ArmchairRuler on How does Rayami, interact with …
9 minutes ago
Does Rayami, First of the Fallen
gain abilities that are only present on the exiled card if the creature dying meets certain criteria? Ex: Weathered Sentinels would give Vigilance, Reach, and trample if sacrificed during my main phase, but would it also grant Rayami Indestructible if I were to sacrifice it during combat when it is attacking?
moo1234 on Card creation challenge
2 hours ago
The Polar Express
Legendary Artifact - Vehicle
When ~ enters the battlefield create 3 coal tokens
Crew - Sacrifice 2 coal tokens
Whenever ~ deals combat damage if you control 10 humans you win the game
'It's not about where you're going, it's about getting on'
2/4
it's jolly time.
Make either the conductor from the Polar Express or the Grinch
Edenjal on [Primer] Karametra's Bounce House
3 hours ago
So glad to see you are working on this again in 2025! I made a Karametra deck in 2019 and used this for some card ideas. And here I am, doing it yet again!
seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge
5 hours ago
Siegebreaker Train
Artifact - Vehicle
Haste, Trample
Whenever you sacrifice a coal token, this artifact gets +2/+0 until end of turn.
Whenever this artifact deals combat damage to a player, you create that many coal tokens.
Crew 3
6/2
I'd like to see something else with coal tokens.
Balaam__ on Abzan Loampox/// Modern
14 hours ago
Haakon, Stromgald Scourge is an awesome card to build around, this list looks quite nice. +1
Control EDH
by Zazi
Esper879 on Fire Lord (Work In Progress)
17 hours ago
Superstrength79 I like the idea. I'll take your suggestion and run a few games. I actually just picked up 4 copies for my Pioneer Hare Apparent deck. Thank you!
Voodoo_Gremlin on Greedy Ghost and Nightmare Cat
17 hours ago
KayneMarco, I've been trying to shift the deck towards more +1/+1 counter and away from Aristocrats. The aristocrat creatures that I do have give themselves, or others, +1/+1 counters and scry selection with Viscera Seer. The other use they have is send creatures to the graveyard rather than exile when someone casts Sunfall (or another exiling wrath) so I want free sac outlets. I also have pretty bad luck with drawing lands in this deck and the can be hard to hold up sometimes. All that being said Dust Animus isn't really performing for bad luck reasons so I'll give Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim another chance.
Profet93 on Ultima (Lemme Suck Ya Lands)
21 hours ago
Thanks for the shoutout in the description, I appreciate it. On that note, you state Winter Orb but then reference winter moon (from a previous deck iteration), might wanna change that when you get a chance.
I will say, with a relatively high cmc (colorless deck so understandable), more ramp would serve you very well. Perhaps replacing some of your high CMC creatures and swapping them for additional ramp and/or simple eldrazi swaps for a more cohesive/unified build with more relevant abilities that can assist you in the destruction of your opponents hopes and dreams that they foolishly cling to.
From my perspective (correct me if I'm wrong), your deck is moderately-commander reliant given all of the equipment + trigger doubling you have. Getting quicker access to your commander in the early game can be crucial for locking opponents out, forcing removal and applying pressure. Ramp is crucial for this, especially with your high avg cmc.
Mana Vault - Turn 2 commander is strong
Expedition Map - Help find urza lands or utility lands like marit lage combo.
Mind Stone - Ramp when you need it, draw when you don't.
As far as other misc suggestions go, here are some to tickle your fancy.....
Unwinding Clock - Untap more than 30% of your deck. Works best with more mana rocks, especially useful with your flash engines to be able to "be like the blue player." Not an entirely serious suggestion but worth noting should you wish to optimize the deck by cutting high cmc cards that aren't greatly impactful and leaning towards the strengths of the deck. More playtesting is probably needed to see which direction you wanna take the deck in.
Sword of Feast and Famine - Pro black removal, pro green creatures, very common colors in EDH. Untapping lands and discarding is great.
berryjon on Card creation challenge
22 hours ago
Steam Tank
Artifact - Vehicle
Crew 2
You may tap two Coal tokens instead of paying this Vehicle's Crew cost.
, Sacrifice a Coal: +1/+0 until the end of the turn.
3/3
Another coal-powered vehicle, please!
