|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|2010 Core Set (M10)||Common|
Combos Browse all
Each player draws three cards, then discards three cards at random.
Price & Acquistion Set Price Alerts
|Have (5)||Joblaska , PreZchoICE1 , Sparky41 , bakeraj4 , zn.tportlock|
|Want (19)||Niroh , mini_tb , SkipYourDrawStep , marsp44 , oryandaw , smaps , Killuas , guacachole , DeifiedExile , Loading_Error , Myllyes314 , Stryfe_ , CatsPajammin , Coopenhagen , atav32 , dontjudgemyusername , kovellen , Ariumlegion , zn.tportlock|
Burning Inquiry Discussion
1 week ago
Not a bad idea. I like having a mix of 4 drops on the side that can come in for Bloodbraid Elf. Right now I only have 3, an Obstinate Baloth for Burning Inquiry decks and Liliana of the Veil mirrors, a Huntmaster of the Fells Flip for grindy matches, and Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet for additional graveyard hate. They all also gain life. Gonti, Lord of Luxury would fill a somewhat similar role, but would probably be better against Jeskai or Dimir style control. Hitting a Jace, the Mind Sculptor with him would be awesome.
3 weeks ago
You're right - the deck has one scenario of winning, and it's an extremely unlikely one.
Adding mana-boosters for a once-every-600-games turn-2 combo doesn't exactly solve that. They're dead weight whenever they're not in your first hand. I think you should move away from focusing on how quickly you can optimally pull off the combo with the perfect 7 cards, and instead put some thought into how to make it work consistently. Because cheesing people once every 600 games doesn't outweigh auto-losing 599 times.
What I'd suggest is either trimming off the parts that don't further your combo-plan in favor of better card-filtering & redundance for your combo (more copies of Faithless Looting, some Tormenting Voices, maybe some Heliod's Pilgrims to tutor your Guilty Conscience right from the deck, 1-2 Sun-Crowned Hunters as backup for the Spitter, Ajani's Presence as extra-copies of the Shields...), or actually making the goblins a viable plan-b (though, I'm not too sure how well it would work to implement an aggro game-plan into a setup-heavy combo deck).
Also, how is Burning Inquiry key to anything, exactly? It disacards 3 cards at random...
3 weeks ago
Dubitable_Salmon Thank you for your feedback and comment. First of all I say that it's really my first pauper-deck! I partly agree with you - the deck is risky, brazen, with one scenario for winning. To solve the problem, the lack of white mana for the second move predicted the replacement: 2xOrnithopter on 2x Lotus Petal However, the role of Burning Inquiry is the key to the combination found and I would like to reinforce it 2-4 Rite of Flame How do you rate my changes, despite the fact that goblins without combo will not play games?
3 weeks ago
That is a neat combo you got there, but no matter how ungodly your starting hand, it's not something this list can get online by turn 2 (turn it as you wish, you're one white mana short).
In general, I'm not sure if this shell really does a good job at supporting & enabling the combo. The goblins don't help you set up your combo, and aren't nearly big enough of a threat to be an alternative win-condition, and Burning Inquiry only risks discarding your engine-pieces before you're set up.
4 weeks ago
Appreciate the feedback Ocelot44
1 month ago
Moving away a bit from high cost ramp, mill, and limited effect draw/discard.
1 month ago
Wow I didn't even realize that Kamahl had haste! My bad!
1 month ago
For the format of the deck put casual, since it's not modern legal, but, I assume, you want to use as much modern cards as possible.
Then, I also assume that you don't want to spend a lot, so I'll try to propose low cost cards.
You have 16 things that do things when your opponent discards something, but only 10 cards that force your opponent to discard and 8 of them are easily destroyable creatures that also cost a bit too much mana for what you want them to do.
Personally I don't like Vile Consumption. It works also on your creatures and does nothing if your opponent doesn't play creatures or has only big things (if I have a 5/5 I'd pay one life cause it will make you lose 5). Do you want something that lets you destroy some creatures? Use Fatal Push, Murderous Cut, Doom Blade, Lightning Bolt or stuff like that
Last thing: 25 lands are too much. Just reduce them and add some shock lands (Watery Grave, Blood Crypt, Steam Vents), or check lands (Drowned Catacomb, Dragonskull Summit, Sulfur Falls). And, if they work well, you could also cut Thaumatic Compass Flip