Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

hkhssweiss on Are YOU a Hopeless Necromantic?! ...

2 minutes ago

Quick question, is your Teneb deck essentially a goodstuff reanimator deck?

raulm3 on Decks not updating properly?

5 minutes ago

I noticed with the last 2 decks i made, even though my commander is gruul the decks come up as colorless on the display. the competitive meter also doesnt show up nor do the prices update after updating cards. Anyone else having this issue?

zenia on Hymn of Darkness: Elenda EDH ...

16 minutes ago

Hey, you have listed Fetid Heath twice. Might check that.

StoneAgeHero on Daxos of Meletis Budget

31 minutes ago

chadsansingThanks for the suggestions. Neurok Stealthsuit was always on the edge of being included, but I will try it out a bit and maybe add it if it works out.

Spirit_Logan on Any cards like the c17 ...

37 minutes ago

I am trying to build a combat-controlling deck. Are there any cards like the c17 curses? (Curse of Vitality, Curse of Opulence, Curse of Disturbance)

I have Curse of Chaos, Curse of the Forsaken, Curse of Stalked Prey, Curse of Shallow Graves, and the c17 curses. THEY NEED TO BE MARDU

druna on druna

40 minutes ago

Hi Guys!

Trotticus on Card creation challenge

42 minutes ago

Rat Grenade

Artifact - Trap

Whenever an opponent attacks with three or more creatures, this spell gains flash.

, sacrifice Rat Grenade: Create a number of 1/1 black rat creature tokens with deathtouch equal to 2 plus the number of attacking creatures.

Create a balanced, non-planeswalker card that makes an emblem.


45 minutes ago

Ive been doing a lot of play testing with Rhonas as well. Here is my list if youre interested:


Pickachu202 on Esper Faeries

47 minutes ago

Latchkey Faerie seems like a shoe in. Also white seems to slow it down

Kalkin on Green Ramp Guide & Deck ...

58 minutes ago

Nice deck ! That's the reason why I run Harsh Mentor in my sideboard, damn that Arbor Elf. There's no real answer in your deck or sideboard should you run into that sort of card or am I wrong ?

recqq on Vial Smasher / Kydele - ...

59 minutes ago

Hey here is my list on mtgo https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/vial-kydele-wheel-partners

Sulk on Casual Dirty combo

1 hour ago

Lol dude, not even close. South Africa.

fizztromancer on BW Ascension Vampires

1 hour ago

Argy I was thinking for ub control


-2 Fatal Push

-3 Legion's Landing  Flip

-3 Martyr of Dusk


+1 Arguel's Blood Fast  Flip

+3 Duress

+2 Lost Legacy

+2 Profane Procession  Flip

This is to improve our removal vs them and keep our card draw good because normally we wont be able to keep 3 creatures out to flip legions landing and martyr is just a dead card just like fatal push. This is the main match I want to try to land an early procession or a blood fast because outdrawing vs them is key and our life total is really negligible vs them because once they hit and stick a scarab god or gearhulk and we dont have an immediate answer we are just dead.

Neth on Shadowborn Athreos prototype

1 hour ago

i goldfished it real quick. this is very fun thanks! i was planning to go for athreos but wasnt sure how

druna on druna

1 hour ago

Hi Guys!

Kjartan on Eldrazi PainBringer

1 hour ago

I have some suggestions the.

Drop Cloud Key. it's good if you cast multiple spells of the choses type per turn. But since that rarely happens Mind Stone is better. Expedition Map is also a key card.

Turn something in your creature base into a couple of Walking Ballista. It's ping-effect is rather important in the deck against certain matchups. Most people run 4. I's say that's a lot, but at least 2 copies would be a helping hand.

Cut down on your biggest creatures. Look into getting some of the midgame Eldrazi. Matter Reshaper, Reality Smasher, Endbringer and most importantly, the best eldrazi in the game Thought-Knot Seer.

If you want to make the deck really good Chalice of the Void is your savior.

thegeekvapor on thegeekvapor

1 hour ago


multimedia on Atraxa budget

2 hours ago

Hey, here's my $160 budget Atraxa deck, Nature's Horrifying Voice (Budget). Check it out it might give you some ideas.

With budget four and five color manabases I think it's better to play two dominate colors, third color less dominate then the first two and small splash of the rest. Trying to play all four or five colors as equal amounts in a manabase is nearly impossible without the Fetch land/Shock land interaction. Both these types of lands are however not low budget cards.

Green gives you the most flexibility for a budget manabase with other cards that can help you be able to make all four colors because green has the best interaction with Basic lands. Cards like Sakura-Tribe Elder, Farhaven Elf, Solemn Simulacrum these are good cards that can help you to make different colors of mana and land ramp at the same time, but they only care about Basic lands.

Lotus Cobra is now a budget green card and it's great for four and five color decks. You can't take huge advantage of the Fetch land interaction with it, but Evolving Wilds, Expanse are fine budget Fetch options. Birds of Paradise is not low budget, but it can make any color of mana as well as help to ramp into Atraxa.

