Rhymenocerous on Yidris V. 2 Bracket 3/4
2 hours ago
Lands are a bit expensive so I'm playing with swapping them for cheaper pain lands, battlebond and fast lands
xram666 on 99 Ways to lose (Nihilist)
2 hours ago
Hi. Till now I only know the 60 card format anbd legendofa pointed me to the deck and the rules. With normal nihilist I found the worst deck was a deck with only overcoted 1/1 with "crappy" effects. Cards like:
So we dicided the decks should have a theme a should be enyoable to play. So the focus is more to create a crappy but fun deck with cards you haven't seen at all or very seldom.
Maybe we will try the commander variant also.
@ Pikobyte The rules for 60 card nihilist I know state that the decks have to be two-colored. If you would adopt this to your EDH-nihilist rules Phage the Untouchable would be out.
legendofa on The Worst EDH Ever
4 hours ago
xram666 PhyrexianDoughnut There are actually a few Nihilist Commander decks floating around this site! I never played, but Pikobyte's deck 99 Ways to lose (Nihilist) introduced me to the format. The rules for the Commander version are in the description there.
pkcentral on Sydri Galvanic Genius
4 hours ago
What does Encroaching Mycosynth do? Also, 32 lands Austin? I taught you better.
psionictemplar on Mono White Knights
6 hours ago
I am going to suggest Solitude over Path to Exile. I do realize this goes against what an aggro deck is trying to do but it's potentially free and allows you to deploy more threats while dealing with your opponents board. Not to mention it can benefit from the Benalish Marshal stat increase.
GutterbonesMan on This Deck Owes You An …
12 hours ago
Profet93 I am open to any suggestions, curious to hear yours as you usually have good ones!
xram666 on The Worst EDH Ever
12 hours ago
Some other candidates for the deck
- Cyclopean Snare best control piece ever
- Firedrinker Satyr such a good blocker
- Goblin Pyromancer as replacement for Mogg Squad
- Flailing Manticore such a good beater
- Staff of the Ages as the are playing so many basics this is a must have
- The Biblioplex it is a rare land. It must be good
- Goblin Test Pilot free shocks. Perfect!
- Zephyr Spirit best creature ever
This deck is very reminiscent of the Nihilist format. The only resource I know of with the rules is a German page: https://magic.freizeitspieler.de/nihilist.php.
The aim of the format is to construct a playable but poor deck. Here are some basic rules for deck construction (60 card decks):
- Only two colours
- at least 16 basic lands in matching colours (8 of each colour).
- at least 22 lands
- at least 16 creatures with a power of 1 or higher that can attack
- etc.
Hand the deck to the player on your left and play a game of Magic (the first deck gets three points, the second two points, and the third one point). Repeat this process until everyone has played with every deck at the table, except their own. The winner is the deck creator whose deck has the fewest points. It could be done in Commander, but the games would take up the whole evening.
Profet93 on This Deck Owes You An …
17 hours ago
what type of suggestions r u looking for? Any budget or meta considerations GutterbonesMan? How about weaknesses you want to improve? Combos?
DemonDragonJ on Nature's Bounty
19 hours ago
I have replaced Shared Summons with Stampede Surfer, because, as great as the instant was, the creature is a better match for the theme and strategy of this deck.
jonjonhholt on Glittering Luxknight
19 hours ago
if youre running Toxin Analysis and a bunch of artifacts, i would highly recommend running Krark-Clan Shaman. if not in your main board then at least in your sideboard
FrostBytes on Kaho, Meme Historian
21 hours ago
SufferFromEDHD Excellent suggestions! This deck is definitely the definition of a glass cannon and will be a lot of fun to pilot! All of your suggestions are fantastic. I might leave this list barebones and create an “ultimate Meme Historian” list (in which you would be tagged. :) )
Coward_Token on Gishath Spared No Expense!!!
23 hours ago
While I'm normally a fan of 2 mana ramp, what you got here is an 8 mana commander in a 4.32 MV deck. I feel like this is the time to go big or go home.
Overgrowth Somberwald Sage Thran Dynamo Shadow in the Warp Semblance Anvil
You already mentioned Smothering Tithe but I don't see enough of a reason to skip it, it can easily let you get a turn 5 Gish
miracleHat on No
23 hours ago
Win con suggestion... perhaps not best on theme except for triggering an opponent beyond all reason - Hair-Strung Koto (just as a single card).
Murrow on My Name is Eldrazi Montoya...
1 day ago
Okay I should've been ready for the description but I wasn't lmfao.
As for the deck. This is my kind of Eldrazi deck! And it feels smooth from the hands I was drawing.
Murrow on My Name is Eldrazi Montoya...
1 day ago
I'm not gonna lie I clicked because of the name and am still laughing about it haha. Thanks for that! And now I'll give the deck a look lol.
ChaseyK on Spelldown
1 day ago
xram666 thanks for the suggestion. I like Deep Analysis, but it has a couple problems here.
The first is that the flashback cost has no real drawback when you're playing without life points. It's just two mana for two cards, which might be a little too strong compared to the other cards. The second is the flashback itself. While it would be an interesting tool both players could have access to in a shared graveyard, I don't want any cards to be able to exile themselves from play.
A variant of this that heavily utilizes flashback cards could be really cool, it's just not what I'm going for with this list.
Balaam__ on Black Burner
1 day ago
That’s fair. I have a Modern variation of this deck where I run Bump, and I found I had to go out of my way to make mention in the description that I wouldn’t be adding any red producing lands. Anyway, I love any deck that pushes against established conventions, so this gets a +1 from me.
amarthaler on Cheesecake Factory
1 day ago
Cool concept, +1. Maybe some Bone Shards for removal and Blood Fountain just so you don't miss the recursion?
