Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Unlife on EDH Under $1 Series - …

21 minutes ago

Yennet, Cryptic Sovereign could be fun, freecasting huge things for free as long as they're odd

It'll be more applicable when commander legends is released, but it would be interesting to see a working 4 color/partners deck on a budget

Unha110w3d on Shu Yun, the Silent Kill

1 hour ago

Nice deck, really interesting build, i am a fan of voltron style decks.

Snake_Oil on EDH Under $1 Series - …

1 hour ago

Just going by Scryfall (even going as deep as <0.90c in terms of value rather than the full dollar) there are quite a few that spring up that I'd be interested in seeing made on such an extreme budget:

Rashmi, Eternities Crafter -- Simic Control/Tempo is something I'd be super interested to see on a budget, not gonna lie.

Tasigur, the Golden Fang -- Recursive politics on a budget?

Kefnet the Mindful -- You could easily do Mystic Sanctuary loops here, there are a couple of spells that require you to bounce a land to cast, like Deprive and Tragic Lesson.

Oviya Pashiri, Sage Lifecrafter -- Only because I have a budget plan for her myself, I'd be interested in seeing another take on it!

Darigaaz Reincarnated -- This is more of a pet idea for me, I love Darigaaz.

Rosheen Meanderer/Hallar, the Firefletcher -- Both are kind of unique in Gruul colours so it'd be interesting to see either made on a budget.

Sachi, Daughter of Seshiro -- If you're looking for a tribal commander, Shamans are a very unique tribe.

Those are just some that spring to mind for me looking over the list, whether you run with any of them or not I hope you enjoy the process of budgeteering! I know I do whenever I get the itch!

Epicurus on Card creation challenge

2 hours ago

Blitz Director

Creature - Minotaur Warrior

Other creatures you control must attack each turn if able

Tapped creatures you control get +1/+0 and first strike

, sacrifice an attacking creature: ~ deals damage equal to the sacrificed creature's power to target creature or planeswalker

3/3


Ok, so that might be rare, but it is actually watered down from where it was when I first typed it out. Honest.

It recently occurred to me (and correct me if I'm wrong), that creatures with changeling can't mutate. Because they're humans in addition to everything else. In honor of my way-too-late revelation, make a rare for Ikoria.

Beebles on OG Multani, the Marvelous Monstrosity

2 hours ago

Hey Profet93, I see you also have a Multani deck. Nice! I have a few tips for you to consider:

Cheers!

Dottorcoffi on Uro

2 hours ago

La principale instant wincon consiste ottenere con mana infinito da Grand architect+ Pili pala, poi 2 opzioni: 1)nel pescare tutto il mazzo con uro dalla zona di comando + Thassa'Oracle O 2) fare pescare il mazzo all'avversario con blue sun's zenith.

Tutori per pili pala --> muddle the mixture Tutori per grand achitect/pili pala: worldly tutor/zanne e unghie x entrambi

JD0GE on the Pauper Cube

2 hours ago

18/9/2020

separatist voidmage -> power sink

blink of an eye ->logic knot

aethersnipe -> anticipate

voidwielder -> anticognition

curfew -> deliberate

rewind -> merfolk secretkeeper

devious cover-up -> overrule

capsize -> stream of thought

rhystic study -> syncopate

ophidian eye -> opt

calcite snapper -> unwind

Monomanamaniac on Trostani's Friends

2 hours ago

Don't know if you like suggestions, but it looks like you're not running Sol Ring or Arcane Signet, which are staples. I'd also suggest thinking about Helm of the Host, because populating non-legendary copies of trostani is particularly spicy. Also Panharmonicon is really insanely good in this deck. Lastly a sleeper card I adore is Seance because trostani can populate a permanent token you can keep.

As for cuts, nothing really stands out to me, I love the use of Aetherflux Reservoir in this deck because even if you're not storming trostani is buffing your life total immensely. I like this deck, I've always wanted to build one and this may have given me some inspiration

Beebles on Mina & Denn's Supermassive ZNR …

2 hours ago

Thanks Profet93 :). I like your questions! They makes me reconsider card assessments formed long ago. Let’s dig into our new ones:

