Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

-Arcanity- on Card creation challenge

a few seconds ago

Ooze of the Origins -

Creature - Ooze


When Ooze of the Origins enters the battlefield, you may search your library for an Ooze card, put it into your hand, then shuffle your library.

Whenever another Ooze enters the battlefield under your control, you may pay . If you do, you gain 1 life and draw a card.



Create another Ooze tribal payoff.

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

1 minute ago

Did you guys know there are only six Whales in the whole game, and literally HALF of them have or can gain flying??

Living Island

Legendary Creature

Whales you control have Vigilance.

Whenever Living Island or another Whale you control attacks, you may return a number of permanents to their owner's hands equal to the number of Whales you are attacking with.

You have no maximum handsize.


More unlikely tribal!!

griffstick on "Menace" to Society

3 minutes ago

You see it works here

DRmagic2017 on Darien, King of Kjeldor

17 minutes ago

Hi! I like the deck and Soldier tribe is among my favorites. Just some ideas. Lands: Eiganjo Castle for more protection, Westvale Abbey  Flip as an alternative wincon. Creatures: Kytheon, Hero of Akros  Flip (turns into a Planeswalker easily), Hanweir Militia Captain  Flip (more tokens to transform Westvale Abbey  Flip), Selfless Spirit to protect your army, Tithe Taker ( Grand Abolisher looks much better but Tithe Taker is a Soldier), Baird, Steward of Argive (an element of pillowfort strategy), Selfless Squire - to protect yourself. Sorceries: Conqueror's Pledge for more tokens. Artifacts: Pennon Blade and Stoneforge Masterwork . Good luck!

RJGiel on The Sky is Ours (5c ...

20 minutes ago

Banned in our playgroup for being too powerful :(

OberstHati on Black Judith

46 minutes ago

Glad you like it! Ty!

OberstHati on Mono Black Aggro Burn

48 minutes ago

Looks good, but would you consider splashing red for Risk Factor , Angrath, the Flame-Chained ? Another Card that you could benefit from is Priest of Forgotten Gods , especially when Fungal Infection is boarded in,... Maybe you want to take a look at my Black Judith and Tell me what you think about it? Good Luck with your Deck!

Circularreason on Black Judith

52 minutes ago

This is a nice use of Judith. I opened one at the Ravnica pre-release and didn't have the card synergy to make any good use of her, but you have a combination of sac creatures that do extra damage. Could add up fast. Thanks!

NV_1980 on Grand Guignol: Judith EDH

1 hour ago

Wow. Just, wow!

Though this kind of deck is not really our cup of tea we have to admit it looks stunningly brutal and effective. Well done.


Mrs. and Mr. NV_1980

ilshg on Mono Black Mill Deck Help

1 hour ago

Trying to get a Mono Black Mill/Discard deck to work in a 3 man pod.

One issue I have is being unable to mill the entire table before being targeted. I'm trying to stay away from "degenerate" strats (Mike/Trike) and the Blood/Bond combo and infinite combos.

I'm sure adding Cabal Coffers would help, but it is out of my price range currently. Any help is appreciated, thanks!

I See Your Graveyard And I Want To Paint It Black

Kilrane on Card creation challenge

1 hour ago

Gth'kxtk, Imp of Prosperity

Legendary Creature - Imp Advisor

Flying, Deathtouch

Whenever an opponent discards a card, draw a card then discard a card.

Exile five cards from your graveyard: cast a card in any graveyard without paying its mana cost. Use this ability only when you have ten or more cards in your graveyard.


Bargaining with imps is thought of as worse than bargaining with a devil. It's twice the price for what ever the imp wishes to give you.

More rare tribal!

griffstick on "Menace" to Society

1 hour ago

Iroas, God of Victory 's 1st and 2nd abilities, aka Menace ability and suto Dolmen Gate will guide you to victory.

Attack and buff your creatures with: Agrus Kos, Wojek Veteran , Hero of Bladehold , Hero of Oxid Ridge , Nobilis of War , and many more.

Attack with these and get other stuff: Victory's Herald , Hero of Bladehold , and Hanweir Garrison .

