Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Avaliere on U/W control for Bob

1 minute ago

Dark Confidant is called Bob as a nickname. It might be good to alert the community that Bob here is actually someone in the local play group who's been playing grixis death's shadow and whomping on us.

AgentGreen on Hour of Devastation Spoilers

2 minutes ago

That card is risky as all hell. Very good chance you could whiff and if you do you are in a world of hurt

Vonderbar on The Cecani Family Reunion

2 minutes ago

Update: -1 Swamp +1 Drownyard Temple

Explanation: Pretty simple switch here. We are milling a lot of cards, so this adds a land we card bring back into play if it's milled.

DarkLaw on Hour of Devastation Spoilers

5 minutes ago

I feel sorry for the red players. You can't even stack your deck beforehand.

Skeraan on JTBachmann

6 minutes ago

I answered your comment if you need it

Skeraan on Energy Turtle Tribal (9$)

7 minutes ago

Yeah I'm sorry, I don't know how to "register" the changes except by writing an update. I replaced 2 Evincar's Justice with 2 Pestilence and changed the sideboard: took out 2 Artful Dodge, Pestilence, 2 Shimmering Wings, 2 Silburlind Snapper, Turn Aside and put in 3 Into the Roil, 3 Pack's Disdain and 2 Scarab Feast.

nocteus on Adbond Nano

12 minutes ago

I see! I like this deck's idea a lot!What about some snipe lands: Shivan Gorge, Stensia Bloodhall or Keldon Megaliths?With Shivan, you can use then Minamo, School at Water's Edge for redundancy.

Wonky.wombat. on Here, I command!

13 minutes ago

You will wart some counters, I would suggest Mana Leak and Remand, so that your opponent can't stick a good treat, or so that they can't kill yours. Also, I don't think that Saheeli Rai is doing much for you here. Love the concept though, +1.

clayperce on Magus of the Crucible (HOU)

15 minutes ago

Calispotato,
Thanks much! I just hope it's as much fun irl as it's been in testing!

MirkwoodWolfPack on Dragon Hive

18 minutes ago

Oloro_Magic, I actually did have Savage Ventmaw at one point, but I found that the deck generates so much mana that when Savage Ventmaw would hit the field it made me wish I just had one of my token-generators on the field instead. As far as Silumgar, the Drifting Death goes, I almost agree with you in that Atarka, World Render would be better, but that limits me in what I'm able to kill. If Silumgar and two other dragons attack, every creature an opponent controls with 3 toughness or less are immediately wiped when I declare the attack, and any bigger creatures left are severely weakened, whereas Atarka giving dragons doulbe strike limits me to being able to only kill whichever creatures decide to block however many dragons I have. As far as the mana goes, I never have a problem getting Silumgar out. With hexproof Sylvan Caryatid, the two dragon lands, and not to mention Elvish Piper giving me any creature for free regardless, I've never thought twice about it. I almost wanted to put in some Black land for Silumgar and Broodmate Dragon but I found that it just wasn't necessary since so many of my cards allow me to ignore the color of mana or ignore mana all together with Elvish Piper. I guess what it might honestly come down to between Silumgar and Atarka would probably be how many creatures the opponent is playing with. If I'm going up against aggro green elves or something, Silumgar is definitely coming, but if I was going up against Black or a deck that uses less total creatures, then Atarka would definitely be the better pick, so I'd probably just side one of the two out in Game 2 depending on the deck I was fighting. But the cool thing about this deck (because it utilizes Elvish Piper) is that I can side-in pretty much any creature I want and abuse their ETBs like Kederekt Leviathan or something, but I'm getting off track.

What I'd honestly love is to get some Dragon Eggs in here to combo with Overgrown Battlement and to abuse Scourge of Valkas even more with belated dragons entering battle. The more dragons on the field sooner, the quicker the game usually ends.

What do you think about what I've said, am I crazy or making sense? Really appreciate the input either way. Love to get an outside opinion. You get tunnel vision hard when working on a single deck for months.

