Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Mark3sie on Can't get a backround photo …

19 minutes ago

I tried copying the dropbox copy link into the description with no luck. How can I fix this? Thanks.

carpecanum on Feather

29 minutes ago

Death Ward , Twinflame

Descent of the Dragons , any "divide damage among target creatures" spells. As long as you target one of your own creatures the spell returns to hand

Azure_Lightning on Mizzix of the Izmagnus: Ride …

1 hour ago

Veyran, Voice of Duality would give Mizzix extra counters if they're both out. And Harmonic Prodigy and Pyromancer's Goggles are also nice too. Shatterskull Smashing  Flip is a nice removal/X spell, and Valakut Awakening  Flip is a nice wheel effect, you're not discarding cards and only you get to draw them

josheheh75 on Dark Depths EDH

1 hour ago

send me back to 2020

thewildwookiee on No Commander Infect

2 hours ago

could you make a more expensive version of this deck?

LunchBox1211 on Card creation challenge

2 hours ago

I have no idea what the Dominarian weather cycle is like, but I also know there were many time rifts open at one point, so I feel like anything is possible.


Vacant Tolarian Academy

Legendary Snow Land

: Scry X, where X is the number of Snow permanents you control.

Discard your hand, : Add equal to the number of artifacts you control. Activate only if you have 5 or more cards in hand.

With all the students taking a much needed break, the teachers finally have a chance to learn.


Tolarian Academy is letting out for winter break! Make another card that is based off a banned EDH card. (Bonus points for basing it off of Iona, Shield of Emeria .)

QuietMyth on Competitive Aurelia Com(bat/bo)

2 hours ago

shizznitskii Doesn't equip the equipment, so, not even a little bit. Kinda makes me feel like you don't read cards

jclaust on Legacy Enchantress, "Enchantress's Wish" Primer

3 hours ago

SynergyBuild

A mistake. I Copied/Pasted various times for another Enchantress deck that I brewed, piloted and scrapped; conincidentally, this was explained in the above message. Thank you for your assistance.

Keep brewing.

jclaust on Legacy Enchantress, "Enchantress's Wish" Primer

3 hours ago

abby315

Although this Enchantress build does not highlight MH2 cards, I have piloted and tested a more traditional yet new White-Green Enchantress list that includes Destiny Spinner, Sythis and Green Sun's Zenith.

It was brought to my attention that it resembles another deck list this Monday, which convinced me to forego the pursuit because of nearly identifcal MB (Differed in Sb Philosophy). Plus, the individual has more time for this than I for Legacy. I just like playing it.

https://www.mtggoldfish.com/deck/1120885#online

Ender02 on Selesnyan Stampede

3 hours ago

What to remove from this deck to make room for some new stuff?

zapyourtumor on Azorius Aggro — Pioneer Edition

3 hours ago

When I read "azorius aggro - pioneer" the first thing that came to mind was a Clever Lumimancer blitz deck. Maybe that isn't the direction you want to go here though.

Dedooraths on Show of Confidence

3 hours ago

It's definitely an interesting deck but without removal it can be overrun. The idea to go full color protection spells might counteract that though not sure.

1empyrean on inniaz, the gale force

4 hours ago

Since you want to give people useless stuff, Coveted Jewel is incredible for Inniaz, and Pendant of Prosperity cool if you want to play nice with the person sitting to your right.

Grubbernaut on Eternal Command

4 hours ago

The vials seem really out of place, to me. You might sub them for baubles, consider goyf or jvp over the 3 drops, and add lurrus as your companion; it's just so dang strong to have a free creature that gives card advantage.

I also think having only two discard spells is a tough plan to execute, especially with control. You'll rarely get them t1, and they're usually bad topdecks late game.

Cheers, I love sultai.

Oof_Magic on My MH2 Deck will ▷BREAK◁ …

4 hours ago

I think the interaction Grief (and all Incarnations) have with Ephemerate / Malakir Rebirth  Flip will get it banned.

Why is Mind Twist banned in Legacy? Oh right. Because making your opponent discard multiple cards on the first turn is almost a win on its own. And then you throw in a body. Strikes me as being on par with Eye of Ugin for a couple Mimics into three Thought-Knot Seers coming in on turn 2. I would say it’s a bit inconsistent but I would have said the same about crazy Eye of Ugin Eldrazi starts. This is just explosive disruption in place of explosive aggression. But it’s gonna get whacked. Then again, WotC may protect their new cardboard by banning around it like Hogaak. Or they may go do the throat like they did with Tibalt's Trickery . But if we start seeing maindeck Leyline of Sanctity (outside of new Enchantress builds) to deal with Grief the same way we saw maindeck Leyline of the Void to combat Hogaak, then we’re definitely looking at a ban. I worry that if a ban is necessary, WotC will hit Rebirth (not a particularly old cardboard) as banning Ephemerate would not only keep the interaction alive but in its more consistent colors. Regardless, the vultures are circling and Grief is ripe.