Taking advantage of the 2nd ability: Sword of the Animist , Lightmine Field , Powerstone Minefield , and Pyrohemia , and other instant speed damage based board wipe effects. Once your creatures are attacking they cant be damaged. This effect last until combat is totally over. So even after combat damage (but still combat phase) you can cast a spell to do damage.

+1 Upvote
Like what you see, +1.

don't like what you see ? Check out my other deck Selvala, Explored and Returned with tokens

I missed this stuff too: Agrus Kos, Wojek Veteran , Hero of Oxid Ridge , and Hero of Bladehold they all buff my creatures when they attack so giving them extra attack phases to attack again, buffs them again. So its "battle cry x2" from the Hero's, and its +4/+0 form Agrus Kos, Wojek Veteran on the second attack. Angelic Skirmisher also triggers twice. Not only for my extra combat phases, but my opponents as well. you're all going "duhhh" right, but i knew this too. Didn't realize i have been missing these triggers all the time.

As you can see it works when I remove the changes you said you had to do scotchtapedsleeves

NV_1980 on Sai's Thrumming Thopters

1 hour ago


It may be a bit of a cheesy win-condition, but depending on how many thopters you have on the field, casting Mechanized Production can instantly win you a game. Turning all thopters into dragons with Day of the Dragons might also be a fun. And we would definitely mainboard Steel Hellkite instead of Myr Battlesphere ; that removal ability is just so good.

With kind regards,

Mrs. and Mr. NV_1980

saluma on Haven't played in 10 yrs. ...

1 hour ago

killroy726 sorry buddie but Queen Marchesa ain't grixis but mardu . But Privileged Position Still needs to be droped.

DarthCoercis on Xantcha's Deck of Rude Things

1 hour ago

I've had a couple of people suggest that I include Winter Orb and Static Orb in the deck, and while I agree they're rude cards, I'm not convinced they fit with what I'm trying to do with this deck. They'd both slow down a game, whereas I'm more interested in ending it fairly quickly.

griffstick on "Menace" to Society

1 hour ago

I'm unable to do the double return



Why not?. Also another things not working. I'm unable to do bullets like this

  • uffycjv
  • uffufu
  • udyrk

scotchtapedsleeves, you can see it's all there in the deck edit screen correctly

griffstick on "Menace" to Society

1 hour ago

Everywhere. Black.

Somethings wrong with the accordions. They are all not arranged in the order I had them


Orion9982 on EDH Green Selvala

2 hours ago

Titus78 thank you, I will consider it!

SamsWrath on My LGS's #1 hated deck

2 hours ago

If you really want to take this deck to the next level then you need all of the fast mana and tutors: Mana Crypt , Mana Vault , Grim Monolith , Mox Diamond , Mox Opal , Chrome Mox , Mox Amber , Talisman of Indulgence , Lotus Petal , Dark Ritual , Cabal Ritual , Pyretic Ritual , Desperate Ritual , Rite of Flame , Culling the Weak , Infernal Plunge , Lake of the Dead , Bubbling Muck , Rain of Filth , Grim Tutor , Imperial Seal , Vampiric Tutor and Diabolic Intent .

Since you're already running Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker you might as well add in Zealous Conscripts , Lightning Crafter and Combat Celebrant because they all go infinite with Kiki.

Rakdos is also the color combination you need for Worldgorger Dragon + Dance of the Dead , Animate Dead or Necromancy infinite combo. Use Buried Alive or Entomb to pitch one of the Kiki combos or to pitch the dragon and then use one of the enchantments to start the combo. Be sure with Dragon combo to have another creature in the GY or you draw the game with an uninterruptible infinite combo. Other cards that help these combos are Victimize and Final Parting .

suarkdivad on Pir/Toothy EDH

2 hours ago

Creeping Renaissance can either get a lot of your instant tricks back or a good number of creatures if you've been wiped a few times. There's also Praetor's Counsel but renaissance is cheaper.

I dig the bounce Toothy (or other useful creature) tech.

That comment about needing Nexus of Fate is exactly why you don't want it or the other auto includes. Boring B.S. This deck actually looks fun.

Psychosis Crawler would do some work, but you've gone down that road before.

How have I not seen Forge of Heroes ?

Beast Within over Rapid Hybridization ? I know it costs 2 more, but more flexible and you've driven down the CMC of the deck as it is.

