Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Lilbrudder on [List - Multiplayer] EDH Generals ...

a few seconds ago

Food chain Derevi has been done by me and I think cobbletpott. Its actually decent since there are like 15 or so good cards that serve as outlets for her without diluting the deck. It still doesn't make her very good unfortunately

Flamoes on Bant Morph

7 minutes ago

I've also made a Bant morph deck, but I kept taking out more and more morph creatures as you really don't want to many in there as they clog the mana you need/want to keep open for tricks. So basically I cut out most of the more expensive morphs and only put in the ones with a cheap morph up cost so you don't have to keep too much mana open.My deck here: http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/morpheronis/ (Probably not updated :P)It is a bit more focused on drawing on combat damage abusing Sidar's ability to get through and finishing off with a blocker step Mirror Entity, Mirrorweave, Biomass Mutation, True Conviction.

Kovarcik on UB Budget Modern Faerie

9 minutes ago

HI, Harbringer is realy important in this deck, becouse its Control budget faerie deck, you need bitterblosom. But you cant play 4x bitterblosom becouse of its price, so I made this. I even play that faerie counter. It good card in this type of deck. And familiars ruse its good with bitteerblosom. You sacrifice one token for two mana counter that can counter everythink.

Lorderos23 on [List - Multiplayer] EDH Generals ...

15 minutes ago

My problem with 'optimized' list is they don't take in account meta specific cards.

GY decks are abundant in my meta with a a sprinkle of FC Tazri list and a couple of stacks decks. The rest are either casuals or total solitare decks. Hence my Prossh list reflects those changes.

I feel like a core 85-90cards can be set for any one deck but the last 10-14 are specific to Metas(hence the Paper player question).

Granted my FC Prossh is still a Shuffle Tribal deck, but it isn't "optimized by the tiered list above".My win rate is higher than 50% most weeks.(Sometimes Demonic Consultation just has it out for you.) Due to the fact I have interaction with my opponents a but more than the listed Prossh deck. I am not saying mine is better overall, just better for my meta. I really think we should have in these lists a 'core set of cards' and slot for 'flex spots' So people who didn't naturally come to build their own deck can understand what's a piece that can be taken out for a card they need for their meta

usaDiabetic on DAnger noodles march!

18 minutes ago

Maybe throw in Westvale Abbey  Flip as a finisher.

Trigon of Corruption for more counters.

Parallel Lives for more tokens.

Either way, sweet build. I'm looking to build a Hapatra deck, and yours looks awesome, epically for the price!

eviljimmy on Optimized Phenax, God of Deception

26 minutes ago

thanks..that makes sense:)did you give up on playing this deck ?

dosfod on Jank Night!

33 minutes ago

Very cool brew! You could maybe put a Mirran Crusader somewhere in the 75... He is soooo good with swords ;)

Quicksilver on Ramos, The Cheap Engine

34 minutes ago

Yeah, Primal Surge has indeed been a flop once due to the instants and sorceries. Mayael the Anima and Gleam of Battle are definitely going to be on the chopping board as I don't attack with Ramos at all and as you say, Mayael hasn't got many targets. Kynaios and Tiro of Meletis has been surprisingly good as a peacekeeper, players are less likely to attack me when he's on the field as they enjoy his benefits. Conflux is so perfect, I'm not sure why I didn't consider it. I'll take the others into consideration, Kalonian Hydra works well for the deck because he can buff Ramos without having to attack. Thanks for the suggestions.

JediCat on We are Myr. Resistance is ...

35 minutes ago

Hmmmm, Throne of the God-Pharaoh seems very nice! Being legendary hinders it a bit, but as a two-of, I suppose, it could work! After all, my Myr need a God to worship. I'll try it, thank you)))

dosfod on The Markov Dynasty

38 minutes ago

Haven't you thought about Sorin, Grim Nemesis and Phyrexian Arena? If you need to grind at some point.... Anyways, a great deck! I'll buy the precon and want to tune it too.