Green has land ramp, Cultivate, etc which you're already playing great, but there's also Farseek. I like Farseek with four and five color manabases because it can Fetch a Battle land, in this case: Canopy Vista, Sunken Hollow, Prairie Stream. Battle lands also work well with lots of Basic lands. Nature's Lore, Skyshroud Claim, Spoils of Victory and Shard Convergence also work well with Battle lands.

Any budget four or five color manabase I make in Commander I try to limit the amount of lands that ETB tapped. Tri lands, Wilds, Expanse and creature lands such as Lumbering Falls are really the only lands I want that ETB tapped because these lands are good enough to warrant ETB tapped.

For a four color budget manabase I prefer to use Tri lands, Wilds, Expanse, Tower, both Orchards, 15-20 Basic lands with Battle lands and Check land interactions and Pain lands which always ETB untapped.

Vivid lands may be the exception with Atraxa because you can proliferate the counters on them, but If choosing to play them then I wouldn't also play Tri lands. I would choose between the two.

Good luck with your deck.

Coward_Token on Shadowborn Athreos prototype

2 hours ago

I made some suggestions for a similar deck, check out Karador, Shadowborn Chieftain if anything's applicable for yours. Mosty notably, I think the Scroll Rack + Thrumming Stone combo is going to work well with Athreos' hand-filling ability.

Magus_of_the_Brothels on Goat Party

2 hours ago

what is the win con here?

Haseoyamazaki on List of Bugs and Feature ...

2 hours ago

View count for decks is not working, the casual/competitive meter longer displays and the color wheel in the deck preview thumbnail is not displaying on two of my decks.


2 hours ago

Wow-Owen Wilson

Jeepod on Jimmy's Animar-Morph l Game Knights ...

2 hours ago

@Last_Laugh watch the video of their deck tech on it and you'll see at 51m they talk about it. It's because ancestral statue and/or cloudstone curio would be too easy infinite loop to assemble. That would make it less attractive for the viewers for their game knights show. But yeah, it was in the deck.

druna on druna

2 hours ago

Hi Guys!

NV_1980 on Meren's Returning Army

2 hours ago

Thanks for commenting and the +1 docbp87. I've never really needed ridiculous amounts of mana while playing this deck. I'm not using any spells with variable mana costs, and stuff that's relatively expensive to cast is often cheated into play. These cards also aren't all that useful during the early stages of a game as you need at least a number of lands or other mana sources on the table to make them interesting. Also, I doubt my friends have either of these available for trade (my husband I no longer buy cards). Still, thanks for sharing your thoughts!

duff87 on Advertise your COMMANDER deck!

2 hours ago

Another Meren deck

Commander / EDH duff87


duff87 on Wizard Tribal Control

2 hours ago

I like it. +1. Maybe Jace, Vryn's Prodigy  Flip? Hes a wizard! And his planeswalker form is great for recasting instats and sorceries. Just a suggestion for ya. Also in the price range you layed out.

Clyde_Bankston on Brago Card Draw

3 hours ago

Thanks lol. I took out Azor and Revelation because it seemed to be getting a bit much. Ill test this bit out.

readerrw07 on Nekusar, the Friendship Destroyer

3 hours ago

Cant think of that much to suggest here, btu what about some land destruction like Wasteland? Great deck overall.

readerrw07 on Advertise your COMMANDER deck!

3 hours ago

Because Wizards are fun and I dont like having friends. Brand new deck looking for suggestions and help

Wizard Tribal Control

Commander / EDH readerrw07


FlamingoBrown on The Queen's Egg

3 hours ago

Great stuff here

yeaGO on Caution With PhotogenicParasympathetic

3 hours ago

Maybe some rule would do, such as no sell-offs, or something.

druna on druna

3 hours ago

Hi Guys!

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

3 hours ago

As legendofas last challenge wasn't fulfilled properly (nezumi, not kitsune) i'll combine that and the dnd challenge:

Sharpeyes, the trapmaster 1WB

Legendary creature - rat rogue

Skulk (this creature can't be blocked by creatures with greater power)

Trap spells you cast cost 2 less to cast.

Trap spells opponents cast cost 1 more to cast.

Whenever ~ enters the battlefield or attacks, you may search your library for a trap card, reveal it and put it into your hand. Shuffle your library afterwards.


Make a trap for sharpeyes to tutor for.

64Demon on Deck Cycling the Cycling Deck

3 hours ago

Replenish and Ancestral Vision if you want to go more expensive. Ancestral visions is really good with As Foretold and replenish is mass replay of enhancements if you ever get wiped.

shadow63 on Caution With PhotogenicParasympathetic

3 hours ago

Why not tag him in this post ?

dommes89 on Etali, Storm of Cheating

3 hours ago

Maybe I will change most of the copy spells for more creatures or ramp since I don't see what meaningful they could copy ...

