Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

DatShepTho on {1}{r}{r} is the best mana …

10 minutes ago

Genuinely hilarious concept, I love the {1}{u} one too, whatever's next... {3}{G} Goreclaw? {W}{W} Eight.5 Tails?

KayneMarco on Sandstorm

2 hours ago

Only 31 lands in a lands matter deck??

detoxmetro on To Get List

3 hours ago

elvish mystic

Fyndhorn Elves

Llanowar Elves

Birds of paradise

Delighted Halfling

Gamble

Worldly Tutor

Blasphemous Act

Big score

Unexpected windfall

Seize the spotlight

Chain reaction

Rolling earthquake

Faithless Looting

Manamorphose

Lifecrafters bestiary

ADDED

Head CoIIector on The Graveyard Getdown

5 hours ago

I do really like what you're doing here, but just a couple things to consider.
Cabal Coffers should definitely be here. I'm guessing the only reason it isn't is budget.
Between your tokens being 2/2 and all the anthem effects, I doubt Skullclamp is doing much for you. Necropotence or Idol of Oblivion might suit your needs better. It seems it really only works if you have your commander out for the power buff/sacrifice. Even so, it might be better to switch out a sorcery/instant draw card for long term gains.
Yargle, Glutton of Urborg would be a really nice target for Gisa as well.
Heraldic Banner is an absolutely nuts rock for monocolored aggro decks like this. Highly suggest slotting it in.
Finally, Crashing Drawbridge would really take your speed up a notch.

ShibaWiz on [Primer] The Land Before Time: …

5 hours ago

Thanks for the likes and suggestions.

@xBrutusx: While that would a huge benefit for the Dino's, it is not on theme sadly. I've let go of a great many good cards due to not being on theme (Ex. The One Ring: This deck really benefits from consistent card draw, but due to not being on theme it's not in).

Optimator on The Question

6 hours ago

I love it!

Master_J on Froggin Time!

6 hours ago

OUT: Cultivator Colossus, Selvala, Heart of the Wilds, Fyndhorn Elves, Elves of Deep Shadow, Vampiric Tutor, Not Dead After All, Bala Ged Recovery  Flip, Demonic Tutor, Lightning Greaves, Greater Good

IN: Zopandrel, Hunger Dominus, Shakedown Heavy, Hunted Bonebrute, Tear Asunder, Nature's Claim, Culling Ritual, Nature's Lore, Arcane Signet, Unnatural Growth, Underground Mortuary

Trying to work out some kinks in this deck. I find myself without big boys to sac to the 'Rog sometimes. Also, upping the land count a little instead of using dorks that will die to Culling Ritual.

I may also come to regret pulling out the tutors, but I never know what to look for that will help me win immediately, so out they come for now.

jawz on BR Dirge for Drivnod

7 hours ago

I saw a list trying to get value from Generous Plunderer and Bloodvial Purveyor as targets for the Lively Dirge. Plunderer has become my favorite ramp card recently so I'm in. Donating all these artifacts to the opponent helps maximize the Plunderer damage trigger which the Bloodletter doubles. Plunderer ramping from 2 to 4 seems better than Goldhound ramping from 1 to 3 given the deck doesn't have many 3 drops but has a lot of key 4 drops.

Purveyor is a nasty clock as a 5/6 flying trample for 4. Especially in a Bloodletter deck. Jaxis, the Troublemaker is a scary combo piece too for Purveyor or Plunderer.

I also felt like Drivnod's double death trigger ability was getting forgotten, so I looked around a bit for possible synergy cards. Body Launderer and Mask of Griselbrand caught my eye. Giving them a try too.

I decided to move away from the Bitter Reunion for Into the Fire instead. I have plenty of 2 drops but few 3 drops. Fire gives me more digging and at least an option for a small sweeper against wide aggro decks. Without the Goldhound I'm less cautious about sweepers. And I'm ok with putting some of my 2 drops into the graveyard because I can rely on Dirge to get a couple back. I don't think I need the Reunion's haste option as much as I originally thought I would.

ClockworkSwordfish on Nerdy Goth Vampire Waifu

7 hours ago

Abiding Grace would absolutely rule in this build, but unfortunately I can't run it due to Lurrus!

detoxmetro on To Get List

7 hours ago

Storm-kiln

mimic vat

staff of domination

combat celebration

ashnod's altar

wideline1414 on Nerdy Goth Vampire Waifu

9 hours ago

Thoughts on adding abiding grace? End step lifegain or bring back a 1cmc from the graveyard.

detoxmetro on To Get List

10 hours ago
  • Dualcaster

  • Grapeshot

  • Pili

nbarry223 on Viga-BOOM!

