Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

TheBombmage on TheBombmage

4 minutes ago

Blev blah

DarkEclipse18 on It's Not Easy Being Green

9 minutes ago

ok so some suggestions:

~Blighted Woodland and Myriad Landscape: Cheap 'fetchlands' to get out your Forests and thin out the deck.

~Garruk Wildspeaker is a little better then Primal Hunter in my opinion, your free to keep him but i suggest adding Wildspeaker.

Chord of Calling: A good Green mana sink

Craterhoof Behemoth: A game ender...though you need:

Mana Dorks: Freyalise, Llanowar's Fury makes 1 each turn plus some utility and card draw, but basic dorks are also great Arbor Elf, Fyndhorn Elves,Elvish Mystic, Llanowar Elves

TheGameV on Melek, Izzet Paragon EDH

15 minutes ago


a combo deck should have multiple win con combos usealy

so maybe more draw

and then consider Guttersnipe as an alt win con, which also goes nicely with rite of replication.

and maybe Aetherflux Reservoir as another combo, doasnt work with copies but still.

Pyromancer's Goggles are also nice in general

Jori En, Ruin Diver is nice draw

also run Cyclonic Rift dont care what kind of deck you are runing this card is amazing and single handedly wins games not even raerly

Raphiezar on Blood is Thicker Than Seawater

15 minutes ago

Ultimately, play the deck first, keep a list of some cards in mind to try out, and replace the ones that are under performing with some cards from that list.

Dismal on Ramos, Dragon Engine Brew

19 minutes ago

Yo Athraithe, wouldn't Jund Charm just let you instantly use ramos?

Winterblast on Chairman Meow

23 minutes ago

Gleeock I don't think I can profit much from empyrial plate and armor because I usually have my hand empty very fast. I probably still need to find more ways to cheaply refill the hand. Sylvan library, hunter's prowess and bloodforged battle axe/puresteel paladin do much, sword of fire and ice also does something for card draw but not quite as much...

I still need to find the perfect balance between cards that put pressure on the board and cards that are investments and produce value over more turns

Hobbez9186 on Harsh Tormenting Punishment

24 minutes ago


Yeah, this is pretty straight forward. Timing is always important, and knowing what to target comes with practice. I've found this easy and fun to play while being effective against most of the popular strategies. Of course there are non-budget upgrades for lower cmc options or slightly more powerful spells, but as-is this is very inexpensive to complete in full. Cards from sets before Kaladesh you may want to exclude as they will no longer be Standard playable with the next expansion, and those could be substituted with several different options from newer sets. Look through the comments to see what others have tried and find out what works best for you.

Good luck, and thank you for your comment :)

Triton on You Can Call Me Grandaddy

31 minutes ago

TheSpiritombEnthusiast I'll consider adding in Gatekeeper of Malakir, the only hesitation I have is it's just target player, and usually I gear my EDH decks more towards multiplayer games so he wouldn't have much impact, sadly. :(

Darkshadow327 there's always room for Edgar Markov decks. ;) I really like some of the Sorins, will pick some up once I'm done with another EDH project haha.

Thanks for all the advice and upvotes! I believe this is the 3rd highest-ranking Edgar Markov deck and now the 14h highest-ranking deck on T/O! I can't thank you all enough!

TransMarx on Chairman Meow

33 minutes ago

+1 for comrade Meow <3

Pondy on Sunmare

36 minutes ago

Hey! This is great, very similar to a list I am working on. I am running Aerial Responder instead of Metallic Mimic and Desert's Hold rather than Renewed Faith. With very limited play it has performed admirably against aggro match ups. How have you found it so far?

LordRedBeard on EDH Derevi Brew

37 minutes ago

Honestly kicking myself for not including her on the first build. Thank you!

Marouke on Mono Green

39 minutes ago

I was thinking tireless tracker, but oracle of mul daya cost to mach for me or I would throw in maybe 2

Etoilebane on The Ur Dragon's Raging Rainbow ...

44 minutes ago

High cost dragons decks really like Cryptic Gateway. Maybe yours has a spot for it?

soupdragons on Storm Crow Voltron

54 minutes ago

this is truly too good.I guess i have to quit Magic now....(sets foil rares on fire)This is the only way to respect the power of storm crow

Inferno323 on Bant enchatments

1 hour ago

You didn't put enough mana in to every be able to cast Elspeth. Might want to reconsider that.

griffstick on Gattison's Obscure List of Obscure ...

1 hour ago

I see this sorted list thing you are doing and I like it. Here's one I made I think you are missing

List of cards good for devotion

AlmightyTentacle on Mogis Trigger

1 hour ago

Hi, hebleb

Nice deck +1!

