Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

DemonDragonJ on How Shall Reality Fracture be …

5 days ago

Now that alternate versions of both Liliana and Ral have appeared, I believe that it is safe to presume that Reality Fracture shall feature alternate versions of other characters, as well, or even alternate versions of major stories or events in MtG, but the Time Spiral block already featured reality fracturing and alternate versions of existing characters, so I wonder how, exactly, the story writers shall make Reality Fracture different from Time Spiral; I shall presume that RF shalla ffect much of the multiverse, as the events of the TS block occurred primarily on Dominaria, but I hope that the writers shall do more than that to distinguish the two events/sets.

What does everyone else say about this subject? How shall Reality Fracture be different from Time Spiral? I am very interested to hear your thoughts, on this matter.

DemonDragonJ on How Many Players Use the …

5 days ago

wallisface, I use the term "mass destruction" to refer to cards or effects that can destroy all of a specific type of permanent, such as Wrath of God, Damnation, Fracturing Gust, and so forth.

RiotRunner789, plakjekaas, if the majority of players use the terms "mana ramping" or "ramping," then I suppose that I should use those terms, as well, even if I dislike them, since I fail to see why Rampant Growth is so popular or powerful that an entire term was named for it.

moo1234 on Card creation challenge

5 days ago

Mr.Self Destruct

Legendary Creature - Demon Spirit

When Mr.Self Destruct enters the battlefield sacrifice a creature

At the beginning of your first Combat step this turn take X extra combat phases after this one where X is the power of the creature you sacrificed to Mr.Self Destruct this turn.

At the beginning of your end step exile Mr Self Destruct.

5/4

"I am the bullet in the gun. I am the lie from which you run"


Absolutely fantastic track on one of the best albums ever made.

Repeat or make another 4 colour uncommon commander (this isn't rly uncommon though)

kamarupa on Only Fams

5 days ago

Murrow - the idea was already there, I just noticed it. You are the true genius!

Murrow on Only Fams

5 days ago

kamarupa you're a mad genius. I love it lol.

kamarupa on Only Fams

5 days ago

May I suggest the very slight name change to "Only Fams" as it's just, well,... sexier?

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

5 days ago

Build-a-Bitch

Creature - Assembly-Worker

When Build-a-Bitch enters, choose up to one plus X colors and up to two plus X keyword ability counters or +1/+1 counters. Build-a-Bitch becomes those colors, and gains those counters.

You don't get to pick and choose.

2/2


So basically 7 (4+3) mana of any combination gets you a WUBRG body that could have something like Trample, Hexproof, Indestructible, Deathtouch and two +1/+1 counters making it a 4/4

Or a WUBRG 7/7 with indestructible

Or a 6/6 with flying and hexproof

Alternatively you can pay only and get something like a White 4/4 or whatever you need at that time.

A 2/2 with Deathtouch and Reach against a flying commander.


Repeat

moo1234 on Card creation challenge

5 days ago

Piggy the gorger

Legendary Creature - Pig

Trample, Haste

When Piggy the gorger enters the battlefield sacrifice a creature, Piggy deals damage to yourself equal to 8 minus the sacrificed creatures power

8/8

"Hey pig. All my fears came true"


Making a legendary creature suitable to be uncommon is very difficult. Especially if it's four colours. Frankly I'd be astonished if it ever happened but that's what this board is for

Making a card based on the title of an album/song

with the flavour text being a lyric from the album

goalieman on Cheap 4+ Power Aggro

5 days ago

CNG_Stream Thank you for the great feedback!!

Ouroboroid has been a hassle feel like if I'm 30% win rate when they drop theirs on Turn 3, but I still like how this has performed. I'll play around with some ramp additions for sure.

I may branch off to drop black, but Kalakscion, Hunger Tyrant was the first card that prompted this deck idea, so I'm committed to it (even if it's weak lol). And Rot-Curse Rakshasa has helped shut down blockers and/or slowed down their attacking and Sunset Saboteur has helped remove 2 cards from their hand most of the time. The +1/+1 is annoying to give to their creature, but most games it's not impactful enough if the toughness stays under 5.

I did drop Tumbleweed Rising even though it was fun to drop 2x 12/12 tramplers on the same turn for 4 mana lol. Added in 4x Molten Collapse to help with pesky creatures and 1 drops like Authority of the Consuls.

I'm hoping to sideboard some graveyard/artifact/enchantment hate with Heritage Reclamation. In normally a BO1 player, but would be cool to test out BO3. Thank you again!

Veethevvitch on Thoth's Library

5 days ago

Accidentaly removed your comment x_x so i'll copy it here : legendofa says...

