Combos Browse all Suggest
Legality
| Format | Legality |
| 1v1 Commander | Legal |
| