Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

SilentBladeOni on Colorless Cascade

4 minutes ago

Hey GodzSoldier, cool deck! One suggestion would be adding Scroll Rack and maybe a Sensei's Divining Top to help you set up your cascades for maximum cascade value. The deck looks awesome!

Andromedus on Progress and Poverty

11 minutes ago

Andramalech thanks for the kind remarks! I like Managorger also, against u/b I run Mold Adder from the sideboard (usually swapping out the Primordials) and they do pretty well as cheap little Managorger wannabes haha. The only thing I waffle on are the Vials and the Dusk Legion Duelists but I like that the deck is a bit spicier with them -- all that to say there's definitely some room to tweak this list to personal preference. Thanks for the +1! (Nice name too btw ;)

Andramalech on Progress and Poverty

34 minutes ago

I have an older build that wasn't quite modern legal and splashed Red for Naydras, and it didn't come close to how clean and precise this must play. I mean, mans really out here beating face the good ole' fashion way with Hydras. My wife mainboards Managorger Hydra and an older shell of 'Scales' and Stompy-associated toolbox. Love to see a deck main Dromoka's Command, because it's utility just can't be slept on. Great work, and love your username. Hope people don't get us mixed up, lol.

Necromantic_Judgementor on karametra

37 minutes ago

Awesome deck with interesting synergy. I never noticed that white and green have the same effect spread out throughout both colors concerning creatures, entering the battlefield and you gaining a life!

Andramalech on Thought and Talon

42 minutes ago

Had never considered an Esper-colored commander but this.. strikes a fancy, for sure. I like what I see, and currently have no notes- it seems to have legs, and I wanna look over the list more before I make a suggestion. I enjoyed briefly checking it out though!

BlockTheWok on Rev Miracles

1 hour ago

4 Counterspell cut any of the blue counter like stuff like charm cut Bonfire for 4th Terminus 3 Counterbalance for anything honestly Counterbalance seems like the big selling point the core of the deck counterbalance terminus and maybe entreat also all planeswalkers should be Jace, the Mind Sculptor

jmmaurer30 on Rev Miracles

1 hour ago

replace azorious charm for counterspell

GabeBurch on Grismold, the Token Vending Machine

1 hour ago

Also Assault Suit is a great choice - definitely adding it to my deck

GabeBurch on Grismold, the Token Vending Machine

1 hour ago

Edit: Oops I must have missed your not wanting these when reading your description


I like to use what I call 'Mass Minus' cards in my Grismold deck so the tokens die immediately

Balvron on Green/Black toxic/proliferate need recommendations

1 hour ago

Azoth2099 thank you! now for the hard part lol need to figure out what to cut to add the maybe board in to the deck

phat_nana on U/B Aggro-Mill

4 hours ago

Kcin I actually was running Invisible Stalker or True-Name Nemesis with Ring of Evos Isle for a bit originally! Tho, like with AEtherling I found the combination a bit slower than I wanted. I do like the Trepanation Blade idea better than Ring of Evos Isle tho and it's def worth testing! Maybe with True-Name Nemesis?? Not sure what I would swap out for T-Blade tho... Without leaning more towards HARD Mill.

PS: I also realized I made mistakes so, if the deck looks a little different... You're not going crazy!

Jimmithee on Wyleth, Boros Voltron

4 hours ago

Boros card draw?!??!

Awesome!

GHoag on Unesh, Ultimate Guide (Tribal)

5 hours ago

I've never had a High Power Tier Commander and found your list and loved the concepts you've put forward!

I want to build something similar with a more combo leaning and some additional redundancy, so I wanted to see if you'd tried a few cards and get your feedback on them if you're open to it.

Does Reflections Of Littjara function as a slightly more expensive, second copy of Panharmonicon that contributes a little to devotion for Nykthos?

Is Emergence zone a viable second copy of Leyline Of The Void, or does it just suck because it's one turn only and produces only colorless mana?

