SufferFromEDHD on "Noct, A Second Robot has …
46 minutes ago
Sometimes I wish it was "iSufferFromEDHD" but we all collectively suffer from it anyway.
Stubborn Denial gets my vote then
plakjekaas on Why Does Black No Longer …
3 hours ago
For white control effects, you're spot on I'd say, with effects like Preacher or Debt of Loyalty.
Also, Olivia Voldaren is red in addition to black, and Threaten-effects are a mainstay there, it's Captivating Vampire that's the rare "flavor over color pie"-effect we're talking about.
Andramalech on What The Rocc(o) is Cooking
3 hours ago
Like how NV_1980 said, also add Ivy Lane Denizen, and Quest for Pure Flame.
Andramalech on What a Cartouchebag
4 hours ago
Balaam__ did someone mention nutty deck ideas that deserve love?! He's right! BAck! AT! IT AGAIN! with these crazy decks. I can always get behind some kind of nuanced golgari themed deck. Food, Elves, Toxic, you name it. This one was no exception. +1
Iddoshka on Planeywalkey
5 hours ago
Comeuppance elspeth storm slayer dreamtide whale wrath djeru with eyes open baird, stewrad of argive is a cheaper option to oathkeeper rings of brighthearth elspeth suns champion flux channeler jin gitaxis// the great synth teferi master of time damn resourceful defense
as for the rest of the planeswalkers it really depends on what you are going for with this deck Tekuthal, inquiry dominus
NV_1980 on What The Rocc(o) is Cooking
6 hours ago
Hi, this looks like a lot of fun to play! Did you know that Rosie Cotton of South Lane actually goes infinite with Scurry Oak and Herd Baloth?
DMFF on Hacked Paladins
9 hours ago
The fact that you can build this for like $35 without fetches and duals makes me very happy. +1
NonetheWeisser on Hoppin to YOUR DEMISE
10 hours ago
I was thinking about Hunters Talent as well! might have to test it.
FormOverFunction on Why Does Black No Longer …
10 hours ago
I’m still FAR more inclined to defer to the flavor of the card over color identity. Vampires taking control of other creatures by turning them into vampires is great, like Olivia Voldaren. I think the answer to the “off-brand” problem is making sure the flavor fits the color of the card you’re making. Honestly, having a white creature that gains “control of target creature attacking you” could fit the flavor of some kindly friar who “rehabilitates” a conscripted goblin during the raid. Feeds him, clothes him, and makes a friend. I would want some downsides, because it’s a strong effect; maybe the target creature deals its damage to the friar as he gains control of it. Maybe give the creature defender too, I dunno. Throw in some flavor text: “Friar So-and-so remained stoic as the goblin raged against the door, waiting for it to smell the food awaiting it outside.” I feel like it’s 100% fine… and this goes for all effects. I think this is how they currently handle things like flying, right? If they don’t want fliers, no problem, just don’t do it because the color isn’t allowed to have fliers.
Crimmeric on Krenko EDH
12 hours ago
If you use a card like Umbral Mantle you'd be able to untap Krenko and use it multiple times per turn and could use Skirk Prospector to fuel these.
Hornetsting86 on Cecil Mardu
13 hours ago
Basic hint of the game is you need plains & mountains to cast the cards such as fable the mirror breaker, ocelot pride ,seasoned pyromancer, etc. MY advice here is to reduce the number of swamps in the deck & add shock lands to the mix that are both swamp plains & Mountain. Try stone quarry,Bloodfell caves, even the basic plains & mountains are better. Otherwise your hand will be clogged up with cards you can't even cast.Right now it's only mardu because you have the white & red creature & a saga,but they can't be cast Nomad outpost is another good card to get the three mana combo for the sake of a turn that it's tapped,but it can count for the three mana you need
Blaster-master on Engineer Forge
15 hours ago
soldiers of rohan or something the exert one its mega chill
seshiro_of_the_orochi on Why Does Black No Longer …
16 hours ago
Looking at all the black cards that have the phrase "gain control", it's not as if black had a ton of this to begin with. There are 15 mono- cards that gain control of stuff on board. A number of these are vampire cards, which will probably still get it for flavour reasons. Most others are old and obscure, or gain control of stuff you gave away in the first place Flip. Or they are Herald of Leshrac, which is a weird card even for Coldsnap standards. So no big loss, and even then, it's still just MaRo who sad that.