LycanoftheDarknessFlame on Rakdos Wizards
1 day ago
Do you still not have the vivi's? i got lucky yesterday i did 5 drafts and opened him 3 times XD
jarid250 on Black Burner
1 day ago
Yeeeah, and I don't exactly want to play tap lands to be able to pay the flashback cost.. and it wouldn't be a mono black burn deck anymore, which is sort of the novelty.
I opted for Fruit of Tizerus instead, but then thought I needed a few more creatures, so I tried Serrated Scorpion.. which I might swap out for Basilica Screecher.
The deck's still a WIP.
Balaam__ on Black Burner
1 day ago
No Bump in the Night? I can only presume it’s because of the pip in the Flashback cost.
lhetrick13 on Gishath Spared No Expense!!!
1 day ago
shepherdofangels - Thanks for the upvote! Actually just sitting down to take a look at this deck as it has been months since I have had it put together and piloted so any suggestions would be welcome!
Belfore on Hazezon Desert Ranger [HELP]
1 day ago
sorta think Awaken the Woods should go in. Could be a funny close out.
Optimator on Spear-It Airlines
1 day ago
So far the deck, despite being pure Voltron with a middling commander, has performed well. The flying has really been more of a help than I thought it would. My playgroup sometime has six players and does 2v2v2 and the deck kind of shines there. Nice! I never pegged it to be seriously competitive but it certainly works in those games. It's a love-letter to Cid anyway, so it's all gravy baby.
NV_1980 on Hic Sunt Dracones
1 day ago
Damn, that's one expensive looking deck :):) I think adding Rivaz of the Claw could really benefit you, both for his overpowered mana-ability as well as his amazing recursion option. Parapet Thrasher can provide some nice card advantage as well as other utility, while Scourge of Valkas can put in some hurt with this many dragons featured in your deck. Ow, and considering your treasure sub-theme, I'm really missing Goldlust Triad in here too.
I'd perhaps also try to include some more card-advantage options, considering your deck currently contains almost no additional resources to draw more cards. Interesting options on this front could include Colossal Majesty, Garruk's Uprising or Herd Heirloom. Lastly, some more options to give your dragons haste could prove nice, like Rhythm of the Wild or Hanweir Battlements Flip Meld.
Have fun with this brew!
The_0bserver on 99 Lands EDH
1 day ago
As a possible add to this list. Marneus Calgar, generate tokens and draw more cards.
NV_1980 on Mid Budget Enchantment Prison
1 day ago
Interesting brew, though I must admit I'm not seeing any true win-conditions in it (yet). Since you're big on taxes, I think Sphere of Safety would be almost perfect for this deck.
SufferFromEDHD on Kaho, Meme Historian
1 day ago
Great use of an overlooked legend from an overlooked block! Might as well sneak a playset of utility land into this glass cannon:
Cavern of Souls guaranteed Kaho
Minamo, School at Water's Edge double the instantaneous trouble
Dust Bowl the really long game haha
Glacial Chasm cumulative upkeep isn't great but 20 turns is a long clock, attacking is irrelevant :) not producing mana hurts the most and why it was suggested last
SufferFromEDHD on Modified Bedecked Brokers
1 day ago
Gemstone Mine the OG vivid land
Lion Sash Scavenging Ooze #2
Phantom Nomad/Phantom Tiger solid creatures. Built in recursion. On curve.
vaati4554 on Choices, Choices
1 day ago
while it would certainly be better to make The Valeyard the commander, eggman is cooler I don't make the rules.
IRREVERENCY on Her Love Is Like Bad …
1 day ago
DreadKhan found another, a bit more clunky but it works -Progenitor's Icon seems another good way to flash it in, and it can work multiple times as well as function as a mana rock!
DemonDragonJ on Battle Hymn of the Seraphim
1 day ago
I have replaced Sacred Peaks with Radiant Summit, since the newer land is strict;y better than is the former land.
DemonDragonJ on Death and Rebirth
1 day ago
I have replaced Wastewood Verge with Vernal Fen, because, as great as the verge was, the fen better suits my playing style.
DemonDragonJ on All Will Be One
1 day ago
I have replaced Kalonian Hydra with Ouroboroid, which reduced the average converted mana cost of this deck from 3.62 to 3.60, because the wurm does not need to attack in order for its ability to trigger and also uses the creature's entire power, not merely the number of +1/+1 counters on it.
DemonDragonJ on Life Springs Eternal
1 day ago
I have replaced Dazzling Angel with Haliya, Guided by Light, because, as fond as I am of angels, Haliya's additional ability is too useful for me to not put her into this deck, and I expect that it shall be trivially easy to gain 3 or more life, per turn, in this deck.
Coldpyro on Kenrith the Combat King
1 day ago
The fact that you have so many ways to have infinite mana is a big turn on towards the deck from my viewpoint.
Very fun way to use Kenrith!
enraged on Anara & Tymna destroy the …
1 day ago
I love a purposeful deck this is clearly very powerful and well built. Way to 'cut the fat' and only play powerful interesting effects. Interesting partner too. Well done.
Coldpyro on Anara & Tymna destroy the …
1 day ago
Hey man, gave you a +1. This deck looks amazing! Thank you for your advice on my shroofus deck, i did add the doubling season and changed it up a little after play testing. operating like a champ.
SufferFromEDHD on The Sibsig Ceremony
1 day ago
Shizo, Death's Storehouse evasion for both commanders
Cabal Pit potentially clear the path