  • Yavimaya Hollow: a card I like and play in other decks. I also considered it for this deck several times. However, every time I do I feel it just does not belong in this deck. I think the reason why I feel that way is because it’s not the creatures that need protecting most of the time (or that I don’t want to focus on protecting them). Opponents could kill Mina and Denn, Wildborn sure. But they are just an enabler for the deck. Not a key piece, like in decks where I do run Hollow. The deck does not really have many vital pieces like that. On certain moments, yes, hollow will save that one creature you needed for the explosive play, so I do agree it would be a useful include. I just don’t think it is necessary or used very often. A bit like Kessig Wolf Run maybe. To be honest, the threshold of getting one in FOIL also contributes to a feeling of resistance nowadays. However, I can totally see anyone swapping out Spikefield Hazard for Yavimaya Hollow if they feel differently. It might be a good idea to test this one again just to see what happens.
  • If I’d cut Retreat to Kazandu now - which I won’t ;) - I’d probably go for another 2-mana ramp piece or put Krosan Tusker back in. I did just put in Rampant Growth in the last update, so I’m already up a ramp piece (5 now) to skip a turn for M&D. Sol Ring is a no go for me because of the total lack of synergy. Life from the Loam was cut in the last update for Ancient Greenwarden and the deck does not need a 4th effect like that I think. Eternal Witness is nice to have, especially with all the green creature tutors, so that is also a valid choice. Has creeped up on my maybe list rank recently because of Valakut Exploration. Depending on your meta, you can also consider something like Vexing Shusher for the spot.
  • Ancient Tomb: I have a similar opinion on this land compared to hollow and kessig wolf run. They all provide a little something for the deck, but creating a spot for them is just terrible. Apart from Spikefield Hazard there are no lands I am willing to cut atm. Blast Zone has been a strong answer on a land so far that’s easily found. Khalni Garden has a lot of applications and synergy, Radiant Fountain I like for the same reasons as Retreat to Kazandu. Cryptic Caves and Temple of Abandon get you out of dead situations, which I value more than the benefits of the competition. Most other lands feel like they are kind of set in stone now.

MenyTaled on cEDH Tatyova Turns

3 hours ago

You should include Fabled Passage, it is an upgrade over Terramorphic expense, you could even run both. Also you could run just 1 Forest and/or 1 Island, so you can have Field of the Dead active easier.

hejtmane on * text wall* Local tournament …

3 hours ago

Elsha of the Infinite can build her without top using things like Soothsaying Penance to manipulate the top of the library lots of mana rocks are uncommon or common flexibility in build styles.

Peoyogon on Soul Sister's Machine Gun - …

4 hours ago

I really like the idea behind this!

So, I immediately thought of Vampiric Link when looking at this. It's one of my all time favorite cards because of it's versatility. As I was typing out how it might really synergize with your deck, I realized that I think it actually just might go infinite with your setup. Hmm...

Vapor621 on Athreos aristocrats

4 hours ago

This deck is always a solid threat at our table.

rdean14 on Card creation challenge

4 hours ago

Elesh Norn, the Compleationist

Legendary Planeswalker - Norn

Activated abilities of lands can't be played unless they're mana abilities.

+1: Detain target nonland permanent.

-3: Create a 2/2 white Knight creature token with vigilance.

-10: You get an emblem with "Creatures can't attack you or a planeswalker you control unless their controller pays for each of those creatures."

4


I'd like to see a Red/White Warrior uncommon

SynergyBuild on Could Black Have This Effect?

5 hours ago

DragonSliver9001 Honestly Idk why people like Trius even complained, Ugin, the Spirit Dragon is literally in standard, we have colorless permanent removal and have had it for a long while xD

LilMissWiz on Selvala (cEDH)

5 hours ago

Lanzo493 I love all the feed back greatly. Ashaya is something I am keeping an eye on. Scale Up is a card I've been thinking about but I chose Berserk over it.

Allosaurus Shepherd is something I 100% want to get but at $100+ with no foil option it's on standby for now.

Lanzo493 on Selvala (cEDH)

5 hours ago

Allosaurus Shepherd would be awesome in this deck. One of the best answers to Island ever printed. I think Ashaya, Soul of the Wild could pull a lot of work in this deck, too. It's gigantic for its mana cost, and it even combos with Quirion Ranger and Scryb Ranger for infinite mana while protecting you against Cyclonic Rift. With the number of fetches you're running, Dryad Arbor would work great. It's useful tech against sacrifice effects and is a good turn 1 Green Sun's Zenith target. My last comment is just a thought, since I don't know how well your deck runs, but Scale Up could be your green version of Dark Ritual, especially if you use it the first time you untap with Selvala.

I would keep Worldly Tutor. You never know when you need to tutor for Walking Ballista because you have no outlet for infinite mana, or games when you need Craterhoof Behemoth to win, or tutoring any number of other cards for other reasons.

wonderboyrox on YOU get a car! And …

5 hours ago

Annaresti Thanks! I'm glad you like it. And yeah, I think Massacre Wurm would make a fine fit for an alt win con, but personally don't see it as a "must have" for Modern due to it's CMC. I think it might be a bit too slow to be competitive. But otherwise, especially for a chill casual game with friends, definitely a solid card that fits the theme well!

ThomB96 on Card creation challenge

6 hours ago

Urabrask, Unbridled

Legendary Planeswalker-Urabrask

0

Make a 1/1 red artifact creature with haste and "When this creature deals combat damage to a player, sacrifice it"

+1

Until your next turn, creatures you control enter the battlefield with haste and creatures your opponents control enter the battlefield tapped

-6

Make a 4/4 red artifact creature with menace for each in your mana pool.

Starting Loyalty: 2


I want an Urabrask planeswalker so bad.

Make an Elesh Norn planeswalker to go along with it.

Annaresti on YOU get a car! And …

6 hours ago

What a fun build. Thanks for sharing this with everyone.