Shadow Rift over Slip Through Space ? I'm not seeing why the colorless makes sorcery speed better, or the slight risk of running into a Nether Traitor.

I don't think the cycling makes Dissenter's Deliverance better than Deglamer .

Glen Elendra Archmage is probably an auto include you should include considering how many uses you'd likely get out of it.

Spike Weaver is something I'd put in, but not really your style. But... fogs...

sergiodelrio on Modern Horizons Reprints / Tinfoil ...

2 hours ago

@DruneGrey Phoenix deck wasn't around when Horizons was made so probably ok imho

IlLupo643 on The Pack

2 hours ago

I can agree to Huntmaster of the Fells  Flip, and actually have one as were I do not yet have Master of the Wild Hunt

carlmoores on Mairsil's Jail for Combos

2 hours ago


Other people's recursion targets. It's not like Muldrotha is currently the most popular commander in the format. Do you also not play Bojuka Bog ?

Really dude. From your commedts on Rediit you're running Mairsil as a discard deck. You aren't qualified to be giving advice.

xandrila on Neheb Wheel of Chaos

2 hours ago

Aggravated Assault... Didn't own it at the time and now the deck is apart. Maybe next time I rebuild. Also I sold my foil Neheb.

rdean14 on Card creation challenge

2 hours ago

Sorry, didn't see your post yet. Sure, let's see more imps

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

2 hours ago

rdean14 Lol I just did one. Razormaw Imp. But we can always make another.


rdean14 on Card creation challenge

2 hours ago

Autumn, Hermit of Nantuko

Legendary Planeswalker - Autumn

+1: Create a 1/1 green Squirrel creature token.

-3: Create an emblem with "non-Human creature tokens you control have shroud"

-7: Create X 1/1 green Squirrel creature token, where X is the number of creatures. Squirrels you control have indestructible until end of turn. Then, every squirrel fights every non-squirrel creature.


I'd like to see an Imp Legendary creature

Mcspacky on The Pack

2 hours ago

Check out Huntmaster of the Fells  Flip, it seems like it would fit in this deck somewhere.

Daddy1ong1egs13 on H: Hydroid Krasis W: Binders

2 hours ago

Just opened a Hydroid Krasis that I don't need. Let me know if you're interested!

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

3 hours ago

Razormaw Imp

Legendary Creature - Imp

Flying, Skulk

Whenever another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life.

Sacrifice a creature: Scry 1.

Sacrifice two creatures: Draw three cards.

Sacrifice three creatures: Destroy target creature.


I'm not sure what Imps are like both in MTG lore and in fables, but a solid Aristocrats Commander felt fair. I was sort of thinking of the Toothfairies from Hellboy.

Anyway, we've got Jarlaxle2014's squirrel-themed Planeswalker up next.

rangers2011 on Soul of the Tokens

3 hours ago

I am a big fan of Second Harvest in any token deck and I would add Darksteel Mutation to deal with pesky commanders

Mcspacky on U/B Mill

3 hours ago

Always love a good U/B mill. If you want another win con, Duskmantle Guildmage + Mindcrank is a fun one. Check out adding Visions of Beyond if you find that you need more card draw. For your mill spells, definitely look into upgrading to Glimpse the Unthinkable , Archive Trap , Breaking , or Mind Funeral .

I agree with wallisface as well. It seems like you're trying to fit both the creature mill and the spell mill into the same deck. In my experience I haven't really found a U/B list that can do both. This is a great start though!

Happy Brewing!

RoarMaster on Secret Tech you have found!

3 hours ago

Portcullis .