Bulldawg1310 on Bulldawg1310

25 minutes ago

Nm hallowed fountain id offer 8 dollars.

andre.neka on monoblack discard

25 minutes ago

if you like this deck or have some ideas please comment here :)

Bulldawg1310 on kyuuri117

26 minutes ago

Definitely interested in the strands! How would you want payment?

wychwoodmonkey on Daretti Scrap Savant EDH

29 minutes ago

First Update

Based on reading at the following resources, I upgraded elements of the deck:

  • (https://www.mtggoldfish.com/articles/upgrading-c14-red-urza-s-janky-combos)
  • (http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/the-game/commander-edh/multiplayer-commander-decklists/579747-daretti-scrap-savant-artifact-shenanigans)

OUT:

Creatures

Artifacts

Enchantment

Instant

Land

IN:

Creatures

Planeswalker

Artifacts

Instant

Sorcery

Land

Alkarius on Competitive Jhoira EDH

32 minutes ago

Definitely like Riptide Laboratory, will probably replace my Wandering Fumarole with it. Omniscience I finally bought a week ago and it is amazing. Maze of Ith I wish would tap for mana, but I can see its usefulness, will probably add it at some point.

wereotter on The Ten Plagues: Locust God ...

32 minutes ago

Hmm. I would suggest replacing Tandem Lookout. I would expect people will just block whatever he's soul bonded to in order to deny you card draw. You'll probably get more cards off Forgotten Creation

Also ironic that we both forgot the creature who's name specifically says he's forgotten :)

Qolorful on Standard Theorized No Creautres

34 minutes ago

considering you have no planeswalkers, oath of gideon is not useful to you at all. Servo Exhibition will do the same thing for less cost.

Thorbogl on werewolfs attack

36 minutes ago

You Sir, need some Isochron Scepters.

+1 for playing werewolves

abby315 on None

37 minutes ago

It's okay to have different trading philosophies! Hope we can work something out in the future. GL!

GeminiSpartanX on None

41 minutes ago

If you don't round the numbers, it's still in your favor by about $1 which is decent for a trade this small. I'm always in favor of fair trades. The reason I trade through this medium is so I can get the proper value from my cards (as opposed to trading in to a shop or dealer). If either of those small cards I requested will break this trade for you, so be it.

Bababad on Egyptian God of the Rising ...

42 minutes ago

I've been tinkering with a French brew of this, but mostly focusing on life loss/damage. That being said, I have some fun options.

Breathstealer's Crypt is god tier. helps drain your opponents of resources and life while gaining you a litany of options by discarding your own creatures for free. Hoses mass draw decks/toolbox decks.

Even though you run a handful of non-zambles, Noxious Ghoul does some serious work...with your level of recursion wiping all non-zombies just gives you options and a winning swing.

Lord of the Undead and Phyrexian Reclamation / Tortured Existence make Gempalm Polluter's cycle abusable as heck

Tombstone Stairwell serves me pretty well in testing, but I generally see it as a worse Endless Ranks of the Dead

depending on your meta Balthor the Defiled might serve you well, I plan on playing mostly 1 v 1 with this deck so his ability should win me the game whenever I decide to use it, since ive been exiling/stealing all their good pieces the entire game. Otherwise he is just a body version of Living Death for you without requiring any sacrifice

Grimgrin, Corpse-Born is a solid beater that doubles as a free sac outlet and slow creature removal (but efficient), usually him alongside Mikaeus, the Unhallowed and as many Diregraf Captain effects as you can fit ends the game outright (scarab trigger on upkeep then clearing your field can do substantial damage). He even fits your mill strategy with Phenax, God of Deception, just tap/mill/sac/untap/etc. until they are wiped out...milling one more card every time you do so

kyuuri117 on Looking for deck completion, have ...

43 minutes ago

I've got 4 tarkir flooded strands I could sell for $50, they're lp/nm. Leave a message on my wall if you're interested.