Here some cards I think you can consider to add in:

AkrosTheClear on Infect/Proliferate Commander

1 hour ago

Hi, recently made a 60 card deck centered around Hapatra, Vizier of Poisons and it got me thinking about how cool the mechanic proliferate is, especially when paired with infect. I want to bring this into EDH and I was wondering what the best commander is for something with infect or proliferate.

MegaMatt13 on The Ur Dragon's Raging Rainbow ...

1 hour ago

jamindragons, I considered it. My deck is high CMC as it is with all the dragons. I wanted my boardwipes to be relatively cheap. That's why I've stuck with Toxic Deluge and Crux of Fate. Thanks for the suggestion!

KylerStar, I've played Skyline Despot in other decks and my experience is that it encourages people to attack me. I rarely got much card draw/tokens out of it. Appreciate the feedback.

Akorndr2 on 89% "NO"

1 hour ago

Is it possible to budget this deck for similar output?

goblinguiderevealpls on Super Friends Commander/EDH

1 hour ago

Teferi, Temporal Archmage

Liliana of the Veil

Jace, the Mind Sculptor

Ugin, the Spirit Dragon

If you can afford these, they win you the game extremely fast.. to the point i took my deck apart because it was way too fast lol

Speaking of which, there is an infinite combo you're missing out on!

Tezzeret the Seeker +1,Prismatic Geoscope and The Chain Veil = infinite chain veil activation :)

Venser, the Sojourner

Bloom Tender

Birds of Paradise

Ashiok, Nightmare Weaver

Kaya, Ghost Assassin

Aceleron on Aggro Minotaur - Game Day ...

1 hour ago

goblinguiderevealpls at this moment I cant really tell you as I changed this deck a lot in the last couple of days and couldnt test it against any deck at all at this moment. But if you test it, let me know ;)

Aceleron on Aggro Minotaur - Game Day ...

1 hour ago


enter image description here

I forgot to check sideboard in this moment but you are 100% correct!

Im thinking about Metallic Mimic and will test this as soon as I could add more creatures into the paper version of this deck to see how this goes.

Sunbird's Invocations sounds pretty good, maybe it is possible to cheat a lot of things into play while casting a creature brings another one on the battlefield. Kind of like this idea. Will see about this as soon as Ixalan has been published.

Lastnotice on Question about Heart-Piercer Manticore

2 hours ago

Yes this is legal. This is because there is not any white mana symbols on the card.

AkrosTheClear on LeoSushi

2 hours ago

Lol, Yeah I was thinking about that myseslf, just letting you know that I posted my decklist onto tapped out. It is just a rough deck right now, but for sure I will keep Mina and Denn, Wildborn, Ramunap Excavator, Rampaging Baloths, and Omnath, Locus of Rage in the deck. a great combo I want to run is Myojin of Infinite Rage and then Splendid Reclamation, it would be great for landfall which is a mechanic I want present in the deck.

Casey4321 on The Deckwatch [Home Base]

2 hours ago

I fucking love the flavor of Walk the Plank. Merfolk can swim confirmed.

readerrw07 on Win-con for Grixis Kess?

2 hours ago

Thats probably the best idea, with the Skithryx and Blightsteel as backups. I'll look up doomsday combos.

DiesToDiscard on Wheel of Elements (Horde EDH)

2 hours ago

Pretty solid deck, i use Liliana's Caress its good with all the wheels

TheFight on Help me with my solo-blue ...

2 hours ago

@Hyperalgialysis - not sure how to reply back yet, (sry if you don't get this)

Hey good call with the Memnite and Ensoul Artifact. Great combo in general.

greyninja on Oops! I generated infinite combat ...

2 hours ago

So I went and updated BOMBnath in case you wanted any ideas or felt like upvoting some decks wink wink nudge nudge

goblinguiderevealpls on Ramos the Voltron Spellslinger

2 hours ago

Ive heard ramos is best used as a storm commander, cast a ton of multicolor spells, then cast double the amount with double the mana

Note that 1 cmc spells like Brainstorm literally pay for themselves with ramos out, and things like Manamorphose and Dark Ritual have double the ramp potential

For storm, you're gonna need a LOT of instants, ramp, and "storm" spells

Storm/ multicolor spells


Gitaxian Probe

Shadow of Doubt

Brain Freeze




Lim-Dul's Vault

Chromatic Star

Mind's Desire

Burning-Tree Emissary

Tendrils of Agony


Increasing Vengeance

Painful Truths


Prismatic Geoscope

Birds of Paradise

Wild Cantor

Bloom Tender

Zhur-Taa Druid

Seething Song

Dark Ritual

Cabal Ritual


Also, charms are a great way to generate mana with ramos while having many modes for utility and building storm count

Crosis's Charm

Grixis Charm

Naya Charm

Dromar's Charm

Jeskai Charm

Bant Charm

Sultai Charm

Abzan Charm

Mardu Charm

Temur Charm

Esper Charm

Azorius Charm

Boros Charm

Izzet Charm

Darigaaz's Charm

Dimir Charm

Jund Charm

Rith's Charm

Treva's Charm

Simic Charm

And many more..