August_Cross on "Noct, A Second Robot has …
17 hours ago
@SufferFromEDHD Excellent ideas! (Also a really funny username.)
Forbid seems great if you want to take the deck in a reanimator direction, where Forbid's buyback could get a creature out of your hand and into your graveyard. I chose the Counterspell just because I had one on hand, and if I was going to switch it out, I personally think I'd go for something that didn't have a second in its cost.
Hex Parasite also seems sick! Removing finality counters hasn't really been a huge concern for this particular build, mostly since I don't care too much about looping things in and out of the graveyard (except for the win-con). But, I think a card like that would absolutely shine in a Noctis build that wants to loop things constantly for value. Doing so might cost a lot of life between the and Noctis' ability, but you could build to compensate for that.
seshiro_of_the_orochi on Elephants... Used to go Stomp
18 hours ago
You're welcome! Btw, in case you want some more protection that's on theme, there's always Dauntless Escort.
ManWithManyFaces on Dragons Green Blue red
19 hours ago
If there and improvements you think I could add please send them.
Gwyrddu on Hoppin to YOUR DEMISE
22 hours ago
Good to hear that rabbits are that competitive. Even the Bloomborrow starter decks the rabbits usually wipe up the otters despite the two decks being designed to be equal power. With that said, my favorite tribal from the set has to be squirrels with their forage mechanic, hopefully we'll see more choices for all these tribals in the future. Maybe Hunter's Talent could work better than ram through since it sticks around and can eventually become a card draw engine.
Andramalech on Ballroom Blitz
23 hours ago
AlistarFiend seems like it would be fairly easy and fun to run! I'm glad you've had success. Thanks for the insight into the playstyle.
AlistarFiend on Ballroom Blitz
23 hours ago
Andramalech, I have have only played this deck twice. Once in a pod of three and once in a pod of four. Won both times! This deck works much better than I originally anticipated. Very fun to play and fairly easy to navigate.
Andramalech on Ballroom Blitz
23 hours ago
I love this construction. It's got power, it's got finesse. It's got that raunchy little snarl leaving the other 3 in Duress. +1, I'm impressed. Reminds me a lot of something another friend of mine is currently brewing. How have your matches gone? Do you use this in 1v1s or more of a pod setting?
Niffum on Felothar: Ya Other Brothers Cannot …
1 day ago
Maybe will proxy a Diamond Valley and Gaea's Cradle.
DemonDragonJ on Why Does Black No Longer …
1 day ago
In this post, Mark Rosewatwer stated that black shall no longer be able to steal permanents that are currently on the battlefield, and I am wondering why that is the case.
I presume that the reason for that change is because black can steal creatures from an opponent's graveyard, so it would be intruding on blue's territory if it could steal permanents that were currently on the battlefield, so what does everyone else say, about this subject? Why can black no longer steal permanents that are currently on the battlefield?
heartunderblade42 on Lulu, Queen of the Octopi
1 day ago
This is where I would put my untapped creatures, IF I HAD ONE!
Bliss266 on Quacked Out Ducks 6-22
1 day ago
Cards Removed (13): - Mountain x2 - Bident of Thassa - Brave the Elements - Crush Contraband - Divine Visitation - Favorable Winds - Fervor - Hammer of Purphoros - Intangible Virtue - Mentor of the Meek - Ogre Battledriver - Sphere of Safety - Stifle - Unbreakable Formation
Cards Added (13): - Dockside Extortionist - Exotic Orchard - Flooded Strand - Gitaxian Probe - Hallowed Fountain - Jeska's Will - Manamorphose - Mystic Remora - Rhystic Study - Scalding Tarn - Steam Vents - Treasure Cruise - Underworld Breach - - Island - - Plains
DemonDragonJ on Waste Not
1 day ago
I have replaced Decanter of Endless Water, Shared Summons, Baleful Strix, and Vorosh, the Hunter with Bloom Tender, Korozda Guildmage, Lotuslight Dancers, and Ruthless Deathfang, which reduced the average converted mana cost of this deck from 3.58 to 3.56, because the newer cards better fit the theme of this deck than did the older cards.
