DreadKhan
Absurdist -
Please login to comment
Said on
Thinking about how …...
#1
If you get sweaty and run Noxious Revival you can pay no mana to have even more versatility (you can give someone ELSE back something instead, which can be huge). If you've built a really strong deck the idea of paying 3 mana to get a single card back (at sorcery speed!) is laughable, that's pretty much giving up your whole turn without committing something important to the board (like Rhystic Study) or attempting a win (Thassa's Oracle + Demonic Consultation is also 3 mana). That's why Noxious Revival is the best option in the eyes of many very competitive players, so I think it applies to most Bracket 4 and 5 decks, where pure card quality is so important. If you're playing in Bracket 3 and under what you want are card synergies, you need bad cards that become powerful when used together IMHO. Personally I try to avoid running recursion effects that are one dimensional at this point, power creep has given us better options in a lot of cases, if you're in Black something like Lively Dirge can get back creatures, but it can also tutor one up if you don't have anything to get back.
All that said there is a plurality of creature decks out there, and in those lists Eternal Witness can make a lot more sense.
I'm also a tad curious why Skullwinder isn't one of the options, it's bad if you usually have worse cards than your opponents (if you get back a Grizzly Bears and they get Questing Beast you'd have been better off with E-Wit), but the ceiling is very high on it if you can make a deal with an opponent (this is also a great example of recursion with added upside that makes it more versatile). I think in a lower power game Skullwinder plays pretty well, it's even easier to cast if your mana base is janky. I've heard some people really hate Skullwinder, has anyone ever tried using it and can give some salient reasons why they didn't like it?
January 15, 2026 9:23 a.m.
Followers
ZEPHYER69 — Arthurshepard80 — Dammjan — Balaam__ — babydreadswolf — Grends27 — Akmenos6576 — IndulgingPatrician — RockIV — FAIRxPOTAMUS — BirdieGirlie — TheTradeMarked1 — hheraa — xipee808 — Craeter — Zigen — magicbike — LunarSeraphMTG Decks
God's Wrath Has a Barrel Chest
Commander / EDH
SCORE: 10 | 6 COMMENTS | 1122 VIEWS | IN 1 FOLDER
Falconer of the Forbidden Way
Commander / EDH*
SCORE: 14 | 8 COMMENTS | 2037 VIEWS | IN 1 FOLDER
Sygg's Labour Relations Incorporated
Commander / EDH
SCORE: 15 | 2 COMMENTS | 1663 VIEWS | IN 2 FOLDERS
Pavel the Mighty, Hero We Deserve
Commander / EDH
SCORE: 36 | 2 COMMENTS | 4927 VIEWS | IN 9 FOLDERS
Staxdrop! (Snowdrop Vorthos Deck)
Commander / EDH*
SCORE: 16 | 3 COMMENTS | 1934 VIEWS
Tobias Andrion, Political Mastermind
Commander / EDH*
SCORE: 21 | 1 COMMENT | 1666 VIEWS | IN 1 FOLDER
Blood for the Bloodbraid!
Commander / EDH
SCORE: 21 | 2 COMMENTS | 1684 VIEWS
Blackstar (Yo pumpkin head)
Commander / EDH*
SCORE: 22 | 10 COMMENTS | 1563 VIEWS | IN 1 FOLDER
| Finished Decks | 69 |
| Prototype Decks | 41 |
| Drafts | 0 |
| Playing since | Revised Edition |
| Avg. deck rating | 8.80 |
| T/O Rank | 21 |
| Helper Rank | 16 |
| Favorite formats | Legacy, Commander / EDH |
| Cards suggested / good suggestions | 725 / 327 |
| Joined | 6 years |
Optimator says... #1
Thanks for the up-vote!
January 5, 2026 11:12 a.m.