|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|Commander 2015 (C15)||Common|
|Modern Masters (MMA)||Common|
|Duel Decks: Elspeth vs. Tezzeret (DDF)||Common|
Combos Browse all
Return target nonland permanent and all other permanents with the same name as that permanent to their owners' hands.
Echoing Truth Discussion
10 hours ago
Good cheap killspells I can recommend would be Tyrant's Scorn , Victim of Night , and Languish . Languish is just a poor-mans Damnation, but i find some kind if board wipe pretty useful, and most of the time this should buy you and extra 2-3 turns. Victim of Night is strong, but the double-black can be pretty restricting, so Tyrant's Scorn might be a better option (or a mix of them both).
4 days ago
Yeah, if your meta is running a large number of those cards, then it is probably running a few Annul . I normally don’t see either of them in my playgroup, though I have to run Echoing Truth to deal with Leyline of Sanctity . I also sideboard Inquisition of Kozilek (or Duress ) to catch some of the nasties like the cards you’ve mentioned, before they happen.
So yeah, keep Annul if you get value from it. Sideboards are entirely meta-dependant
1 week ago
I like your list quite a bit, one thing that I do have to suggest is to up Gush , from my playtesting, I found 3 Gush and 2 Foil to be the perfect number to run. Many games turned around for me the moment I drew Gush, and it allowed for some really crazy turns.
One card that has overperformed for me is Echoing Truth over Snap. I'm currently running 2, but for the next tournament I'm going to be running 3, and this is mainly for my local metagame, as some of the matches I came against were elves, mono white wheenies, and blue mill with Persistent Petioners. In all these matchups it often removed lots of tokens, or bounced 2 or 3 creatures at a time. It was even helpful against boggles, as it allowed me to bounce enchantments in multiples.
1 month ago
I would argue the lands are the most crucial as at the end of the day you do need to make your colors for this deck very effectively, and you need the duals for helping your Pentad Prism math. With your remaining starting budget I would get all your scry lands, the artifacts (or else you will never win quick enough without them), Simian Spirit Guide , and the actual wincons. Anything left over after that should go to cantrips and Spoils of the Vault , unless of course it is enough to buy a few of the other lands. As for the 2 remaining Pact of Negation , for the time being you can get away with running 1 Echoing Truth and 1 Desperate Ritual in those spots, that should save you some money until you can upgrade them and if control isn't a problem where you live this should be decent for now. You can also throw a Solemnity into the deck for the time being seeing how your ability to stall will be hampered by your lands.
Keep me updated on your progress I am always willing to help out as well!
P.S. Lotus Bloom not petal (I wish) make sure you don't accidentally buy the wrong card ;)
1 month ago
so I'll adjust my sideboard accordingly,
-1 Harbinger of the Tides + 1 Echoing Truth so I have 2x Echoing Truth and 2x Hurkyl's Recall ( i went with echoing because I feel like I should not be troubled too much by creatures that should force me to run vapor snag due to island-walk being a thing.)
For the mainboard, I am either thinking of taking out the Merrow Reejerey as you said because it isn't as popular anymore... and put in 4 Benthic Biomancer ? was also looking at Phantasmal Image for more lords and stuff but that doesn't get played either + it dies to bounce :s... Or play the 4 retorts mainboard and add the biomancers in the side if I really need to race or have card draw while pitching some dead lands draws in the late game sound good as well. aaaaaaaaaaaaa decisions xD
1 month ago
I'm looking at death shadows, storm, Tron, 8rack, infect, also saw some knight of the reliquary stuff before don't really know what the archetype is called, lantern control, affinity, hollow one, uw control, fearies, I've also seen something that cheeses "restore balance" into play with as "foretold" but also don't know the name of that deck... , dredge, valakut, elves and prolly some others that don't really have a name or i am not aware of...
Anyhow I'm not really as invested into playing this at tournament level but I do want to have it work versus the current metagame and have it be relevant so I'm liking Vapor Snag and Echoing Truth ... I like Wizard's Retort and Mana Leak even more as it is easier to cast without requiring a wizard to be in play... that said though it's not a hard counter like retort is in the mid/late game where some might be able to pay the 3 mana and I'll just have to learn those match-ups i guess where that is relevant xD!
Deprive will probably also have its place in some decks as it can act as a mid to late game hard counter with no drawbacks, but early one it could hurt you as well so not a fan of that really...
1 month ago
How do you feel about a green splash?
R/B are arguably the worst 2 colors for sideboards (with white then green being the best).
As for Tron, pick your flavor of land destruction. Crumble to Dust is my pick. They can win through almost any form of hate, even Blood Moon and Pithing Needle effects so you just need to be quicker than they are. Keeping them off Tron will makes things easier.
Your actually decently tech'd against burn with Izzet Charm , Rune Snag , Lightning Bolt and Remand . If you need something more Kraken's Eye or Dragon's Claw can work wonders. I'm a personal fan of Amulet of Safekeeping as it's useful for against many decks and great against Storm. I also like Fountain of Renewal since it can be played turn 1 and involves no additional investment, plus can be cashed in if it gets to a point its not needed.
As far as the graveyard decks, you could run Relic of Progenitus or Surgical Extraction without splashing. You could run Leyline of the Void but if you side it in you would have to commit to mulling for it. Sentinel Totem and Tormod's Crypt are decent as well.
1 month ago
I really like the idea behind this deck.
How are you planning on handling something like Electrickery , Echoing Decay , or Echoing Truth ? The rats also trade with tokens or elves which means you can't attack with anything other than your gnawers without impacting your Gary plan.
Dealing with flyers will also be challenging. Maybe it's worth adding more removal at the expense of the draw from Dusk Legion Zealot ?
It might be worth thinking about some cards like Ruin Rat or Rancid Rats for the deathtouch to deal with Anglers. Also, Rancid Rats gives you some evasion which may help in getting monarch back in the event that you lose it.
I think Gnat Miser would be an interesting inclusion if you feel like you want more on the hand disruption package. Rotting Rats is a symmetric effect but it has unearth to give an extra activation of its ETB and given your card draw you can use that to your advantage, or before you toss our Gary you can unearth them to pump up your devotion.
Echoing Truth occurrence in decks from the last year
Commander / EDH:
All decks: 0.0%
All decks: 0.04%
All decks: 0.04%