Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Argy on Blame Game Upgrade

6 days ago

+1 for the name.

The Commander looks interesting.

rmbm99 on Zurog Stormrender Commander

6 days ago

First time, needs more removal or counters.

rmbm99 on Exdeath, Void Warlock

6 days ago

First time was great for mana ramp about six turns in it really took off, need to adjust the lands to include types.

Balaam__ on No

6 days ago

@IRREVERENCY try as I might, I wasn’t able to find either a cheap enough combo or a strong enough beater to rely on to close the game out. Not strictly within the theme, anyway. The closest is probably Iona, but she’s too expensive to cast reliably. I suppose chip damage with a few Angel of Jubilations is the best bet to win with, but it’s more about griefing the opponent than anything else :D

Andramalech on Sephiroth's Revenge

6 days ago

Of course, BotaNickill! It's a solid list! I think Sephiroth is an incredibly powerful commander that also has tons of room to play a couple different styles.

BugBanger69 on Koma. Cosmos Serpant

6 days ago

Have you thought about adding Rustvine Cultivator? I think it's a really good swap for Monster Manual :)

Caran_Lyg on Drone Strike

6 days ago

Thanks for the upvote legendofa.

IRREVERENCY on No

6 days ago

I love that even if this deck has no clear path to winning (against certain decks) it is still absolutely frustrating and obnoxious to sit across from.

IRREVERENCY on Elves

6 days ago

Collected Company might be a decent sideboard card, I realize with this type of deck it's not ideal, but against certain decks, getting to dig 6 cards deep for almost any creatures you have when only running 15 lands isn't a bad option for the back locked.

BotaNickill on Sephiroth's Revenge

6 days ago

Andramalech, Thank you for checking out the deck list and for the upvote!

graveborn582 on Red blue template

6 days ago

1 Aether Gale 1 AEther Sting 1 AEtherize 1 An Offer You Can't Refuse 1 Archmage Emeritus 1 Ash Barrens 1 Basilisk Collar 1 Behold the Multiverse 1 Big Score 1 Blazing Volley 1 Blisterspit Gremlin 1 Brainstorm 1 Brimstone Trebuchet 1 Burning Earth 1 Butcher's Cleaver 1 Caltrops 1 Chandra's Incinerator 1 Circle of Flame 1 Coldsteel Heart 1 Consider 1 Corrupted Conscience 1 Coruscation Mage 1 Curiosity 1 Dagger Caster 1 Defiler of Instinct 1 Desert 1 Dramatic Reversal 1 Dual Shot 1 Electrickery 1 Electrolyze 1 Electrostatic Field 1 End the Festivities 1 Erebor Flamesmith 1 Fabricate 1 Fact or Fiction 1 Fear, Fire, Foes! 1 Fiery Confluence 1 Fire Diamond 1 Firebrand Archer 1 Flame Fusillade 1 Flatline 1 Flick a Coin 1 Gelectrode 1 Goblin Chainwhirler 1 Gorgon Flail 1 Gorgon's Head 1 Grapeshot 1 Gut Shot 1 Hissing Iguanar 1 Immolation Shaman 1 Impact Tremors 1 Izzet Boilerworks 1 Izzet Charm 1 Izzet Signet 1 Kessig Flamebreather 1 Kindlespark Duo 1 Lava Dart 1 Lightning Greaves 1 Loxodon Warhammer 1 Maestros Theater 1 Magic Missile 1 Mana Geyser 1 Manabarbs 1 Monastery Siege 1 Myriad Landscape 1 Mystic Remora 1 Narset's Reversal 1 Needle Drop 1 Neurok Stealthsuit 1 Nevinyrral's Disk 1 Niv-Mizzet, Parun 1 Opt 1 Outpost Siege 1 Ponder 1 Propaganda 1 Pull from Tomorrow 1 Quicksilver Dagger 1 Quietus Spike 1 Razorkin Needlehead 1 Repercussion 1 Shivan Gorge 1 Sigil of Sleep 1 Sky Diamond 1 Smash to Dust 1 Spark Jolt 1 Spikefield Hazard 1 Spiteful Prankster 1 Spitfire Lagac 1 Staff of Nin 1 Storm-Kiln Artist 1 Sunscorched Desert 1 Talisman of Creativity 1 Tandem Lookout 1 Tectonic Hazard 1 Temple of Epiphany 1 Thermo-Alchemist 1 Thousand-Year Storm 1 Treasure Cruise 1 Tunneling Geopede 1 Unexpected Windfall 1 Urabrask 1 Wayfarer's Bauble 1 Windfall 1 Witty Roastmaster 1 You Find the Villains' Lair

legendofa on Alaska Whales

6 days ago

Is there a commander creature in this format?

