Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Legendary_penguin_of_death on Jeff

2 hours ago

Finally!! Someone with a detailed description that I can understand. +1 for that

MsSysbit on Dralnu is love; Dralnu is ...

2 hours ago

Have you considered Buried Ruin to regain your Engine? Beacon of Unrest can do that too or help steal a fatty. Id probably do Lightning Greaves too for haste and safety for dralnu. Torrential Gearhulk? Seems omitted too. Just a few ideas for an already awesome and a big fan.

Chiberia on The Stony Mountains Cold

2 hours ago

enpc

Good notes, and I completely forgot that Kira targets your own creatures! Fuck she's getting out of here now. However some of those counter spells are not good enough (such as putting on top of library), as I play games with about 5 people in my friend group. If it is going to be countered it is going to the graveyard.

Lightning Greaves could leave I guess, I will make some changes as the time goes on. I ordered a lot of cards around Christmas for a different type of deck.

When I get home I will make some changes to the decklist, but the physical version won't change for a month or two.

thegigibeast on Naya Food Chain

2 hours ago

I will have time to continue working on this deck in a couple days, right now I am preparing for a gamejam, but I will return here after it ;)

spiritgolem on Golem Foundry Enrage

2 hours ago

I'd advice a full playset of Walking Ballista to this. Gives you a little bit more versatility (also combos veeeeeeery nice with Bellowing Aegisaur ;-)

Chiberia on New Inf. Turns Combo

2 hours ago

DarkMagician

Glad to see someone was inspired by this:)

Draakeragon on Treva the dragon princess

2 hours ago

Well I do want to add some but I don't have an idea which cards to add, Can you give me some recommendations on which cards to add or to look at?

clayperce on UR Modules (RIX)

2 hours ago

Marcs7,
Oh, Era of Innovation is really interesting. I'll check it out; thanks much!

TheOrakle on Gift of Mettle

2 hours ago

Nice deck.

I recommend replacing Glory-Bound Initiate with Captain Lannery Storm to help with splashing, even out your curve a bit, and also, T1 Courier, T2 Path of Mettle  Flip, T3 Lannery, swing, and Path flips and you now have two mana open of any colour for combat tricks.

Good luck in your games!

bbluebaugh on What happens if buyback cost ...

2 hours ago

I know the rules state that buyback cannot cost less than 0 but is it possible for them to cost 0? for example Sprout Swarm with Memory Crystal?

clayperce on UR Modules (RIX)

2 hours ago

Cragon18,
Thanks so much! I really appreciate your inputs; you've given me a TON of things to think on and test! Here are some initial thoughts:

  • In testing so far, there's almost always been something useful to do with Vault of Catlacan. Extra +1/+1 Counters and Servos from Animation Module for sure, but also huge Walking Ballistas, tutoring with Inventors' Fair, or block-then-bouncing Glint-Nest Crane or Whirler Virtuoso.
  • Nezahal, Primal Tide is an intriguing option ... though The Locust God might be better in that kind of role. I'll have to check them out.
  • Maverick Thopterist is worth looking at for sure ... not sure why I hadn't thought of him earlier!
  • Yeah, I'm not sure about Metallic Mimic either. The card is pretty much terrible on its own, but it's just sooooo good with Animation Module (choosing Servo), Whirler Virtuoso (choosing Thopter), and especially Walking Ballista (since we can then tutor for it Whir of Invention after choosing Construct).
  • The board definitely feels a little weird without some sweepers ... but so far, the deck hasn't really needed them (I found they often hurt me worse than my opp, plus it can just chump-block so effectively). But yeah, since we will almost certainly see more "can't be blocked", Trample, and Lifegain now, I probably need to just plan on it ...

Thanks again!

shiwei87tan on G/R Karnless Tron

2 hours ago

Ever thought of Simian Spirit Guide for the turn 3 ugin with tron?

Skinken on Fuel, Furnace, Profit

2 hours ago

Suhbruh I like Rekindling Phoenix a lot. The fact that you can keep hitting with it every turn because of haste is very strong. The only thing i that the token is very vunerable to removal like Fatal Push or Shock. However, even in that case, bringing back in Costly Plunder makes it a lot less fragile. And it has very good synergy with Bontu's Last Reckoning as well.