Have you tried the Isochron Scepter + Dramatic Reversal combo as a functional second copy of Omniscience and maybe even a Mystical tutor to give you infinite turns if you find it plus Isochron and use it to repeatedly fetch Nexus Of Fate without having to FoF through the entire deck leaving only Nexus in it?

That's all for now, but I'm sure I'll have more later.

king-saproling on Counting on Life

7 hours ago

I mean it's infinite damage if S&H has lifelink

Jimmithee on Esper Creative Mode | EDH

7 hours ago

Really like the idea, but imagine explaining out each step of the combo to whoever your playing with lol

FolkOccult on It was Lier! In the …

7 hours ago

I hope your Stromkirk is as cool as your other deck! Vorthos is all I've come to appreciate after my decades of time with the game, tournaments used to be a practice in puzzle solving turned ever so slightly competitive to this new 'non-standard' standard and it's impossibly frustrating to no longer have a standard rotation to supplement EDH organically? It's all power-leveled to the pits and back, it's almost in the benefit of Vorthos (as they now have to print as much as possible every set to inflate those set-lists for collectors and whales) but at the detriment of the game's integral structure. EDH is a perfect game mode for these themed decks, but it leaves a lot to be desired as a whole when you remove 60-card structure decks and remove them, introduce duel decks but only randomly implement them, alter and change the release of every commander precon in a way to find a cheaper manner of printing them (and still releasing entire miscut decks), cut core sets, cut planeswalker decks, introduce an entire Commander Color series with Green and Black but no plan on finishing it because it's been tied to an arbitrary 'spell book' cycle of notably less-viable 'staple' in the theme the commander colors are, remove blocks and act shocked when your 'Multiverse of Madnass' set flops due to lack of narrative congruence. It's all such a big mess that Vorthos benefits and falters in the way it's been introduced as this 'name the guy everyone will flip!' sort of topic per set. Imagine the immense hype put under the inevitable money-leeching return of Nicol Bolas.

Rant aside, sorry, WotC is a wild-ass company now with both of my hobbies since I was a child have been D&D and MtG I've got this sore spot for their recent-most business practices which are ultimately inconsistent and half baked more often than not. Keeping up feels like the name of the game now that every set has to have over 900 cards in four to six treatments to keep customers from statistically pulling much of anything. Resulting in boxes meaning less, fat packs becoming extinct, and boosters as a whole becoming little more than a dopamine spike. I've been playing since Mirrodin and sometimes wish I'd come in later so I didn't know how good it once was. I have the comics, most of the games, read all of their books/novels, but now it's all shallow internet material you can stumble over and easily miss reading (and that's when what you find from recent isn't full of grammatical errors and insane narrative inconsistencies that only show for lazy writing).

If you like Vorthos, most of my decks are Vorthos exclusively. I've been painstakingly creating a cycle of decks per plane, some planes just getting additional decks, but making this three or mono colored cycles of each plane. Naturally Ravnica would be two colors, like Innistrad. They're all fairly classic or nostalgic I'd say, using only cards from sets representing their planes (making Dominaria and now Phyrexia, like Innistrad; suuuuuper stacked in terms of card selection).

Headers13 on Counting on Life

8 hours ago

king-saproling I did consider it, but that counts instances of life gained rather than amount. In my mind I've set the deck up for a few occurrences of large amounts of life gain so I do think it'd be worth the return on investment but I'll keep it in mind, thanks.

Vicarian on Milla Jovovich

9 hours ago

A four-of on Consuming Aberration bothers me a bit. If your intent is for your creatures to help you in the early game, that's a dead draw until at least turn 6 or more (on average, mostly depending on how often you draw land). Mana screw is very real, and hurts in control/mill decks a lot more than aggro decks. I'd cut a couple of those guys for a couple Drown in the Loch.

ecd2294 on Bastion

10 hours ago

I really do like the idea of Valor in Akros. Thanks for the great suggestions.