Because the additional combat spells untap creatures when they're cast. So copy them is quite useless.

hwagner on Caution With PhotogenicParasympathetic

3 hours ago

I just finished a trade with them about 2 weeks ago. It was a smaller trade (only $20 in value) but I had no issue with them. Perhaps they are busy or something came up? Idk but I would keep your head up and be patient and hopeful

WillowtheCouncil on Current Lantern??

3 hours ago

Lantern is still generally decent against mostly everything, it still has its matches it just gets wrecked in, and it's gotten cheaper mainly because demand for its cards have dropped.

I think after the unbannings, people are so busy on finding out how to warp the format that they have forsaken playing Lantern. Also, Lantern's popularity has actually hurt it. Players have begun learning how to play against Lantern (SB options, sequencing plays, etc) and it therefore has gotten a little punch.

I don't think Jace is good for Lantern. Jace is one of the cards that actually can beat Lantern, so that's another point against it.

Still, the deck is good and is worth buying if you find that fun. Players hate Lantern for good reason, so it won't make you any friends. It's a hard deck to play, which is part of the reason it isn't more popular.

Disclaimer, don't personally play Lantern myself, but I spend a lot of time looking at Modern's meta.

hwagner on Best sleeves and playmats ?

3 hours ago

Inked gaming has incredible playmats with thorough instructions on how to make your own. Couldn't recommend them more!

For EDH I always buy Dragon Shields but for constructed formats I prefer Ultra Pro Eclipse sleeves! For limited i just use whatever extra old sleeves I have!

Cansani on Brycej304

3 hours ago


druna on druna

4 hours ago

Hi Guys!

WillowtheCouncil on Wizard's Retort + Wizard's Lightning

4 hours ago

Following comment is for non-Standard formats. I think retort will really only see play in Modern Merfolk. Other decks have options they'd rather have instead of a conditional Counterspell. As it turns out, despite being only a difference of , sometimes being Cancel and sometimes being Counterspell is enough to drive a lot of players away. Also can be annoying to use, especially if the deck isn't monoblue. UW control only gets value when Snapcaster Mage is on the table, so that's kinda meh.

Wizard's Bolt will not see play in formats besides standard. But in standard they might see play, so that's nice. IMO, bolt will end up being more valuable in Standard. Then again, I mainly play modern so take my words with a grain of salt.

For the point about 8x bolt in decks that use wizards, I don't think they really want another playset. Especially because you have to run out a 2 mana creature to make your 3 mana instant cost less? you're still basically paying 3 for the bolt. Sure, there's some dank may mays with flashing back the now cheaper Wizard's bolt, but face it. Unless you run out Snapcaster, an incredibly versatile card, ASAP you have a 3 mana do-nothing.

Bjorn34 on Jaceageddon

4 hours ago

Terrible, mono blue and wins by being jace wtf, downvoted

multimedia on Talrand Control

4 hours ago

Hey, looks good. Is the budget low or high here? I can't tell because I see lots of low budget cards, but then there's Mana Drain, Cryptic Command, As Foretold, Mystic Confluence and Rhystic Study these are great, but not low budget cards.

Low budget suggestions:

Consider High Tide and a three card package of spells Frantic Search, ect. that untap Islands? Even without Tide these cards at instant speed able you to cast two or more spells a turn to create more Drakes. The two mana instant card selection spells Impulse, etc are good with Talrand make a Drake and find another spell to make more. Capsize with buyback for six mana can make a Drake each turn at instant speed while also bouncing any permanent of your opponents or yours such as Archaeomancer. Merchant Scroll is a nice blue tutor finding any blue instant. Archaeomancer can get back a card from the graveyard to cast again such as Tide or Drain.

Cards to consider cutting:

  • Aethersnatch
  • Domineering Will
  • Dream Fracture
  • Overwhelming Intellect
  • Censor
  • Stubborn Denial
  • Braingeyser
  • Draining Whelk
  • Sphinx of Uthuun
  • Geth's Grimoire

High budget suggestions:

Good luck with your deck.

xyr0s on Into the Woods

4 hours ago

Leyline of Sanctity can wreck the whole plan for some decks - bring a couple of them in sideboard, if you expect to see much discard or burn.

WillowtheCouncil on Can I use abrupt decay ...

4 hours ago

No. For activating an ability, any text before the colon is a cost. By the time the ability has been activated, Expedition Map has already been sacrificed.

ExtraEasy on Finding a Semi budget competitive ...

4 hours ago

Seems like bob thinks u should look on youtube for the bannana deck or the land swan hunt.

Comodou on Prepare Your Salami for the ...

4 hours ago


I wanted to know why you use Mana Leak. I've been thinking about it, but I don't know. I've been thinking about using it over Flusterstorm.

Djricci97 on UG Emerge

4 hours ago

Great advice thanks! Fierce Empath is definitely going in. Everything else is awesome as well and I'll be testing all of it. I'm willing to cut Bloodbriar if that's what it comes to. Thanks so much for the comment.