Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Slavetomints on Hold My Counters

20 minutes ago

Amazing deck man!

beleren2013 on Mono Green Whatever I Had ...

37 minutes ago

That might actually be useful, lol. Thank for the tip.

DKquaid420 on Kalamax, the Bomb Droppin Dinosaur ...

48 minutes ago

Ordered the few lands I didn’t have and will let you know how i like them thankyou for your input I appreciate it a ton!

Magic_Faqs on Riku of Two Reflections - ...

52 minutes ago

Cool, let me know how it turns out! I'm kinda curious to see how good it can be.

Icbrgr on Nissa: Believe In Your Elf!

1 hour ago

lol the archived comments is basically everyone telling me to switch to Heroic Intervention hahaha... the dang card just hasn't been in the game store in the bulk rares/class case whenever I look for it.... but with it being reprinted for M21 im sure its gonna come my way via booster pack or something in short order.

PhoenixWombat on "The Retirement Fund"

1 hour ago
  • Actually the basic forest land base is more broad then this, I just never bothered to enter the codes it's now updated correctly
  • I've tested sword of the paruns and decided that the 10 cost for casting, equip, and activation were too steep a cost. But I am always reevaluating this deck. So I might add it back in.
  • If Illusionist Bracers work as you suggest that would be amazing. Unfortunately the fact my play group has learned to nuke Seton the moment he hits the field would likely make the bracers a dead draw.
  • I'm still testing The Great Henge to see if I will officially add it. So far the cost is generally a bit too high.
  • I'm secretly hoping Elvish Spirit Guide is in the incoming "Green Commander Foil Set"
  • Lotus Petal would probably be a fantastic addition. But finding a spot for it in an already tight list is problematic.
  • Temur Sabertooth does help infinite combo. But I nixed it because it honestly didn't fit the theme I was going for.
  • Jolrael, Mwonvuli Recluse and Earthshaker Giant are in a similar boat as Sabertooth that they don't fit the theme.
  • Path of Discovery is a fun card but doesn't particularly help this deck
  • Paradise druid, Elvish Rejuvenator, and Quirion Sentinel are all cards that I have rotated in and out in the past. Currently they didn't make the cut.
  • Argothian Elder is in a similar boat to another card I cut Norwood Priestess because the 4 cost makes comboing out that much more difficult.
  • Hidden Herbalist does seem like it would be good with Curio but alas it's not an elf :(
  • I totally forgot about the new Nylea. I will have to do some testing. The Reduction and the filtering abilities could very well make the cut.
  • I'm still on the fence on Llanowar Visionary. I love the card draw but the 3 mana is a potential drawback when i'm trying to combo out

Thank you very much for the suggestions

Abzkaban on Yeva Draw-Grow

1 hour ago

precociousapprentice

Your Marchesa deck was the inspiration for my own version and is now one of my favorite decks to pilot. You got a whole discord community started. I just know they’d love it if you found your way there.

A_L_Mustang on The Strong Get Stronger

1 hour ago

I like the list so far. I would recommend taking out the enchantment draw cards, there are not enough of them to really capitalize on their effects. Instead run draw cards that depend on your creature's strengths such as Return of the Wildspeaker

Some budget yet strong cards for a +1/+1 counter focused deck would definitely be Mowu, Loyal Companion and Jiang Yanggu, Wildcrafter

Magikarpet on Unicorny Power

1 hour ago

You're welcome! I already saw a few great ideas in this deck that I hadn't thought of so the least I can do is try to return the favor :)

Firebird on Nissa: Believe In Your Elf!

1 hour ago

Honestly, if I might make a suggestion, replace Wrap in Vigor with Heroic Intervention. Same price but makes them (and everything else you have) hexproof and indestructible, which is better than regenerate—stuff like Damnation doesn't get around it, and it doesn't remove them from combat.

Otherwise, as a fellow Elf, I love it!

Flusterstorm-of-Possabilities on Prodigy Scepter

1 hour ago

My bad didn't see the Balista at first.

Flusterstorm-of-Possabilities on Prodigy Scepter

1 hour ago

Great build. With the number of dorks, you and others run Wirewood Channeler might be a good addition. It can also go infinite with Freed from the Real with only two dorks out total. Have you thought about Walking Balista as an outlet to the infinite mana?

SurpriZe on Queen Marchesa: Politics, Aikido, and ...

