|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|Ninth Edition (9ED)||Uncommon|
|Eighth Edition (8ED)||Uncommon|
|Seventh Edition (7ED)||Uncommon|
Combos Browse all
(2)(Blue)(Blue): Draw a card.
Price & Acquistion Set Price Alerts
Treasure Trove Discussion
3 weeks ago
Some of the cards here feel very underwhelming:
Arcane Adaptation only affects four of your creatures: the fish, the elemental, the king, and the spellskite. Doesn't seem worth it. Also, except for spellskite, those cards aren't outstanding. I'd try to replace them with good pirates, like Kari Zev, Skyship Raider or Adaptive Automaton, then replace the arcane adaptation with Revel in Riches.
Navigator's Ruin is only a good card if you plan to kill someone by milling them. If you don't kill them, then it didn't do much. Even if you mill like 50 cards with it, that's not enough for a win, and you might be filling their graveyard with good stuff they can re-use or re-animate. Milling their good cards is exactly as likely as milling their bad cards so that they draw right into their good cards. It's just not good. I'd swap it out for Walk the Plank
1 month ago
Treasure Trove is all about what you want but also costs 4. This must be a sign that this is about the 'going rate' for the effect, and half price if you're discarding too.
You could use something clue related like Ongoing Investigation.
Excavation is cheap but has an annoying downside, but maybe not so bad if you're banking loads of mana and ramping into lands.
4 months ago
I'm doing something similar. Some cards I've added are War Tax for pirate flavor, and War Cadence to push pirates through. Curse of Opulence for flavor and mana ramp. Mass Mutiny (if only there was a piratey art) and Treasure Trove are some more flavor wins.
4 months ago
9 months ago
Love the deck +1. Got some flavor based ideas... Skysovereign, Consul Flagship, Gild, Treasure Trove, Treasure Cruise, Treasure Hunt, Treasure Keeper, Ghost Ship...not sure about that last one even though its a sweet looking ship...its not very good, lol. Happy gathering!