Really just by itself, but if you wanna get trixy with it, add some creatures with ETB effects like Fiend Hunter / Banisher Priest , and/or Flickerwisp style things.

rangers2011 on Emmara's Army

3 hours ago

I also have an Emmara deck, but mine is a bit less focused and on a budget. Despite this I can recommend adding Conclave Tribunal this shuts down any permanent an opponent has even if only for a limited amount of time. I would also recommend Divine Visitation (if you add this you might want to cut Crackdown ), while having 1/1 lifelink is good, 4/4 vigilance ensures you can pressure and keep blockers. On the note of tokens I recommend Doubling Season , while I don't run it because of my budget, it helps to dissuade opponents attacking you. I also recommend Mirari's Wake to double mana for a huge March of the Multitudes you can also dump excess mana by adding a Staff of Domination , or for more budget friendly Sword of the Paruns , to create more Emmara tokens. For more defense i recommend Sandwurm Convergence this shutsdown fliers and gives you a big blocker on the ground every turn. Also to maximize Emmara's ability I run a Wirewood Lodge . For end game I suggest Wayfaring Temple it builds off of the tokens and creates more, also [Shanna, Sisay's Legacy]. to make your creatures bigger and to tap Emmara I run Dragon Throne of Tarkir . Twilight Drover doubles tokens. Hour of Reckoning kills everything but tokens. Darksteel Mutation to remove problematic creatures (works really well to shut down commanders). Beastmaster Ascension and Overrun ends games. Shalai, Voice of Plenty prevents targeting. Nature's Chosen to tap and untap Emmara. I hope this helps give you more ideas and I wish you the best of luck finishing your deck :D

Jarlaxle2014 on Card creation challenge

3 hours ago

Quiznak 3UUU Legendary Creature- Homunculus

During your upkeep, create a token that is a copy of Quiznak except that it is not legendary. At the beginning of your end step, if you control 7 or more Quiznaks, return all non Quiznak shuffle all other permanents into their owners library, each player discards his or her hand and draws that many cards. 3/4

Make a squirrel themed Planeswalker.

Scaletipper1418 on Modern Naya Soldiers

3 hours ago

Please let me know if there are any other good red or green cards that can be added to the deck to improve it.

Lordofthesith on Missing render silent triggers

3 hours ago

I had a disagreement with someone at my LGS and wanted your opinion on the matter

Player A: casts Render Silent

It resolves and counters the spell

Player B: attempts to cast a spell that would end the game

Player A was going to allow it to happen despite Player B being unable to cast spells

I am sitting at a nearby table and am spectating and make sure that Player B knows that he cannot cast spells so they back up

Player B becomes upset with me interfering with the game if I’m not a player in the game.

Should I have stayed silent and told them after even though the game would have been fundamental changed based on a illegal action?

What is the ruling on this now that WOTC has said when you miss a trigger you can’t go back?

Thanks guys

Joe_Ken_ on Help with Budget Izzet Combo ...

3 hours ago

Well a good tutor card in Blue is Long-Term Plans since it is the only one that lets you select any card and not need to reveal it, granted it’ll take a little while to get to. Another card I would recommend is Seal of the Guildpact to make all your stuff cost less mana.

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

3 hours ago

rdean14 I love how we both did Dimir Rogues with 4cmc and 4 toughness.

I swear, some things just fit.

rdean14 on Card creation challenge

3 hours ago

Oops, ninja'd

Prakhata Broker

Creature - Aetherborn Rogue

, Sacrifice an Aetherborn creature: Create a black artifact token named Aether Powder. It has ", Sacrifice this permanent: Target creature attacks or blocks this turn if able. You may choose who it attacks or how it blocks."

, Sacrifice two Aether Powder artifacts: Create a 2/3 black Aetherborn Rogue creature.


Same challenge.

cainrod on Modular Partners

3 hours ago

Should think about proliferate with storage lands

multimedia on Budget Niv-Mizzet, Parun Combo EDH

3 hours ago

Hey, saw your forum topic asking for help. Nice budget deck :) What is the max budget amount?

Budget cards ($4 or less each) to consider adding:

Cards to consider cutting:

  • 1x Mountain
  • Izzet Guildgate
  • Highland Land
  • Chemister's Insight
  • Dismiss
  • Ionize
  • Dissolve
  • Opportunity
  • Deep Analysis
  • Shock
  • Starstorm
  • Lightning Strike
  • Erratic Cyclops
  • Gelectrode
  • Crackling Drake
  • Enigma Drake
  • Wee Dragonauts
  • Spellheart Chimera
  • Beacon Bolt
  • Concentrate
  • Foresee
  • Corrupted Grafstone
  • Vessel of Endless Rest

If you would like I offer more help. Good luck with your deck.

Jarlaxle2014 on Jarlaxle2014

3 hours ago