Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

MerkelSerner on Bird Flu (5 Color) (75 …

48 minutes ago

Only 4 card types - no artifacts, enchantments, planeswalkers, etc.

KibaAlpha on Toxic Feminism

4 hours ago

Profet93

Yawgmoth hasn’t been performing since making the switch to turn the deck in to a spell slinger style. I knew I was going to have to swap him out. Took me a while to do so. He was solid flavor for the deck as it had once been.

I’m sure Evolution Sage will be a far better performer in this type of deck.

CaveBoy on JUST DIE ALREADY

6 hours ago

Have you considered these two cards: Molten Vortex or Forgotten Cave?

Molten vortex is a good outlet for late game land draws, and it can help kill mana dorks without using the spells that do more damage. Increases the odds that you can use Skewer and Light up the Stage a little also.

Forgotten Cave is good when you draw it and don’t need the land. If you are running 20 lands in a burn deck, I recommend some of these because it’s likely you will draw lands when you don’t need them.

DemonDragonJ on Battle Hymn of the Seraphim

8 hours ago

I have replaced Crystal Ball with Loran of the Third Path, because directly drawing a card is usually better than scrying, she requires no additional investment of mana after her initial cost, she can destroy a permanent, and she provides an additional creature for this deck, which focuses heavily on combat.

haki2022 on Kroxa cedh - Fast Supper

10 hours ago
  • how u want to discard your Worldgorger with "Necropotence" on battlefield ? o.0 Your deck is kind a weird, i guess u dont have too much experience playing with "Discard Kroxa" cEDH ?

  • how your "Sire Of Insanity" works with necropotence ? o.0 u should replace them by enchanment "Oppresion"

  • i rly dont see any kind of speed here... Night's Whisper is too weak and slow... yes u draw 2 cards but u lost 2 mana on sorcery speed it's great card but too slow and expensive in cEDH.

  • Thrill of Posibility replace by "Cathartic Pyre" - if u need to remove opponents Dauthi / Dranith u deal 3 damage, i u need discard Worldgorger u chose second option.

Best speed for Kroxa is:

turn 1) land, cast entomb (put Vilis on grave), mox diamond or lotus petal cast reanimate, put Vilis on battlefield, lose 8 life, draw 8 cards , cast enother 0 mana ramp for example chrome mox, cast burnt offering, sac Villis add 8 mana in any combination red/black cast your combo from hands, tutor , stax, draw engine etc <-- this could happen in turn 1 or u can cast "Yawgmoth's Will" and again reanimate Villis, draw additional 8 card, cast additional stax / tutor and win on next turn with counterspell on hand etc.

this is scenario when u draw in first turn 17 cards... this is how it should work on cEDH

  • u should consider to add in your deck new cards in cEDH meta like: "Tinybones Joins Up", "Chthonian Nightmare" (which combo with Dockside to generate infinite mana) or "Tinybones, the Pickpocket" wich can steal "Mystic Remora"

Necramus on Alela, Artful Provocateur

10 hours ago

Roaming Throne has been an absolute haymaker for me for this deck!

Always happy to find a fae friend.

Balaam__ on Knights

11 hours ago

If you already have a set or they fit within the budget, I like to run 4x Flagstones of Trokair in anything mono white. Better draws through deck thinning with no real downside.

Optimator on Fight Club

12 hours ago

Love it

ForEverLost1 on Jund Token/Devour

12 hours ago

An enchantment that would put the screws on your opponents with this deck, is All Will Be One. I highly recommend it. Great deck build

Necramus on Enchantress Lockdown

12 hours ago

Mirri's Guile - great card selection at the cheap rate we want to keep churning through the deck with the engine in the CZ.

Swift Reconfiguration - instant speed enchantment removal that also removes from combat.

All That Glitters - wins games.

Blind Obedience - plays to the game plan and offers an alternate win condition.

Kenrith's Transformation - Similar to making it a bug, we can turn our friends' commanders into something useless, and it gets us an extra draw.

Hallowed Haunting - a better win condition than Approach of the Second Sun for an enchantress deck, imo.

Privileged Position - pair with Greater Auramancy for some fun.

Sigil of the Empty Throne - also a better win con than Approach, imo.

Sythis was the very first deck I ever built in Selesnya and I absolutely love her! She's one of my favorite decks. Feel free to check mine out, if you'd like- Hand of Sythis

Hordebane on Jarad

23 hours ago

(Eyes Emoji)

Predator_90 on Quest for the Turn 4 …

1 day ago

i love the concept but i really can't stand having to play around Serum Powder...it would be nice to make the deck playable without it

DemonDragonJ on All Will Be One

1 day ago

I have replaced Metastatic Evangel with Zameck Guildmage, since I feel that this deck does not contain a sufficient amount of creatures to justify the former, and making that change provides both another mana sink and another source of card advantage, and also improves the balance between colors in this deck (or, at least between three of the four colors in this deck).

Mirilanda on Fast Bunnybunnybunny

1 day ago

I think it could definitely be a good card to replace a lot of the tempo cards!! If I was to put it in this deck I'd replace Reaver Cleaver or Arachnogenesis, probably Reaver Cleaver, I think that card if anything fits the decks theme better.