10 hours ago

So as of right now, I am going to be doing these swaps with current spoilers:


Maindeck
+1 Disciple of Freyalise
+1 Urza's Cave
+1 Bojuka Bog
+1 Spelunking

-1 Courser of Kruphix
-2 Explore
-1 Arboreal Grazer


Sideboard
+1 Six
+1 Vexing Bauble

-1 Colossal Skyturtle
-1 Khalni Garden

nbarry223 on Viga-BOOM!

11 hours ago

Disciple of Freyalise // Garden of Freyalise is also definitely going in, it's even better than Six is for the deck, MH3 is looking exciting now.

Soulreavent on Red/Blue Demo 2

11 hours ago

Suggestions:

  • Lightning Greaves
  • Swiftfoot Boots
  • Nivex Guildmage
  • Past In Flames
  • Any cheap cantrip (opt, ponder, brainstorm, consider, ect…)

Spodge17 on 'My Devin Townsend Project'

15 hours ago

Normally don't stop to look at other people's decks on the front page, but the name caught me off-guard, so i had to stop by and check it out. What a rad idea! I admire your "Resolve!", and i hope you leave your opponents wanting for "More!".

jjjwalker on Titania Lands

15 hours ago

Out

Ghost quarter, Maze of ith, Worldshaper

In

Petrified field, Glacial chasm, Archdruids charm

ArtemisFox on Squirrels, All I really want …

15 hours ago

DesmondBear- That's interesting as I had thought I had too much token creation in there with the 8 landfall token creators as well as the others. I understand that landfall is a condition but it's a generally common condition. I could certainly readd some of the squirrel token creators I left in the maybe board. My thought process on removing those was that they were limited in how much they will create and in terms of power were fairly lacking comparatively. (I'd certainly prefer to have almost any landfall card than the one off token creators). You're definitely right that there are not a lot of unconditional token creators, about 6 or 7 cards, I might look at adding more back in. My play group does tend to try to play longer and not have games end earlier so I had figured the landfall triggers would be enough.

Forceofnature1- I had thought of eldrazi monument as well as akroma's memorial or even just some overrun effects. I wasn't quite sure what I would want to cut to achieve that and if I did add more wincons i was thinking I would just add a few of the gain/loss of life creatures like Zulaport Cutthroat or Falkenrath Noble.

Saljen on Mono White Weenies

16 hours ago

Witch Enchanter

jjjwalker on Titania Lands

17 hours ago

-Out

??

+In

Glacial Chasm

Petrified Field

Archdruid's Charm

jjjwalker on Titania Lands

17 hours ago

-Out Urza's Mine (CMM) Urza's Power Plant (CMM) Urza's Tower (CMM)

+In Geier Reach Sanitarium Gaea's Cradle (proxied) Emergence Zone

Forceofnature1 on Squirrels, All I really want …

17 hours ago

Oh fun! What an interesting build. How does it play in a 1 v 1 or pod setting? I love me some chatterfang and have been working to make him as scary as possible. I'll have to update my version on here to match what I am playing now. Recently retooled it to have more interaction.

Have you thought including Eldrazi Monument as a game ender? Flying indestructible squirrels is pretty awesome.

DesmondBear on Squirrels, All I really want …

17 hours ago

Just playtested it a little. I feel like there's not enough unconditional token creation in here. Plenty of things like Academy manufactor, but not nearly enough things like verdant command to trigger them.

Crow_Umbra on Hitting Licks Expeditiously

17 hours ago

Thanks for the recommendations KayneMarco. I actually have 2 copies of Revel in Riches, but I have them in my Burakos and Vraska decks respectively as alt win-cons. I figured Revel in Riches might get a bit more mileage in those decks since their creatures are a bit on the smaller side. I definitely considered it for this deck, but opted for some of the X spells instead.

This deck is more so a quick successor to my old Windgrace deck (not really my playstyle after a few games) and my Prosper deck, so I threw it together with what I had on hand. Not sure if I'll keep this deck around for long term, since it has some overlap with my Goro-Goro and Satoru deck, in terms of wanting to play Haste-y stuff, and also has overlap with the aforementioned Burakos & Vraska decks with the Treasure synergy.

I don't currently own a copy of Old Gnawbone, and since I'm unsure if I'll keep this deck long-term, I'm not really sure I'd want to invest in a copy at the moment. Proxying is definitely an option in my play-group.

KayneMarco on Hitting Licks Expeditiously

18 hours ago

Just saw you don’t have Old Gnawbone in here either

KayneMarco on Hitting Licks Expeditiously

18 hours ago

Honestly surprised I don’t see Revel in Riches in here. With the heavy treasure theme it seems like a no brainer. Did you leave it out on purpose or did you or did you forget about it?

