Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

VesuvanDoppelbanger on Tap Dance

3 hours ago

Throne of the God-Pharaoh would make a good addition - you're already turning all your critters sideways.

Pdemi559 on A Token of My Appreciation

3 hours ago

Alright Whiskerbro the reason I'm running Monstrous Onslaught is for Hanweir Militia Captain  Flip but I thank you for the suggestions I just don't know what to add right now I'm gonna try Anointed Procession

jhTheMan99 on firemind12

3 hours ago

Same to you! Thanks again.

tams on [Bant] Golem Slalom

3 hours ago

I'm still working out the what ifs and why's with this deck. I've only really tested this deck via a proxy deck. So far it's won every game against all of my friends' modern/casual decks. I included 2 elixirs mainly as a back up for my friend's mill deck, but I might end up replacing it with something else and sideboarding it. As for Lifecraft Awakening, I just wanted to include some spells that weren't creatures that could help beef up my Golems (not that they need anymore buffs lol). I'm actually thinking of replacing Dramatic Reversal with some more blue counter spells or tapping spells. I'm also gonna somehow fit a Broodstar or two and a Prismatic Omen into my deck somehow. The latter to help with Emeria. The memorial is also included mainly for the haste buff and the extra protection. Also because I will most likely not have both the memorial and Odric in my hand at the same time, so both do a good job with mass buffing.

flintshadowrider on 5-Color Tribal Zoo

3 hours ago

Oh, learn something everyday ;)

WItC on Lunarch Wipes (AKH) - Fun ...

3 hours ago

Did a rewrite after winning a lot and following the banning of the cat combo.

emrakulinsmugglers on Speculation about Amonkhet Gods (Spoiler ...

4 hours ago

Zaueski
haha that would be great, if bolas has time travel capabilities, and when he attacked ugin, and learned of eldrazi, he went back in time to create the eldrazis to attack zendikar (creating a bootstrap paradoxparadox where the eldrazi came from no where, because bolas had to make them for them to exist, but to make them, he needed to attack ugin to get the info)

then that would make bolas the one who time traveled sarkhan back in time, because ugin was really dead, and it was bolas's black mana (and his mind breaking touch) that kept tarkir alive

watch sarkhan be a god

sarkhan god of time

collinburns on Izzet Prowess

4 hours ago

Maybe add in the new Insult / Injury. It can lead to some crazy swings.

Argeaux on Baral Control by LSV

4 hours ago

Jimmy_Chinchila I'm not that impressed by this.

My deck does well against Control if I can run them out of spells.

Baral, Chief of Compliance just speeds up that process.

Things are worse for this deck if I am able to grab Dynavolt Tower with Lay Bare the Heart.

I wish he'd made a Sideboard for this. Guess I'll have to try to make one myself.

Rith12 on Kamahl, Fist of Krosa viable?

4 hours ago

kamahal is a pretty cool commander, from a player who once had a deck with him as a general tho a bit wonky...sence then ive learned a few tricks & other stuff....if i where to make him again id stuff Awakening Zone, From Beyond & Illusionist's Bracers the 2 first cards would make great ramp at start of game...then when you dont need ramp its creatures you can dump mana into them with kamahal,the last just gives buy one get one free with him. they are about $2, 50 cents& about $1.50 in that ordereven with from beyond if you decide you need/want to you can tutor up an eldrazi titan or some of the smaller ones that bring along tokens of their own Brood Monitor for example

DemonDragonJ on Iconic Masters Announced

4 hours ago

Two more cards that I would like to see reprinted are Privileged Position and Rhystic Study, both of which very much need to be reprinted due to being very expensive.

orion1575 on The Hunters Moon Rises

4 hours ago

Have you had any luck with this deck? If I ever figure out my zombie deck id love to have a werewolf one

djnewellmit on Bant MechaMog

4 hours ago

Unsubstantiate works well against the Pummeler decks, especially when used after they've pumped up the robot with energy and a handful of pump spells.Have you considered Confirm Suspicions for your deck? It works very well with both the Inspiring Statuary and Mechanized Production.

collinburns on Izzet Blitz

4 hours ago

Any reason there is so much sorcery speed removal in main? I always prefer it in instant speed when possible. Also Insult / Injury is so freaking good for those clutch wins. Do you really have that much mana problems that you need to play Evolving Wilds? If you don't mind take a look at my [Izzet Tempo] Deck.(http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/29-04-17-izzet-tempo/)

Ryttiss on Tap Dance

4 hours ago

well done

orion1575 on Orzhov Zombies

4 hours ago

Oh trust me I've seen it. Been on the maybe list awhile. Six mana is just so much...