ReticleMouse on Jolrael’s Cloud Migration Strategy

1 day ago

AH! right, ok cool thanks for the clarification :)

irish_trunks on The Philosophy of Soc-RAT-es

1 day ago

Man, if I could I would looove to play this one. So good with rats!

DMoney31 on The Philosophy of Soc-RAT-es

1 day ago

Wait nevermind that is a green card so it doesn't work here. oops!

AwesomeDude7113 on Chair Tribal

1 day ago

A great addition would be War Roomfoil!!!

gibber-muzagi on List of EDH Tutor Cards

1 day ago

Just a heads up: didn't find Thaumatic Compass on here.

WilldelaRoche on Sharing is caring

1 day ago

This deck only have Delaying Shield, Illusions of Grandeur, Nine Lives and Statecraft that need to be donated to work, so I think that both Donate and Harmless Offering are too expensive to have in the deck for only those cases.

To donate those and other permanents I already have Coveted Falcon, Bazaar Trader + Starfield of Nyx (so the goblin can also donate enchantments), Puca's Mischieffoil and Shifting Grift.

Last_Laugh on The Sixth Doctor

1 day ago

Hey, just a heads up, but you have several cards that work with Romana but not The Sixth Doctor due to rules technicalities. Tokens that are the result of copying a permanent spell aren't "created" and won't trigger any of your token doublers like Adrix & Nev, Doubling Season, Ojer Taq, Mondrak, etc. It's rule 111.12 if you feel like checking (or check my deck's description, link below).

You're after effects that copy The Sixth Doctor's trigger (copy specifically, not 'trigger an additional time'), copy spells, or copy his tokens after the fact. Lithoform Engine, Esika's Chariot, Second Harvest, Errant, Street Artist, Strionic Resonator, Battle for Bretagard, and City of Death are all options that work here.

Feel free to check out my list for ideas. I personally run Peri Brown as my companion and have an emphasis on flash/untap enablers, but the decks function more or less the same. Upvotes on any of my decks are appreciated. Dopplegangbangers - Historic Flash Convoke Copies

Beebles on Jolrael’s Cloud Migration Strategy

1 day ago

Hey ReticleMouse,

Thanks for your message, however there is no such issue with the deck: cards are tagged for the functions they serve. Several cards serve multiple functions and therefore appear under multiple categories when looking at the deck using the “custom” filter. If that is confusing for you, consider switching the sorting to “Type”. You’ll then also see that the only card that is in there 3 times is Island.

WhyJWhy on Crabs for the Crablord

1 day ago

Justice 4 Crabbeh

TheRoaringRegisaur on 11, auf Deutsch

1 day ago

God I hate Elves. Anyway, Three Tree City would kill here

TheRoaringRegisaur on Ajani's Pride

1 day ago

Also, since it's a modern deck, I'd add some Soul Sisters (Soul Warden, Soul's Attendant). I also like Lunarch Veteran  Flip, but he's not as good. With all these Clerics/Angles, consider Righteous Valkyrie. Daxos, Blessed by the Sun is another worthy consideration. ... Instead of Revoke Existence, I really like Banishing Slash, even if you don't get the token from it. From the same set, Eiganjo, Seat of the Empire is a great land with good utility. Also, if you wanna drop Scoured Barrens/Blossoming Sands entirely, I'd look at Kabira Crossroads. And although it's not actually out yet, you'll want Essence Channeler from Bloomburrow.

TheRoaringRegisaur on Ajani's Pride

1 day ago

If you want a land that has you gain life, I'd do Blossoming Sands instead of Scoured Barrens because you actually have a card (Shalai, Voice of Plenty) that could potentially use it. It's extremely you'd have the two green mana, but it's better than nothing. I also wouldn't run 4 Shadowspears because they're legendary... you can only have one out at a time and since they're artifacts they're more likely to stay on the battlefield than a creature.

ReticleMouse on Jolrael’s Cloud Migration Strategy

2 days ago

Do you realize you have 3 copies of a card here?

TheBreadedCat on Kamahl & Tymna EDH/cEDH Stax

2 days ago

Stopped updating this deck. No longer use it. :( If I wanna throw hands frfr I play Ezuri or Najeela. Revamping Najeela into a stax oriented build due to my local playerbase. Making greta for lower power pods. peace out loves.

VANgolden33 on Malodorous Toads

2 days ago

This is sick because of the frogs

hootsnag on Oloro White Blue Black Creatureless …

2 days ago

I dont think I can run that if I have mill as one of my win conditions. It's a good card but I'm not sure it fits well here.

Profet93 on Maha EDH

2 days ago

Beseech the Mirror and Beseech the Queenfoil are additional tutors that might interest you to help you with consistency. More card draw in the form of Syphon Mind and Read the Bones are useful as well to maintain gas and help you get what you need. Dead of Winter might fit well for this deck as another wipe given your snow lands.

Regarding non-creature based decks, what is your meta looking like in terms of that? Is it a lot of blue players? If so, some hand hate in the form of Mind Twist (note, it says random!) as counterbait or Thought Distortion for something as a silver bullet.