If you find replacements for all your basic lands and related cards, Hermit Druid can self-mill to empty. It's probably not a good idea to take out all of the creatures here for Oath of Druids, though. That would be a different deck.

legendofa Those are cool card , thank you for sharing! I'll note them down for future reference. But I would also have to remove Winter Moon if I remove all my basic lands. I run this many basic lands to penalize people who run a lot of non basic lands like Maze of Ith and Spires of Orazca, I have a lot of people who run those in my pod ! :) But i'll consider it still because I could always run Cloudstone Curio to help me untap my nonbasic lands.

Ultarian on Double faced cards not showing …

5 days ago

Appreciate the issue being acknowledged, even if it hasn't been addressed.

DrummerGarrett on Idiot Goat

5 days ago

Make 2 Swaps and a Trade...

Swap Howl from Beyond with Demand Answers.

Swap War Cadence with Ensnaring Bridge, but you gotta trade for the signed copy from Brandon first !

mrprofiteer on Raggadragga Mana Saga

5 days ago

Totally see what you're saying. Radha, Zhur-Taa and Whisperer are more pet cards (even Quirion Elves). I really liked the Bugenhagen, Torgal and Somberwild. Also reminded me I had a Tender Wildguide and Cradle Clearcutter I keep forgetting to slot in.

The nice thing about Wurmcalling is even without the haste enabler, Raggaragga will still trigger each time you pay the minimum 7 mana (go infinite mana) and you can keep recasting it targeting everything else = infinite board pump without swinging with the wurms. I'll update ya when I make some tweaks. :)

Prixx on Aragon, King of Gondor - …

5 days ago

Changes - OUT: Fable of the Mirror-Breaker and Expressive Iteration. IN. Wan Shi Tong, Librarian and Teachery.

Prixx on Phelia, Exuberant Shepherd - active

5 days ago

Changes - OUT: Mutavault. IN: Abandoned Air Temple

DDB27 on Necropotence Deck

5 days ago

Does anybody know of a video or article explanation on how to play this deck?

Hymdor on Elemental Madness

5 days ago

First Time upgrading a deck on my own without help from EDHRec or moxfield. I wanted to make a good synergistic deck with "tribal" elementals, starting precon is the Lorwyn eclipsed five color Ashling deck but I chose to use Mass of Mysteries instead in order to get more ETB triggers and sacs for mana.

Ike_Diamonds on Attack of the Attacks

5 days ago

Great suggestions, thank you!

bobarius on Elven empire 2026

5 days ago

Update 15/3: did my first casual two playthroughs yesterday.

1st game First game went ok, with a Door of Destinies on turn 3, Lathril, Blade of the Elves on turn 4 and Dionus, Elvish Archdruid on turn 5. Did a decent amount of combat damage with Lathril and got her buffed and untapped with Dionus, but my 1/1 tokens got shanked due to a combo of having my door of destinies destroyed and a spell that gave all creatures on the board a -1/-1 counter. After this player was out I got my tokens out more consistently through Lathril and Rogue's Passage. Was about to finish the game in 1 turn, but my Lathril got Blinked and as there were multiple propaganda-type effects on the board I couldn't pump through with my tokens. Killed by enemy commander with flying. Oh, good to mention. My Quirion Elves works great for green/black mana fixing. But it got taken by another player in the beginning of the game. Then missed out on 1 black mana for the rest of the game.

2nd game Second game I had a mana-screw, probably due to lousy shuffling on my part. Started with 2 mana and a mana dork. Quirion Elves got captured again, which made some early play, even with the mana-screw impossible. Got some 2 mana creatures out but Conceded after my 9th turn with no mana-draw. Need more testing, but thinking about switching 2 dorks for hard 1 forest and one swamp for more consistency.

Cloudy2024 on Sultai Ritual

5 days ago

Four basics if right, but you should consider cutting the scalding tarn for verdant catacomb

clayperce on Amazing Card Art

5 days ago

Ultimate Price, maybe?
Gwenom, Remorseless, for sure. Original art here.

hiddengibbons on Card creation challenge

5 days ago

Kiara Star Moon Silver Fire Night Shadow Future Of The Dream Reality

Legendary Creature - Elf Shaman Wizard Warrior Soldier Knight

Non-creature spells you cast cost less.

1/4

It’s basically a fancy Goblin Electromancer that would be fairly an uncommon due to mana cost, but also potentially a useful commander. Not sure if I met the challenge

Repeat challenge

DragonMaster420 on Sultai Ritual

5 days ago

i'd recommend swapping Scalding Tarn for Verdant Catacombs and adding some more snow basics. for the removal i think Fatal Push and Counterspell are the best in these colors. Harbinger of the Seas counteracts your own dual lands and makes them only able to tap for blue.

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

5 days ago

Intrusive Insanity

At the beginning if each player's upkeep, each of that player's opponents shuffles their library, then each player reveals the 11th card from the top of their library. Each player who revealed the card with the highest mana value or tied for the highest mana value mills cards equal the mana value of the card they revealed. After that, each player who revealed a card this way shuffles their library.


