Chthonian Nightmare

Combos Browse all Suggest

Tokens

Legality

Format Legality
1v1 Commander Legal
Archenemy Legal
Arena Legal
Block Constructed Legal
Canadian Highlander Legal
Casual Legal
Commander / EDH Legal
Commander: Rule 0 Legal
Custom Legal
Duel Commander Legal
Freeform Legal
Gladiator Legal
Highlander Legal
Historic Legal
Historic Brawl Legal
Legacy Legal
Leviathan Legal
Limited Legal
Modern Legal
Oathbreaker Legal
Planar Constructed Legal
Planechase Legal
Quest Magic Legal
Tiny Leaders Legal
Vanguard Legal
Vintage Legal

Chthonian Nightmare

Enchantment

When Chthonian Nightmare enters the battlefield, you get (three energy counters).

Pay X , Sacrifice a creature, Return Chthonian Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card with converted mana cost/mana value X from your graveyard to the battlefield. Activate this ability only as a sorcery.

capwner on Grog (Jerk Edition)

2 weeks ago

Looks like modern goodstuff but also has some of that oldschool grixis feel and some smooth interactions, I like this! I'm questioning Street Wraith since it only seems good with Riddlers and you are already losing life to your manabase and thoughtseize. I recommend something else in the slot Emperor of Bones is good as it can hit opponents' creatures, Snapcaster Magefoil is always nice for grixis, or maybe something that mills cards like Ripples of Undeath or Stitcher's Supplier/Flare of Malice. Orcish Bowmasters+Chthonian Nightmare is another engine you could consider. I've also found Surgical Extraction to be a little lukewarm recently precisely because of the prevalence of frog in reanimator lists, unless you are using it in conjunction with e.g. a lot of artifact destruction to remove Amulets or similar. Good ol' Fatal Push might make sense too. I think you're on the right track with sb board wipes, could use The Meathook Massacre as another option if u need more. Maybe split up your sb counterspells and try some Mystical Dispute, Strix Serenade, Flusterstormfoil in the board? That's all I got, nice concept!

Balaam__ on The Word Undead (Modern Reanimator)

2 weeks ago

Reanimator is my favorite archetype. This has good bones (heh, pun) but looks like it hasn’t been updated in quite some time. A whole host of cards from more recent sets has hit the scene which could benefit your build. Stuff like Persist, Chthonian Nightmare along with some older staples like Goryo's Vengeancefoil and Unearth. Some might require adjustments to the deck, others not so much. You’re bound to find something to make a meaningful improvement, and you have a good base to build from.

Azoth2099 on Yarok, the Trigger Happy

3 months ago

Build around Chthonian Nightmare and thank me later

zapyourtumor on Insidious Graveyard

4 months ago

My point wasnt to become a hollowvine deck, but about keeping the deck theme consistent instead of mixing aggro and midrange strategies. From what I'm hearing you want a grindier midrange deck, in which case I recommend dropping all vengevines and running maindeck thoughtseize unless you want to autolose to combo decks. And probably some number of push as well, nothing but 2 mana removal spells just doesn't cut it ever since MH1. If you want to truly pivot into a grindier strategy like this I highly recommend building around at least 2 Chthonian Nightmare and small grist (maybe big grist too) and making sure to run more disruption.

Again pathways are just not needed in modern manabases but whatever thats not that important

Lastly I didn't even realize you had 3 ghost quarters sideboard, and I saw you say you might want bojuka bog sideboard. That is ok, but the main upside of utility lands is you can just run them maindeck as incidental hate without taking up sideboard slots. Sideboarding lands is rare, but sometimes you see a singleton additional boseiju or a basic mountain from belcher, or the OG boseiju from some spell based combo deck etc.

Sideboard is kind of weird with 6 discard 6 surgical effects and 3 lands. I'd move 1 quarter main and drop the other two. If you move thoughtseizes main then sb I would probably run a mix of duress and dreams of steel and oil. Some artifact enchantment hate would be good (force of vigor probably). Could run veils but not mandatory. Theres various other combo hate pieces which are important since they are narrower than discard but much stronger against applicable decks. Stuff like Collector ouphe, pithing needle/phyrexian revoker, damping sphere, void mirror, vexing bauble, torpor orb, etc. Scooze is a good yard hate option because unlike surgical effects its repeatable and can be used to trigger roots multiple times. You could also run wraths for aggro decks, even though they hurt you as well the fact that so many creatures cant block is a big problem.

SniperFrog on The Reunion At Last - Sephiroth V1

8 months ago

Love the list. +1

Have you considered things like Reanimate and Unearth as ways to reset Ol' Sep-Daddy?

Also, cards like Marionette Apprentice, Reassembling Skeleton, Weaponcraft Enthusiast and Chthonian Nightmare have felt really good in playtesting for me so far.

Decks like this are my favorite. Sephiroth seems like he could be the best option for mono black in the architype, which has me very excited.

Archon_Bel on Yawgmoth

9 months ago

Always nice to see another Yawgmoth user. I personally prefer Funeral Room / Awakening Hall due to the mass reanimate it can provide in the late game.

Regarding reanimation spells, I feel Victimize is a must have since it's amazing value in a deck like this. Chthonian Nightmare can also recur many of your creatures every turn.

I'm curious why you're not using any of the cheap reanimation enchantments like Animate Dead and Necromancy. I get your reasoning in using the instant revives for protection, but I like the option of being able to revive things on my own timing.

Spymaster's Vault gets you some great card selection potential with enough sacrifices.

Some favorite sac fodder providers I enjoy are Weaponcraft Enthusiast, Chittering Witch, and Sengir Autocrat. Like the Wriggling Grub, they provide the most bang for your buck.

Since you're running Vindictive Vampire, Phyresis might be a nice tech to include for her as a way of getting around either massive life totals or not having your undying combo out.

Lethal Scheme is another option for planeswalker removal, letting you squeeze a bit extra use out of your creatures and giving you extra card selection.

Not a suggestion, but I think it's fair to classify Nest of Scarabs as a boardwipe lol.

wallisface on Mono Black Zombies

1 year ago

Some thoughts:

legendofa on Yarok + Energy = Fun Theme

1 year ago

How do you feel about kinda janky infinite combos? I discovered yesterday that Yarok, the Desecrated + Priest of Gix + Chthonian Nightmare + any mana value 1 or 2 creature gets infinite black mana and infinite energy.

Load more