Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

vic on Ulalek, Fused Atrocity (upcoming MH3 …

12 minutes ago

EquivocalVision Okay, I thought you meant just the pic in the actual picture box portion. I got it now.

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

20 minutes ago

Calamity's Impact

Instant

As an additional cost to cast this spell, reveal a giant card from your hand.

Choose one. If the revealed card's manavalue was 7 or greater, choose one or both instead:

  • ~ Deals X damage to each non-giant creature, where X is the revealed card's mana value.

  • Draw X cards, where X is the revealed card's mana value.


I'm currently really enjoying my giant EDH. That card would be a blast in there.


Create a mono- mythic rare wolf creature.

MrSilk on Squirrels, Squirrels, Squirrels! (Squirrel Prison)

38 minutes ago

DatShepTho Not a bad suggestion, its just with Dowsing Shaman I can keep bringing stuff back whereas Eternal Witness only does it when it play it. Shaman brings back only enchantments, but in reality, its only the enchantments we need to win with here. I dont think itd be the end of the deck to use witness instead of shaman though.

Elgravo on Martyr Life

48 minutes ago

Hi tchau204, thank you for your suggestion. Martyr of Sands is just too important to give up on her: when in the starting hand, she really speeds up the deck and makes things easy, letting Righteous Valkyrie give +2/+2 to all the creatures and Speaker of Heavens spam Angels from the get-go. Ajani’s Pridemate, which I’d played for years in the past, is just a worse version of Voice of the Blessed. In the future, I may shift towards a completely Souls Sisters-based strategy, and then I would reconsider Ajani’s Pridemate and cut Martyr of Sands. I may as well get to a totally Martyr of Sands-based strategy, and I would even cut Voice of the Blessed in that scenario. Modern Horizons 3 could already be a nice crossroad. For now, the list features the cards that I feel to be more capable of making the difference, and Ajani’s Pridemate just isn’t among them

K4nkato on Killing the Same Goblin Infinite …

1 hour ago

Weekly Results:

UW Affinity:❌❌

Tortex:✅❌❌

RB Artifact Sac:✅✅

Bad First Day Of Class draws. Maybe I should mull for them more often iunno :p

tchau204 on Martyr Life

2 hours ago

Ajani's Pridemate? Possibly a good replacement for Martyr of Sands -- more threats the better?

Profet93 on Empress Stealina

3 hours ago

SufferFromEDHD +1

Will try to provide feedback later.

Profet93 on Tsabo Tavoc Havoc

3 hours ago

SufferFromEDHD +1

Do you feel you have enough ramp? Your commander costs 7, 2 colored mana + tap for activated ability. No haste to even use it. I actually love your commander, I just wonder how often you get to use him.

Jeska's Will - Draw/Ramp

Spreading Plague - Could be super fun....could backfire.

Command Beacon/Volrath's Stronghold - Recur expensive commander

Crystal Chimes - Recur 25% of your deck

Why run gamble over an omni tutor, low cost?

Thaumatic Compass  Flip - Could be too slow, but ensuring basics could be nice. The land transformation works with your defense theme.

No Mercy > Sunstone? - Or do you need the lack of damage?

How has heartless summoning been working for you? You only run 2 creatures, why not just run a Jet Medallion instead? Easier to cast, affects all black spells rather than just 2 cards. Is an artifact so it might be more susceptible to removal but the benefits far outweigh the costs IMO.

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

3 hours ago

Yindri, God of Fables

The artwork was borrowed from the real MTG card Inspiring Bard

Femme_Fatale on OTJ draft

3 hours ago

Inter-set pack allocation is definitely a very difficult thing that we aren't going to be doing for a while sadly. Especially what with "The list" and SPG and all that.

Crow_Umbra on List of Bugs and Feature …

4 hours ago

Thank you for following up Femme_Fatale. Everything from OTJ/OTC/BIG looks like it's showing up as legal now.

Femme_Fatale on List of Bugs and Feature …

4 hours ago

Crow_Umbra: still bugged?

Crow_Umbra on Petrified by the Gorgussy [Primer]

6 hours ago

Hello once again ShadowTheMonk. Thanks for stopping by again

Vulmathrax on Operation Desert Storm

6 hours ago

Sandy cheeks lookin ahhh

EquivocalVision on Ulalek, Fused Atrocity (upcoming MH3 …

6 hours ago

vic no. That's just the ability the card has. I can rename that. Sorry. I tried to used tapped out's custom card thing, but I'd didn't work, so I adapted it. It's just the commander's ability. The card I have set as the commander is a substitute until the Eldrazi Commander officially releases.

vic on Ulalek, Fused Atrocity (upcoming MH3 …

7 hours ago

I'm confused about the "Rules Text" part. Is it going to be a subset of rules specifically for some kind of Eldrazi Commander game? Because I don't see of that on the card or anything.

ShadowTheMonk on Petrified by the Gorgussy [Primer]

7 hours ago

Saw you on the front page again wanted to say hi

MTGFan3000 on Abuse, Murder, and Exploitation

7 hours ago

lands? also only 9 of all the cards are nonlegendary

Profet93 on Thrun Voltron-His Silence is Violence

7 hours ago

MysticSnake, thank you for your patience. Since you didn't mention budget, I just put what I thought could work regardless of price point. You should add some non-basics to provide utility, also, add maybe 1-2 more lands just to ensure you don't miss land drops.

Rishkar's Expertise - Draw, either as a replacement or in addition to soul's majesty. Same with Garruk, Primal Hunter

Nylea's Colossus - Big Guy

Bear Umbra - Works well since they can't 2 for 1 u in response to cast. Nice buff and the "ramp" aspect is good, all while being an enchantment

Song of the Dryads - Removal!

Nyxbloom Ancient - Supe ramp!

Herald of the Pantheon/Cloud Key - Ramp

Season of Renewal - Recursion

Composer of Spring and Weaver of Harmony - Potentially worth considering

Rofellos's Gift - I actually don't like this card but worth mentioning.

Creeping Renaissance - Crystal chimes #2 but can be used twice and is more flexible

Overgrowth - Ramp

Sylvan Library - Draw/utility

Greater Good - Draw that is also a sac outlet to prevent theft and exile.

TCK_Green on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

8 hours ago

Recon Craft Theta is showing up in my deck with the Creature type rather than an Artifact.

(Interestingly it appears in the right place during deck-test for an Artifact so not sure what's up with it!)

EquivocalVision on Ulalek, Fused Atrocity (upcoming MH3 …

8 hours ago

Formless0209 today there was a leak releasing information about the upcoming Eldrazi commander deck set to release in Modern Horizons 3. I have decided to get a jump on things and start building a deck in anticipation.

Case42 on Treasure for Nothin' and Constructs …

8 hours ago

hydrothermia Ojer Taq is great in token decks for sure, however it only triples creature tokens and the deck is mostly focused on Treasure.

I tried it out a few times in the past and ended up cutting the card because of its high cost and low reward in Treasure Matters.

Profet93 on My 3-headed baby girl

9 hours ago

austintayshus

Tokens are outside my wheelhouse, but I'll do my best to help. Also, I see you run the Emeria Shepherd + Sakura Tribe elder synergy, nice!

Shamanic Revelation - Draw with a side of lifegain

Alhammarret's Archive - Double lifegain, double draw!

Harmonize - Simple draw

Elemental Bond - Steady draw

Skullclamp - You run a decent amount of mana dorks.

Reliquary Tower - Maybe not needed yet but once you add more card draw, it should definitely be considered. Currently, Creeping Renaissance could warrant this inclusion.

Greater Good - Such a good card for draw. Also helps prevent exile and theft tactics.

Momentous Fall - Used in response to removal. Beware of the blue player! Also note Life's Legacy.

I understand that tokens are secondary, but have you considered at least adding one token doubler card such as Doubling Season? Not necessarily doubling season itself given the price constraint but any one of it's close cousins can fit the bill.

Winding Canyons/Emergence Zone - Flash would help primarily with Felidar Sovereign, Sunblast Angel and combat tricks. It also helps you from over-extending your board

Castle Garenbrig - Ramp

xadrus1799 on Mono black scam rack

9 hours ago

Please fucking stop playing like a snail in mtg arena.

36hammond on Dopplegangbangers - Historic Flash Convoke …

9 hours ago

Wow, I love this deck! I’m building a Sixth Doctor//Peri Brown deck on paper and this is very helpful.

I’m pretty new to magic but I thought Clara Oswald wouldn’t be able to trigger the doc an additional time because the doctor states his ability can only trigger once per turn. And Strionic Resonator works because it is actually copying the ability.

Let me know what you think!

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

11 hours ago

Yindri, God of Fables

Legendary Creature - Bard God

Indestructible

Whenever you finish a fable, create three treasure tokens, scry 2 and draw a card. You may then discard a card. If you do, destroy target nonland permanent with equal or less mana value. (To finish a fable, cast both halves of a spell that has Adventure, complete a Dungeon, or complete a Saga from its first lore counter.)