Liquidbeaver on Ib Halfheart, Goblin Sac-tician [PRIMER]

10 hours ago

enter image description here

What Ib doesn't want anyone to know is that he liked dragons. Likes them likes them. He's just Donkey from Shrek but with hair consolidated in fewer places.

Seanxofthedead on Oops, All Ajanis

10 hours ago

KongMing Great suggestion, was also thinking Vedalken Orrery I'll update the lands as well Thank you!

Liquidbeaver on Ib Halfheart, Goblin Sac-tician [PRIMER]

12 hours ago

Moria Marauder

More ugly cousins coming to join the ranks! Ib will be sure to sacrifice them before the final assault so that they don't make us deck ourselves.

Crow-Umbra on Isshin Homebrew

12 hours ago

Welcome to Tappedout and to Isshin brewing. In looking at your list I have some thoughts and potential suggestions. A few quick questions: Do you have a budget per card or total budget in mind? Is there a particular avenue of Isshin that you have in mind, I see that you mentioned multi-combats.

  • Your deck generally looks solid, but I think you creatures are what could use the most focus in terms of swaps. Stuff like Heliod, Megatron, Hooded Blightfang, Raiyuu, and Academy Manufactor are good, but don't fit this deck super well.

  • If you like Hooded Blightfang, I'd recommend adding some deathtouch anthems like Vault of the Archangel, Ankle Shanker, and/or Kaya, Geist Hunter to really take advantage of its ability. Otherwise, I think you could remove it.

  • If you like that GroupSlug style of play like Hooded Blightfang, I'd recommend checking out other stuff like Hellrider, Brutal Hordechief, Vicious Conquistador, or Infectious Horror, which aren't as narrow in focus to pull off like Blightfang.

  • I think you could probably swap Feed the Swarm for something like Dismantling Wave, Anguished Unmaking, or Vanishing Verse. Mardu has more options for enchantment removal than other color combos with Black in them where Feed the Swarm is one of their few options.

  • Lastly, these are not budget friendly, but are generally good cards for any Isshin strat. I'd recommend checking out Dolmen Gate, which will be getting another reprint in The List pretty soon when the LotR set drops, and Reconnaissance, which is like a pseudo-Vigilance anthem that can save your creatures from combat. This article details how Reconnaissance works a bit more.

I hope these suggestions are helpful. I've had a lot fun playing Isshin for the past year, and I hope you do too.

x1AlphaWolf36 on Minsc, Beloved Ranger CEDH

14 hours ago

Pabs4444 Thank you for taking the time to check out my deck. The main goal of my deck is to win through pod/hulk combos and I have thought about adding other combos enablers like Temur Sabertooth or Restoration Angel for Kiki. When I first built the deck I had them in it but I have found more success by running other combos like Gerrard, Weatherlight Hero and Saffi Eriksdotter loops with Twinshot Sniper in my games. Thank you for the suggestion and sorry to hear Kiki has been glitching on your end. I didn’t do anything special when I made my deck list, besides selecting the version I have show in the decklist. Maybe it’s the version you choose that is glitching. Again thank you for checking out my deck.

UltimateRoxas40 on It was Lier! In the …

15 hours ago

I completely agree, Vorthos is such a fun way to build commander decks. My Lovecraftian deck is Eldritch Captain of the Deep [Lovecraftian Primer], but I'm also stockpiling cards to build a Runo Stromkirk  Flip sea monster deck as well, since he's too good of a Lovecraftian cultist to ignore haha. Shadows over Innistrad and Eldritch Moon are actually the sets that brought me back into Magic for the third time, and I've been playing/trying to keep up ever since.

Spyrechild on Halvar, Divine Voltron

15 hours ago

Waiting patiently to see how busted Andúril, Glamdring and Sting are...

pinecone2k3 on The Nobility Are Athirst

17 hours ago

Cliffhaven Vampire and Marauding Blight-Priest are a couple of additional options to pop off with Exquisite Blood. And Hall of Heliod's Generosity can help you get Exquisite Blood back from your graveyard, if need be. Food for thought.