Dedooraths on Starter Black Deck

4 hours ago

The changes stated previously are for these reasons; Removal of the Walking Corpses, A 2 mana 2/2 is good on the vanilla test but with no abilities it's worth the switch ( Audacious Thief for card draw, Blightbeetle for a 2 drop which is good against green decks, this is what Walking Corpses should be; Sanitarium Skeleton is a 1 drop that recurs unless exiled and has a better vanilla test (3/1 instead of 4/2 or 2/1)

Removal of 2x Skeleton Archer; Skeleton Archer has an underwhelming ability and statline for a 4 cmc card, however one copy was kept to help remove tokens from the enemy board with it's pings. Dread Presence is a slightly costlier card at 1 dollar instead of 2 cents, but this comes with the upside of the same cmc with the same ability but 4 times better and likely every turn not just once. Boneclad Necromancer is 1 cmc higher than Skeleton Archer however it synergizes better with the deck due to dropping multiple bodies on the field.

Removal of Finishing Blow; Due to the nature of this being a starter deck and the rarity of planeswalkers in newer games this removal spell is just bad. Murder is 2 cmc and does the same thing to creatures ( doesn't target planeswalkers but that doesn't matter as stated before ). Bone Splinters is a sorcery however is only 1 cmc and this deck has sacrifice fodder so there isn't much downside.

TheRavenMVP on inniaz, the gale force

4 hours ago

Ooh, thats an interesting commander

CommanderNeyo on Jadzi topdeck

4 hours ago

Have you considered adding Sensei's Divining Top ?

Prospekt on Modern Treefolk Tribal

4 hours ago

Wabbajacke I don't think Faeburrow Elder would be very useful because Doran is the only other multicolored card in the deck, so Birds of Paradise and Bosk Banneret are better for ramping mana here.

Colfenor, the Last Yew has a nice effect but I think it just costs too much for what it does. If it costed 2 or even 1 less it would be worth considering.

Meanwhile, Battlewand Oak and Everbark Shaman are solid choices but just aren't as strong as the beaters that I'm using.

Thank you for the suggestions!

Epicurus on Look at me, I am …

4 hours ago

Evolution Sage and Drop of Honey . Though I haven't the slightest idea what you would drop for them.

Absolutely love this shytt.

Dedooraths on Starter Green Deck

4 hours ago

1x Leafkin Druid replace 1x Humble Naturalist (This change is in place due to the nature of this deck having more creature so Leafkin Druid is more likely to tap for 2)

SourRnaGrapes on Radha Gruul/Landfall

4 hours ago

TheMeadiator thank you, it's exactly as fun as it looks - especially in a 1v1!

Dedooraths on Starter Black Deck

4 hours ago

1x Audacious Thief 1x Blightbeetle 1x Sanitarium Skeleton replace 3x Walking Corpses

1x Boneclad Necromancer 1x Dread Presence replace 2x Skeleton Archer

1x Murder 1x Bone Splinters replace 2x Finishing Blow

HobbyMan5000 on Rakdos Wins

4 hours ago

I’m sorry but to say you might be a little young and criticizing and trying to sound like you know what you’re talking about it someone else’s expense is just rude.

magwaaf on GRAND AHBITAH

4 hours ago

I need 1 cut to add 1 basic

HobbyMan5000 on Rakdos Wins

5 hours ago

I saw your page mr 2 turn win, instead of criticizing other people’s decks why don’t you try playing something that makes you the underdog, so many people are playing the same competitive bull crap I like decks that are against the norm like underdog decks with cards that are not meant to be played together, when they say don’t play this card with that card the first thing I do is put them together,

MULRAH on COVID/Cockatrice Commander Cube

5 hours ago

Here's another update that seems small but is still swapping out nearly ten percent of the cube! These shifts address a few things:

  1. Residual redundancies from recent decks: In keeping with my "universal singleton" rule, I'm replacing any cards that have found a better home in a specific deck.
  2. Multicolor miscellany: A number of multicolor spells were effected by #1, and I found the "archetype support" this section had been providing was a little inconsistent. As a result, I just went with more general effects here.
  3. Recent sets: I brought in a few changes from Kaldheim, Strixhaven, and their associated Commander products. We'll see if these stick, but for now they look exciting!

