TheMadRocketeer on The Borg - Robots in …
1 week ago
Currently, this deck is at 122 cards. I could use some input on stuff to remove. Advice on additions is welcome too, but my biggest concern at the moment is trimming the fat. I think I'm probably a bit over-supplied on disruption and protection. I also know I need to shift to more non-basic lands and twiddle with the land mix a bit, but I figure to do that after my other changes show me what I'll need. I've been pulling out stuff I like in order to get me closer to the stuff I need, but my progress is slowing. Any helpful thoughts? Thanks in advance.
Asder on Jitterin' & Glitterin'
1 week ago
Insurrection could be worth playing over In Garruk's Wake
jsepeta on Envy
1 week ago
Sporemound + Life and Limb does not creates Infinite Saprolings, but they definitely multiply the amount of mana available for Helix Pinnacle win condition or for pumping into Ezuri, Renegade Leader
. But it's a 9 mana cost to put them both on the battlefield vs. Vorinclex, Voice of Hunger who costs 8 and doubles mana from tapped land. I'll have to think about this.
Ultarian on Orzhov Phalanx Leader
1 week ago
Cloudy2024 Not to be rude but you win by turning creatures sideways...
DreadKhan on Is he a goat man? …
1 week ago
No Fanatic of Mogis, I feel like my boy is better than something in here.
Also, this is going to sound crazy, but maybe Pyrohemia/Pestilence as a way to repeatedly clear out weenies that people are desperately casting to try to block your guys? it's also good with any Toughness boosting anthems.
PhantomHuscarl on All I want for Christmas …
1 week ago
Man this looks diabolical, love it.
Ever though about adding other Goad effects as they are pretty strong with what you're gifting here?
Things like Disrupt Decorum, Nelly Borca, Impulsive Accuser, Coronation of Chaos,
Death Kiss, Day of the Moon, Bloodthirsty Blade, Geode Rager, Havoc Eater, Hot Pursuit, Laser Screwdriver, Immortal Obligation, Popular Entertainer, Shiny Impetus, Spectacular Showdown, Taunt from the Rampart and Vengeful Ancestor.
Expecially Disrupt Decorum, Spectacular Showdown and Taunt from the Rampart almost feels like wincon in there while i feel that Immortal Obligation really fits the theme of "good gifts" and Laser Screwdriver is a good mana dump when you've got nothing else in hand.
Brinckenberger on Teval - Sultai Casual
1 week ago
Big lands upgrade- dropped the scry temples, opulent palace, dream root cascade, haunted mire , Llanowar wastes, fetid pools, terr expanse, 2 forests, 1 island and one swamp. Added Sultai fetch, shock and battlebond lands, plus gemstone mine, waterlogged grove, nurturing peatland, prismatic vista and shifting woodland.
Brinckenberger on Golgari Elves
1 week ago
Dropped nuturing peatland, overgrown tomb, undergrowth stadium and verdant catacombs to move them to Teval, added Gilt-leaf palace, necrobloom snarl, wastewood verge and a forest.
Brinckenberger on Teval - Sultai Casual
1 week ago
Dropped phyrexian reclamation, life from the loam, aftermath analyst, skull prophet, seedship broodtender, steward of the harvest and Junji. Added in their place- reanimate, entomb, exploration, molt tender, remunap excavator, tireless provisioner and the Gitrog monster.
SufferFromEDHD on Sharing is Caring
1 week ago
The OG commanders were the best!
Some cards worth considering:
Rainbow Vale > mountain
Humble Defector > plains
Treasure Nabber > your least favorite mana rock
Puca's Mischief > island
Perplexing Chimera > Mirrormade
Paradox Haze > Fraying Sanity
Political Trickery > The Locust God
Squee_Spirit_Guide on The Rackoning [Competitive Budget]
1 week ago
I love this! 'Unwrap from a rubber band, bridge shuffle without sleeves' really speaks to me :)
Blobby_Bobby on Boots for the Beatdown
1 week ago
Optimator I actually tried to keep all Shinra out of the deck. The Turks' equipment is stuff we stole.
SufferFromEDHD on Teferi, Mage of Zero Turns
1 week ago
Blinkmoth Well I still think this is being slept on in EDH!
DubMC on Children of the Woods
1 week ago
Thank you! I just made this so I was playtesting it and a mana sink would be great, maybe Untamed Might? Or go classic and splash red for Fireball
Balaam__ on Children of the Woods
1 week ago
Looks great. Only thing I might suggest is a decent mana sink for all the green Priest of Titania can genenerate.