Storm also needs a lot of tutors and recursion spells if you can afford them

Snapcaster Mage

Yawgmoth's Will

Mizzix's Mastery

Kess, Dissident Mage

Past in Flames

Vampiric Tutor

Demonic Tutor

Mystical Tutor

Enlightened Tutor

Sylvan Tutor


Increasing Ambition

Signal the Clans

But yea, from what I've heard and seen about ramos, you want to storm multicolor spells in order to cast more spells with the mana and using the insane ramp to win via stuff like Mind's Desire, Grapeshot, Brain Freeze and Tendrils of Agony after a huge storm count of multicolor spells

dahhahm on Devastating Reclamation

2 hours ago

Don't tell me what to do, I'm an adult. Take my upvote!

Rise_of_the_Hangover on A +1/+1 Counter A Day ...

2 hours ago

Lol, Sekki for the memes! Thanks Deepstriker29 for the suggestions! I actually just got a Cold-Eyed Selkie and added it to the deck. For now I'm keeping Crowned Ceratok (I get that sometimes Trample is a "win more" mechanic, but at least in the games I play with my friends where we let the board get ridiculous and then all swing at each other's faces, it can certainly be the deciding factor lol). I have Ugin's Insight and probably had it in an earlier version of the deck, but I'll consider throwing it in - there are only a handful of cards I would really even consider taking out at this point so if I feel like I'm not having any issues with draw I will probably leave it out.

Also thanks Wurmspiralmaschine14, those are definitely some strong cards I will need to look into!

Daedalus19876 on The Deckwatch [Home Base]

2 hours ago

Hey, guess what spoiler season began today? :D


And yes, this is an official spoiler, so no problems linking it.

Om3gaOm3n on Rishkar Ramp

2 hours ago

From Beyond is a good mana producer. Natural Connection is good for ramp... in standard, but if you don't care about the format try Rampant Growth and Fog(so you can get to the late game with your creatures).

rockleemyhero on Win-con for Grixis Kess?

2 hours ago

If you are looking to win consistently, I would recommmend running a Doomsday package with a Laboratory Maniac combo. There are a lot of resources for the combo and it is extremely competitive, nets in consistent t3-4 wins, and typically has counter back up on top of that.

CotyWithaT on Advertise your STANDARD deck!

2 hours ago

The Ballista Paradox

Standard* CotyWithaT


Please send help!

Bant-ish type deck that's trying to make infinite mana with Paradox Engine Cryptolith Rite and Aviary Mechanic. Possible to do on turn four, but only sometimes. Would like help making it more consistant and keeping the combo safe. Thanks!

npparsons on EDH Arahbo! Roar of the ...

2 hours ago

Does your commanders ability trigger if he's in the command zone or does he have to be on the field to be able to do it?

readerrw07 on Win-con for Grixis Kess?

2 hours ago

Working on a decklist for the new best grixis commander Kess, Dissident Mage but win conditions are hard to choose, especially without infinite combos (our LGS limits infinite combos).Any thoughts on wincons for that color combination beides Skithryx and Blightsteel? One or two combos arent out of the question but I need non-combo ways to win for tournaments. Thank you in advance

ticked-off-squirrel on Red/White/Blue Vehicles

2 hours ago

hmm. interesting set up. I suggest these for cards:

Speedway Fanatic give vehicles Haste when crewed.

Spireside Infiltrator can pop each opponent for 1 when crewing a vehicle.

Consulate Dreadnought a really beefy vehicle for 1 mana (yes a crew of 6 but that not hard)

I also suggest removing both Aether Hub and Aethersphere Harvester. without energy they do nothing helpful.

DaringApprentice on Blood is Thicker Than Seawater

3 hours ago

That makes sense, I feel like Serra Avatar has potential, too, but I am concerned that it has no evasion. Right, yeah I was considering Noble Purpose, as well, but am worried about putting too much pure lifegain into the deck. Do you have any suggestions for cuts to the deck?