I notably skipped over Commander Legends because I suspect that set will merit its own overhaul. In fact, I'm considering adding 90 cards to the "sideboard," which I'd add in whenever we have an extra player. I'm holding off on that for now to focus on this more minor update.

Changes

  • Mentor of the Meek --> Archaeomancer's Map
  • Paradigm Shift --> Mystic Reflection
  • Folio of Fancies --> Prosperity
  • Harvester of Souls --> Living Death
  • Painful Quandary --> Stinging Study
  • Murderous Rider --> Rise of the Dread Marn
  • Sudden Spoiling --> Cunning Rhetoric
  • Rolling Earthquake --> Crackle with Power
  • Impact Resonance --> Tibalt's Trickery
  • Treasure Nabber --> Cursed Mirror
  • Dwynen's Elite --> Elvish Warmaster
  • Quest for Renewal --> In Search of Greatness
  • Burnished Hart --> Skyclave Relic
  • Commander's Sphere --> Chromatic Lantern
  • Dreamstone Hedron --> Belbe's Portal
  • Hedron Archive --> Primal Amulet
  • Blackblade Reforged --> Illusionist's Bracers
  • Rogue's Passage --> War Room
  • Temple of the False God --> Ghost Quarter
  • Growth Spiral --> Oversimplify
  • Sorin, Vengeful Bloodlord --> Kaya the Inexorable
  • Dance of the Manse --> Spell Queller
  • Havengul Lich --> Sire of Stagnation
  • Master of Cruelties --> Captive Audience
  • Dragonlair Spider --> Atarka's Command
  • Ashen Rider --> Inkshield
  • Poison-Tip Archer --> Underrealm Lich
  • Sunforger --> Outlaws' Merriment

RNR_Gaming on The Pragmatist's Pet

5 hours ago

Environment dependent. If its casual edh and I have a sentimental connection to a card/deck I probably won't tear it all apart. If it's a sanctioned format and the deck is meant for tournment play 100% cutting suboptimal cards. I love lantern control and everytime the list got new toys you best believe I made the upgrades.

Femme_Fatale on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

5 hours ago

superbed: They still have bugs with them, but are getting fixed gradually.

Draconian712 on Stormpy

5 hours ago

Rockman1967 Yeah! I haven’t gotten around to finishing the deck, was playing around with the new MH2 cards to see if I could brew a storm/ stompy hybrid

TheMeadiator on Radha Gruul/Landfall

5 hours ago

Love a good gruul deck! This looks really fun. +1 for my gruul friend

Femme_Fatale on List of Bugs and Feature …

5 hours ago

Enlightened_Magi: To learn how to denote card variations, please check the site updates forum for the indepth thread on that very subject. As for the see all printings button, that seems to have been the case though I don't know why.

zapyourtumor on Rakdos Wins

5 hours ago

ItsMeJax I think they might be a little young ._.

Besides swapping out the go for the throats for push, why do you have 3 copies of Manamorphose ? I don't really see any cards in the deck that benefit from the draw, storm count, or instant cast trigger. And even though Rakdos has a really restrictive mana cost, you definitely have plenty of dual lands for a 2 color deck, so I don't think you need to worry about that.

SynergyBuild on Legacy Enchantress, "Enchantress's Wish" Primer

6 hours ago

Why not run the last Sythis in the sideboard, it's fetchable from both wishes?

zapyourtumor on W/U/b MH2 Urza

6 hours ago

I suppose its unfortunate that Power Depot can't tap for U for whir. Honestly, I'm not sure how useful power depot even is for this deck, since I don't see much artifact sac besides foundry. If you cut some of those and add more U lands, I think you could definitely play whir (plus Urza gives you a lot of U mana).

Gleeock on Indiana Jones: the 40th Anniversary

6 hours ago

It is difficult for me to pinpoint exactly what made said skull movie that much less enjoyable. I mean impossible survival moments and jumping the shark in that way is present in all of them. It is noticeable that fight or confrontations seem less inspired. Most the movies confrontations or chases historically show pretty ironclad character motivations. I felt like there where more moments in Skull movie where the scenes were more stunts for the sake of stunt without motivations. Like, why am I still sword fighting on this unstable surface?

Mechanon on Metallurgy Beatdown

6 hours ago

Frosto I would usually just sac a creature with Fling if its subject to some kind of burn or removal. That might be handy though, thanks.