Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Foster_I_Am on Necronomicon | Teysa Karlov | …

8 minutes ago

Masterful Thanks for that insight! Yeah I thought Sultai Emissary was not that great and my buddies all said "mehh" lol. But now that you explained it that way - ?It might be worth adding in to test. Still not to sure how I feel about manifesting a land. The interaction with Broodmoth seems a bit niche as well. Just doesn't seem all that "consistent"

Of those I do think Ministrant or Sultai might be the cut (leaning towards Sultai). I cut Hallowed Spiritkeeper as well but looking back - It was always a solid card for me, won me a few games haha.

Keep the updates and thoughts coming!

FormOverFunction on The Great Planeswalker Debate

23 minutes ago

I feel like the swarm of blink stuff is actually filling a void that was created when the bounce-line was started, connecting the dots between the old Boomerang-like cards and Restoration Angel. The good news is I think we’re approaching that vacuum being filled. I feel like there will be a consistent anti-PW stream, with a potential spike if there’s another War of the Spark type of event/plot. The one thing I worry (for lack of a better term) about is WotC’s apparent hesitancy to “ruin people’s fun” by “not letting people play with their planeswalkers” (see: legend rule change). As we swerve deeper into the solitaire style of play it could result in less of that “break other people’s board states” than we would want. //shrug//

Dobdchitots on Metalwork These Nuts!

24 minutes ago

Take out manifold key and Thran Dynamo for wurmcoil in order to lower the amount of just metalworker draws?

hejtmane on Why is Tappedout wrong about …

36 minutes ago

maybe because of Garth One-Eye

While technically banned it is sorta of legal

evantyde on What happens when oblivion ring …

1 hour ago

I think I might have figured it out: Oblivion Ring must have a legal target when being played, so by tapping Mother of Runes, that target is no longer legal and can not be chosen. If there were another creature out that creature would have to be chosen instead as a legal target.

evantyde on What happens when oblivion ring …

1 hour ago

I am wondering if oblivion ring must choose a new target or fizzle in this situation, also if there is another creature on the field will oblivion ring be forced to choose that as the new target?

Gleeock on The Great Planeswalker Debate

1 hour ago

FormOverFunction yeah, well you'd think nature would have abhorred the vacuum of having almost no punishment for bounce, blink, or mass bounce by now... but good punishment is something that WoTC hasn't figured out too well yet. They have stax & removal down to a tee though

KBK7101 on Isshin, Two Heavens As One …

1 hour ago

I had a few Revenge of Ravens type effect in my initial draft of this deck, but ended up taking all of them out in favor of more aggro stuff. Angelic Exaltation is another one that I removed in favor of more go-wide effects. One of the reasons Isshin is so great is because he's so wide open. A forced combat/goad/pillowfort/politics theme is definitely possible!

Inkshield is already in the deck. :P

As much as my lifegain loving heart loves Linden, the Steadfast Queen, I think the triple-white cost is a bit too much for three color manabases. That being said, she does seem like a good inclusion to offset the inevitable backlash from other players that I've attacked. Added to maybeboard!

Paladin Class isn't something I thought of before, but it seems like it might work. Gonna have to add that one to the maybeboard, too. Thanks!

BroJuice on Bruiser Bruse Build by Bruce

1 hour ago

carpecanum I love Concerted Effort, that's a great suggestion. However, it does not share the spicy keyword menace that we get from our girl Ikra Shidiqi, the Usurper. Also, the double strike from Bruse Tarl, Boorish Herder will not get shared unless he is cast precombat with Odric, Lunarch Marshal.

Bodrio95 on Venerated Rot Priest, At Your …

1 hour ago

You are missing some gold pieces for this deck. The interaction between Spellskite helps a lot protecting the combo and getting twice the triggers from rotpriest. For instance, you can storm to 5 and redirect every storm copy to spellskite, triggering rotpriest each time.

Also March of Burgeoning Life gets your second rotrpiest on board while triggering the poison counter.

Delphen7 on Attractions and Pauper

2 hours ago

By the current rules; yes, they cannot be run.

You seem to know the rule, but I'll cite it anyways

718.2a: "In constructed play, an Attraction deck must contain at least ten Attraction cards and each card in an Attraction deck must have a different English name."


However, if you were to play in an informal setting -- perhaps a friendly game -- then I'm sure most opponents wouldn't mind.

FauxFaux on Card creation challenge

2 hours ago

Mass Effect, eh? Haven't played one of those games since the calamity that was Mass Effect: Andromeda was making the rounds. Favorite character from the series was the Geth Boi Legion.

