Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

AlistarFiend on Ballroom Blitz

4 minutes ago

alchemist4533, Thank you for the suggestion. I have added Felidar Retreat to the deck along with a few others that were in my maybe list that I finally got my hands on. I played it with these additions a few times and I am very happy with the the way it played!

ZorrosRage on Ninja Equip * Needs Help

2 hours ago

Nohx

I got it down 100. How's it look so far? I think it'll be a bracket 2 if it wasn't for yuriko being a GC

Epicurus on Card creation challenge

4 hours ago

Kitsune Deathspeaker

Creature - Fox Warlock

You may spend Black mana to cast this spell as though it were White

Protection from White and Black

Whenever a nontoken creature dies during a main phase, create a token copy of that creature. Sacrifice it at the beginning of the next main phase.

1/2


My attempt at making a single color identity spell that can be cast with multiple colors. And an Aristocrats nightmare.

Shadow the Hedgehog is a broken abomination. I hate it almost as much as I want one. Make a Secret Lair style Universes Beyond character of your choice into a card, and make it equally as broken as Shadow. Which is to say, it wouldn't get the ban hammer, but you know it totally should.

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

7 hours ago

Yesna, Rosethorn Archdruid

Legendary Creature - Elf Druid

Tap an untapped druid you control: Add , or

Tap three untapped druids you control: Mill three cards, then return up to one permanent card from your graveyard to your hand.

Tap nine untapped druids you control: Exile up to three target nonland permanents. For each permanent exiled this way, its controller may search their library for a basic land card, puts it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffles.

1/4


This feels very druidic. The first ability is a better Seton, Krosan Protector. The second and third ones are fitting flavourwise with Acolyte.


Create a kitsune warlock.

blodman1234 on deck

9 hours ago

heading text1x sailor of means

1x caller of gales 1x dire fleet hoarder 1x gutless plunderer 1x scroll thief 1x wind zendikon
1x Kukemssa pirates 1x warkite marauder 1x skyship plunderer 1x changeling outcast 1x deasdeye tracker 1x skyyship plunderer 1x gutless plunderer 1x deadeye quartermaster 1x wingspan 1x crafty cutpurse 1x gryff vanguard 1x reconnaissance mission 1x staunch crewmate 1x siren lookout 1x neurok invariance 1xt hieving otter 1x keen buccaneer 1x burnished hart 1x maze glider 1x siren storm tamer 1x oaken siren 1x fathom fleet cutthroat 1x bigfin bouncer 1xt timestream navigator 1x dreamcaller siren 1x howler's heavy 1x spectral sailor 1x dire fleet ravager 1x prosperous pirates 1x wormhole serpent 1x sky diamond 1x ghostly wings 1x charcoal diamond 35x land

GutterbonesMan on Force your opponents to shuffle

11 hours ago

Had the same idea with the same commander, never made it in paper though as my playground won’t let me haha

MLS91 on Deforestation Techniques

12 hours ago

DreadKhan

Phenomenal insight into Altar of the Brood totally overlooked that! As soon as I can stop by my LGS to pick up the copy I literally just traded in for credit, it will find its way back into the deck like it originally was.

As for Omen of Fire, I’m playing this deck in the cEDH community. The more I look at this card the more I do still want to play it but as we both I’m sure agree it is in fact very meta, but the only real thing holding me truly back at this point is that I’m running Dryad of the Ilysian Grove. Although it’s only a single copy I can’t risk bouncing my own lands. Looking back at Tectonic Break now and maybe even potentially Epicenter

Profet93 on The Man, the Myth, Legends

14 hours ago

KingL0nsur

what kind of suggestions r u looking for?

Madaraximundar on False Hope

15 hours ago

SufferFromEDHD,

Blighted is nice but only a one-time use and I lose the land in the process. Unless my token gen is exceptional at some point of the game, it's very much not worth it.

Inventor's Fair is passive yea but its condition of 3 or more artifacts puts it below the many free passive options I have now. Especially when I don't run that many artifacts.

Nomad is the same reasons as Blighted, and more. Its life cost to use it as land makes it counterproductive, and the threshold to sac it for life makes it only useful later on. If I have to wait on it, I don't want it.

I will however add those 2 lands though, those are nice. Thank you!

Coward_Token on Zug Zurg

16 hours ago

You're already on that track, but maybe more temporary copy makers?

Scryfall search

Balaam__ on Additional Charges May Apply

16 hours ago

Thanks slvstrChung, I actually really really like the artwork on Binding Agony. That one’s going in the maybeboard.

slvstrChung on Additional Charges May Apply

16 hours ago

I just found Binding Agony, in case you need more functional reprints.