Andramalech on Moonage Daydream ~100$
1 week ago
Roughly five minutes of solid reading and I agree with Optimator about why I would include Twenty-Toed Toad. However, building this on a budget AND managing to provide so much utility in a mono-colored deck is simply impressive. I like this a lot! Gonna check out the predecessor list, too. Cheers! +1
Andramalech on Oh Yeah!!
1 week ago
Balaam__ you managed to include a Dark Souls reference and a Super Mario 64 reference. This list is GOATed. A simple enough concept to follow, I appreciate your efforts all the same. Cheers! +1
DatShepTho on GO GO DINOSAUR!
1 week ago
I would be careful with what you define as "card draw". Have a think about whether after casting it, you've gone up or down on how many cards you have left to be able to cast. Top deck manipulation is more on the card selection side, which is fine for the plan of putting dinosaurs on top for Gishath.
I would also separate your protection spells from your buff spells, since it's useful to know how much protection you have access to.
I would probably take out Temur Battle Rage as another card to cut for a land. Multiple sources of Double Strike are redundant, and this is probably the least useful one, since you can't set it up on board before you resolve Gishath unlike the others.
Also three green pips for Llanowar Tribe seems unlikely to hit reliably. This is one I would cut for a land.
Also I just thought about Hulking Raptor and Regal Behemoth which are dinosaurs that can help ramp out Gishath that you might like. Commander's Sphere and Chromatic Lantern are a tad on the slower side and could be replaced by these.
Optimator on Boots for the Beatdown
1 week ago
Since you have an above-average amount of equipment, Professor Hojo might be worth noting
IRONBAR on ME GOBLINZ
1 week ago
Nice! Goblin decks are always fun to have, Have you considered goblin piledriver?
ME GOBLINZ
by Hi70
TheSlowestBro on 7th Breakfast
1 week ago
Blossoming Bogbeast and Night of the Sweets' Revenge have been really solid finishers in my Frodo and Sam deck. My list is named Toasted Acorns if you're interested in having a look for more ideas, though it's a pretty thematic build.
TheMadRocketeer on The Borg - Robots in …
1 week ago
Comments, feedback, and suggestions are welcome. As a kindness, please keep it clean. Thanks. :-)
legendofa on Dead Metal
1 week ago
Cloudy2024 If you do and you put it up here, can you please tag me?
legendofa on Dead Metal
1 week ago
TheoryCrafter Yeah, I had the sideboard Pull from Eternitys as kind of a buffer for that, but Karn, the Great Creator's probably the better option. Thanks for checking it out!
TheoryCrafter on Dead Metal
1 week ago
This deck looks pretty good! It reminds me of an Urza, Powerstone Prodigy Unearth deck I was on the brink of building before The Brothers' War rotated out.
Only thing that I find concerning for your deck is the inability to deal with graveyard hate. If you were to find a spot for any combination of Karn, the Great Creator and Revoke Existence in your deck and/or sideboard that should do it.
Happy Hunting!
Andramalech on Memnites Perform a Demonic Ritual
1 week ago
I've been brewing and troubleshooting a deck focused on Ormendahl, Profane Prince Flip since I saw it spoiled a bit more than 10 years ago. I found your old reddit post and just had to mention that I stand with you in solidarity. One of these days, we'll make this tinfoil hat into an Iron Crown.
FormOverFunction on Antique Shop
1 week ago
Idoneity thanks so much!! I do LOVE Refurbish, that’s perfect. I’ve tried to limit the physical size of the antiques (ancient artifacts like Colossus of Sardia is as old as anything, but can’t sit on a shelf) so I’m probably going to miss out on the scarecrows. Even suits of armor, like Haunted Plate Mail, barely missed the cut. If commander ran on 200 or 300 cards then I’d be getting a lot more swords and other cool things, but I’m trying to zero in on things that are more… I don’t want to say ‘worthless’ but definitely more trinkets and oddities than cool combat-ready badassery. It makes the deck WAY worse at killing opponents, obviously, but it makes wins with Metrognome a lot more hilarious. I’m really glad you enjoyed the deck. That’s the real win I’m always shooting for!