I'm pretty positive this works for the challenge xD and just imagine the rules conversation once a player is below 11 cards in their library.


Create a 4-coloured uncommon commander. Not a CI of 4, but actually 4 colours.

hiddengibbons on Card creation challenge

5 days ago

Pi In The Face

Sorcery

~ deals x damage to any target where x is the number of digits you are able to recite unaided after 3.14 in the Pi number sequence

Create a super complicated irritating card that would make you extremely unpopular in commander. And I mean the rules text/what the card does is like a paragraph or more. Imagine reducing the font size radically to fit it on the card

Long_Con on Simic Omni-Cheat

5 days ago

Hey, just glancing at the Deckcycled decks, and the name was interesting. I thought this was a cool deck idea!

BotaNickill on God-Like Tendencies

5 days ago

Those are awesome suggestions. Thank you!

TheoryCrafter on Attack of the Attacks

5 days ago

Have you considered replacing a couple of your mana rocks with Gruul Signet and Rakdos Signet this will give you more mana for the cost. Also, your deck is missing out on cards that can punish opponents for attacking you. May I suggest any combination of Crown of Doom, Emberwilde Captain, Marchesa's Decree and Revenge of Ravens? Finally, some Eldrazi cards have Annihilator, which causes opponents to sacrifice cards. My favorites are Ulamog's Crusher and Eldrazi Conscription. I hope this helps. Thank you for reading me out. Happy Hunting!

TheoryCrafter on Card creation challenge

5 days ago

Folly of Idleness

Image: A Grasshopper is cold and shivering outside while looking into a house where the ant rests by an open fire eating a smore.

Sorcery- Lesson

If you create a food token, or put a brick counter on a permanent this turn, if an opponent cast no spells nor activated any abilities since your last turn, all creatures they control are tapped, receive a stun counter on each of those creatures and cannot untap during their next turn.

Play today, pay tomorrow.


Choose one:

-Repeat!

-It's Pi day! Create an Unset card that benefits you for knowing places of Pi after 3.14

clayperce on The Scarab God

6 days ago

Saw your 'help' tag so thought I'd reach out. Are you looking for anything in particular?

Cheers!

Flarhoon13 on Kydele & Eligeth draw forever …

6 days ago

Power Level 5.79 / 10

⚖️Tipping Point 3

⏱️Efficiency 6.73 / 10

Impact 482.49

Score 460 / 1000

️Average Playability 67.8% Edhpowerlevel.com

Dayman763 on Urza, Chief Artificer - Aggro …

6 days ago

Hey thanks, I really like all 3 suggestions.

Last_Laugh on The Sixth Doctor // Romana …

6 days ago

Just a heads up, but your token doublers don't work with tokens made by The Sixth Doctor. Tokens that are the result of copying a permanent spell aren't created and won't triggers things like Adrix & Nev, Doubling Season, Mondrak, Ojer Taq, Parallel Lives, Annointed Procession, or Elspeth (Rule 111.12 if you feel like looking it up).

For extra tokens here you need more stuff like Twinning Staff and Esika's Chariot. Peter Parker's Camera, Strionic Resonator, Rhys the Redeemed, Romana II, Errant, Street Artist, Second Harvest, City of Death, and Battle for Bretagard.

Icicles on mono white token

6 days ago

Your help is amazing thanks so much!

I really appreciate it :)

GhostYou on Atraxa, Praetors' Voice

6 days ago

Thank you heaps this is just the type of information i was after and both cards look like fun as well

kamarupa on Legacy Of the Blessed Soul …

6 days ago

1xThe Ozolith is always nice when lots of creatures can get counters.

With so much lifegain, something like Chalice of Life (Chalice of Death) or Aetherflux Reservoir seems like it would be a great push toward a lot of wins.

kamarupa on X-ing

6 days ago

Big thanks for the +1, Squee_Spirit_Guide!!

Long_Con on Raggadragga Mana Saga

6 days ago

mrprofiteer I love it. Infinite Wurms, each one 7/7 bigger than the last! Finish off with a Finale of Devastation for 439 mana or so, and conquer the world!

I noticed you have Concordant Crossroads and Mass Hysteria as Haste enablers, among others, and I do see the appeal. I just have Rhythm of the Wild because it's just too good, and I'll often grab Xenagos, God of Revels as half my Tooth and Nail double-whammy.

I do think you could upgrade your lesser mana dorks though - Biophagus, Torgal, A Fine Hound, and even Bugenhagen, Wise Elder are much more functional than Whisperer of the Wilds, Zhur-Taa Druid, and even Radha, Heir to Keld, who I found was an underperformer.

I don't know what I would take out for Wurmcalling though. It would have to be something from the '7+CMC stuff' category... maybe Shriekwood Devourer?