Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Basshunter on [1DH] Orim, Samite Healer

12 minutes ago

like the idea and wanna build it on my own, the problem for this cleric/prevention-theme is the lack of wincons imo - lets see what we can do..

im sure youre not even on tappedout anymore :D

Abbanation01 on Jodah, the Unifier

1 hour ago

and last thing, Karakas is a life saver to keep your commander from wandering back to the command zone, since Jodah is killed on sight so often

wideline1414 on Giada, Font of Hope

1 hour ago

Also no avacyn? LORAN of the third path is good draw but non angel

wideline1414 on Giada, Font of Hope

1 hour ago

How does your version of giada play? If you need a draw source scroll rack works with all the lands you pull with land tax and Archaeomancer’s map

PhyrexianPraetor on Modern Black Devotion

1 hour ago

I like what you got here. Reminds me of my old version from 2018.

If you were interested, you can take a look at my version to get new ideas. I run orzhov for side-board options.

Kaweiwu on This Is Going To Hurt

1 hour ago

Bro his Deck has an average CMC of 4.1... a Keen Duelist just kills him lol

IlumniDevil on Group Backstab 2.0?

5 hours ago

I would like help narrowing this down to 100 cards

magwaaf on Miirym, Sentinel Wyrm: Double Dragon

10 hours ago

i went this route

https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/cloning-around-3/?cb=1715046128

keizerbuns on Unstoppable Oil Drip

11 hours ago

Interesting deck, it looks like fun!

I'm curious though, what is the purpose of Pilfered Plans in your deck? It doesn't seem like your deck has any synergies with milling your opponent. If the goal is just to draw some cards then you could achieve that for a lower cost using something like Chart a Course.

I do also have some other suggestions for you if you want to use them.

Blink of an Eye is a strictly better version of Leave in the Dust and it lowers your mana curve. Serum Snare is also a good replacement since it synergizes better with your poison counter game plan.

Prophetic Prism is an alright card for more card draw, but it doesn't help you mana ramp, and is more for color fixing, which is something your deck doesn't seem like it needs. Instead, you could use something like Mind Stone as a cheap way to mana ramp while also giving you the option to draw a card later if you need it.

And Slither Blade is a strictly better version of both Triton Shorestalker and Mist-Cloaked Herald, I would suggest putting Slither up to a full set of 4 and cutting one copy of either of the other two.

YamishiTheWickedOne on What is a Man? (a …

13 hours ago

Finally got my hands on a Wheel of Fortune. I know I've been a big proponent of Mirror Entity but somehow even with my increased access to ramp he just isn't as explosive as he was in previous iterations of the build, so he goes in maybeboard for now. 3 cmc for 3 cmc. Though I'd love to have an even 40 creatures, I wanted one more way to refresh resources. This deck has a tendency to play my entire hand pretty quickly due to having so many 1-2 mana cards and ways to ramp out 3 cmc creatures early.

Godzilla2012 on Sage of Hours

13 hours ago

Unfortunately, I haven't used this deck since 2016, and now that I exclusively play EDH/Commander, I don't think I will be making any changes to this deck. I did add Elven Rite, Earthen Arms, and Howling Mine to the Maybeboard for Thewayoflife234, as well as Collected Company for b0n3m4r3.

Balaam__ on Sprite Dragon

17 hours ago

I like what you’re going for, but I’m not sure Street Wraith belongs. You clearly don’t intend to hard cast it, but I can’t see any other potential interactions with anything else in the deck. Cycling Street Wraith won’t apply any counters to either Sprite Dragon or Stormchaser Mage, temporary or otherwise. I think this slot would be better served by a free-to-cast card that would buff your creatures or by a cheap utility spell.

Sombertone on Yennett, Cheapish Sovereign

18 hours ago

I saved up for Void Winnower. Having it so folks 'can't even' is something the proxy version had and I wanted it back for the lols. Taking our Butcher of Malakir for it, as there's not sacrifice triggers to really abuse the Butcher's sacrifice ability and the Void Winnower should be much more disruptive.

tchau204 on Marit Lage's Awakening

19 hours ago

Very cool deck! Looks fun!

Coward_Token on Ertai the Corrupted

20 hours ago

Induced Amnesia basically doubles your cards in hand

Gimmicky but Reality Acid is some fun removal

Pretty obvious but check out https://edhrec.com/commanders/ertai-the-corrupted if you haven't already

xBrutusx on [Primer] The Land Before Time: …

20 hours ago

Childhood nostalgia.

Not really on theme, but Gimli's Reckless Might would be great here. Haste for the clones and removal when attacking.

matvone on Dylan BBD

22 hours ago

Why the Cabal Stronghold land when you have NO basic swamps?

BenTim on Light-Paws' 69

1 day ago

could use a bit of crowd control; I do get the hilarious meme of 1 creature, all voltron, but... it will fall flat against anybody with half a braincell, and I want to see this succeed. I'd throw on some targeted removal, some enchantment stax, etc.

Brinckenberger on Muldrotha Value

1 day ago

Dropped Coiling Oracle and Crop Rotation, added Phyrexian Altar and Worldly Tutor.