Legion, Geth Infiltrator

Legendary Artifact Creature - Geth Scout

Persist

Whenever ~ enters the battlefield or dies, you may sacrifice an artifact. If you do, search your library for an Equipment card, and put it onto the battlefield. Until the end of the turn, that Equipment gains Equip to ~:

“Organics fear us. We wish to understand, not incite.”

3/4

humanbean on Arahbo, Roar of the World …

2 hours ago

I should make a cat deck again.

DrummerGarrett on Defensive Ink Humans

3 hours ago

Potential Update

Replace both copies of Snap with Awakener Druid to get more use out of forests

Add Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth and bring deck card count up to 67, to get more consistent forests

Soulus101 on Isshin, Two Heavens As One …

3 hours ago

I love a good token deck, and Isshin seems like fun! Have you considered playing more into doubling triggers on your opponent's attacks? Revenge of Ravens is a very good Propaganda-type effect for Isshin. You could then lean into Eiganjo Uprising or Genesis Chamber and goad/force-attack effects, with cards like Goblin Spymaster, Karazikar, the Eye Tyrant, Kardur, Doomscourge, Vengeful Ancestor, Baeloth Barrityl, Entertainer.

In terms of protection spells, Inkshield seems like a great effect in this deck.

Paladin Class seems a good fit. protection from spells on your turn, an anthem, and a massive double-boost on the last effect. And Linden, the Steadfast Queen also seems like a strong effect to maintain your life total while your team is tapped down. Angelic Exaltation is an all-in Exalt effect that lets you get in for a lot of damage with one creature, should the need arise.

akatosh40 on trelassara, the stomper

3 hours ago

I don´t know how respond each commentary here on tappedout, so I will say in this post, thank you everyone that helped fix my deck, still not played enough, since my work occupied most of my time, but I enjoyed build this deck with the help of you all

sorry for the bad english, isn't my native language

Epidilius on Where are the new cards?!

3 hours ago

Out of curiosity, why does the site not have an automated card adder process? It could just query Scryfall once a day or something for new cards.

Arrzarrina on 【Emotional】▷ RANT ◁ WOTC's GREED …

6 hours ago

Personally, I'm fine with the current state of Modern Horizons block constructed. It's a weird format to get into but apparently it's popul-

Mumbling in background

What do you mean people can play cards from other sets than MH1/MH2?

Further mumbling

Back to Mirrodin!?

zapyourtumor on BW Combo Zombies

6 hours ago

The main thing you changed from Saffs list is the manabase and it definitely shows.

You have a single white card in the entire deck, with 3 copies, which only has one pip. You also have 16 black one drops and 4 double pip cards, which is a total of 20 cards that Plains can't help cast. Needed for 3 cards, casts 18 cards, can't cast 20 cards? Yeah, cut all three copies.

Normally, when people don't have fetches I suggest alternatives like cheaper dual lands, but here the deck is literally mono black besides three cards so you can have 8 swamps and it still functions fine. I'd probably cut the 8th swamp for a third Castle Locthwain though that card has won me a ridiculous number of games in any deck running black.

redb on Lands of the Praetor

7 hours ago

adding: infectious inquiry, vraska's fall, necrogin commnuion, prologue to phresis, contaniment crafter

WishcoinCrab on Theme Decks: Grixis

7 hours ago

I love your decks so much, theme decks are some of the most fun I've ever had playing

Gsanna on Full Metal Alchemy

8 hours ago

Hey!

New sets have brought fresh new good cards, just wanted to know what did you think about running Cityscape Leveler instead of Platinum Emperion, and if you would run something like Mondrak, Glory Dominus and if yes, what would you swap it for? Something also worth considering for a maybe board would be Bitter Reunion pretty powerful in this deck and adds an haste enabler.

Looking forward to hear your thoughts on this!

carpecanum on Bruiser Bruse Build by Bruce

9 hours ago

Does Odric, Lunarch Marshal give his bonus before attackers are declared? That would mean you don't get to share Bruse's bonus but abilities from other creatures still work. Maybe Concerted Effort would be better.

K4nkato on Attractions and Pauper

9 hours ago

So the constructed rules say Attactions require a ten-card side deck with no repeat names. Unfortunately there are only eight legal attractions in pauper. Does this make attractions impossible to run in pauper?

tmurphy3100 on Prosper Test

13 hours ago

https://www.moxfield.com/decks/6eP7MUADUUWoW4wsWIcf0Q/primer

BlueGriffon on jeskai monk tribal

13 hours ago

just played and needed counters, mana rocks, and spot removal for creatures & enchantments. unblockable enablers were good but had to cast shu yun 4 times, and he got countered the last time which pretty much sealed the deal. I think 1 mana draw cantrips will continue to be important and might even be more important than other good instants that don't draw a card.

berryjon on Card creation challenge

13 hours ago

Tacos? Oh, you sweet summer child....