Josephiav on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

17 hours ago

Silence is missing the secret lair promo Porom's Silence Magic

Mortlocke on Atraxa, infectious scream (Need help)

17 hours ago

Venum,

In regards to your manabase, you still haven't answered what your budget is looking like. A manabase tends to be the most expensive (and important) part of any EDH deck. Does your playgroup allow proxies?

Side tangent - the upcoming set Edge of Eternities has recently teased the return of shock lands. Shock Lands are some of, if not the best lands in modern magic. With this upcoming reprint they will be more accessible than ever so I highly recommend you get them their prices lower, namely: Watery Grave, Breeding Pool, Godless Shrine, Hallowed Fountainfoil, Overgrown Tombfoil and Temple Gardenfoil.

You slightly misunderstood what I meant when I asked about your meta. Do you use the bracket system that was introduced by Wizards? Using that to describe your deck (or the one you wish to build) will make this process go over much more smoothly. Seeing that your Meta includes the infamous likes of Najeela, the Blade-Blossom and Yuriko, the Tiger's Shadow you are facing some very strong commanders that would likely have decks that would place them in Bracket 4 (using the aforementioned bracket system as a reference). But, and a very big but here - it depends on what kind of decks these commanders helm. Do they have big expensive manabases with lots of (monetary) expensive interaction cards? e.g. Mana Drain, Force of Will, Mana Vault

It seems here that you have a misunderstanding of infinite combos. The aforementioned combo of Thassa's Oracle and Demonic Consultation are used almost exclusively in the alternate format known as Competitive EDH or cEDH. That is an essential combo for the format, and is expected to be part of a deck running . To you that may look like someone who just doesn't want to engage with other players - but to those who wield the combo in a game where other players are using similar strategies this is what everyone signed up for. Infinite combos are a staple of Magic and Commander. I understand that you are a person and you are absolutely entitled to your opinion. But please, have consistent logic here: Infinite Combos may be unpopular to some players, but for the love of Father Yawgmoth Poison is a FAR less popular mechanic in Commander.

Not saying you shouldn't use it - I for one embrace it. But using Poison will give you a distinct political disadvantage at just about every single table you show up to. Once the other players know, they will more than likely work together to tear apart your boardstate and shove you off the table.

Venum on Atraxa, infectious scream (Need help)

18 hours ago

Mortlocke you are right, there are some missing piece to my description...

I am looking to upgrade the mana base to get more consistently access the GWBU. I am open to MDFC, but i do not have the habit or the knowledge for them yet.

As for the Meta, I just want to get the poison counter up as fast as possible and proliferate to finish it up. I usually go up against really fast deck and hated commander such as Yuriko or Najeela.

Concerning the infinite combo, i mostly mean a win-con such as Thassa's oracle & Demonic consultation kinda infinite-combo. I see it as winning the game without playing you deck how it's intended for a Win, which is by poison counter.

LunchBox1211 on Card creation challenge

18 hours ago

(I forgot to add "this turn" to my card. Woops.)

SufferFromEDHD on God's Wrath Has a Barrel …

18 hours ago

You and I went different directions but there's still some overlap in cards and strategy. I see dat Power Matrix! (Pet card of mine. The 1st "equipment")

You have some Indestructible where I really leaned into it since has so much. I also have a few creatures with Flash to play around the Wrath of God on a stick.

The only thing I'm going to individually suggest is discard fodder since spell shapers so desperately need Squee, Goblin Nabobfoil.

Glory going to be bold and suggest cutting Mother of Runes

Soul of New Phyrexia that indestructible I mentioned earlier

Sevinne's Reclamation/Prismatic Strands efficient flashback tricks

Containment Construct fixes the drawback

Eternal Dragon for the long game :)

LunchBox1211 on Card creation challenge

18 hours ago

Righteous Valor

Sorcery

Target creature you control with a +1/+1 counter on it deals damage equal to its power to any target. Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt to that creature.


OK, so I was looking a copy of Rosethorn Acolyte that I have, and I can't get over how much the red eyes stand out against the rest of the piece. That, plus the flavor text, made me think about what "Rosethorn" is. But the existence of Acolytes implies that it is some sort of druidic circle, and the existence of members of greater power. Make a Legendary Elf that is some sort of Rosethorn Archdruid.

Trogattz on Zug Zurg

19 hours ago

Smashing around with warrior who want to kill themselves

Mortlocke on Atraxa, infectious scream (Need help)

20 hours ago

It appears you are in need of some help with your manabase, well what would helpful is your budget. How much are you looking to spend, and what exactly is your goal? Do you want more functionality? (e.g. Modal Double Faced Cards (MDFC) more consistent access to GWBU? Do you tend to lean toward one color?

