|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|Guilds of Ravnica (GRN)||Uncommon|
Combos Browse all
Creature — Spirit
Whenever you surveil, put a +1/+1 counter on Thoughtbound Phantasm.
As long as Thoughtbound Phantasm has three or more +1/+1 counters on it, it can attack as though it didn't have defender.
|Have (31)||ironax , sneferie , stephen1212 , SpottedGee , Pelli , Mousemke , jstn.mrrtt , Shiromakuro , marcus638 , Riders_of_Brohan , vashaclarens , mziter501 , Wolfninja , SirFowler , Slowbro23 , saj0219 , Lander , Schuesseled , sonnet666 , infernalbubblez , conker3009 , bakeraj4 , Mortiferus_Rosa , dbregman8585 , bradyofportdetroit , Tiddilywinkus , YossarianLives , Kimimaro , Antiat , ChainerDragon65 , joshw335|
|Want (43)||Daeyel , smaps , DeifiedExile , 1337_Nerd , GarethGrey , yerfdog1935 , Luftwaffle , Kleptozaniac , nealcm , scouts2nd , P13 , PRO-AUGMANDOO , Dk1997 , Cambro6587 , volcomstone2892 , chain_letter , tornadomkii , Awuztein , TerminalGeek , Rasp , aire86 , Travkier , olivebagel , l13199l , jkicker1 , vovoomz137 , snowmaster55555atgmaildotcom , nullwraith , lmsmq , kovellen , guntermench , toocoolrad , egh9cu , mcstew , Etello , Genres , Slivortal , Dimensquare , YaslerFuj , correcthorsebatterystaple , JOKU420 , Therrion , ImmortalCancer|
Thoughtbound Phantasm Discussion
1 month ago
Merits testing, but I'm not sure Thoughtbound Phantasm has enough Surveil support to enable it to attack reliably in most games. Seems fine as an early blocker, though. Is that what you were going for with this card?
1 month ago
I'd probably take out Memorial to Genius and Sorcerous Spyglass. Search for Azcanta Flip flipped is better than MtG i think, and Unmoored Ego just does Spyglass's job better. I'm also not sure about Deadeye Tracker, I would probably sub that out for Sentinel Totem if you want to exile graveyards or something like Hostage Taker or more Doom Whisperer or even Thoughtbound Phantasm if you need early game board presence.
2 months ago
I usually really dislike mill deck in standard right now but this seems pretty nice !
If you're really in need of something against mono-Red, Golden Demise might do the trick ? Or also Moment of Craving, it's really painfull to deal with ( I'm playing mostly mono-Red and I hate this one ).
Else, I would feel a bit safer with more creature but I don't know what to cut for them. They would be more Thief of Sanity or Thoughtbound Phantasm. If you go for the Phantasm, you could try to get a bit more surveil card, it will also help the Disinformation Campaign on the way.
Good luck !
2 months ago
I think I'd get rid of one or both of the Dimir Guildmages depending on how much you like the card (the ability is a bit expensive for what you get in my opinion). If you like the dual utility of Dimir Guildmage you could also consider swapping it for House Guildmage which I think is a tad better unless you're really hurting for draw abilities. Same with Dinrova Horror, while flavorful 6 cmc for a 4/4 with bounce seems a bit much when you have a good number of counters, removal, or things like Unexplained Disappearance. Of surveil cards, Nightveil Sprite can give you some great mileage out of just one card. As far as Dimir Spybug and Thoughtbound Phantasm, you'll have to make the call if you think its worth it for just one copy of each. From experience playing a Dimir deck I drafted with lots of surveil but only one of each those creatures, they're amazing when you draw them, but also often I had games where I didn't draw them. Or they got immediately removed. Surveil helps filter your deck to get to them faster, so 2 of each would probably make it much better. Up to you.
You could probably replace Dimir Charm with one of the cards I mentioned that you like, since I think the best ability on the charm is usually going to be the counter, followed by the removal, and you have a fair number of counters and some removal already.
Unmoored Ego is cool but if your friends/playgroup are also playing "guild kit" style with few duplicates, then it probably wouldn't make much sense in the deck, unless you have that one pesky friend that's always rocking 3-4x of a particularly annoying card that you need to nip at the bud.