5/5


:)

Wild

Tsukimi on Card creation challenge

11 hours ago

Issekai, Story's Thread

Legendary Creature - Shapeshifter Spirit

Flying, Ward

You may have Issekai, Story's Thread enter the battlefield as a copy of any creature, except it has "token copies of this creature are non legendary" and "At the beginning of your upkeep, create a token that is a copy of this creature."

0/0


I love clones, I love token copies, and I would absolutely use this card in a few different decks. Repeat!

Rhadamanthus on Tetsuko Umezawa and Prosthetic Injector

11 hours ago

You're right, Tetsuko's ability would no longer apply. If something refers to a creature's power or toughness and doesn't specifically say "base power" or "base toughness" then it's talking about the creature's total power/toughness including any modifiers.

Naikkelisnaaz on Niko lindvall

12 hours ago

This is my tryout for halfling deck.

markbeloit on Card creation challenge

13 hours ago

Sun Container

When Sun Container enters the battlefield, draw a card.

Sacrifice Sun Container: Add two mana in any combination of colors. You cannot activate this ability if Sun Container entered the battlefield this turn.


Wild.

Goldberserkerdragon on Yisan, Guitar Hero

14 hours ago

milohenry13 Great taste in flavor, my guy! That old Genesis brought me to tears. Thank you.

hydrothermia on Treasure for Nothin' and Constructs …

14 hours ago

Ojer Taq, Deepest Foundation  Flip would give you three times as many tokens on top of using Anointed Procession and Mondrak, Glory Dominus, so in theory you can get 7 tokens off of one token. Only issue I see is that you're unlikely to attack(Though cannon fodder 1/1's would do the trick.) with 3 or more creatures to turn Temple of Civilization back over to Ojer Taq when and if he dies.

Crow_Umbra on Countdown to Infinity (Counters Primer)

14 hours ago

Great mana curve! I love a great curve like that lol.

The tough thing with +1/+1 Counters strats is that there's always so many good options to choose from; some a bit more meta dependent & narrow than others for sure. A few ideas for potential considerations:

  • Ripples of Potential - Board protection & proliferation, but def the priciest of the recommendations

  • Mutational Advantage - A more narrow Heroic Intervention that can also proliferate.

  • Ravenous Slime - I've played this in a few counters decks, especially since I play in a meta with a decent frequency of Aristocrats & Reanimator decks. Def a more meta dependent option, but one that can get huge pretty quick.

  • Wave Goodbye - Should be fairly asymmetrical most of the time.

dnthymamai on Urza's Iron Alliance

15 hours ago

Nice artifact deck!

I would suggest you think about some of these cards:


  • Super winning condition: Masterful Replication! Its second mode can turn all your artifacts (pesky 1/1 fliers and artifact lands included) into your best creature. That can be a Construct that Urza makes (or Bronze Guardian, etc). This way all of your "useless" artifacts can turn into death machines of extreme power or double strike. Plus, you can also save your whole board when the enemy casts Wrath of God by turning every one of your creatures into a Darksteel Citadel if you are lucky to have it on board.

Last_Laugh on Why is my squirrel deck …

15 hours ago

Because a squirrel is gonna get a nut? Ergo squirrels are NSFW.

SomeDipshit on Shanghai Dawn - Obeka, Splitter …

16 hours ago

You can probably eat it!

You get to stack the triggers so you do n - 1 sacs each upkeep, so let it grow to 3 - 4 and leave it out for a turn or two, then sac it to its own first trigger on the turn you are ready to dump it.

pair with something that makes tokens during your upkeep and its pretty sustainable

9-lives on Tetsuko Umezawa and Prosthetic Injector

16 hours ago

If I use Prosthetic Injector and I put it on a card to where it has more than 1 toughness, and that's the only attribute at 1, would that negate Tetsuko Umezawa, Fugitive's ability to give it unblockable?

moo1234 on Card creation challenge

16 hours ago

rainbow

Land - Rainbow

Rainbow enters the battlefield tapped unless you control a green creature

: add one mana of any colour

"I will not rest till i have me gold"


repeat

Motolinsky on EDH Merens Reanimator

1 day ago

Thank you guys! Very interesting and progressive advises! Thx very much :)

Prodless on Ulala

1 day ago

Hey, this is a comment tutorial