Given your commander deck is heavily based on your commander, you should find additional ways to protect it. Whether it's something simple like lightning greaves or swiftfoot boots, or something more generally helpful such as Necropotence to give you additional draw to help with your ward.

I can give you ideas for cuts if you want.

Crow_Umbra on Hornburg Hero - Vigilance +1/+1 …

2 days ago

Lol exactly! Knotvine Paladin became one of my pet cards when my friends and I used to play janky 60 card homebrews when we were broke college students back in 2013-15. One of the decks I brewed up was a not so good Exalted deck featuring Knotvine.

izzet4lyf on Maha EDH

2 days ago

Profet93 I'd say probably consistency and relevance against non-creature based decks...

Goldbranner on Hornburg Hero - Vigilance +1/+1 …

2 days ago

Haha I love it Crow_Umbra! Hilarious that came from the same block as exalted

Wesinator69 on Imma Baddie I Do What …

2 days ago

I know you hate tapped lands so I would suggest the following:

Also I hate Temple of the False God it should stop being included in precons. Plus 37 lands is a bit much. There are a couple other cards that don't seem to do enough for the mana cost. So I would also suggest the following:

SufferFromEDHD on Oloro White Blue Black Creatureless …

2 days ago

That OG Oath of Druids tech.

Echo of Eons? Flashback Timetwister is no joke. Cute alongside Null Brooch. Or too group huggy for the strategy?

Crow_Umbra on Hornburg Hero - Vigilance +1/+1 …

2 days ago

All good, and totally understandable on all fronts, Goldbranner. One of my Alara block pet cards from my earliest days of playing is Knotvine Paladin.

Goldbranner on Hornburg Hero - Vigilance +1/+1 …

2 days ago

Crow_Umbra You're totally right about that. But I'm mostly just building this with cards I already owned (the griffin is an older pet card), plus what I wanted to buy for the deck for less than ~2 bucks a card. Kodama is a beast tho.

Nilinor on Slivers

2 days ago

This deck is actually a few years old, I don't intend to change it. I know it can be better, especially with the newer stuff, I spend more time making new decks.

DreadKhan on Uril Test Deck jtneal92

2 days ago

I'm not sure how fast you usually end games, but I love Field of the Dead in my Voltron decks, it's ability to generate blockers is usually very relevant by the time it's active. It's best in a Green deck, where you often run land ramp effects over stuff like Arcane Signet, but technically if you fetch Jetmir's Garden it'll still enter tapped, and Signet doesn't, I just hate stuff like Vandalblast wiping me out, they price the effect so low. Anyways, if you wanted to run Field of the Dead, you would probably switch out 1 of each Basic for a Snow-Covered version (you'd only need 3, so it's not a big investment), these have a different name and can help turn on Field! Other things that might help Field work are Crop Rotation, since you run Ancient Tomb (and Sanctum!) I think this is a must anyways, Open the Way is a truly great ramp effect, Farseek is another spell that can find a typed dual or tri, the only thing it can't find is a Basic forest, which is usually fine when you've already got Green in my experience. Considering you're using some pretty strong lands I would consider Hour of Promise, it's a Primeval Titan trigger for less mana, but you just get the one. With lands this good getting two of them should give you a pretty big edge. Into the North can find a Snow land, which would help in a Field of the Dead deck. I suspect with a 5 mana Commander your deck will run smoother if you could find space for a few more lands, up to you obviously but I do suggest a few lands you could consider. At the same time I'd also toss in a few more ramp effects, Green has some good ones, ones that survive the board wipes people will be tutoring up vs a deck like this!

If you're on Serra Sanctum, I feel like mentioning a few cards I like to use with it, to eek out a bit more value. Ruin Ghost can flicker it and generate a bunch of mana, as can Nature's Chosen (which is even an Enchantment!), you might even look at Deserted Temple (probably the worst option all told). Kessig Wolf Run is a card I don't run with Sanctum (I don't have Red i that deck), but plays very well with large amounts of mana, and if you're stuck playing vs a guy that keeps wiping your board. I'm always impressed by it's ability to generate a threat from a weenie, I imagine it'll be more effective with your Commander. Normally I run Wolf Run as much for Trample as the buff, but you do have a lot of Trample sources in here.

Oh yeah, I just remembered a weird trick I like to use in a Boros deck (it was desperate for card draw and I didn't want to spend even more), I settled on using Crown of Flames and Flickering Ward as auras that I could recast over and over. You could also use Whip Silk if you wanted, but the only one of those that seems worth the include in a deck this competitive is Ward, which can make you very hard to block vs some boards, but I think you'd mostly have it to trigger your Enchantress cards.

Headers13 on Doran, power of the nature

2 days ago

Skeleton Key and Slagwurm Armor are always useful and stay around with being equipment.

concorde on Ooze midrange

2 days ago

Just to clarify, extirpate removes the card from the game, so it technically wouldn’t add the slimes against humanity to the graveyard, if the goal is the use grist’s ult. Slime against humanity itself, however, checks exile, so it would still work.