RaphaelRaven on Avatar Aang
23 hours ago
The boulder - toph earthbending master vindictive warden - badgermole cub enlightened tutor - deflecting swat redirect lightning - firebender ascension fierce guardianship - enlightened tutor appa steadfast - yue moon spirit badgermole - earth kings lieutenant
TijuanaBachelorParty on Halvar, Divine Voltron
1 day ago
Sweet deck! +1
I would love to see this deck in person as a lot of love has been put into it.
Balaam__ on List of Bugs and Feature …
1 day ago
Today’s deck cycles haven’t replenished for me, has the bug reappeared?
TijuanaBachelorParty on Allied Invasion
1 day ago
A very cool deck! +1
I appreciate the commitment to the theme. My suggestions are the Avatar the Last Airbender cards that lean more into Ally that etb strategies that do not use bending abilities. There are some solid cards that could be useful for the deck - up to you for flavor!
South Pole Voyager would be a great include, adding in life-gain and a little draw if you can trigger it again. United Front can add numerous bodies to the battlefield, hopefully triggering many other allies. Allied Teamwork leans into the go-wide strategy like this. Earth King's Lieutenant and Appa, the Vigilant can both add some serious power to your creatures. Hakoda, Selfless Commander is pseudo-card advantage and protection. Finally, Katara, the Fearless is a Panharmonicon for your allies, no bending, except in the art.
JassicaElla60 on RDW: Enchantment Removal?
1 day ago
In Pioneer, enchantment removal is efficient but color-dependent. White leads with Leyline Binding, Portable Hole, and Get Lost, while green offers Haywire Mite and Krosan Grip–style effects. Black and red rely on discard or damage workarounds. Think of it like —targeted, thoughtful, and best when chosen for the right moment.
BlondieN8 on The Rackoning [Competitive Budget]
1 day ago
dgalarza, The short answer is yes. During playtesting, the biggest challenges have been handling Planeswalkers and keeping momentum. Since the announcement, I have been editing a copy of this deck behind the scenes and will publish the edit here at a later time.
dgalarza on The Rackoning [Competitive Budget]
1 day ago
Love that you're taking 8-Rack off the beaten path by doubling down and going 12-Rack! Do you ever feel like you're missing some utility in this list? The more recent versions of Rack I've seen go down to 7 or even 6.
FauxFaux on Card creation challenge
1 day ago
Soot Elemental
Creature - Elemental Shaman
Whenever a creature is dealt excess damage, create that many tapped Coal Tokens.
Whenever ~ attacks or blocks, deal 1 damage to target creature blocked or blocking ~.
2/3
"Embers are but a breath away from a raging inferno."
Create a value engine for Coal Tokens, like an outlet to use them in a unique way, or as an alternate cost!
Tsukimi on Painting Love, Painting Life
1 day ago
Clair Obscur decks get an upvote on theme alone! I really love the theming you decided on, fits well with the mood of E33. AT a quick glance, composer of spring always stand out to me as a card I have never gotten good results from even in an enchantment heavy deck.
seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge
1 day ago
Chandra, Hellfire Extinguisher
Legendary Creature - Chandra
Sorcery spells you cast cost less to cast for each planeswalker card in your graveyard.
0 You may sacrifice another creature or planeswalker. Put X loyalty counters on Chandra, where X is the number of counters on the sacrificed permanent.
-X Destroy target nonland permanent with mana value X or less. You create X coal tokens. (It's an artifact token with ", sacrifice this token: The next time a source you control would deal noncombat damage this turn, it deals that much damage plus 1 instead.")
Chandra, Hellfire Extinguisher can be your commander.
5
Let's see more coal tokens.
yeaGO on Deck not showing up in …
1 day ago
if you edit the deck it should appear now if its not there already
Profet93 on Big Kozi (Bracket 3)
1 day ago
what kind of suggestion r u looking for? Budget or meta considerations?
PhotogenicParasympathetic on Card creation challenge
1 day ago
Chandra, Heir to Teixcalaan
+1: Until your next turn, your opponents can't attack you unless they pay 2 life for each attacking creature.
-2: Chandra deals 2 damage to each creature and to each planeswalker your opponents control.
-5: Create four 1/1 white monk tokens. Until the end of your turn, each creature you control gains prowess and haste.
