Pebbles the Betta Fish

Legendary Creature - Demon Fish

Ward

Reach

While fighting, Pebbles the Betta Fish can only take 1 damage at a time.

Whenever a creature enters, Pebbles the Betta Fish fights that creature. The first time Pebbles the Betta Fish fights another creature and survives each turn, you may draw a card. The second time, place a +1/+1 counter on Pebbles and you may gain 3 life.

2/6

Wild, kitchen implement, or repeat!

Galatea, Clay Brought to Life

Legendary Enchantment Creature - Golem

Eminent Imprint - When the game begins, you may reveal a sorcery from outside your deck to imprint upon Galatea, Clay Brought to Life. Galatea, Clay Brought to Life becomes the color/s of that sorcery.

When Galatea, Clay Brought to Life attacks an opponent alone, you may cast the imprinted card until the end of your turn. Timing rules and restrictions apply. When you cast the imprinted spell, it costs X generic mana less, where X is Galatea, Clay Brought to Life's toughness.

1/1

Wild, and/or take another stab at this idea of piggybacking an instant or sorcery into the command zone!

Ok this is so weird but this is what popped into my head. A is the villain person/persona from the tv show and book series Pretty Little Liars. A knows information that is seemingly impossible for A to know and messes with the protagonist's heads, communicating almost exclusively via text messages. I tried to catch that impossible knowledge aspect while also making sure the predictions/spikes in mana don't happen so often by giving A a returns to the battlefield effect and also protection from being targeted with blink even by its controller. Would be a very interesting dilemma for a deck with white in it, but I think also extremely well worth the ramp potential for a deck with black in it.

A

Legendary Creature - Human Illusion Villain

Eminence - At the beginning of the game and whenever A returns to the Command Zone, you may secretly predict how many lands each opponent will have in two turns. At the end of each opponent's turn, you may reveal your prediction. If it is correct, you may search your library for a land card, or lands equal to the difference between the number of lands you control and the number of lands that opponent controls, and place them on the battlefield tapped.

Deathtouch, Undying, Shroud

2/3

Repeat challenge!

The Magic School Bus

Enchantment Vehicle - Bus

When The Magic School Bus enters, attacks, on your untap step, and at the beginning of your end step, roll a 6-sided die:

1 - Planeswalk

2 - The Magic School Bus and up to two other creatures you control explore

3 - when you next face a dilemma, draw an additional card

4 - phase out until your next turn

5 - time travel

6 - chaos ensues

Crew 3

7/7

Create a Ms. Frizzle and/or Liz to go along, or Wild!

Sentient Eyeball

Creature - Vision Horror

20/20 Vision - When Sentient Eyeball enters, for each opponent, choose left, right, or forward. They may only attack in the assigned direction until Sentient Eyeball leaves the battlefield or is Exhausted. (If no valid target is sat at the assigned direction, that player cannot attack. Each direction is assigned according to the opponent's line of sight.)

Exhaust - Eyes in the back of my head - , sacrifice a nontoken creature and a mana source: You may see the hand of each opponent during their turn until your next turn.

3/4

Create a card for an Animal Crossing character! Or maybe Polly Pocket. OOh the items from Pretty Pretty Princess!!! Or wild ;D

What would maybe be interesting with a "0 loyalty planeswalker" is if it was like, an artifact planeswalker with text like, "if this planeswalker reaches 0 loyalty, it becomes an artifact named X with ((some effect idk, maybe even one that negatively impacts you)). it is no longer a planeswalker."

But I haven't heard anything about this either, thats just the only way i can think of that it would make sense - the planeswalker "dies" or abandons the field upon 0 loyalty, leaving behind a trace.