Bulldawg1310 on sideboard help

4 hours ago

should I run both Oblivion Stone and Ratchet Bomb in my eldrazi tron deck? I have a lot of removal in the sideboard already, money isn't an issue, I just don't know if I need to focus on destroying everything once its on the board. please help.

kactar54@ on BR Aggro AHK

4 hours ago

idk about the 2 hazoret the fervent seems like the mana curve is a little high for an aggro deck also have you ever thought about the cartouches the red one. instead of cuts maybe 1 lightning axe and incendiary flow idk if you need the cuts because of the other burn. i mean if you run it to be discarded you could prob run insult/injury cause usually ribbons takes to long to get to if you are looking for aggro.

sonnet666 on When Victimize returns a Sun ...

4 hours ago

Link all your cards please: Victimize, Sun Titan

Short answer: yes.

Long answer: The creatures are all sacrificed as part of Victimize resolving. Sun Titan's ability triggers at this time, but waits to go on the stack until Victimize finishes resolving. Once it does go on the stack the creature you sacrificed is in the graveyard, and you can target it with Sun Titan's ability so long as its CMC is 3 or less.

orion1575 on Orzhov Zombies

4 hours ago

Have you played the Mono Black Zombies deck you have at any games? It looks decent. I've never been able to win a tournament with any type of zombie deck and there's so many ways you can go with the tribe. It just seems like the different strategies dont work great together (making zombie tokens, zombies that make ppl discard, zombie lords, graveyard recursion)

ashling33 on Name A Card, Any Card

4 hours ago

Booby Trap 4 the win! I've never seen it used in a deck, so props to you.

DemonDragonJ on LEOVOLD IS BANNED!

4 hours ago

Nintendows, yes, that does seem to be a fairly miserable experience, so I can understand why the EDH committee decided to ban him, but I shall now need to find a replacement for him in the deck that I am building.

Bobbbyyy on Card creation challenge

4 hours ago

Hypnotic Capture

Sorcery

Tap target creature, it doesn't untap during its controllers next untap step.

if you control a card named Argurd's Wand gain gontrol of that creature instead.


create another card that refers to the wand

Niblet on 90° Angle Deck

4 hours ago

How often are you able to get your higher CMC creatures out? It seems like you have no way to get mana other than Pristine Talisman, and you only have 2 of those

Bobbbyyy on Card creation challenge

4 hours ago

Argurd's Wand

Artifact

Blue non creature spells you control cost less to cast.


and

Negatatory Cantrip

Instant

return target spell to it's owners hand.

if you control a card named Argurd's Wand counter that spell instead, and draw a card


create another card that refers to the wand

Alexdagreat on Doomsday Zur Modded and Foiled

4 hours ago

Glad you like it, and thank YOU for making the original deck! As far as a budget list goes, read Bolsheviktory's primer, and I'd prioritize the mana base first, as the lands are what really allow this deck to maintain consistency. You could probably cut Candelabra, Grim Tutor, and Timetwister (although that should be the first of the expensive ones to acquire) for other, more budget-friendly options.

imsocool1234 on Orzhov Zombie Horde

4 hours ago

Hey buddy I've been fiddling around with my own esper zombie brew and it's still private atm but I figured I'd hit ya with my 2cents to hopefully help us both. I've found having Cryptbreaker and Wayward Servant to be great. But with Cryptbreaker you really want good discards, like Haunted Dead and Prized Amalgam if those aren't available to discard any creature will have to suffice. The new Lili is awesome for bringing back those creatures and I think Noosegraf Mob is a great card to reanimate. Dread Wanderer and Haunted Dead also combo with Prized Amalgam. Now I understand with your deck you want to go the creature heavy route but there is solid low cmc removal, Grasp of Darkness and Time to Reflect, even Never / Return. I think losing cards such as Binding Mummy, maybe 2 Relentless Dead, Metallic Mimic, even Lord of the Accursed could help this deck curve nicely and possibly play more consistently. Anyways just my 2cents. I'd love to hear your feedback and your reasoning for inclusion of some cards, maybe you know something I don't! Let's get sharing and learning, so we can brew some really strong, competitive Zombie decks! Cheers

tazleon7 on Orzhov Zombies

4 hours ago

yeah maybe even a sac combo and bridge from below t3 kill style deck its certainly getting close to do able :)

gallenwolf on gallenwolf

4 hours ago

Done! I'm building my own kraken deck, yours gave me inspiration for the smaller creatures. Thanks!