Asgeren on Ertai the Corrupted

1 day ago

Nice deck, I'm a big fan of esper ;) How about something like Pemmin's Aura, Patriar's Seal, Freed from the Real to abuse Ertai's ability ;) and maybe some token generation to always have something to sack?

idfkgabe on Ty-Ramp-A-Saurus Wrex

1 day ago

take everything out except ghalta primal hunger

Belfore on Miirym Copy Dragons

1 day ago

I think I would drop the Rapacious Dragon for the Astral Dragon even though the CMCs of Astral is higher

carpayn on Prosper

1 day ago

I think that -Mana Vault -Uba Mask and -Wild Magice Surge Need to be switched out for -Urabrask, Heretic Praetor -Valki, God of Lies and -Grim Hireling

Yisan on Jarad Aristogoyfs

1 day ago

No Lord of extinction? Love the deck

ShadowMasterNL on Desecrating the Landscape

2 days ago

No idea, looks fine to me bro!

Emrock221 on Toralf, God of Fury - …

2 days ago

The red god from the new ixalan set would would fantastic in this deck as little extra fire power

FriendlyManatee on More Planes

2 days ago

WoW! Great Build

MrHuffle on Hangry Boi Needs a Snack

2 days ago

Profet93

Whatever you think might be terrible for my opponents or terribly fun for me haha... Mostly I'm just waiting for MH3 to drop :) Tryna keep in the Eldrazi only theme

Profet93 on Hangry Boi Needs a Snack

2 days ago

What kind of suggestions r u looking for?

Asgeren on Damia: Carbonized in Cruciform

2 days ago

What are the combos you use in this deck?

Gandolfini on Tiamat: The Three Hunters

2 days ago

tazorface6 Sounds great! Have fun, they won’t know what hit them!

DreadKhan on Unparalleled Cognitive Dissonance

2 days ago

No Reassembling Skeleton? What about something like Sengir Autocrat, make a bunch of bodies to generate maximum triggers? Gixian Puppeteer seems like a good fit. I feel like Dreadhorde Invasion might be good with your Commander, as long as you sacrifice the token you get a fresh one on your upkeep, this is a relatively affordable alternative to Bitterblossom. If you like the Underworld Dreams effect, perhaps Fate Unraveler, though it's not exactly budget at this point and will surely go down in price if it sees reprint, so maybe keep an eye on it? I feel like your deck would benefit from anything that prevents life gain, stuff like Grima Wormtongue and/or Knight of Dusk's Shadow might keep opponents from running away from your damage/life loss effects, and Plague Drone actually punishes opponents for trying to gain life.

Gidgetimer on "Why are the pages sticky?"

2 days ago

...

There are 13 permanent spells in the entire deck with all of them being 0 or 1 MV ramp. "Forgot about Cody's first line of text" isn't how I would phrase it. "Wants to hit turn 2 Cody 69% of the time, more if you factor in mulls" is how I would phrase it.

wallisface on Genesis Surge

2 days ago

Just looking at the updates, some further thoughts:

  • firstly, on Unbound Flourishing, it’s only going to double the value of X for Genesis Hydra, as that is a ”permanent spell”. For Genesis Wave it’s only going to copy that spell, but leave the value of X unchanged (because its a sorcery, not a permanent-spell), which is severely more underwhelming.

  • I would suggest either going down the route of your genesis cards OR the Tooth and Nail strategy - but not both, as this just makes it harder to enact your plan. Specifically the genesis spells play poorly with the eldrazi titans because you miss-out on all those cast triggers (the genesis spells don’t cast the card you put into play), but also those Eldrazi titans have very high mana costs - needing 12-13 mana is a very tall ask.

  • Whichever path you go down, I think you need to aim to speed your deck up. Turn 6 is too slow. You want to be representing a winning boardstate by turn 4-5 at the very latest. If you go down the Tooth&Nail path, this deck here is one a friend has played a lot and done very well with. He hasn’t updated the list on this site so it’s a bit out of date, but should give you an idea of the build, it can win as early as turn 3. If you’re sticking to the Genesis build then I suggest lowering your mana curve a bunch so that you can get out a decently-powerful threat asap… you probably don’t want any card costing more than 8 mana and you want to ensure you can reliably put one of these cards onto the board by turn 3-4.

tazorface6 on Tiamat: The Three Hunters

2 days ago

Gandolfini thank you so much I am just looking to play sweaty fun casual games with friends. I am super new and they have been playing for a long time so I was to just hoping to replace some of the super expensive cards like the 100$ ones and keep all the core cards and main deck and hopefully make it work! And show up one day and them be like wtf is happening right now hahaha

MadHatter23 on Mono-Black Enchantment

2 days ago

The combo works by having Warehouse Tabby and Ayara, First of Locthwain on the field. Use Screams from Within to kill any 1/1 creature. The aura hits the graveyard triggering the taby creating a 1/1 black rat token. Ayara triggers opponents lose 1 life. The aura then returns targeting the new rat token. Thus continues the loop.

indieinside on Dauthi Shadow Tribal

2 days ago

thanks Asgeren. I put a lot into this one.