LeaPlath on What's the best way to ...

2 hours ago

EmblemMan You sacrifice the Scarab God so it returns at the end of turn

CraigBlanchette717 on Lo_Pan

2 hours ago

Hey Lo, just saw your message about my Saskia Infect Perfected and you are right on, it's meant to hit hard and fast naming person 2 on turn 4 consistently. I recently made it more potent and will be updating the card list slightly soon. Also, love the thought of Reforge the soul, might not use it in this deck, but decinitely using it in Kaydele and Kraum partners (Decklist coming soon.)

Naksu on Sacrificial Spirits (Modern Budget Weenies)

2 hours ago

My non-budget recommendation would be Fatal Faeries. This deck feels pretty solid as is, I think I would have to stray too much from synergy and flavor if I try to de-budgetecize this.. if thats a word.

EmblemMan on What's the best way to ...

2 hours ago

Well, that isn't possible because yahenni doesn't protect the scarab god from vraska's contempt. Contempt exiles yahenni gives indestructible so the god still dies to the same things it would without yahenni.

lukas96 on 4 color casual 60 card ...

2 hours ago

well there where good esper control decks in standart at that time but thats not the color combination you are looking for.when you want a control deck id cut all the ramp stuff, you dont want to tap out to ramp when your in a control deck. Play more removal and counterspells instead. Also id try to cut the 8 drops. For a control deck you already have a lot of win cons and you dont need additional ones for 8 mana.

URT123 on Treva the dragon princess

2 hours ago

There is no life trrigers in your deck, are you sure you don't want to add some?

RedWizard97 on Sacrificial Spirits (Modern Budget Weenies)

2 hours ago

I missed that we are on a budget here, sorry for that.

Do you have any non-budget recommendations?

Ah, now I see the reason for you building this deck :D

Justsayin on Reel Big Fish

2 hours ago

Sideboard?

FlabbyAbs on GB explore

2 hours ago

Great deck! How does Enter the Unknown play? Supernatural Stamina could be a safer bet to me.

Dorotheus on And My X

3 hours ago

Garmads, well to be fair, statistically, you probably weren't playing EDH 4 years ago when I made this deck :)

lukas96 on healing indestructible Artifacts

3 hours ago

Altar of Shadows seems preeetty slow.Cathar's Shield does nothing.Cranial Archive does nothing.why do you needGhirapur Orrery?There are better ways for unblockable than Hot Soup, but why do you need to be unblockable?.Trading Post is very versatile but what is he for?You have only two cards to make things indestructible so Worldslayer is a dead card in any other case.

get rid of all the one ofs that cost more than 6 mana, they all do dofferent things and make the deck very inconsistent

DickHeiney on Eternal Pilgrimage

3 hours ago

Thanks for checking it out! I honestly think my it might be unfun to use the Diabolic Tutor with Exquisite Blood and Sanguine Bond in my playgroup(which is just two other friends). It is an insane combo for sure though! Same with Felidar Sovereign I eventually took him out.

That being said your recommendations are great, I have a list for new cards to get now. Also Archangel of Thune is never at my LGS I'll have to buy offline. I love the recursive sac for mass life gain, more efficient use of my mana. I need a Dictate of Erebos for sure!

Swiftwolf on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

3 hours ago

Sadistic Skymarcher is not classified as a Creature instead its set to "Unknown"

lukas96 on IDGAFOS

3 hours ago

well first of all you shouldnt play 70 cards and a lot of one or two offs also dont help the consitency of your deck.i think you have to be clear, what the deck should be about, there has to be a kind of theme, if you have one we can try to make it work.

leleco07 on Wistful Thinking

3 hours ago

Thanks for the tips, cdkime.

As much as I like The Rack it's still quite slow for this deck. In order to work properly it have to kill fast. If you give your opponent the opportunity to survive long enough he'll surely build something to destroy you since our defenses are not so good.

Waste Not, on the other hand, can be quite helpfull indeed. This deck can make good use of every aspect of it. I'll try to add at least one copy to see how it fares.

DarkMagician on New Inf. Turns Combo

3 hours ago

Use it with Deadeye Navigator in an Inalla, Archmage Ritualist deck... And now I know what I'm building again.

