Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Bara on Bloomburrow Blu/W Wings & Paws

2 days ago

Play tested the first few turns for a couple of rounds: Need more creatures, Need more low cost creatures, Mana seems ok, Swamped with Instants

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

2 days ago

Prosper of Hailfire

Creature - Demon

When Prosper of Hailfire enters, it deals 2 damage divided as you choose among any number of targets equal to the amount of paid to cast it.

When Prosper of Hailfire enters, exile target nonland permanent with mana value equal to or less than the amount of paid to cast it.

3/4


Make another hybrid-mana creature with an ETB trigger based on how much mana was paid for each color

DJST0RM on Hiding cards from analytics

2 days ago

It would be very useful if there were a way (perhaps some tag that could be put after cards in the deckbuilder) that could hide a card from the color pie and CMC curve calculations.

This is useful because I want the color pie to act as a tool so I can see if my mana base matches well, but cards I will never play for mana (eg. Gitaxian Probe or Street Wraith) pollute the data (and similarly for CMC curve).

Not sure how hard this would be to add, but it would be lovely to see something like this.

DryadArborGoesInCreaturePile on Pauper Splice Tide

2 days ago

Adversarial, this list is a meta deck. While I can admit I should be running a playset of Snap for graveyard hate matchups you can still churn through your entire deck until you find your combo pieces for a win on turn 3-4, then you can Deep Analysis your opponent to deck them. Playtest it yourself if you don't believe me. Merchant Scroll also tutors for Dizzy Spell which tutors for Stream of Thought. And the copies of Psychic Puppetry splice onto almost every draw spell, meaning your netting like 3 mana every time you cast an Ideas Unbound to keep digging on your big combo turn. Though when you can put your entire deck in your hand it doesn't really matter.

Icbrgr on Poison Apple

2 days ago

My brother runs this commander and as much as I hate this commander I absolutely love this commander! Ill be all happy to get a kill spell just for him to Timely Ward/Not Dead After All keeping her alive and adding more auras for more drain/gain. +1 happy brewing!

SufferFromEDHD on Perpetual Patterns of Proliferated Prosperity

2 days ago

Yooo I missed that Goblin Bomb haha this deck has so much potential. Staying with the OG theme... Mind Over Matter if this can't accomplish what the deck needs nothing will!

Trickster Mage mini Mind Over Matter

Tidal Bore weak one shot Mind Over Matter

Orim's Cure/Sivvi's Valor not as good as previous suggestions but on theme with narrow potential

Retreat to Coralhelm consistent land drops consistent triggers

Some good spitballs in there Coward_Token Drumbellower is such a pushed new card. Slow vigilance. Stinging Lionfish is the perfect 2 drop for this.

fifthdawn on Kwain Overdraw

2 days ago

Definitely a cool build and cooncept! Kwain is really great!

I approve!

philias on Card creation challenge

2 days ago

Brand of Kalom

Enchantment - Aura

When ~ enters, tap enchanted creature.

At the beginning of your next upkeep, exile the creature ~ is attached to. If the enchanted creature is legendary, return it to the battlefield under your control. Its owner gains control of it at the beginning of the next endstep

The brand weighs heavy on the wearer, only the strongest of wills can push through


I've been throwing around the idea of a red/white, non-black demon for a while. Make a non-black demon. (it doesn't have to be red/white specifically)

CandrewAndrew9090 on Urza's Workshop

2 days ago

yes I know it's not legal this is exclusively for my friends in our silly online play group.

DemonDragonJ on Mark Rosewater Considers the Fetchlands …

2 days ago

Here is further commentary from Mark Rosewater about the fetchlands, saying that it is very unlikely that those lands shall ever again be in the same standard environment as the shocklands, and I actually agree with that idea, although I still say that efficient mana bases are better than being mana-screwed.

shadow63, fetchlands that can find only basic lands already exist, so why not have fetchlands that can find non-basic lands, as well?