1 hour ago

precociousapprentice Are there reasons to include Sun Droplet instead of Delaying Shield? It seems that the Delaying Shield has more value, as it protects against commander damage. Or is it because of cards like Deflecting Palm and Comeuppance?

Bjm on Kenrith, The Returned King - ...

2 hours ago

thewildone and I didn't put that shit horobi in there because if it was on the field it would also destroy my creatures dumbass

Bjm on Kenrith, The Returned King - ...

2 hours ago

thewildone stfu the reason willbreaker isn't in here is due to the abundance of blue and it's slow. why don't you make a budget kenrith deck and show me then I'll see if it's even worth replying to your comment you arrogant prick. (this is an alt account btw)

Kiran_M on "The Retirement Fund"

2 hours ago

Ah yes, metallic elves. How ironic. Funnily enough, I did an intensive search for Forests for my pauper Elves deck and settled on those exact ones, albeit in non-foil.

Profet93 on Urza Storm

2 hours ago

Impulse > Anticipate

Fierce Guardianship is a blue staple

Academy Ruins is nice recursion for an artifact deck

Sensei's Divining Top - Good on it's own, synergy with future sight

Is howling mine needed in a mono blue deck?

DBCooper on Nice board you have there, ...

2 hours ago

check my similar build, you may enjoy some of my additions: The First Rule of Fight Club...

great deck, by the way

curmevexas on Riku of Two Reflections - ...

2 hours ago

Yep, I've used it before. I'll give the deck a spin to test it out.

DankMagicianD on Lord Windgrace at a cEDH ...

2 hours ago

I've been looking at making a Lord Windgrace cedh deck for a while now, and this looks pretty cool. https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/wherever-you-thar-lord-windgrace-cedh-1/ is another list; maybe you could compare?

flyingcodfish on Haunted House!

2 hours ago

Nice deck. :) I played it with some friends, and the whole table enjoyed the theme. We narrated all my turns and made it into a spooky story. It was a good time.

casual_competitive on Cute Little Dog With a ...

3 hours ago

win by default, no one wants to fight against a cute pupper

casual_competitive on Cute Little Dog With a ...

3 hours ago

win by default, no one wants to fight against a cute pupper

Magic_Faqs on Riku of Two Reflections - ...

3 hours ago

Are you familiar with untap.in? It's a site where you can play online with people, 100% free to play (they have a patreon). It's all manual and can be a headache to learn the hotkeys, but it's my favorite site for play testing decks before becoming financially invested in something that may or may not be good.

Scallywallwest on Mill for all

3 hours ago

Dude, your curve is really weird here...

Phostration on first online build

3 hours ago

I agree with sergiodelrio. None of your current creatures really provided any benefit to your mill focused sorcery. Double Vision Would allow you to cause even more damage, and if you take sergio's advice, would double any first spell you play on your turn. (also if you have more than one they triple/quadruple etc... :o)

Magic_Faqs on Riku of Two Reflections - ...

3 hours ago
  • It looks like you should have plenty of energy. Between triggers giving you energy and the cloning spells, you should have plenty to play with. Aethersquall Ancient may use a lot, but by the time you use it's ability again you should be sitting on a nice stockpile.
  • It DEFINITELY feels like an energy deck lol. The power level looks like it would be around a 6, but I'd have to play test it.
  • It looks like your ramp/removal is pretty well balanced. Your card draw seems kinda light, maybe consider adding Bonders' Enclave?

FLATSO99 on Lemures Citadel

3 hours ago

Nice job with the deck here's a +1! Have you noticed any issues with the list/do you have any kinks you are working out at the moment?

DreadKhan on Would you rather die to ...

4 hours ago

Really good deck, totally beats my most competitive deck reliably, but I am amused to note it struggles vs my creature heavy mono green deck. Not sure what you could realistically do to deal with a deck like that without hurting the deck in general. I doubt you have to deal with a deck like that in your meta, so I think it's a non-issue. Maybe Attrition? You do have a great supply of creatures potentially, as long as you have one player you can hit, and you generally should have some B mana to use it. It seems more like a sideboard card though to be honest, but pro-active defense of your planeswalkers is a good strategy.

Note, there is no salt like the salt of being beaten by planeswalkers. Kudos for really making them a force here.