Gminor7 on Y'shtola Theorycrafted: Esper Experiment No. …
1 week ago
Hello 0okm9ijn! Thank you for recognising the flaw on the lands. Yes. You're right and sorry for this late reply. Because when I saw your comment, I got panic to fix it quickly and search what it is the better to swap in. In the original list, it had a basic lands. But as the time goes by, I got rid of it out without thinking about Prismatic Vista. I change it into Morphic Pool now. Again, thank you.
NV_1980 on General Kreat, The Pain-bringing Waifu …
1 week ago
Considering your deck is not entirely budget anymore, why not add Purphoros, God of the Forge as well? Very effective though a bit of an expensive choice, of course. Weftstalker Ardent could also be nice in a similar way. Speaking of non-budget options, some really effective stuff in here could also be Roaming Throne (to double all your tribal trigger benefits) and maybe Ojer Axonil, Deepest Might Flip (to vastly increase Kreat's damage output for every critter popping onto the battlefield).
I've got a Purph-Gobbo build that features some additional combos, requiring only a few extra cards in this deck (sometimes none at all). Maybe it has something you like.
GAMEBOY1234 on GO GO DINOSAUR!
1 week ago
DatShepTho,clayperce Thanks for the suggestions, I really needed it. For Almost Perfect and Rancor the goal was to make Gishath, Sun's Avatar more powerful so I can maximize its ability. As for custom sorting I barely figured that out a few weeks ago. I will be sure to add these changes thanks!
SufferFromEDHD on Oloro White Blue Black Creatureless …
1 week ago
Hootsnag, just remember. It's not a lie... if YOU believe it...
0okm9ijn on Y'shtola Theorycrafted: Esper Experiment No. …
1 week ago
Greetings Gminor7. I'm trying to learn more about how to run advanced decks like this, and I found your instructions quite helpful. While playtesting the deck, I drew a Prismatic Vista, but upon looking at the decklist, I could not locate any cards able to be fetched by it. I am still studying advanced mtg, but am I correct in that assumption? Thank you in advance.
hootsnag on Oloro White Blue Black Creatureless …
1 week ago
I'm unemployed right now also but not for much longer. I can hire you into a new company called Think Outside the Box. It's a company where we don't use the most popular cards on EDHREC and build focused decks outside the box!
Profet93 on Oloro White Blue Black Creatureless …
1 week ago
I'm unemployed, can you get me a job at Vandalay Industries?
SufferFromEDHD on Oloro White Blue Black Creatureless …
1 week ago
Who ARE you, Hootsnag Costanza?
I'm the opposite of every MTG player you've ever met.
Balaam__ on On the Level
1 week ago
Good call, dgalarza. That one’s being updated the moment I have time. Thanks!
dgalarza on On the Level
1 week ago
Is that a Square Hammer reference on my children's card game website?
Not a sideboard card, but I would be remiss if I did not mention that Volcanic Spite could replace Fire Prophecy.
milohenry13 on Aragorn, the Charmer
1 week ago
Thanks for the +1 TheSlowestBro! This is one of my newer designs and I CAN'T WAIT to play it when it's finished in a few months!
Thejeff4 on Zellix The Undying Miller
1 week ago
Those are 2 super interesting cards, I haven't seen those before, I liked having some way to protect some of my utility non horror creatures which is why I had Maskwood Nexus in there but Breach the Multiverse does essentially the same plus more so will switch those 2. Singularity Rupture after giving Undying to all my horrors is rather nasty.
Thanks for those ideas!
clayperce on GO GO DINOSAUR!
1 week ago
My deck is a little inconsistent with mana, I need better mana ramps
Yeah, casting a 3-color 8-drop anywhere even close to curve is no small feat! To get there, I would seriously recommend moving from your current 30 Lands/12 Ramp pieces (unless I missed some) to something like 38 Lands and 21 Ramp pieces. That should allow you to reliably cast Gishath on Turn 7+ ... instead of the current Turn 9+.
I know that sounds like it would require cutting a TON of awesome cards from the deck, but I think you'll be amazed at how much better the deck would run. Maybe try playtesting this deck I threw together, over at Moxfield? It's not tuned at all, but it'll give you a feel for what 38 Lands/21 Ramp pieces will feel like.
Good luck (and good skill!) with Gishath! Cheers!
RedShirtComics on 32 - Colorless - Jank …
1 week ago
DubMC, thanks, yeah, they'd work nicely and I used to have those in another artifact deck. However, this one I made just from things I had and opened. I haven't bought any specific cards for it. The more sets that come out the more powerful it gets, lol.