You say you're open to making your deck bracket 4, so I must ask - what is your meta? What kind of decks do you want this to go up against? Are you committed to bracket 4? It can be expensive if you don't want to proxy. What is your vision for this deck?

I understand not wanting to run Infinite combos if it's not part of your vision, but I do take slight umbrage with the attitude of "not playing the game to actually play" when using an infinite combo to close the game. I think that take is very strange coming from someone who wishes to run Poison counters ala Toxic/Infect.

Coward_Token on shadow the hedgehog edh

20 hours ago

Tombstone Stairwell, basically Grim Flowering with Shadow on the end of each turn

DemonDragonJ on Death and Rebirth

21 hours ago

I have replaced Nezumi Bone-Reader with Korozda Guildmage, since the latter creature is a better match for the themes of this deck.

DemonDragonJ on Grim Feaster and Orzhov Pallbearers

21 hours ago

wallisface, no, your response is not harsh, but I was erring on the side of caution, since I believe that some creatures today are simply far too powerful (with Elder Gargaroth, Baneslayer Angel, or Phyrexian Obliterator being some key examples, and I shall think of more, later), so I can certianly modify both of these creatures, if you believe that that would improve them.

DreadKhan on Tsabo Tavoc Havoc

23 hours ago

Cool card! I agree it's probably not as good in most decks as Brawler, but that doesn't mean it's not a fine card in it's own right, costing only 3 is a real upside! I have multiple decks that might like it!

The drop rate of new cards has become unhelpful, even someone with a fair bit of time to invest in a hobby (me for example) can't really see everything new, so thanks for pointing Revenant out!

I'm not sure if I mentioned it, but Brash Taunter is bloody hilarious with Scavenged Brawler or Qarsi Revenant, Brawler gives you a beefy aggro blocker that can beat stuff to death, Revenant lets you ping anything to death, and both give the Taunter the key lifelink ability, very useful when he fights the biggest things on the board. The funniest part about using this is that the base creature is indestructible, and you're not equipping/aura-ing him, so some colours have almost no way to answer Taunter once it's resolved.

Epicurus on Card creation challenge

1 day ago

Try to keep it to an Oracle text wording. For example, you wouldn't say "whenever any creature you control...", because Oracle text would actually read either "whenever a creature you control," or "whenever one or more creatures you control," or "whenever at least one creature you control."

In all of these instances, it wouldn't be a proper use of the word "any" in respect to the Oracle text.

Epicurus on Card creation challenge

1 day ago

Ifflbvrrt, Deceptive Coercionist

Legendary Creature - Homunculus

Whenever you cast this spell, each player discards their hand, then each opponent draws 3 cards

When ~ enters, if it wasn't cast, put it on top of its owner's library

: Draw cards equal to the number of cards in each opponent's hand, then shuffle ~ into it's owner's library

~ can't be your commander

1/1


Snuck the wandering homunculus into a wildcard situation!

(The OG thread crew will understand)

Make a Sorcery with the words "any," "combat" and "with" in the rules text.

46546785267 on making it difficult

1 day ago

Have you considered Argentum Armor? (Don’y know how to link it sorry), the price to play and equip it is high but i think for Ultima its worth it, the stat buff makes him capable of getting someone to 20 commander damage in 2 hits rather then 5 while the destruction can help disrupt your opponents board state or compound Ultima’s blighting by destroying their unblighted lands.

Hylandia on shadow the hedgehog edh

1 day ago

Shadow deck yayyyyy

Can I yoink this once you have a full deck I need a Shadow deck so badly after the annoucement :3

Brinckenberger on Muldrotha Value

1 day ago

Dropped Siren Stormtamer, added Dryad of the Il Grove.

LycanoftheDarknessFlame on Rakdos Wizards

1 day ago

I am interested in a wizard deck. have you tested the queen or going grixis for vivi?

LunchBox1211 on Card creation challenge

1 day ago

Goldnight Scriptures

Artifact

At the beginning of your Upkeep and whenever a creature you control deals combat damage to a player, put a Page Counter on ~. If there are 5 or more Page Counters on it, creatures you control gain Vigilance. If there are 7 or more on it, they gain First Strike. If there are 10 or more counters on it, they get +2/+1.

Before Avacyn came to her aid, Gisela wrote a code for her followers. Decades after Goldnight was a memory, Sigarda discovered them.


Wild

Moondrop on Volo, guide to monsters and …

1 day ago

thank you that clarifies things and you did a good job of explaining it( better then I did)