Ishio on Mono-Black Discard Matters

4 hours ago

WhrThRdFrnGr0w5: Depends on your meta and what type of powerlevel you're trying to go for. Mortuary Mire is not a card we want in our hand mid/late game at a higher level, since it enters tapped. However, if you're short on some recursion cards, due to price or availability, it's a decent trade off for a land cantrip. Yet, for more tuned levels, we would want to make sure to capitalize all our cantrips to keep our opponents hands empty.

I have not experiemented with Witch's Cottage, and since I had a small step away from Magic during Eldraine, that is something I'd consider putting in, in place of a Swamp. Might actually look into whether I have one that I opened and forgot about, or my LGS has one foiled, since it's a common after all. Thanks for the reminder!

jconeil1988 on The Strong Get Stronger

4 hours ago

If you are going to run Argothian Enchantress I would add it a lot more enchantments. right now you have 10 spells that will trigger it, making it a very unreliable card draw source. Same with Enchantress's Presence.

Keep in mind that Chord of Calling and Green Sun's Zenith can't really search for any of your Hydras with x in it's cost because you wouldn't be paying the x in the creatures cost, making them 0/0's when they enter the field.

It's a nice start, and look forward to seeing you develop your deck building skills

Daveslab2022 on The Meat Grinder! - (4-Color ...

4 hours ago

Agree wholeheartedly with Balaam__

Replace Tymaret with Relentless dead for sure

keystone554 on Portside Party Korvold cEDH

4 hours ago

Its totally criminal that this list isn't playing Razaketh

precociousapprentice on Yeva Draw-Grow

4 hours ago

I like surprising decks. Unfortunately, my Queen Marchesa list is way out of date, but has been a surprise to many people I play it against that do not know ahead of time. Also unfortunately, it is tuned for a more casual meta. This Yeva deck has been my most favorite replacement of that deck in more competitive metas, and surprises just as many people. I really like it, and play it as my go-to deck at this point for highly tuned and competitive metas. I will probably get there with Discord, and maybe this is what I need to figure it out.

Omniscience_is_life on Cedh attempt #2(Anje Madness)

5 hours ago

around what turn can this deck consistently win?

DC_Geno on Modern Mono-Black Devotion

5 hours ago

Bile Blight in the side could be helpful against ramp. I like it better than Drown in Sorrow.

Poseidon31 on Modern Mono-Black Devotion

5 hours ago

I like it, run it with a few other aspects. At the moment i play it without fetches but with more Dismember. Therefore i run more Lifelink creatures like Aetherborn and Nighthawk. But i can switch to fetches and Push if I want to.

I removed Gatekeeper and play now a set of Bloodghasts. And I run 4 Garys. T5 a Gary with a landdrop can easily hit for at least 4 maybe 6. With more on the board it could be over T5. With only 2 of them, you wont have them every T5.

Instead of Freebooter I run a complete set of Inquisition and Thoughtseize. Murderous Rider is also a good removal and can even hit a planeswalker. The ability to go back to the deck is a nice synergy with your fetches.

Maybe you found something else is missing on my side: Black Obliteration

Lanzo493 on My Deck is my Phylactery

5 hours ago

Zur has 2 other ways to not get killed.

Energy Field + Rest in Peace

Solitary Confinement + any enchantment that draws

So those would be great adds. You also have Pariah + Shielded by Faith. Zur is good at assembling any of these, especiall

Kcin on Mono Green Whatever I Had ...

5 hours ago

Dictate of karametra and the other mana doublers would like to speak with you!

roseink on Karametra, God of Lawns

5 hours ago

Amulet of Vigor has excellent synergy with Karametra, so you might want to consider that. Knight of Autumn is nice creature-based removal you could consider.

Also, in my experience, since Karametra is so good at getting out lands, you might not need so many color fixing lands and might want more basics that she can search for

curmevexas on Riku of Two Reflections - ...

6 hours ago

I had a few areas of concern:

  • Am I going to have enough energy to keep things going, or am I going to feel energy-starved when my big threats hit the table? Aethersquall Ancient, Aetherwind Basker, Aetherworks Marvel
  • Is it going to feel like an energy deck or did I cut too many cards for that to still feel like an integral theme?
  • Is my removal, ramp, card draw, finishers etc. balanced, or do I have some glaring weaknesses?
  • How's the power level/synergy?
  • Does anything need to be added/changed/removed?