3
Her name is a little nod to "A Memory Called Empire" for Arkady Martine fans. Thought it fit with the theme for Ixalan, plus fit the request for a sun-warrior type. My focus was on a Chandra who uses her fire to augment those around her, or to redirect an opponent, rather than just striking our for herself.
Next challenge, make another Chandra in whatever colors you like, to represent the mourning we might have gotten if Nissa had died.
bradtheimpaler13 on The Cutest Thief That Ever …
1 day ago
Crypt Incursion could be a huge chunk of lifegain and can help against recursion decks or other graveyard centric decks
jack552 on Spelltable?
1 day ago
Spelltable is great for casual Commander, but it’s pretty basic. It won’t add digital tokens, counters, or let you transfer cards—you still manage those yourself. It mainly just makes it easier for everyone to see the game. Kind of like Bus Simulator Indonesia—the game is fun and immersive, but you still control a lot to make the experience realistic. Check it out here: https://bussimulator-apk.com/
jack552 on Spelltable?
1 day ago
Spelltable works well for casual Commander, but it’s pretty simple. It won’t create digital tokens or counters, and you can’t transfer cards between players—you still handle that yourself. It mainly just gives a clear way to play through webcam.
Same vibe as for me: the core experience is solid, but you still manage a few things on your own. Still makes the game fun and easy to jump into.
Murrow on Extra Value Meal
1 day ago
DubMC thanks a ton and I like that Devour Intellect suggestion I was wondering what kind of treasure related cards might be out there.
clayperce on Zurgo's Workforce Reduction Plan (Zurgo …
2 days ago
Greets!
I've been working on the manabase for my Bracket 3 Zurgo deck over on Moxfield, and I've been super-impressed with the Mardu Triome (Savai Triome) and Battlebond lands (Luxury Suite, Spectator Seating, and Vault of Champions). Might be worth checking out ...
Cheers!
DubMC on Extra Value Meal
2 days ago
Blood Pet into Bone Picker is awesome. Devour Intellect seems like it could be good here since you have a few ways to make Treasure tokens. Great deck so far!
MilesHiles on Breya, Mistress of Machines
2 days ago
Looks like a fun build! Seems like a lot of lands for a deck with some many mana rocks though. You might want to consider ditching a couple of Plain and playing Deflecting Swat and/or Fierce Guardianship. The Avatar reprints have knocked the pricing down for them again and they would both help with free anti-removal for Breya, Etherium Shaper
DreadKhan on Buggs Bunny and Friends
2 days ago
I think it's the kind of Commander that's very happy in a high bracket pod, so I had fun testing it other than those issues I mentioned! I've had issues with it in lower brackets where it's too much value for mana, but in Bracket 4 this is very reasonable, and it's a lot more entertaining than something like Voja, Jaws of the Conclave.
I think tokens are more fun than something like Artifacts or Lands, especially if you're heavy on creature tokens (which can be dealt with more easily).
DreadKhan on King Gizzard And The Lizard …
2 days ago
It's always nice to see someone bother with Un stuff, especially at higher power levels! Lots of cool ideas were smuggled in!
DubMC on Burn the Library Down
2 days ago
I know it enters tapped, but Restless Reef could be a good option against control decks that counter. This inspires me to build a mill deck, I've never made one.
legendofa on Card creation challenge
2 days ago
Jaya, Sunburst Elder
Legendary Planeswalker - Jaya
+1 Create a 1/1 white Monk creature token with prowess.
+1 You and target opponent each draw a card.
-2 Until your next turn, whenever a creature attacks you or a planeswalker you control, Jaya deals 2 damage to that creature.
-7 You get an emblem with "Whenever a creature you control blocks or becomes blocked, it deals 2 damage to target attacking or blocking creature."
4
Same sardonic and unsubtle personality, different magical focus. I imagine this version of Keral Keep founded in her honor would be a solar temple mixing weapons training with magic, rather than a fire monastery with just magic training. Chandra might end up as after studying there.
Let's make that the challenge. Create a version of Chandra who augments her pure pyromancy with weapons and solarmancy. (Is that a word?)
legendofa on Golgari Beats
2 days ago
jonjonhholt I never noticed that Bushwhack had a common print. This should be a clean switch.
legendofa on Tortex Birdturbo >:)
2 days ago
Sounds like you got it figured out. The different synergies here feel really good.