Airakk on 11.7% OF THE TIME, IT ...

46 minutes ago

how can i leave this chat ?!i dont wanna get a messege every time someone subscrubes this deck -_-

moonbeee on The Night's Watch

49 minutes ago

@codpieceofjustice Brave the Elements does not protect from any sweepers as they do not target.

@Sinchiroca The green is for Collected Company, which is a house in this deck. Gavony Township is must have in any deck that is running creatures and G/W. Also this is a modern deck so Swords to Plowshares is illegal, although the Dawn Charm might be decent sideboard tech. Probably better than rootborn defences.

Speaking of which, Sundering Growth is kind of expensive for what it does in this deck. There are not enough token generators to make it's upside count. I'd rather have Natural State or Fragmentize.

m0use on Teneb, the Harvester

1 hour ago

Living plane is very expensive. A more budget friendly option would be Natural Affinity. The advantage is that it costs less mana, is an instant so is much harder to interact with, and can be cast in response to someone targeting Elesh Norn, Grand Cenobite with removal. The downside is it does not combo amazingly with Linvala, Keeper of Silence. The downside of running Living Plane like cards is that they do not pull any weight by themselves, so they can be dead draws. They also can't be tutored as easily as creatures in your deck, so they might not even be worth running despite the combos.

Also, have you considered Praetor's Grasp instead of Grim Tutor? This depends highly on the people you play with, but if your playgroup runs similar cards as your deck, it can be basically the same thing, with an added upside of taking it away from your opponents.

Goronagar on The Markov Dynasty

1 hour ago

Hey, thx for your opinion!

There is no reason to play Anointed Procession and Cathars' Crusade, because that doesn't suit my plan. The plan is, to play vampires until turn 4 and 5, so i need direct and effective support cards like Vampire Nocturnus, Sorin, Solemn Visitor and Coat of Arms.

I'll take a look at your deck ....

Fangs2005 on Opponent Rage Producer

1 hour ago

Megrim or Fate Unraveler could be used if you wanted them to lose some extra life.

Kilrane on Let's Rage Cage Bro! - ...

1 hour ago

Was going through some old cards and came across this beauty.

Flowstone Sculpture

Cage it use it to simultaneously buff our Commander as well as chuck another cage piece for later.

Bou on EDH Licia, Tribute for the ...

1 hour ago

Yeah that's why he's already in there! ;)

MartialArt on Locust Swarm

1 hour ago

Looks very good. But how should Bident of Thassa + Niv-Mizzet, the Firemind work? The Bident clearly says "combat damage" and Niv Mizzet does not combat damage with you drawing. This can't go infinite unless you use Ophidian Eye or Curiosity instead of the Bident.

Raphiezar on Ramos, The Cheap Engine

1 hour ago

Death's Presence is good because you can dump counters onto Ramos or other creatures. Necropolis Regent gets out of hand fast, as does Kalonian Hydra. Drana, Liberator of Malakir is decent for buffing your army for only 3 mana. Chasm Skulker and Hangarback Walker are great ways to utilize those +1/+1 counters to make a big board state. In tandem with Vorel of the Hull Clade, you can run Gilder Bairn which can also double planeswalker loyalty if you need it. Casting Conflux while Ramos is in play tutors for a bunch of cards that you can then cast immediately, like Doubling Season for your green card and Tamiyo, Field Researcher for either your white or blue card.For cards to take out, Mayael the Anima is the first because have only 4 creatures that she can grab, which means she will miss a lot of her activations. Gleam of Battle and Forced Adaptation are very low impact cards. You run too many instant and sorcery cards for Primal Surge to be reliable and can often turn into paying 10 mana to get little to nothing for it. Kynaios and Tiro of Meletis don't even synergize with the deck other than giving Ramos 4 +1/+1 counters, which Saskia the Unyielding can do, and she can deliver some mean beats in this deck as well. Borborygmos, Tariel, Vorosh, and Oloro are all good cards to cut as well.