MTGBurgeoning on Myra the Magnificent Stars in: …

20 hours ago

YES! She is so much fun!

I must apologize for the tardiness of this reply. I did not receive a notification of your comment.

decideo on Abusive Relationship

23 hours ago

I live to build and improve, if there is anything that could be improved upon, please let me know.

Icbrgr on Emissary-whacker

1 day ago

hey this looks pretty good! +1

Icbrgr on Zoo deck wins

1 day ago

this looks great! love seeing zoo translated into pauper this pleases me!

huey87 on U/G Mill

1 day ago

I appreciate it. TBH i threw this together a couple years ago and I've been meaning to update it some. Thanks for the advise!

FormOverFunction on Lich Themed Deck Guide

1 day ago

This is sort of tangential but Pact Weapon made me think of Rakdos Riteknife. It’s not likely to fit in most Lich builds, but I thought I would mention it. Sort of ensouling something with someone ELSE for your benefit... Lich-by-proxy, maybe.

FormOverFunction on Lich Themed Deck Guide

1 day ago

You had me at the use of the word “theme” lol great list!!

wisegreenbean on Jolene Beats You With Her …

1 day ago

Rampage of the Clans is pretty funny for a deck that dumps so many artifacts onto the battlefield.

Kenrith's Transformation and Lantern of the Lost are primo cantripping interaction that I put in nearly every green deck.

Gruul Signet is sussy in green decks imo. I also don't love the 4 mana ramp sorceries in a deck with a 4 mana general. like, when u even gonna cast them? and your general ramps too? and you don't even have that much high mana stuff. There are 2 mana ramp sorceries you aren't running that curve much more nicely. Nature's Lore and Farseek and Three Visits

RockIV on Black Suicide

1 day ago

I love this deck, did you ever think about adding a creature with lifelink?

Apollo_Paladin on Menace to Society ($60 Menace …

1 day ago

Yeah, dealing First Strike damage with Goldhound makes it really easy to get a double trigger off the Face-Breaker in combats, and then being able to sacrifice the tapped Goldhound itself for card advantage after the treasures are created is just... < chef's kiss >

I definitely think the prowlers are a good one to drop for them too, namely since they can't be pumped with the Labyrinth Raptors.

You might also look at Sonorous Howlbonder. It's one I phased out of my build in favor of running the Pestilent Spirits full-time, but there still are a few games where I do miss him. Combined with the raptor triggers he lets you turn your board into a lethal attack extremely early, even against decks with massive creature (blocker) presence.

In any case, good choices thus far. Feel free to add me on Arena if you ever want to run some test games or even just discuss deck & meta tech. Info is on my profile here - Cheers!

Jopling on Menace to Society ($60 Menace …

1 day ago

Apollo_Paladin Seeing your deck is actually what inspired me to build my own version!

I didn't even notice the synergy between Professional Face-Breaker and Goldhound. I think I'll remove Nezumi Prowler for it.

Last_Laugh on Spanisshin Inquisisshin

1 day ago

Ok, I'm pretty stoked. I got an extended art copy of Trouble in Pairs for $10 from my LGS. I was flipping through a pile of rares they'd just barely bought and asked if TiP was still $25ish. I got the "wait, what?!?" look and he looked up the price and looked a bit sheepish as he admitted "that's not what I paid for it". "Do you mind passing that savings on?" was my immediate reply. When he said "I can go $10", I couldn't pull a $10 bill out of my pocket any fast enough...

MTGBurgeoning on Magar the Horrible

1 day ago

Rise of the Eldrazi is meant to be more of a target for Magar of the Magic Strings than a card to cast from our hand. I would love to add Ancient Tomb TO EVERY DECK haha, but, alas, a copy must become available...and at a more affordable price. To be clear, there are four lands that can tap for colorless mana (Access Tunnel, Rogue's Passage, Sulfurous Springs, Tainted Peak) and three artifacts (Mana Crypt, Sol Ring, Talisman of Indulgence). For me, Mirari is too pricey. I love the card and have tried playing with it in a variety of decks. However, it just comes down to being too mana-intensive. You hit the nail on the head with Wheel of Misfortune: we don't want to help our opponents!

Preturbed on CHOOSE YOUR FIGHTER

1 day ago

I think some fighters tend to pull the gameplay in certain direction. For example, putting Zamriel, Seraph of Steel in the command zone means I want to find Worldslayer and lock the game for a win. Commander Eesha wants to go for the straight-ahead voltron strategy. Balan, Wandering Knight and Halvar, God of Battle  Flip are pretty much the same - I'll be looking for a way to give them evasion. I think this is a fun way to play and depending on the choice of commander, I can adjust the deck's power level a little to better suit the table.

Noobybro_ on K'rrik

1 day ago

You need more lands