Shmobley9 on Spirit Breaker

43 minutes ago

I suppose the deck is more midrange

Vyronix on H: 3 chalice of the ...

45 minutes ago

I have a lot of pieces for an Enchantress EDH deck but with the value of Chalice growing everyday, I doubt it'll come to 3x Chalice of the Voids

TheAlexGnan on Modern Tiered List Weekly Update ...

47 minutes ago

This list is great. Its extremely easy to read, trends are also shown very nicely by giving 3 weeks of meta share. The only question is the one above: where is the cut-off point for tiers? is it the number of decks, or its percentages? or its points? thats not clear to me.

Otherwise: best metagame breakdown I know in terms of information value and readability.

Oloro_Magic on Dragon Hive

47 minutes ago

Savage Ventmaw can give you tons of surplus mana to cast another dragon with also I feel you should focus this deck down to wither Jund or Gruul, SIlumgar is a stretch on your mana base, Atarka, World Render would work just as well in the colour you play.

Fine_Dough on Krunko, Party Animal

47 minutes ago

Good point, but that is exactly what I intend to do. Win within the first 5 turns, that is. But it would probably help to have lil' more interaction, so I will try it out.

DarkLaw on Hour of Devastation Spoilers

47 minutes ago

The worst of the entire cycle, apart from black. That's a lot of mana to pay for not a lot.

odinson12thor on Badger pump

49 minutes ago

needs more cowbell

dhoby87 on Ad Nauseam Doomsday Zur

49 minutes ago

Thoughts on Glacial Chasm and the new card Solemnity??

Reverie42 on Meren Sacrifice

49 minutes ago

Thanks for the suggestions, much appreciated.

Yavimaya Elder is a great idea. It's clearly better than Viridian Emissary. I think Hermit Druid is also better than Mulch. Sadly, Life from the Loam is too pricey for me.

I've been waffling a lot on Grim Haruspex and forgot to maybeboard it, so this was a good reminder. In general, I've found that card draw isn't too big of a problem, but I think there's a good chance that it's just better than Altar's Reap. Harvester of Souls would probably have to compete with something like Sidisi, Undead Visier or Demon of Dark Schemes for a spot, though.

Jleatz91 on Red white RAWR

50 minutes ago

Help appreciated:)

brayark on Teal_Fox

54 minutes ago

thx for the comments on me edh deck :P

zandl on TappedOut Commander Series: Episode 1

55 minutes ago

Yeah yeah, you guys. Just forgot, is all.

Editing...

DRmagic2017 on Atraxa, Praetors' Infection

55 minutes ago

It's nice to see four Praetors in your maybeboard. All will be one!Nice deck too. + 1

Thorbogl on Thorbogl

57 minutes ago

Hey there.Actually i'd Like to trade Archangel Avacyn  Flip for your Green Sun's Zenith and Regal Force if that's an Option for you aswell.Would definitly send First due to Not having traded on tappedout so far.

n0bunga on Mono Red Prowess

58 minutes ago

Hey! Some thoughts for possible entries and sides, some probably transfer over to your jeskai build.

Magma Spray - probably side, but the exile is definitely huge in a format with Scrapheap Scrounger, etc. By ForceI'm still debating about Chandra, Torch of Defiance here. On the one hand, mid-to-late game, supposing a game ever lasts that long, it nets you to cast your spells and leave your mana open.

I also dig the idea of running Temur, or Naya-Blue shells for the sake of Blossoming Defense, Become Immense and Heroic Intervention to protect your stuff.

Dynavolt Tower and Harnessed Lightning might be something to mull over.

Enral on Toxic Relationship: Hapatra EDH

59 minutes ago

Daedalus19876: I think the only thing I would do is to put the Mike combo back since you already have hulk to fetch for the instant win. This will give you an alternate out to impossible games and mike is really good in your deck already.

puetypoo on Fling, Metalwork Colossus. Enough Said

1 hour ago

oh, ok good on you then, I've never really payed that card any attention.