mtg, mtg cards, magic the gathering, gaming, geeks
Casual Planeswalker EDH deck based on producing masses of tokens and draining life for total board control.
For those of you who don't know, Planeswalker EDH is a casual format of... a casual format.
Instead of a legendary creature, a Planeswalker serves as General, and follows most of the same rules (i.e. Command Zone, Additional Casting Costs, etc.). However, a player cannot win through "commander damage," because not all planeswalkers have access to it, making Gideon Jura and Chandra Nalaar a big advantage.
Also, you can't have any planeswalkers in the deck aside from your general: this is because many have multiple versions, and having 3 Lilianas in your deck against someone who uses her as general would suck for them (thanks again, Planeswalker Rule).
If it sounds like something you'd like, try it. It's fantastic, and a great change from normal EDH.
Wow, I'm so glad people are digging the format so much! I can't believe how well it's caught on. Thanks to everyone who gave me suggestions, +1'd, or just found this interesting.
Don't forget, I want to know if you have any suggestions for the format/my deck in general, any luck trying your hand at Planeswalker EDH, anything.
What a cool format and an interesting deck. =D
While looking it over a couple of card suggestions came to mind:
Bloodghast would be a great card to sac with your Ghost Council of Orzhova and even without that synergy he makes an annoying and effective attacker who keeps coming back.
Wall of Souls is a nice wall but Souls of the Faultless probably best fills this niche in your deck already; still, thought I should at least mention it...
Simulacrum has a nice synergy with either Souls of the Faultless or Wall of Souls and is just a handy way of deflecting damage. It could also work nicely with your Tainted Sigil.
Also, have you considered Sudden Spoiling ? With Elsh Norn it could be devastating...
Thanks again for introducing me to such a neat format. Hope you found some of these suggestions useful.
Thanks for all the suggestions! Bloodghast is a great idea, my friend even has a few I could trade for.
Sudden Spoiling is a fantastic idea, but a little more money than I'd like. I'm trying to keep all the cards I don't have at about a dollar or less. I'll definitely test it out though!
I'm glad you like the format! If you can get a few people to try it it's extremely fun, and definitely worth trying. Cheers!
Well, as of now we've decided against it because of the Planeswalker Rule and the fact that there are like 5 versions of Jace would totally screw with a deck using him as their general. This ruling is open to change though, so if you have any ideas then lemme know.
Fair enough, I was thinking along the same lines; since it could be pretty confusing.
My playgroup was musing with the idea of having all of your planeswalkers in the command zone together, but that seems just as bad.
Seems like you've got a few too many small spells and not enough ramp effects or big spells. Are you ever really stoked to play doomed traveler, beckon apparition, funeral pyre, putrid warrior, or soul link? It's a 40 life format - I don't think cards that are only efficient in the first few turns are really worth it. They're just too small of effects. I run a Tesya deck in EDH (which is really the same as a Sorin deck..) and using it showed me the same thing. You want cards that are still good when you draw them turn 13 with a ton of mana.
Sure. If it works for you. It doesn't really seme like enough of a dedicated weenie deck to be winning that fast/I guess your playgroup doesn't pack many boardwipes, but okay. You should at least swap out some of the cards that just have better versions/do very little. It looks like you're budget? So I guess I wouldn't suggest Bitterblossom
, Deathbringer Liege
, Grave Titan
, or Sol Ring
, though those would all help the deck.
Definitely though some of the specific cards are a little jank. Luminous Angel seems very weak if you strategy is to overwhelm them early with small guys. By the time she drops (7 turn minimum, since you have no ramp), it seems like that effect wouldn't save you from the horrors that edh decks can play that late. Ogre Slumlord might be worth considering.
Souls of the Faultless and Putrid Warrior are both strange. Why would you want to be blocking? You're an offensive deck. A wall with lifelink won't help much. And Putrid Warrior is just a too weak for a weenie deck. Accorder Paladin would be a billion times better in that slot.
And as far as random cards go, Increasing Devotion , Promise of Power , Sadistic Hypnotist , Hour of Reckoning , Skirsdag High Priest , Prison Term , Banishing Stroke , and Honor of the Pure would all treat the deck well!
aeonstoremyliver, yes they would. Seeing as it's casual, it's not unlikely that they'd just agree to let them live though for the sake of the game.
seeemwhykay, wow, thanks for all the feedback! You're right about it being on a budget, so those aren't really options (although I think I have a Sol Ring left over somewhere). Some of the other cards in this deck that are on the weak side are either because I own them or they're just really cool. Souls of the Faultless is my favorite card of ever so I had to put it in. Putrid Warrior was just cool, but could definitely leave.
And as with the bigger spells, it's because the deck starts to pick up at turn 5 or so. Usually that's when the tokens start hoarding and I can steamroll in about 3 turns. As for your suggestions individually:
Ogre Slumlord would be nice if not for the "nontoken" part
Accorder Paladin I like, especially for that slot
Increasing Devotion I'm not sure of, but might find a slot
Promise of Power seems fun and a good utility
Sadistic Hypnotist 's effect doesn't seem quite potent enough imo, but I could be convinced
Hour of Reckoning is genius how have I never seen this. Definitely in.
Skirsdag High Priest is a possibility, but would make me targeted HARD
Prison Term is good, but idk how well it fits
Banishing Stroke maybe, but tucking is frowned upon in my group. I'll think about this one.
Honor of the Pure is a good anthem, but rules out a lot of my tokens so I'll pass.
Any ideas on what to drop for what I liked? Thanks a bunch for the ideas man!
You're welcome! Increasing Devotion
is good because of the flashback. It's nice to have something play late game. Sadistic Hypnotist
really has to be seen in action. It's insane when you can drop him and make your opponent discard their entire hand, and keep doing that whenever needed. And again, I really think you need more mana/land stuff. Orzhov Signet
, Everflowing Chalice
, Endless Horizons
, Gift of Estates
. You probably don't need all of those, but a few wouldn't hurt at all. And probably throw in a Diabolic Tutor
because you're black, why would you not?
So I'm thinking:
-1 Perish the Thought , -1 Soul Link , -1 Spiritual Visit , -1 Funeral Pyre , -1 Putrid Warrior
+1 Accorder Paladin , +1 Increasing Devotion , +1 Promise of Power , +1 Hour of Reckoning , +1 Gift of Estates
Just a quick note. I understand that the reason why there is only 1 planeswalker in the whole EDH is because of that planeswalker rule. I just want to make sure you now about the new legendary rule. If not, the quick definition is, that both players may control a legendary permanent of the same name at the same time, and it is the same for walkers - both players may control a walker with type Liliana, for example. And if you control a legendary creature named AB and you play another AB, you choose which AB will stay on the battlefield and which will go to the graveyard - they will not die both at the same time any more. The same is for walkers.
If you already knew that, than I'm sorry for comment :)
|Date added||11 months|
|Last updated||8 months|
|Legal formats||Commander / EDH, Vintage|
|Top rank||#9 on 2013-03-22|
|+1||Gather the Townsfolk||main|
|+1||Beacon of Unrest||main|
|+1||Pontiff of Blight||main|
|+1||Teysa, Envoy of Ghosts||main|
|+1||Debt to the Deathless||main|
|0||Crescendo of War||main|
|-1||Vault of the Archangel||main|
|-1||Sorin, Lord of Innistrad||main|
|-1||Obzedat, Ghost Council||main|
|-1||Ghost Council of Orzhova||main|
|-1||Gift of Estates||main|
|-1||Circle of Despair||main|