JML200129 on Argy

3 hours ago

Can you please take a peek at this U/G merfolk deck.

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/15-01-18-elT-ug-merfolk-standard/

Naksu on Sacrificial Spirits (Modern Budget Weenies)

3 hours ago

Westvale Abbey  Flip could definately work (and fits thematically too) and Bloodghast would definately work, but it would stray away from budget.

I like kamigawa too, along innistrad which blends perfectly :)

Garmads on And My X

3 hours ago

I am disappointed with myself that I did not think of this name for my Rosheen Meanderer deck.

Garmads on Narset (growing in competitiveness)

3 hours ago

Hi, I also made a voltron Narset deck recently. Mine focuses on tokens while controlling the board as a win con rather than taking 3+ turns at once. The main thing I found when playtesting was that I had to upgrade the manabase to get Narset out sooner, or I'd forever be stuck at turn 5-8 and usually closer to 8. I also included a lot of protection to clad Narset with before swinging. So you have other creatures as well, is that why you have many card draw spells to get them in your hand rather than dead with Narset's ability? I'm curious on what you think because I have not used my list in real life yet.

dekalabia on Tezzeret Thopter Fabrication Agency Inc.

3 hours ago

Yeah he's in there as a placeholder really. I should just take him out to be honest.

Insectodroid on Eldrazi Annihilator

3 hours ago

Gouden kies eruit door die harde klap

zigge85 on Tezzeret Thopter Fabrication Agency Inc.

3 hours ago

Metalwork Colossus is going to cost 11 every time.

waly91 on Atifact suicide

3 hours ago

Thanks for the comment, i have made few changes.4x Sharpenel blast go in

SpremePhantasm on Draft Sim for RIX

3 hours ago

I found that when I play draft sim of RIX, the immage is not loading. I wonder is there anyway to fix this.

elementary on Paradox Bridge

3 hours ago

My original idea was to exclude fetchlands and instead to run painlands with Blood Suns in the main deck. But I couldn't find anything I could cut to add the Blood Suns. With the Ancient Tombs and Sacred Foundries it sounded like a fun idea.

ShadowKaras on U/G(Simic) Rivals of Ixalan Merfolk

3 hours ago

During my testis i did notice that tempert caller was kind of underwhelming. It was good against token senergy but very bad against aggro (like HazoRed its the New nickname of ramunap red) did you concider to play Swift warden instead? Its protection is very good to protect your lord and with either metallic mimic or mistbinder on the field its a 3 mana 4/4 flash

soupdragons on Really Fun Budget Sultai Modern ...

4 hours ago

If you are trying to go for mill via getting rid of land then Mind Funeral might be a good idea.

Insectodroid on black lock

4 hours ago

With the absence of a real lock in this deck, i would suggest to change the title from 'black lock' into 'black hole'

Insectodroid on 4c control

4 hours ago

Is dit de tjechische stapel?

Insectodroid on Simic

4 hours ago

You need more expensive cards to make this deck work!

evangelmagic on Cranky Krenko

4 hours ago

I missed the hammer. I put is as an enchantment. I have gamble in my krenko deck. My list has gone through a major overhaul a few months ago. It went from an aggro strategy like you have to looking to abuse his tap ability as much as possible and killing without having to attack. I have had a lot more success with it.

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/11-07-17-krenko/

clayperce on Kizmetto

4 hours ago

Hey, thanks much for the upvote on UR Modules (RIX)!

clayperce on WizardOfTheNorthernCoast

4 hours ago

Hey, thanks for the upvote on Ponza.dec (Deckbuilding Primer)!

Bulldawg1310 on Power Metal: the 30th Anniversary

4 hours ago

Doubt it, i mean, vinnie lost a brother right after phil said some very ill timed things about him. Somehow I think this falls under the realm of unforgivable. I could see if dime was alive we may get a reunion show as a one night only in texas, but sadly hes not. Meanwhile, Rex Brown released his first solo album and it was... lackluster to say the most.

Murphy77 on W/B Vampire Tribal

4 hours ago

For a similar deck with token swarm, what do you think of Vampires at Twilight?