dosfod on CAT-AMETRA, HATE(bear)CATS

1 hour ago

What about Nissa, Vital Force? With all the ramp, drawing cards by only playing lands seems cool. I'll consider Tireless Tracker for this reason too. Good luck with the deck!

dosfod on Mathas Midrange-Pillowfort-Politics

1 hour ago

CChaos thanks for the suggestion, Nova Pentacle is added to the mayboard now... I'll consider what to remove for it, it seems very cool and flavourful ;)

Mike94 on EDH Darien's Soldiers

1 hour ago

If you are playing soldier tribal I would recommend Recruiter of the Guard. I also would swap out Relic Seeker for Stoneforge Mystic but I see you are running the promo version so maybe he is just there for the flavor (witch is nice!)

Last, I think you lack a bit of control during the combat-phase. Since you have tokens to spare maybe Knight-Captain of Eos could be something for you to look at.

Nice deck! I love mono-white +1

ChaosJester on Djeru, Gideons Champion

1 hour ago

Very interesting concept bro! +1 :)

Wolf123101 on Trampled!

1 hour ago

no, it's modern

Murphy77 on Locust of Control

1 hour ago

Have you considered Forgotten Creation and/or Chandra, Flamecaller for mega-draw once you have your The Locust God out. With the large number of discards to the grave, Perpetual Timepiece could then return cards to your library. I know that it is a different strategy, but it could be fun to play.

The7thBobba on Liliana's Torture Dungeon

1 hour ago

Lovely description and cool deck to boot! Stay frosty!

Beaches0777 on "Mono" Green Storm

2 hours ago

I recently put together a deck that's similar to this one except it's further midrange. I run 4 Animation Module along with 4 Metallic Mimic to produce a combo that goes off with a module and a metallic mimic on the field (mimic is set to servo). Then I can activate the Animation Module , pay 1 create a 1/1 servo then metallic mimic gives the servo a +1/+1 counter as it enters the field which, in turn, triggers the module again. This interaction only becomes truly infinite when you have a Paradox Engine in play to untap the mana dork you're using. I also run 3 Nissa, Steward of Elements along with 3 Lifecrafter's Bestiary. I actually got the idea for Bestiary's inclusion from your build. I use aetherflux reservoir, Aetherwind Basker , and Nissa, Steward of Elements as other win conditions.

Pappyy1369 on W/U Control

2 hours ago

Updated the deck again after playing some FNM....(went 4-6)

The wins all came from using my Multiform Wonder + Untethered Express + Aethersphere Harvester

Card updates:

Removed:Cogworker's Puzzleknot, Consulate Turret, Pacification Array, Pressure Point, Confiscation Coup, and Spire Patrol

Added:Cast Out, Hieroglyphic Illumination, Fumigate, Approach of the Second Sun, Censor, and Countervailing Winds.

Also added in more lands with Irrigated Farmland

I am also thinking of adding in Gideon, Martial Paragon but am a little unsure.

Now there is an additional win con with Approach of the Second Sun if it doesn't get de-spelled.

Murphy77 on Izzit to soon?

2 hours ago

Make that Murphy's God of Draw (name-clash)

Murphy77 on Izzit to soon?

2 hours ago

I went a bit heavier on the draw with God of Draw, but good idea.

Darksch81 on Yidris, Cascade Lord

2 hours ago

I've made some changes:

Added Chainer's Edict, Hunting Wilds, Ranger's Path, Sylvan Primordial, Mwonvuli Beast Tracker, (soon Fierce Empath), Flametongue Kavu, Bring to Light, Cinder Glade, Eternal Witness


Explosive Vegetation, Artisan of Kozilek, Thrasios, Triton Hero, Rupture Spire, Gamekeeper, Simic Signet, Far Wanderings, Ancient Excavation, Frenzied Fugue

And the deck goes better. Sometimes I don't need to cast Commander because the deck works all alone like a mana ramp deck for big spells who can break game for their own.Leave some comments or suggestions for the deck. I'd like to add a Baral's Expertise or Rishkar's Expertise but I don't know how to remove

Moonbar on Serious Ponza

2 hours ago

I know, I was kidding haha.

