too. Spara's Headquarters - cut a forest for this! my first triome

Out Dovin's Veto - i'll take the 1 cmc, 1 color pip counterspell instead Wall of Junk - think this is my last vanilla 2 cmc wall?


July 2022 Deck Changes

In Kabira Takedown   - I have 30+ creatures and am light on removal. Pulled a plains


August 2022 Deck Changes

In Gatecreeper Vine - essentially an ETB draw wall

Out Wall of Hope - i like the card but not enough room


September 2022 Deck Changes

In Floriferous Vinewall - similar to gatekeeper vine, above Walking Bulwark - 1 cmc colorless with 3 toughness, nice to have these easily cast-able ones Cathedral Membrane - "" Tangled Florahedron   - mdfc ramp. pull a forest for it

Out Errant, Street Artist - - i like the card but not enough room. prefer the colorless 1 cmc options above Larder Zombie - "" Portcullis Vine - ""


October 2022 Deck Changes

In Sporocyst - 3 cmc, ramp 1, draw 1. OR - 1 cmc cantrip and this thing dies, if i'm in a pinch.

Out Arcane Denial - great card but the deck is really tight


November 2022 Deck Changes

Canopy Vista - sick of my lands coming in tapped, pulling these for snow basics Kabira Takedown   - "" Prairie Stream - "" Vineglimmer Snarl - ""


November 2022 Deck Changes Part II

In Another basic forest

Out Sporocyst - realize i never want to cast this for 3 cmc. and if i do, i just get a 1/1. not worth it.


January 2023 Deck Changes

In Bountiful Promenade - $5 dual land upgrade for a very optimized deck. swapped these two out for a forest and a snow covered island Waterlogged Grove - ""


September 2023 Deck Changes

In

Stroke of Midnight - pretty much on par with Generous Gift and Beast Within which are premium removal spells

Out

Walking Bulwark - not quite good enough


May 2024 Deck Changes

In Vault 75: Middle School - one sided board wipe with extra value

Out Cathedral Membrane - not quite good enough


July 2024 Deck Changes

In Cathedral Membrane - don't think i have quite enough wall density Wall of Vines - "" Two plains

Out Aura Shards - too much of a hate target Stroke of Midnight - think i have enough spot removal - most cuttable Two snow-covered plains - stealing these for heliod


July 2024 Deck Changes Part II

In Diamond City - protecting arcades is key Collective Resistance - same here - try this one out

Out Wall of Vines - right on the bubble Snow-covered Plains

Suggestions

Updates Add

Comments

97% Casual

Competitive

Date added 5 years
Last updated 4 days
Legality

This deck is Commander / EDH legal.

Rarity (main - side)

2 - 0 Mythic Rares

40 - 0 Rares

27 - 0 Uncommons

20 - 0 Commons

Cards 100
Avg. CMC 2.27
Tokens Beast 3/3 G, Bird 2/2 U, Dungeon: Dungeon of the Mad Mage, Dungeon: Lost Mine of Phandelver, Dungeon: Tomb of Annihilation, Elephant 3/3 G, Goblin 1/1 R, Skeleton 1/1 B, The Atropal, Treasure
Folders neato, asdasd, Possible comander decks, New deck imaginations, Commander, neat, Arcades CMDR, Commander Inspiration
Votes
Ignored suggestions
Shared with
Views