Cerberus Taco Cart
Artifact
At the beginning of each upkeep, sacrifice this card.
"Huh, that lasted longer than expected..." - CMDR. Shepherd

(meme here; http://www.threepanelsoul.com/comic/on-threat-assessment )

You know what? Make a Mass Effect Universes Beyond card, themed around Space: The Convergence if it will help.

SacredAtsira on Zombies ... Ya Herd Me!

14 hours ago

After facing it in a Wilhelt deck, I humbly recommend Relentless Dead.

Good source of reanimation, and for Wilhelt, free card draw

bushido_man96 on Advertise your COMMANDER deck!

14 hours ago

SweetDreamsies, you didn't leave a comment on my deck.

DemonDragonJ on Phyrexia: All Will Be One …

15 hours ago

I am very displeased that Staff of Compleation costs 5 mana to untap, when Staff of Domination costs only 1 mana for that, but, I suppose that that ability is so expensive to balance out the fact that its other abilities cost no mana to use.

LordKunai on Army of the Suntree

15 hours ago

yoooo, love the deck. also a HUGE emmara fan. where's that Nature's Chosen at???

Max_Hammer on $5 Red Improv

15 hours ago

Hey, question here, have you considered Tooth of Chiss-Goria instead of Cathar's Shield?

This deck is really cool, but aside from being an 0-cost artifact, I don't really see the value in the shield.

Either way, you should definitely replace it with the simply superior Accorder's Shield if you don't like Chiss.

IltaertheZendikariRiddleMaster on Unite the New Coalition

15 hours ago

Jaroc249. Teferi, Temporal Pilgrim is an asset to any deck, beyond question. As to Retrofitter Foundry, I honestly do not think the game will be won or lost by it and, since it is not Legendary, Jodah cannot summon it. If you truly desire colorless tokens, though, I would go for Thopter Spy Network since at least it requires no mana to generate said tokens. Honestly though, I think it better to simply add another quality Legendary creature.

ArmageddonPanda13 on Card creation challenge

16 hours ago

Herbie, the Con-car-er

Legendary Artifact Creature -- Vehicle

Oilthirst 3 (This creature enters the battlefield with 3 oil counters if an opponent was dealt damage this turn.)

Whenever Herbie attacks, you may put an oil counter on it.

Whenever you crew Herbie, you may remove any number of oil counters from it. If you do, draw that many cards and lose twice that much life.

Crew 3

5/4


Make a nonlegendary card about tacos. Pray for no ninjas.

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

16 hours ago

Time to bring back my most favorite, least supported tribe.


Line Foreman

Artifact Creature - Assembly-Worker

Line Foreman enters the battlefield with three oil counters on it.

Remove an oil counter: The next artifact spells you cast this turn costs less. Put a -1/-1 counter on Line Foreman.

It ensures production continues uninhibited, at any cost.

3/3


Nice challenge. Let's repeat.

I may have botched it anyway, as Line Foreman doesn't "rely" on them :p

kamarupa on 'fender-benders

16 hours ago

Thanks for the +1, keizerbuns!

TheoryCrafter on Card creation challenge

16 hours ago

Spark Dampener

Artifact

If an opponent casts a planeswaker spell, ~ gains Flash until the spell resolves.

Planeswalkers enter the battlefield with two fewer loyalty counters.


Create an artifact that relies on oil counters. The card cannot be Phyrexian themed in any way.

4to16characters on Primer: Kozilek, The Great Distortion …

16 hours ago

What's nice about this Kozilek is you can be pretty aggresive with Mulligans, seeing as you'll just draw up to 7 later anyway. The bad thing is you'll usually be a big target and opponents with consistent artifact removal will be a pain with too few lands.

Also infinite mana to draw cards is fantastic and gets even better if you can draw enough and just counter other peoples responses. I went in a swiss army knife direction that needs some tweaking and definitely is behind by a set or two at this point.

enpc on Why is Tappedout wrong about …

16 hours ago

This thread was moved to a more appropriate forum (auto-generated comment)

PhyrexianPraetor on My idea of what a …

17 hours ago

I have no clue as to what to expect from the design team. All I know is that this better not turn into another “companion” disaster. Bad enough a format like modern got ruined by WAR, MH1 and MH2 by effectively creating a pseudo-rotation issue with a lack of testing and pushing the power levels of cards.

Max_Hammer on How to Draw Dinosaurs

17 hours ago

Hey, if you don't like the idea of drawing multiples, you could just add one Kiora and have three Bonds instead.