|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|Commander 2016 (C16)||Rare|
|MTG: Commander (CMD)||Rare|
|Tenth Edition (10E)||Rare|
Combos Browse all
Creature — Spirit
Flying *(This creature can't be blocked except by creatures with flying or reach.) *
Creatures can't attack you unless their controller pays for each creature he or she controls that's attacking you.
|Have (6)||Mortiferus_Rosa , sonnet666 , Bluboltar , metalmagic , shinbatsu , adventfaith|
|Want (5)||Lavatails , rotusq , jagodot , xxTheDoctor , Nuregami|
Windborn Muse Discussion
6 days ago
lifemtg - Windborn Muse flies for an extra mana, making it searchable. I'll give it a try though to see how it pans out, I just didn't want to go full on stax with this. The Archetype was in at the beginning, however it not flying itself made it less shiny for me. I don't find running out of gas a problem so the Sphinx seems an unnecessary expense. The Wrath I'm on the fence about, I've been thinking for awhile on replacing Sunblast Angel but wasn't sure... then I saw Flood of Tears and thought it could be a thematic replacement... I can try them both out though. I could also try out Git. Probe again as paying life is generally no consequence.
bushido_man96 - Tef's Prot. is one of those 'hope it's in a prize pack' cards. I can see the Amulet doing well though, I will have to try it. Now I shall go look for a flyer that Digs out artifacts maybe.
1 week ago
Came here after seeing your Khobolds version and decided to comment here because of my distaste for infinite combos.
Personally I'd make Marchesa the Queen of taxes and run all the taxing stax pieces and discard effects to make everyone feel the oppression of the crown. Cards like Damping Sphere , Aura of Silence , Thalia, Guardian of Thraben , Vryn Wingmare , and myabe even Rule of Law for flavour. There is also Ethersworn Canonist and Eidolon of Rhetoric as a Rule of Laws with legs that don't get hit by the non-creature taxation. If you can ensure that you will hold monarch then cards like Necrogen Mists , Oppression , and Painful Quandary start to thin your opponents hands.
1 week ago
There are a lot of unfocused or suboptimal cards in this list like Phantom General and Famine that could easily be replaced by more suited cards that help your game plan of: Play dudes, protect face, beat down, draw an additional card at EoT.
Equipoise is a very old card but it let's you dictate combat more effectively by controlling what your opponent has to block with. If you have deathtouch tokens then maybe phase out their small utility creatures and make them decide between having their big creature die to a 1/1 deathtouch token or lose monarchy. If you want to be more effective in combat maybe phase out their big guys and let your valuable legends swing in with their keywords giving them the edge in combat. Similarly Duelist's Heritage can give ANY attacking creature an advantage in combat. You can use it as a political tool by offering to give an attacking creature an opponent controls doublestrike as long as it doesn't attack you which further incentivises your opponents to squable among themselves while you sit back and draw all the cards.
You don't have any way of protecting your face by non-vigilance creatures so maybe consider Ghostly Prison , Baird, Steward of Argive , and Windborn Muse to make attacking you more difficult. Michiko Konda, Truth Seeker is also a fantastic rattle snake because each intake of damage makes them lose a permanent.
Your deck also seems like it has very few ways to draw cards outside of the monarch mechanic. Skullclamp , Phyrexian Arena , and Tymna the Weaver can keep your hand full with plenty of answers and creatures.
2 weeks ago
Hey, saw your forum topic asking for help.
Not sure what kind of advice you're looking for because the deck is bad, but you know that already. Consider more hatebears? Increasing the pillowfort/opponent disruption strategies and decreasing everything else? Teeg is a good Commander for hatebears. You already have a few good ones Ouphe and Honor Guard, but consider more? Instead of playing a lot of lackluster creatures play hatebears that can both attack and disrupt your opponent. You can build a hatebear/pillowfort strategy on a budget especially since you already have Ghostly Prison
Cards ($5 or less each) to consider adding:
- Luminarch Ascension : win condition when you have established a pillowfort and have your opponents disrupted. Repeatable source of 4/4 Angels that gets around many hatebears and disruptive enchantments/artifacts.
- Sun Titan : can reanimate lots of different hatebears including Teeg, disruptive enchantments/artifacts or Wasteland/Strip Mine.
- Aven Mindcensor : Teeg doesn't stop low mana cost tutors this does including Fetch lands.
- Thalia, Heretic Cathar
- Leonin Arbiter
- Containment Priest : prevents opponent reanimation.
- Vryn Wingmare
- Windborn Muse
- Hushwing Gryff
- Phyrexian Revoker
- Loxodon Gatekeeper
- Spirit of the Labyrinth
- Eidolon of Rhetoric
- Alms Collector
- Kataki, War's Wage
- Suture Priest : good against opponent token creation, can stop an infinite token combo.
- Remorseful Cleric
- Scavenging Ooze
- Aura of Silence
- Blind Obedience
- Rule of Law
- Authority of the Consuls
- Suppression Field
- Pithing Needle
If interested in these suggestions I offer more advice including potential cuts. Good luck with your deck.
1 month ago
multimedia I need to update the deck since I do have a few of the cards you are suggesting and I need to remove and swap some stuff out.
I would like to keep Sorin, Grim Nemesis in the deck since it has just won me a game before.