Murrow on Artificery

6 days ago

legendofa hey thanks for the tip. And as for Network Disruptor originally it was just for a one drop flyer I could target with the transmute type spells. But this was before I updated it. I removed it completely in favor of a few major tweaks.

dr320203 on Torbran Damage

6 days ago

add call forth the tempest

Balaam__ on No

6 days ago

This list is getting readjusted. Thank you :D

legendofa on No

6 days ago

Reprinted in Modern Horizons 3, and totally Modern-legal.

Balaam__ on No

6 days ago

@legendofa is that Modern legal after all? I use a generic app to do all my MtG research (don’t like gatherer or scryfall, too clunky on phone) and it said it wasn’t. I’d love to include it if my intel is wrong. In any case, thanks for the approval!

legendofa on No

6 days ago

I guess I can't let this go by without an upvote, either...

How about Orim's Chant? Anti-spellcasting with an option for anti-attacking.

legendofa on Artificery

6 days ago

Mistvault Bridge is another on-color indestructible artifact land, but it enters tapped, if that's a concern. What's the intent behind Network Disruptor?

The-French-Guyz on THEFRENCHGUYZ DRAW/DISCARD/RETURN

6 days ago

COUPLE COMBO

UNDERWORLD DREAM MEGRIM LILLIANA CARESS WARPED DEVOTION WASTE NOT

DECK IS BASED ON DRAW DISCARD AND RETURN ( THAT MAKE PEOPLE DISCARD )

LOTS OF TUTOR , LOTS OF DRAW FOR MYSELF !

THATS IT , THATS ALL

triplec525 on Alaska Whales

6 days ago

This is our own custom format. 60 Card Commander where you can only have one copy of any rare. It's meant to be a thematic deck with whales.

jdc on Researcher

1 week ago

Ya , how you getting lantern for card advantage and harvest? Yes Is very strong the tutors in combo decks. Suppose this scenario they kill 2 researcher and u have no cards in hand just perplex, the only possible card to get is lantern, to rebuild your game. Another thing latern give u all colors, is a key card.

Another possible build is "land tutors". You can attempt to use land tutors like expeditation map and the other green , another one is comming in FF i din't play test that you don't have time for all details. But i'm guessing width out tutors you will need heavy draw cards witch make combos less efficient since you have less pieces.

In legacy which deck have at least 2 or 3 possible different versions...

legendofa on Researcher

1 week ago

How well is Perplex working here? It's a good counterspell, but I think you might get more value from another source of repeatable life gain, or another way to protect Blood Researcher. That looks like part of the main win condition here, so getting it to trigger as many times as possible and keeping it around should be a priority. Is the blue splash helping the deck win?

Direwulf on Life GAINS copy copy

1 week ago

Nice take on Lathiel! Question: How well does Ashes of the Abhorrent typically play for you? I like graveyard hate, but the lifegain side seems kind of inconsistent.

trisking on Vorinclex w/ planeswalkers

1 week ago

I'm always looking to make this deck better so if you have any advice feel free to let me know :)

Nicetryguy on No budget, no lands, no …

1 week ago

My attempt at a no land commander deck pls help with tweaks.

CrazyDanPsycho on Mikaeus, Hater of All

1 week ago

SufferFromEDHD: That's a fantastic suggestion...but a bit out of my price range at the moment. (lol) I'll keep it in mind, though, thanks!

Caran_Lyg on Invaders from Beyond

1 week ago

Thanks for the upvote Balaam__.

Caran_Lyg on Blood Death Knight

1 week ago

Thanks for the upvote Balaam__.

Skyhi on theres bugs in your skin …

1 week ago

To be added: Icetill Explorer

SufferFromEDHD on Cracked out Lizard

1 week ago

Confused by this card. The Viashino are on old tribe with Dash and Haste. They like to return to hand! Eating your own kind/strategy seems counterproductive. On top of that it's an artificer which implies artifacts and here we have yet another Izzet legend slinging instants and sorceries. Whatever WOTC has been smoking the past few years they need to start sharing with the rest of us.

Prismari Command always useful

Bishoprage on The Queen's Egg

1 week ago

Mortlocke and Doombeard1984 Thanks! I already purchased the pain lands but will look into the Bondlands as a small upgrade once I finish acquiring the remaining like 16 or so cards I need!