Andramalech on Gravemind Within

3 days ago

Veitanah, thanks for the upvote. Cheers!

mrsnorajackson on Advertise your oathbreaker deck

3 days ago

**I've been attempting to expand my wine business in my hometown in White Plains. For the past 7 years I do play the lottery in my spare time, but on this blessed day I came across an article about Lord Meduza's spell to win the lottery. I contacted Lord Meduza to see if it would work and after I agreed to his terms and conditions for completing the task for me, he performed his magical powers for me and within 48 hours, he provided me with the numbers I needed to play the lottery and I followed his directions. I found out at the store that I was the winner of a $105 million jackpot. For a moment I felt uncertain but I looked again and I saw it was real. As I speak to you, My level has been elevated from grass to grace and I've come to know that life is more spiritual and with the Lord Meduza spell, you can actually win the lottery. Please assist me in thanking him and his contacts are listed as follows;

WhatsApp: +1 (807) 907 2687 Email: [email protected] **

Kamerot on Jetmir's Myriad Debauchery

3 days ago

Coward_Token all of my lists are in need of updating on here, I've been busy (and lazy). I've definitely added quite a few of the new myriad creatures.

I will definitely look into mobilize effects, and I didn't even catch that on zopandrel. I've considered dropling him anyways due to the high mana cost, so this will probably be the catalyst for that change. Thanks!!

shadow63 on Why Has WotC Changed the …

3 days ago

I mean the yearly announcement vid has been the norm for a few years now. For better or worse where stuck with it

Coward_Token on Jetmir's Myriad Debauchery

3 days ago

Lots of new myriad cards if you want to update this list.

In the same spirit, mobilize and more of other "tapped and attacking" effects would work too. I especially like Ainok Strike Leader since it's cheap and produces up to three tokens (even if they're temporary, that's four bodies for two mana).

I think Zopandrel, Hunger Dominus is less good here, because it'll trigger before e.g. myriad has a chance to increase your creature count for the purpose of Jetmir's anthems.

shadow63 on Mark Rosewater Considers the Fetchlands …

3 days ago

Them being able to get non basics is the issue if they said basic island on them theyed be fine

Jaceper on tokens

3 days ago

wow tokens

Andramalech on Red-Glove Landscaping LLC.

3 days ago

Thank you for the upvote, sv7nn. Cheers!

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

3 days ago

Gonti, Avenue Boss

Legendary Creature - Aetherborn Rogue

Deathtouch, Ward

At the beginning of each player's end step, that player exiles the top card of their library. Each of that player's opponents may cast that card for as long as it's exiled.

Whenever an opponent cast a spell they don't own, they lose 3 life and you create a treasure token.

3/4


Create an uncommon enchantment with an enters trigger and an upkeep trigger.

Adversarial on Pauper Splice Tide

3 days ago

DryadArborGoesInCreaturePile That would be cool and all, if any of those cards were in this deck. As it stands you're relying on the single copy of Stream of Thought and 2 copies of Archaeomancer and one single copy of Snap out of the entire 60 card deck to mill your opponent, while those same 2 Archaeomancers are your only creatures/blockers, leaving you open to any and all attacks while you draw and search for your one copy of Stream of Thought. Those few tap spells aren't nearly enough. You'll die long before you can even start to mill anything.

vic on Does "choose a creature" equal …

3 days ago

Slashdance That's great stuff. Thanks!

Chaospyke on Volrath Shapstealer and Summon:Primal Odin

3 days ago

if I have Volrath, the Shapestealerfoil as a copy of Summon: Primal Odin get its second lore counter and gets Primal Odin's second chapter ability, will it keep that ability indefinitely or will the ability go away once Volrath is no longer a copy of Primal Odin

Chaospyke on Volrath Shapestealer and Enduring Glimmers

3 days ago

I unfortunately forgot about this, but I see two conflicting answers.

@Rhadamanthus: I would ask if the time stamp of the abilities matters here.

DryadArborGoesInCreaturePile on Pauper Splice Tide

3 days ago

Hello Adversarial, that is incorrect. Winning involves either meticulously milling your opponent via Jace's Erasure or Sphinx's Tutelage with a lock in place, or with infinite mana and a spell to use it on. As shown here with Stream of Thought, Snap, Archaeomancer, and a few copies of High Tide. Door to Nothingness is acceptable as well

jonjonhholt on Pauper Scam (with Wildfire)

3 days ago

Oh weird yeah idk why the spoiler wont open, the cards name is temporal intervention if you wanna look it up :)

McDuckington on Golgari Goth Girls

3 days ago

A player of class i see.