Could Massacre Wurm work with this set up as an alt wincon? Murdering all the gifts, and pinging into oblivion?

Maybe it wouldn't fit, but I want to try it out.

Benthehen333 on EDH Under $1 Series - …

6 hours ago

So I've decided to begin my series of budget commander decks again from scratch, but this time I'll try to keep them as updated and current as possible, as well as actually making them as good as I possibly can with price restrictions in mind. I'm also planning to playtest each of them extensively, either on Tappedout or Untap.in, and once they've been tuned I will buy them in paper to have the true experience.

So basically, I need suggestions for commanders to start it off! I've looked at lots already, and have some in mind, but I'd really appreciate some from you guys. Here's a link to Scryfall that shows all legendary creatures currently under $1. (amazing site for finding cards by the way.) Link

DragonSliver9001 on Could Black Have This Effect?

6 hours ago

gavriel1136 i dont think anyone said anything about conspiracies, but ok lol

carpecanum on Arcades - Quarantine King

6 hours ago

The vows are nice but targets can still block your creatures. Bloodthirsty Blade, Martial Impetus, Psychic Impetus and Predatory Impetus instead? I hate Vow of Duty unless its on my guys.

Necropolis is an old fun card. Wall of Junk can be recast for card draw.

gavriel1136 on Could Black Have This Effect?

6 hours ago

Mark Rosewater, Magic's head designer, said on his blog that the reason for the change was because they didn't like that, unlike artifacts and creatures, only 2 colors could destroy enchantments. So they found a way to allow a third color to do so. There's no vast conspiracy. They explained quite clearly why they made that decision.

Lanzo493 on * text wall* Local tournament …

7 hours ago

From what I've heard so far, 2 of the first place winners were Sigarda, Host of Herons voltron and Korvold, Fae-Cursed King that could also get rather large. Sounds like going big is a good idea if you can't figure anything else

Squirrel_of_War on The Doom Song

7 hours ago

@Themysteriousone I know but I love the art and I like having a card that helps the table out. It is definitely possible it could backfire but it also stops counterterspells and removal during my turn so it's not all bad. Definitely the first card I'll cut if it doesn't work out.

griffstick on Deadshot

7 hours ago

I've decided to add Mirage Mirror because I feel the deck could use more of the similar effects its looking for like another pinger, or another Quietus Spike, or another Inferno Titan, or another Wound Reflection, or another Cabal Coffers, or whatever juicy target you want. Its Just good utility

MindAblaze on Would Dovin Have Been a …

7 hours ago

To elaborate on the conspiracy theory...tezzeret and Baan had an uneasy relationship while serving Bolas, but they recognized each other’s skills. Tezzeret also has a prior relationship with the praetors, and I’m sure could arrange a salvage...

Themysteriousone on The Doom Song

7 hours ago

Yeah, no problem. Honestly don't think Sire of Stagnation is a bad card at all, and if you can get it out early gives you good card advantage. I would suggest taking out Tidal Barracuda that one just doesn't fit in.

enpc on Sen triplets + Head games

7 hours ago

If you did want to, your other option (against non-combo players) would be to fill their hand with lots of really cheap mana ramp (especially rocks). Then you can play all of the cards in their hand in one turn, leaving them top decking.

MindAblaze on Would Dovin Have Been a …

7 hours ago

Or maybe teZzeret salvaged his corpse?

kei1 on Nekusar EDH Cards for Everyone

7 hours ago

Peoni Thank you. There are definitely a lot of things to try out. The part I'm having the most trouble with now is trying to figure out what to cut.

Out:
Bottomless Pit
Necrogen Mists
Oppression

In:
Notion Thief
Fate Unraveler
Force of Will

DuTogira on Would Dovin Have Been a …

7 hours ago

Yes, Dovin would have been a fantastic Phyrexian. He was even an artificer to some degree.
Chalk it up to another “wizards totally screwed the pooch on THAT one” moment.

GhostChieftain on * text wall* Local tournament …

7 hours ago

Could do lurrus reanimator and have a combo wincon with animate dead and leonin relic warder

DragonOfTheWest on Card creation challenge

7 hours ago

Avacyn, Restored to Servitude 

Legendary Creature - Angel

Flying

Avacyn enters the battlefield tapped.  When she does, search your library for a Demon creature card, reveal it, and put it into your hand.

4/4


See above.

StardustDragon11 on Card creation challenge

7 hours ago

Avacyn, back in black

Legendary Creature- Angel Demon

Whenever you cast Avacyn, back in black, each opponent sacrifices all but one creature the control. You may put a creature sacrificed this way onto the battlefield under your control, it is a black and red demon in addition to it's other types and colors.

Flying

5/5


Remake an iconic phyrexian as a Planeswalker.

DragonSliver9001 on Could Black Have This Effect?

7 hours ago

DemonDragonJ: they probably waited 27 years cuz thats how long it took for people to start complaining about it. each color is supposed to have things it can't do well, or even at all. plus we've had Scour from Existence for 5 years now. so at a bare minimum, every color has had access to unconditional removal for any permanent, even lands, for at least 5 years.