Hanarama on Gisa and Giralf

2 hours ago

No Gravecrawler or Diregraf Captain? Having a sac engine with Gravecrawler and a pinger can be super handy with G&G.

Medivo on Jund Burn

2 hours ago

How do you feel about Claim/Fame and Hellspark Elemental? as well as vexing devil?

Irishboy585 on G/W Creature Bounce

2 hours ago

Aaaaaand.. I just realized that's kaladesh.. >.<

Irishboy585 on G/W Creature Bounce

2 hours ago

Legendary_penguin_of_death I'm trying to keep it for FNM so I don't believe the gearhulk is standard legal. But I do have AoC in my sideboard. I just kept the cheetah because it has flash and I can drop it during my opponents end step. It's definitely worth looking into

Everyday on Embalming Everything

2 hours ago

Embalm? Why not Eternalize? It's a good deck overall, maybe add some counters in it.

CChaos on Politics of the Damned

2 hours ago

Nova Pentacle allows players to work together to pick off creatures with bounty counters.

CChaos on Mathas Midrange-Pillowfort-Politics

2 hours ago

Nova Pentacle is great to help destroy creatures with bounty counters.

LeaPlath on A Beastly Stampede

2 hours ago

So, to start with, there is a lot of beast synergy.

Krosan Warchief provides reduction and the regenerate isn't bad.

Ravenous Baloth is a great way to blank removal and gain life from it, as well as being just efficient.

Beyond that, I don't know what your casual meta is like. Fog/Naturalise are still bad in the main deck. That is what your sideboard is for.

Temur_Frontier on Yahenni of the Endless Offerings ...

3 hours ago

Hmm, that makes sense tbh. I actually just ordered Aetherworks Marvel for my Jund sacrifice deck Ruthless Vengeance. I hope that I can make solid use of it considering I end up killing a lot of tokens and a good amount of my creatures. But I definitely see why you wouldn't want it in your deck (also kind of neglected the fact that in standard/modern, it is much more viable to generate energy for it outside of Aetherworks Marvel itself), hopefully I don't come to a similar conclusion with mine, bc I literally just bought one and it looks fun lol.

sonnet666 on [List - Multiplayer] EDH Generals ...

3 hours ago

chaosumbreon87, Unfortunately Food Chain doesn't work too well with Derevi. The activated ability to put her into play from the command zone isn't casting.

If you went with the normal Misthollow Griffin/Eternal Scourge combo you could get infinite untaps and potentially use a noncreature outlet to win the game with, but then you're essentially playing Tazri Food Chain without access to Black. It also becomes a 3 card combo instead of a 2 card one... I don't think it's worth it.

Everyday on Tariel EDH Deck

3 hours ago

I forgot I needed more ramp spells, thanks. I am a n Eldrazi player so I had the Conduit Of Ruin, and Kozilek's Channeler for big Eldrazi.

7000_Pounds_Of_SALT on Trying to make Tibalt git ...

3 hours ago

JackTheDemon I like that idea. The only reason i haven't considered going vampire tribal before is because i wanted to have as many spells with madness as possible so i could minimize the chances of Tibalt making me accidentally discard the wrong card. But i guess it wouldn't hurt to add just a few.

Jaytotheareokay on Curse Control

3 hours ago

Gotta say Ravenous Demon  Flip seems like a bit of a liability. You only have 4 humans, and if you sac her to flip she comes back as an enchantment, so archdemon will just sit on the field and damage you. Am I missing something?