PrincessOfFriendship on Best Mono Red Burn Cards
1 day ago
Pulse of the Forge can be useful if playing against a lifegain deck. It deals 4 to your opponent then returns to your hand if they have more life then you.
Prixx on Deadpool - active
1 day ago
Changes - IN: City of Traitors, Sheoldred the Apocalypse, Party Thrasher. OUT: Reflecting Pool, Lightning Skelemental, Long Goodbye.
Reasons:
City over pool - I find Pool quite able to be akaward in todays landscape of DC, since it can happen you only have 1 other land on a 5-6 hand or 2 lands extra on a 7 hand where one or two depending on the hand size, are colorless or one colored, which gives yourself a soft lock, which could been prevented. Although City do not fix this issue, the upside of it being able to make a surprise deadpool turn three is devistating to certain decks.
Shelly over Skelemental - I tested Skelemental and seemed awaful, when your oppoenent were far ahead and did nothing against aggro decks, where shelly is great against aggro and makes certain matchups like Asuza, which can be akward a much better matchup.
Thraser over removeal - Thought had enough removeal in the deck, and seen a lot played thrasher and been against it where a phlage player used it and really like the card selection it can provide, plus it makes your own unearth and animate dead better, plus can increase the strength of the three goys I have in my list.
Prixx on Aragon, King of Gondor - …
1 day ago
Changes - IN: Voice of Victory. OUT: Abhorrent Oculus.
magwaaf on Why is Mark Rosewater so …
1 day ago
Upkeep* even when I fixed it I didn't realize it changed again lol
magwaaf on Why is Mark Rosewater so …
1 day ago
Because he's been at the job way too damn long and it's time for a change.
I want them to bring back up to you effects in standard sets
Barnie22 on Frog Goddess
1 day ago
Updates 22nd June 2025
Out: Sphinx of Magosi and Disciple of Freyalise Flip
In: Death's Presence and Stealth Mission
Infiro on Graha Tia - The Crystal …
1 day ago
This is a very slight modification of Scion and Spellcraft Pre-constructed deck to better suit Graha Tia's Scion Reborn and still stay within the realsm of FFXIV!
Polaris on Can negative counters from instances …
1 day ago
As a side note, Judith's best friend is Electrickery. Who says Izzet and Rakdos can't get along?
Polaris on Can negative counters from instances …
1 day ago
Well, yes, but actually no, for two different reasons.
Deathtouch and lifelink are just keywords, and Judith, Carnage Connoisseur can apply them to any spell, as the ability says. However, those keywords only apply when something deals damage.
First reason: Disfigure gives a creature -2/-2, and that's it. It does not put -1/-1 counters on the target, and it does not deal damage. Neither deathtouch nor lifelink will apply here.
Second reason: Even as a 1/1, your friend's indestructible creature cannot be destroyed. Since deathtouch has the effect of "whenever this deals damage to a creature, destroy that creature," indestructible nullifies it.
To deal with an indestructible creature, you generally need to exile it, reduce its toughness to 0 or less (at which point it will die without being destroyed), or force the opponent to sacrifice it. Something like Disfigure is usually ideal for the job—it just wasn't big enough in this case. Grasp of Darkness would have worked perfectly.
Usually, Judith, Carnage Connoisseur wants damage spells like Lightning Bolt for removal, though those will have issues with indestructible. On Disfigure, you'd just use the Imp mode of her ability.
seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge
1 day ago
So for anyone who didn't notice, we're getting a rules change for commander: Any legendary vehicle can be your commander now.
Ghaltratron, the Challenger
Legendary Artifact - Vehicle
Trample, Haste
As an additional cost to cast this spell, you may tap any number of creatures you control with power 6 or greater. If you do, Ghaltatron becomes a creature until end of turn as it enters.
Whenever one or more vehicles you control deal combat damage to a player, you may search your library for a land card or a vehicle card, reveal it, put it into your hand, and then shuffle.
Crew 8
12/12
Wild
Gidgetimer on Can negative counters from instances …
1 day ago
So, deathtouch and lifelink only apply to damage. Neither counters, nor temporary power/toughness reductions deal damage. They are therefore unaffected.
Also, for reference something only puts counters on a thing if the effect uses the word "counter". Black Sun's Zenith puts counters on creatures. Disfigure does not.