Kcin on U/B Aggro-Mill

18 hours ago

I have found that Trepanation Blade and Invisible Stalker can do some pretty nasty stuff together. Just something to ponder. +1 from me.

HahaStax on Vito, Lifesucker

20 hours ago

drwombat That's the same reason why I'm also not running Exquisite Blood. With Blood Tribute you have the option to just play it unkicked though, or even point the lifegain damage at someone else. And in case its down to 1v1 - you got a finisher there. But i very much understand your reasoning. :)

ThuperThlayer on That monkey took my spell!

21 hours ago

It's a fun deck. It has ways to win other than stealing spells with the commander, like making all the artifacts into creatures that can attack

Pabs4444 on Minsc, Beloved Ranger CEDH

23 hours ago

I thought I left a comment but I guess I didn't. What are your thoughts on other combos like Temur Sabertooth for dockside or Restoration Angel for Kiki? Speaking of, Kiki has been glitching out on my end. Did you code yours a certain way to be visible?

FolkOccult on It was Lier! In the …

1 day ago

UltimateRoxas40 Thanks! I've been playing for a long while, and have come to a time in my life where the challenge of constructing a proper Vorthos library is the fun I get out of playing this game. To hear of your involvement with an HP Lovecraft deck reminds me of when I'd made one back in Eldritch Moon's release for standard, tons of fun. Those 60 card formats are awfully satisfying to fulfilling these vorthos 'challenges' so to speak. I plan eventually on creating a color pie deck for each pair and using Runo Stromkirk  Flip as the commander to specifically play a role in a Lovecraft inspired deck. I totally recommend taking a look at Halana and Alena, Totally Just Roommates as a fairly consistent Innistrad-only library. Feel free to link your finished deck in the comments, I'd love to see it and allow others who may enjoy this deck to enjoy yours as well!

Oromuerto on Enchanted to Meet You

1 day ago

Or Planar Portal / Ring of Three Wishes, which are more expensive but probably less risk of possibly getting it exiled. Tamiyo's Journal could work but it would take some time to build enough clue tokens.

Oromuerto on Enchanted to Meet You

1 day ago

KingLonsur Would Mangara's Tome not work to search up Approach? There's a slight risk to it, but if you can keep someone from interrupting until you can draw out from under it you should be pretty safe?

RoleSmith on Tezzeret, Master of Bridgebreaker

1 day ago

What about: Tezzert, agent of bolas or Tezzert, Master of metal

GeminiSpartanX on Halvar, Divine Voltron

1 day ago

Forge Anew will definitely make the cut in my deck (which is turning RW now). It's 3 cards in 1! - Part Bruenor Battlehammer, part Leonin Shikari, and part arguably-better Buried Ruin. I'm uncertain if the other 2 will ultimately make the cut for me, but I'll take any equipment support I can get!

UltimateRoxas40 on Nezahal The World Destroyer

1 day ago

Looks fun! I tried to build a similar blue deck with Lier, Disciple of the Drowned. I think he might be a good addition here, since you aren't running too many counterspells, and he can Flashback some of the cards you might have pitched to exile your commander for extra value.

Housegheist on Death and wine

1 day ago

wideline1414 First of, thank you for your vote and comment. :)

I added the monuments for several reasons, like fluff… but i’m casting so mich creature spells, that they trigger pretty often… and the mana-reduction counts for each creature spell i’m casting. I admit, that the suggestet rocks are pretty powerful, but i like the monuments for what they do. Even if they lack a bit in power.

Unfortunately, i do not own a copy of Else… bit if, she would battle for the PW-Slot against Lili… since Lili was my first ever drawn PW, i would assume that i can’t dismiss her :oD

Thanks for pointing put the misscount. It’s corrected, Body Launderer has to go for the Battle Angels of Tyr

NensouHiebara on Halvar, Divine Voltron

1 day ago

Some nice Equipment support coming out of the Lord of the Rings set.