Thank again!

SufferFromEDHD on Mikaeus, Hater of All

1 week ago

Urza's Saga to grab that Hex Parasite and/or Skullclamp

WItC on Budget Beginner Teach Decks (#1 …

1 week ago

major revision 2025. I replaced the Force of Nature with Ghalta, Primal Hunger. The pay mana at upkeep mechanic is awkward for a new player, and the simple Ghalta ability plays into the general theme for this green deck. Most importantly, this will really connect with the inner "Timmy" in new players and maybe help get them interested in the hopes they can do the big, flashy thing.

legendofa on Pain.EXE

1 week ago

There's six copies of Fireblast and five Mine Collapses between main board and sideboard here. Maybe switch the extras out for more Goblins--something like Reckless Lackey or Fanatical Firebrand?

MaliciousMayhem on Cloud's Courageous Coalition

1 week ago

lil_cheez Figured as much. Thanks again for your help. I've made some changes and I'm going to continue to tweek and test this deck online before I purchase it.

Murrow on Grift (a Cycling Reanimator deck)

1 week ago

Balaam__ haha thanks for the tip! Yeah I always tend to go light on lands. But I took your advice. I could only bring myself to cut the River Serpent by two haha. Time to proxy and playtest.

lil_cheez on Cloud's Courageous Coalition

1 week ago

MaliciousMayhem Yes, Spectral Lynx has a color identity of black and white, so it cannot be legally ruin with a monowhite commander!

Balaam__ on Grift (a Cycling Reanimator deck)

1 week ago

I love the premise, but I think your land count is too low. Yes, you’ll be playing cheap spells or cycling for 1 most of the time but 16 isn’t quite enough to guarantee the power to do so. Dropping some of the creatures down to 3x copies could let you bring the lands to about 18-19 or so.

cc13 on Gruul Rampage

1 week ago

A deck that aims to exploit the rampage mechanic and combat triggers to yield effects

crowfather1307 on Ob Nixilis Demon Tribal

1 week ago

Coward_Token

I won't be changing the helm, unless to another Ob, as I want this to remain a nixilis deck. His story is one of my favorites so I want to showcase as much as I can in the deck, whilst keeping it functional.

I've considered varragoth before and I think he's just not good enough unless he's at the helm. He's basically a 5 mana vampiric tutor that has suspend 2, except he can be removed. Even getting 2 effects off over 3 turns is 7 mana tutor two. For that effect I'll take profane tutor.

Speed demon is interesting and a nice bloodgift demon alternative. And you don't need to wait for upkeep. I might make a swap.

FormOverFunction on The Mind-Razing Monarch

1 week ago

Nin is a good sport about it. I always appreciate people using removal on not-Nekusar loool. My torture deck is all theme, but there’s some oddball stuff you might enjoy. Have at it if you like!

Welkitends on Edward Kenway

1 week ago

Could use some more lands. maybe like 34 or so.

Genderfluidia on Alarm Ping - Premodern

1 week ago

I think that's just two-headed giant.... .... Anywho, I'd prolly take out reveka, and the saprazzan skerry's. Not sure what I would put in tho.

PhyrexianPraetor on Back in Black

1 week ago

I saw your list and thought I would suggest a couple of ideas.

Since you're running fetch lands you could consider running some number of Godless Shrine and a long side of it, Silent Clearing. My reason is that you can then substitute Damnation with Damn, it's far better than Damnation due to it being both spot removal and a board-wipe when needed. Silent Clearing will also give you additional card draw in the late game and since you run fetch lands you could consider Fatal Push since you will have a decent number of opportunities to have revolt.

Another card you might want to consider is Withering Torment. It costs one more than Feed the Swarm, but is an instant and only costs you two life points. If you do consider my idea of running dual lands you could even go with Vindicate as an option. It would effectively fill the role of Feed the Swarm and Fulminator Mage at the same time, the only downside is that you can't recur it like Fulminator Mage. Another option would be Anguished Unmaking in place of Feed the Swarm. It would deal with every problematic non-land permanent and could potentially cost you less life than Feed the Swarm would.

I would also suggest looking at adding cards like Hopeless Nightmare, The Meathook Massacre and Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet. Hopeless nightmare will still give you control over your opponent's hand and will add to your devotion count. In the late game it can be sacrificed to scry away needless cards. If you play both The Meathook Massacre and Kalitas you end up having a very strong combo. You can clear the board with Kalitas in play and gain some life while creating zombie tokens.

If you wanted some additional ideas you can take a look at my list on my profile.