Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Icbrgr on Pauper Dragons

1 week ago

this is beautiful i absolutely love this idea +1

Frykas on Los Drazos

1 week ago

Ahahaha!! Fortunatelly they won't have to I recently ordered an additional copy of each specifically for the deck!

legendofa on Pauper Dragons

1 week ago

Yeah, Sword Coast Serpent is really good for that. If it's working, keep it.

I learned not to rely too much on the Orbs. They're a strong supplement, but the deck doesn't shut down if they go away. More like an extra bonus than a key part of the deck. I might end up cutting them down further or sideboarding them, but so far they've been okay.

ChaseyK on Pauper Dragons

1 week ago

legendofa, I like Sword Coast Serpent a lot as both a tempo option and as a way to break through stalled boards (I play against a lot of White Weenie.) Dirgur Island Dragon has been less useful, but I do appreciate its flexibility. I could see swapping it with either more Fang Dragon or Avenging Hunter.

I'm not sure I'd want to cut blue completely (I find the counterspells quite useful, and cards like Sagu Wildling and Patron of the Arts make it really easy to get that blue mana), but looking over your list, I think you probably have better consistency. Though I have not had much success when I tried the orbs and globes you're using. They're just a bit too slow and there's enough artifact hate in the format that I don't often see their value.

Kamerot on Om Nom Trample

1 week ago

FistofPickCity sorry for the long delay, I've been lazy with updating lists. I will get it updated soon though. Glad to hear you like the list and a big kamahl fan in general.

FistofPickCity on Om Nom Trample

1 week ago

I've been lurking on this list for a long time. I'm patiently waiting for an update....less patient now that I finally commented. I have a similar list, thanks to inspiration from you. (Favorite character from back when was Kamahl). What's your thoughts on Lifestream's Blessing over Return of the Wildspeaker?

legendofa on Pauper Dragons

1 week ago

How are the blue dragons working for you? In testing my Pauper Dragons deck, it felt like they didn't help me that much, and I ended up cutting blue completely. Good creatures, lackluster tempo Adventures. But the Masked Vandal is a great inclusion; I'm going to have to add that into mine.

Balaam__ on Los Drazos

1 week ago

Nice build, +1. Maybe Wizards ought to retcon the Eldrazi lore and reprint Imprisoned in the Collection Binder.

Balaam__ on No

1 week ago

@PrincessOfFriendship I was going to dismiss the idea because I happened to look at the Nemesis printing first and it doesn’t mention anything about “can’t”, but a quick cross reference shows the other printings do indeed use the forbidden word in parentheticals when defining the Flying ability.

I’ll maybeboard it so I remember it exists, but for now I’m leaning toward it being just a touch too costly to cast to really be able to take advantage of the ‘skip combat’ benefit. I do appreciate the input, as always!

PrincessOfFriendship on No

1 week ago

Have you thought about Blinding Angel? If it hits your opponent they skip their combat next turn.

PrincessOfFriendship on Circled Pit Lords

1 week ago

This deck is hilarious, I love it!

Coward_Token on Perpetual Patterns of Proliferated Prosperity

1 week ago

Teferi, Who Slows the Sunset yet another untapper, ultimate shouldn't be too hard to achieve. Probably worth looking into planeswalkers in general.

I'll try to shut up now.

Coward_Token on Perpetual Patterns of Proliferated Prosperity

1 week ago

Minamo, School at Water's Edge utility land that taps for colored mana and enters untapped

Manifold Key strictly better Voltaic Key (both are OK)

Aphetto Alchemist & Voltaic Servant cheap repeatable free untappers

For tapping, obviously keep an eye on the Planets and cheaper Spacecraft as they use counters and can give value. (Only at sorcery speed tho.) Scryfall link

Vehicles for crew-tapping whenever:

Mothdust Changeling is pretty much the same as Voyager Glidecar

octopimp on Poison Apple

1 week ago

I've added both of those, awesome suggestions, thanks for the feedback!

Bara on Bloomburrow Blu/W Wings & Paws

1 week ago

Play tested the first few turns for a couple of rounds: Need more creatures, Need more low cost creatures, Mana seems ok, Swamped with Instants

DryadArborGoesInCreaturePile on Pauper Splice Tide

1 week ago

Adversarial, this list is a meta deck. While I can admit I should be running a playset of Snap for graveyard hate matchups you can still churn through your entire deck until you find your combo pieces for a win on turn 3-4, then you can Deep Analysis your opponent to deck them. Playtest it yourself if you don't believe me. Merchant Scroll also tutors for Dizzy Spell which tutors for Stream of Thought. And the copies of Psychic Puppetry splice onto almost every draw spell, meaning your netting like 3 mana every time you cast an Ideas Unbound to keep digging on your big combo turn. Though when you can put your entire deck in your hand it doesn't really matter.

Icbrgr on Poison Apple

1 week ago

My brother runs this commander and as much as I hate this commander I absolutely love this commander! Ill be all happy to get a kill spell just for him to Timely Ward/Not Dead After All keeping her alive and adding more auras for more drain/gain. +1 happy brewing!

SufferFromEDHD on Perpetual Patterns of Proliferated Prosperity

1 week ago

Yooo I missed that Goblin Bomb haha this deck has so much potential. Staying with the OG theme... Mind Over Matter if this can't accomplish what the deck needs nothing will!

