, , Discard your hand: Counter target noncreature spell.
Printings View all
Combos Browse all
|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Null Brooch occurrence in decks from the last year
Commander / EDH:
All decks: 0.0%
Null Brooch Discussion
1 week ago
Cool deck! You might like these: Reveillark, Nim Deathmantle, Palace Jailer, Fanatical Devotion, Bottled Cloister, Tome of Legends, Erratic Portal, Eldrazi Displacer, Magewright's Stone, Village Bell-Ringer, Adarkar Valkyrie, Lapse of Certainty, Null Brooch
2 weeks ago
These might interest you too: Lotus Petal, Salvaging Station, Lion's Eye Diamond (infinite mana with Salvaging Station and Karn), Dross Scorpion, Cauldron of Souls, Scrapyard Recombiner (finds all kinds of dudes including Metalworker and Voltaic Construct (thanks errata!)), Meteor Golem, Scour from Existence, Null Brooch, Warping Wail (surprisingly versatile. at worst it can be used as a delayed ritual to get Karn out a turn sooner), Empowered Autogenerator, Umbral Mantle, Mirrorpool, Endbringer
2 weeks ago
With my commander discarding stuff I wonder if colorless reanimation is enough of a thing? I've got a few pieces... I'll try and find room for some more...
Sword of Light and Shadow, Workshop Assistant, Scrap Trawler, Myr Retriever, Metalwork Colossus, Junk Diver, Conqueror's Galleon Flip, and Trading Post are all possibilities. Returning to hand is actually perfect for the commander's ability. Of course an empty hand is also good (luls) so maybe Null Brooch?
6 months ago
What I noticed is there is an issue with being vulnerable to control/removal strategies, as it is hard to protect your big creatures once you get one out. I mean, it's great to get a 9/9 annihilator 3 out on turn 2 or 3, but an Innocent Blood can drop it just as fast. I think you are very set however vs decks that don't have a way to immediately deal with your eldrazi, including a deck that just didn't draw any removal, or used it up already.
I wonder if you might get a tad of stability from using Null Brooch to protect your big bad once they are on the field. I mean, who cares what you've got in hand if you can otherwise attack with an annihilator creature, right? It's a bit slow to set up, so maybe throw in 4 Dark Rituals too? I dunno, just a crazy idea.
8 months ago
+1 from me I love my Daretti runs Purphoros's Forge!
9 months ago
Thank you for your thoughts!
I've been tinkering with this list as I continue to test and play more EDH games. Here are further observations I've made and card options I've considered to replace those that have underperformed.
I've tried Blast Zone for several games now, and it's been difficult to use to say the least. The card tends to be slow because you have to invest mana to increase charge counters, then you have to tap the turn after to destroy whatever you need to. It's been difficult justifying tutoring for Blast Zone with Expedition Map, and I haven't found it productive to use the ability in any of my games. Maybe I'm just unlucky, but thus far I'd almost rather play a Wastes in its place.
I haven't missed Haunted Cloak at all. I probably wouldn't swap Tormod's Crypt , there are tons of games where it's dead but I consider it an important tool against too many other decks for it to be worth removing. Sometimes, it's the only reason why I won at all. It still activates Paradox Engine , helps with Inspiring Statuary , etc.
I find it difficult to justify Karn, the Great Creator considering that this deck doesn't have many ways of protecting the dude. I already assume that whenever I cast Karn Liberated or Ugin, the Ineffable (both of which are incredible btw) they're going to die immediately. Expensive removal spells essentially. Perhaps I'm narrow-minded though, if you have better experiences with him I'd love to hear them!
A few cards I've been trying lately are Unstable Obelisk , Crawlspace , and the Grafdigger's Cage mentioned earlier. I consider those to be the safer cards to test, though I've also considered more splashy effects in their place like Null Brooch , Ring of Three Wishes , and Planar Bridge .
Null Brooch is the craziest of them all I think. The ability interests me as one of the few ways to interact with spells/combos, and the theory is that the drawback of discarding your hand can be negated by the numerous draw options present (including the commander). Whether the tradeoff is worthwhile remains to be seen, I haven't tried it yet but I will. Ring and Bridge are just expensive and I'm dubious as to if they're really necessary. One benefit I can see to Planar Bridge is that it can serve as Ugin, the Spirit Dragon #2, which is a card I tend to look for in most of my games.
Finally, Stony Silence is so crippling lmao, I've lost to it so many times. It makes me wonder if there are tools that can be played to alleviate that, whether it be circumventing the ability through Inspiring Statuary , not involve activating abilities or removing it altogether (two of Ugin, the Ineffable 's abilities)
11 months ago
Silent Arbiter is definitely worth considering to avoid being swarmed ( Crawlspace will be coming in to do a similar job) and Null Brooch seems like a great way to get value out of and empty hand. Probably going to pass on Geode Golem though: while I can see the value for colour-intensive or expensive commanders (e.g. The Ur-Dragon ), he does next to nothing here. Even if he gets out and hits you still have to pay the commander tax, and if I'm at the point in the game where I've already cast Karn twice but can't make as much colourless mana as I need then things have Gone Wrong. At the end of the day he's a 5/3 for five with a limited, linear ability and that just isn't enough for EDH.