Whispering Snitch and Enhanced Surveillance are also fun if you feel like you're surveiling enough to make it worth it. Though one could also say, if you're surveilling a lot then Enhanced Surveillance is a bit unnecessary overkill.
Also keep in mind, I don't think Whispering Madness would be nearly as useful without something like Notion Thief, outside of a scenario where you only have a couple cards and your opponent/s have a full hand. If the scenario is reversed, you'll only be helping them out. However, with Notion Thief it basically becomes a reusable "opponent discards hand, you discard and redraw a full hand" or some such.
Kinda hard for me to answer specifically "replace A B C with X Y Z" since a deck with few duplicates is generally less consistent in the direction it's trying to go. Some fun cards here though for you to consider.
Oh by the way, I didn't realize this at first so I'll throw this in here in case you didn't already know, but you can bounce Etrata back to your hand after damage to get her whole "hit counter exile" wincon thing and avoid reshuffling her ;)
2 months ago
Not much surveil for a Dimir deck, given it's their signature. If you want to go more with the surveil theme I'd highly recommend Dimir Spybug, Thoughtbound Phantasm, and Nightveil Sprite. If you're open to Dimir cards from past Ravnica sets, there's a bunch of cool ones all with the transmute ability (Dimir's old signature ability) like Perplex and Dimir Infiltrator (not the best examples maybe), and others like Notion Thief, Psychic Drain. I could go on and on, Dimir was always my favorite.
2 months ago
@pbowen331, I'd say "Welcome to Tapped Out," but you've been here longer than I have.
Etrata can work, but only on non-token creatures, since exiling a token makes them nonexistent. You'll need to work on finding another form of winning condition if the first option isn't possible. I also notice that this is very budgety, is that deliberate?
I'll try to suggest things around that if possible, but I'll will suggest some pricer cards as well. I also don't know how heavy you want to go into Surveil. While I'm not going to name all of them, just the ones that seem useful.
- Useful cards would be Duress, Unmoored Ego, Plaguecrafter / Ravenous Chupacabra and Midnight Reaper to name a few.
- Better suited lands would Watery Grave or Drowned Catacomb.
- Cards that take advantage of Surveil: Blood Operative, Disinformation Campaign, Thoughtbound Phantasm, Whispering Snitch and Dimir Spybug.
- Cards that have the Surveil mechanic: Unexplained Disappearance, Price of Fame, Barrier of Bones, Sinister Sabotage, Doom Whisperer, Notion Rain, Dream Eater, Nightveil Sprite, Mission Briefing, Discovery / Dispersal and Connive / Concoct.
Hopefully that gave you some additional insight on improving your deck.
2 months ago
Good Morning captainamerica,
I'm not sure I follow the core concept for this deck. So my apologies if you have already fielded this question, or another like it. You call this an aggro deck, however, it is more "reactive" (like a control deck) than "proactive" (like an aggro deck). I only say that because you are running a total of 7 creatures in the main board. I understand your budget constraints, and would like to recommend a budget Dimir Surveil Aggro list to you for consideration.
4 Thoughtbound Phantasm 11 Island 4 Nightveil Sprite 3 Dimir Informant 4 Dimir Spybug 8 Swamp 3 Discovery / Dispersal 4 Thought Erasure 4 Notion Rain 4 Drowned Catacomb instead you could run 4 Dimir Guildgate 3 Sinister Sabotage 3 Cast Down 2 Barrier of Bones 3 Disinformation Campaign
This list would be a little more aggro. I hope this helps.
3 months ago
Lightning Strike, Shock, Lava Coil, and Shivan Fire aren’t needed and frankly I don’t get why anyone would want these in a Control deck. If you really must play a 3rd color black has better options, but anyway. These all can be replaced with bounce spells such as Blink of an Eye, more counterspells and/or if not already in the deck, Opt. As for more cheap removal, There is Baffling End to get rid of more early plays and some decks may be able to make Isolate work for any pesky one drops. Also a great early blocker is Shore Keeper it can keep early Aggro decks at bay for a time if it is not removed immediately and can generate card advantage late game. Thoughtbound Phantasm could also work if running lots of surveil.
Thoughtbound Phantasm occurrence in decks from the last year
All decks: 0.05%