MWorl91 on What Plane Should be Revisited?

4 hours ago

Did someone say something about revisiting Kamigawa? I'd like to revisit Kamigawa.

orion1575 on Orzhov Zombies

4 hours ago

I hope so; waited a long time. I keep second guessing myself on whether Blue or maybe Green should be played. I think someone will eventually break it and we'll be seeing Zombies in GPs

MagicalHacker on Card creation challenge

4 hours ago

I'm not sure how you mean it, so I'm gonna take it both ways:


Misrey, Pact Maker

Legendary Creature - Spirit Advisor

~ has flying unless you control an untapped land.

: Search your library or graveyard for a card named Intervention Pact, Pact of Negation, Slaughter Pact, Pact of the Titan, or Summoner's Pact and put it into your hand. If you search your library this way, shuffle it.

You skip your upkeep step.

1/7


Anim the Perceiver

Legendary Enchantment Creature - Illusion Rogue

Skulk

Players play with the top of their libraries and their hands revealed.

At the beginning of each player's upkeep, you may put the top card of that player's library into that player's graveyard. You may U/B (Dimir). If you do, repeat this process.

1/1


Up next, make a sorcery based off of hypnotism.

Rant on Hanna Montana v2

4 hours ago

you have two treasure mage here

firemind12 on jhTheMan99

4 hours ago

Thanks again for the trade! Looking forward to trading again in the future!

Kylesafgt on Karador's Graveyard Harvest

4 hours ago

Hey! Thanks for the suggestion, I've definitely considered adding Vampire Hexmage into my deck. As of now, counter and planeswalker based strategies aren't too big of a threat for me nor occurrence and I currently have enough relevant hate cards towards those strategies that the level at which they exist in my meta isn't too threatening.

I definitely like the idea of her, especially if I included something such as Dark Depths into the mix. I'll add her to the potential inclusions section for future reference.

Bulldawg1310 on cant beat em join em

4 hours ago

GabeCubed do you think I need to run Oblivion Stone and Ratchet Bomb in the side or should I pick one or the other and grab something else?

Argeaux on UR Control by OAFMCNAMARA

4 hours ago

Never mind.

I found a list and built it.

Baral Control by LSV

tazleon7 on Death's Menace

4 hours ago

i like this deck its not, just another goyf deck and looks like it could ramp out more counters than a hardened scales deck, i might actually have to test this one see how it goes :D

KailDaemon on Food Chain Prossh

4 hours ago

I like the snow covered ide

As for the alternative win con, prossh himself is a terrifying voltron commander thats hard to evade in the early game, i feel kikki/conscripts is a little excessive but ill test it out

As for the lands, ive never had an issue with hitting my land drops or starving for mana, and its actually been reduced from 31 lands for the extra dorks due to food chain ammo and it been alot more consistent with that change

But thanks for the feedback!

TheBlakPhenix on UB Faeries

4 hours ago

Not to be rude or anything, but b isn't this the deck that the professor from tcc made?

SirupyTuna on When Victimize returns a Sun ...

4 hours ago

If I cast Victimize and target a Sun Titan + whatever creature in my graveyard, then choose and sacrifice a creature with CMC = 3, can Sun Titan return the creature I just sacrificed?

b4nchs on Esper Zombies

4 hours ago

haha you're right that card should be in here also thinking of adding Embalmer's Tools just to randomly mill someone out. Thanks for your suggestion!

tazleon7 on Orzhov Zombies

4 hours ago

spicy new zombies, i wonder if its now possible to play modern zombies competitively with a more black/white control approach? +1 :D

Monochromacy on RG Standard Stompy

4 hours ago

And, if you're new at brewing decks, you'll want to watch this playlist of helpful deck building videos. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLtLlcD-b2JRH8kzX1ymYm8wj22QJPty7c

Argeaux on UR Control by OAFMCNAMARA

4 hours ago

Do you have any links, Jimmy_Chinchila?

I'd like to test against them.