I like Torment of Hailfire but I could see removing it since I’m not playing mono black and don’t have a crazy amount of mana ramp.
I’ve been meaning to put in my Luminarch Ascension , Windborn Muse , No Mercy , Gisela, Blade of Goldnight , and Enlightened Tutor . I also have a Containment Priest so I should probably put that in since it also goes good with Kaya, Ghost Assassin
I would like to hear your reasons for making some of the cuts you suggest.
1 month ago
Hey, I see why you're confused if you're going in the right direction because your deck is kind of all over the place. There's lots of good cards here, but I think you can reduce the themes and streamline the strategies.
Consider increasing the pillowfort theme? Increasing the token theme? Decreasing the combat themes (first strike), equipment theme and politics themes? In my opinion combining pillowfort and token strategies are the only themes you really need because both these themes require a lot of setup and they both strengthen each other. If you add other themes to these two all they will do is disrupt the ability to pillowfort.
Consider Luminarch Ascension ? It's a good win condition mana sink for pillowfort and token strategies. With three opponents it can activate fast. Windborn Muse is an upgrade for Baird, Steward of Argive . Consider Aura of Silence ? It's good opponent disruption making it more difficult for them to cast mana efficient artifacts and enchantments.
Other than Sun Titan you're not playing reanimation strategies. Consider Rest in Peace or Containment Priest ? Peace is more expensive price, but it affects everything. Consider Knight of the White Orchid ? It's a great card for land ramp in white especially since you're playing Plains Shock lands and Mistveil.
Depending on the budget of cards you want to add, Elesh Norn, Grand Cenobite , Ethersworn Canonist , Twilight Prophet and Elspeth, Sun's Champion are good here, but they're all expensive price. Elesh or Elspeth are an upgrade for Teysa. Both Elesh and Elspeth are very good finishers for tokens. Canonist shuts down some decks and Prophet in combination with a token strategy, getting the city's blessing fast, can give you lots of value.
Consider Kher Keep ? A repeatable way to make tokens that's a land; make a blocker at instant speed. Bitterblossom or the less expensive price, but much worse Dreadhorde Invasion are other good repeatable sources of token. Ophiomancer can be a repeatable source at each upkeep of a token that has deathtouch making it a good blocker on each of your opponent's turns.
Wrath of God as well Day of Judgment or the more expensive price Damnation or Toxic Deluge are cards to consider adding. Board wipes are good with pillowfort and the token strategies since tokens are being made from repeatable sources. Cursed Totem or the more expensive price Linvala, Keeper of Silence is opponent creature disruption since you're not relying on your creatures activated abilities only their ETB or static abilities.
Cards to consider cutting:
- Baird, Steward of Argive
- Vow of Duty
- Vow of Lightning
- Crown of Doom
- Curse of Opulence
- Disrupt Decorum
- Sorin, Grim Nemesis
- Duelist's Heritage
- Archetype of Courage
- Disciple of Bolas
- Protector of the Crown
- Hammer of Nazahn
- Thaumatic Compass Flip
- Torment of Hailfire
- Shinka, the Bloodsoaked Keep
- Teysa, Envoy of Ghosts
If you like some of these suggestions I offer more advice about why I think these cards can be cut. Good luck with your deck.
1 month ago
I'm not a 100% sure I understand and like the changes. Yes I understand that you want to go back to the more aikido way, but I really have the feeling you tuned down the powerlevel of the deck. I'm looking a bit at my list as well and I am making some changes too.
I did remove the Helm of Obedience combo as well, for me it was unfun and a lot of people experience it in the same way in my meta. Yes it is a finisher, but I don't think it's in the way of the deck. That kinda brings me to my next point, by removing so many wincons Dark Depths for example, also thing's like Insurrection seems like a wincon as well. In my opinion there is no problem with stalling the game and extending it (that's what this deck does) but we do need ways to close it, especially by using our opponents power. Right now I have the feeling this build will just stall and then stall some more.
Also maybe a Academy Rector ? Makes you go for your important enchantments and people are reluctant to attack you most of the time.
If it is worth anything, this is how I run it now. It's not in the most aikido way possible, but I try to keep the spirit alive. I kinda fell in love with playing a deck and calling it Mardu Control. Especially newer players go "wow, can red do that?" when I play a red counterspell or a copy spell.
I am really glad that you are updating the deck a bit more often. Please don't take my feedback in the wrong way. Your previous decklist resulted for me in one of the most fun decks I've played in my entire magic career (since legion). It took some while before I got used to it how to play it, but it is so awesome because it is so different. Maybe that's also the reason why I really want to give you this feedback and hopefully help improving (even if it is a little bit) your decklist.
So thank you for updating again and hopefully you have a bit more spare time in your personal life that you give us a bit more often a update of how the deck is being played :)
Commander / EDH
SCORE: 3 | 168 VIEWS | IN 1 FOLDER
1 month ago
This one is the correct list of questions... (tappedout changed my form after the posting T_T) what do you think about the new land Hall of Heliod's Generosity ? if i could use fetchs, duals and so on they will be better for the deck? Ghostly Prison , Propaganda and Norn's Annex instead of Vow of Malice and Assault Suit ? your opinion on Windborn Muse and Silent Arbiter ?
Windborn Muse occurrence in decks from the last year
Commander / EDH:
All decks: 0.03%