Coffin Queen

loonofmoons on Welcome to Hallownest (Hollow Knight-themed …

4 days ago

I finally got the chance to start building this deck for myself (I love Hollow Knight). You mentioned being uncertain about Renata as Hornet, I decided to switch Renata out for Nissa, Voice of Zendikar. The art doesn't line up perfectly, but I think the abilities compliment the deck incredibly well.

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

4 days ago

cuts: fog bank, rootha, mercurial artist, marble diamond,

adds: library of leng, smoke spirit's aid, refute

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

4 days ago

cuts: mandate of peace, erebor flamesmith, refuse//cooperate, talrand, sky summoner, increasing devotion, ethereal haze, fumigate

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

4 days ago

adds: storm-kiln artist, curse of the swine, negate, comet storm, heliod's intervention, baral's expertise, path to exile, soulfire grand master, reality spasm, goblin electromancer, galvanic iteration, demilich, gale, waterdeep prodigy, fogbank, shiko and narset, unified, storm the vault, mana geyser

cuts: strike it rich, swiftfoot boots, spellgorger weird, crackling drake, teferi's ageless insight, ghostly prison, collected conjuring, thundering rebuke

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

4 days ago

adds: thought vessel, midnight clock, Raugrin Crystal, jeskai banner, fire diamond, marble diamond, reliquary tower

cuts: sevinne, the chronoclasm

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

4 days ago

adds: murmuring mystic, kykar, wind's fury, myriad landscape, sulfur falls, glacial fortress, port town, clifftop retreat

lollitopicc on Card creation challenge

4 days ago

Multani, corrupted by Norn

Legendary creature - Phyrexian Elemental Avatar

Trample

~ gets +1/+1 for each land you control

When ~ enters, you become the Realmshaper (As long as you're the Realmshaper, you may play an additional land during each of your turns. Whenever a creature deals combat damage to you, its controller becomes the Realmshaper.)

As long as you are the Realmshaper lands don't cause abilities of permanents your opponents control to trigger

0/0


Make a card that exiles from each library (kinda like Rocco, Street Chef) but only lets anyone play cards they don't own

Slashdance on Does "choose a creature" equal …

4 days ago

For anybody else reading this in the future, this answer is kind of misleading when viewed in a google search.

The main question in the headline is "does choosing a creature equal targeting a creature", and the answer is NO! Choosing is not targeting. Unfortunately, when searching on the internet, people will only see the subject, or headline, and below it will see the answer "Yes, it does". But the answer given by the 2nd user is referring to a follow-on question that is much more specific, asking, basically: "does my creature die?"

The second question is if Imperial Edict can kill a creature that has shroud (cannot be targeted). Yes, it can, because choosing is not targeting.

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

4 days ago

cuts: burning vengeance, monastery siege, conflagrate, rolling temblor

tkobs on sevinne rework, new commander and …

4 days ago

commander: kykar or hinata

cuts: daring apprentice, moonhold, relic amulet, burning prophet, opal palace, scholar of the ages, rustvale bridge, razortide bridge, battlefield forge, ray of distortion, dusk//dawn, secrets of the dead

plakjekaas on Mark Rosewater Considers the Fetchlands …

4 days ago

I like them in online clients, but the copious amounts of shuffling do make me choose monocolored decks regularly :|

FormOverFunction on Mark Rosewater Considers the Fetchlands …

4 days ago

The challenge of running a two or three color deck is so low nowadays that I have a hard time getting upset at one specific facet of the land base of mtg. It’s great to reduce that “invest in a land base” barrier to entry for standard and modern, but I don’t even know how much of that is even played anymore. Lands are too far gone for me to worry about fetches.

Rhadamanthus on Does this Aura modify the …

4 days ago

Ricochet_9000: Since it's clear you got a satisfactory answer to your question and there don't seem to be any follow-ups or corrections that need to be made, I marked it as the "Accepted answer" so this topic can move out of the list of unanswered questions. In the future you can take care of this yourself using the "Mark as Answer" button on the response that you feel is the most helpful answer to your question.