Trickster Mage mini Mind Over Matter

Tidal Bore weak one shot Mind Over Matter

Orim's Cure/Sivvi's Valor not as good as previous suggestions but on theme with narrow potential

Retreat to Coralhelm consistent land drops consistent triggers

Some good spitballs in there Coward_Token Drumbellower is such a pushed new card. Slow vigilance. Stinging Lionfish is the perfect 2 drop for this.

fifthdawn on Kwain Overdraw

1 week ago

Definitely a cool build and cooncept! Kwain is really great!

I approve!

CandrewAndrew9090 on Urza's Workshop

1 week ago

yes I know it's not legal this is exclusively for my friends in our silly online play group.

Andramalech on Gravemind Within

1 week ago

Veitanah, thanks for the upvote. Cheers!

Kamerot on Jetmir's Myriad Debauchery

1 week ago

Coward_Token all of my lists are in need of updating on here, I've been busy (and lazy). I've definitely added quite a few of the new myriad creatures.

I will definitely look into mobilize effects, and I didn't even catch that on zopandrel. I've considered dropling him anyways due to the high mana cost, so this will probably be the catalyst for that change. Thanks!!

Coward_Token on Jetmir's Myriad Debauchery

1 week ago

Lots of new myriad cards if you want to update this list.

In the same spirit, mobilize and more of other "tapped and attacking" effects would work too. I especially like Ainok Strike Leader since it's cheap and produces up to three tokens (even if they're temporary, that's four bodies for two mana).

I think Zopandrel, Hunger Dominus is less good here, because it'll trigger before e.g. myriad has a chance to increase your creature count for the purpose of Jetmir's anthems.

Jaceper on tokens

1 week ago

wow tokens

Andramalech on Red-Glove Landscaping LLC.

1 week ago

Thank you for the upvote, sv7nn. Cheers!

Adversarial on Pauper Splice Tide

1 week ago

DryadArborGoesInCreaturePile That would be cool and all, if any of those cards were in this deck. As it stands you're relying on the single copy of Stream of Thought and 2 copies of Archaeomancer and one single copy of Snap out of the entire 60 card deck to mill your opponent, while those same 2 Archaeomancers are your only creatures/blockers, leaving you open to any and all attacks while you draw and search for your one copy of Stream of Thought. Those few tap spells aren't nearly enough. You'll die long before you can even start to mill anything.

DryadArborGoesInCreaturePile on Pauper Splice Tide

1 week ago

Hello Adversarial, that is incorrect. Winning involves either meticulously milling your opponent via Jace's Erasure or Sphinx's Tutelage with a lock in place, or with infinite mana and a spell to use it on. As shown here with Stream of Thought, Snap, Archaeomancer, and a few copies of High Tide. Door to Nothingness is acceptable as well

jonjonhholt on Pauper Scam (with Wildfire)

1 week ago

Oh weird yeah idk why the spoiler wont open, the cards name is temporal intervention if you wanna look it up :)

McDuckington on Golgari Goth Girls

1 week ago

A player of class i see.

Coffin Queen

loonofmoons on Welcome to Hallownest (Hollow Knight-themed …

1 week ago

I finally got the chance to start building this deck for myself (I love Hollow Knight). You mentioned being uncertain about Renata as Hornet, I decided to switch Renata out for Nissa, Voice of Zendikar. The art doesn't line up perfectly, but I think the abilities compliment the deck incredibly well.

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

1 week ago

cuts: fog bank, rootha, mercurial artist, marble diamond,

adds: library of leng, smoke spirit's aid, refute

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

1 week ago

cuts: mandate of peace, erebor flamesmith, refuse//cooperate, talrand, sky summoner, increasing devotion, ethereal haze, fumigate

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

1 week ago

adds: storm-kiln artist, curse of the swine, negate, comet storm, heliod's intervention, baral's expertise, path to exile, soulfire grand master, reality spasm, goblin electromancer, galvanic iteration, demilich, gale, waterdeep prodigy, fogbank, shiko and narset, unified, storm the vault, mana geyser

cuts: strike it rich, swiftfoot boots, spellgorger weird, crackling drake, teferi's ageless insight, ghostly prison, collected conjuring, thundering rebuke

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

1 week ago

adds: thought vessel, midnight clock, Raugrin Crystal, jeskai banner, fire diamond, marble diamond, reliquary tower

cuts: sevinne, the chronoclasm

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

1 week ago

adds: murmuring mystic, kykar, wind's fury, myriad landscape, sulfur falls, glacial fortress, port town, clifftop retreat

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

1 week ago

cuts: burning vengeance, monastery siege, conflagrate, rolling temblor

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

1 week ago

commander: kykar or hinata

cuts: daring apprentice, moonhold, relic amulet, burning prophet, opal palace, scholar of the ages, rustvale bridge, razortide bridge, battlefield forge, ray of distortion, dusk//dawn, secrets of the dead

FadedFerocity on Kitchen Table Magic - Casual …

1 week ago

Ah exciting idea, I look forward to the Ramp and Prison decks!

8netherwind8 on Straight Outta Lovecraft

1 week ago

DubbleDecker - Surging from the sea, Cthulhu grabs you with the smallest of his gargantuan tentacles! Holding you up to his hideously huge maw, he whispers: "Its pronounced Choo-choo-Lou, cause I like trains." ;)

Direwulf on Life GAINS copy copy

1 week ago

One card I consider a secret soul sister is Leonin Elder. With all the treasures and food out there these days it's often very strong.

Here's my list if you're interested: https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/gw-lifegain-mtgo/

kamarupa on Halo, and Welcome!

1 week ago

Big thanks for the +1 and folder add, skibulk!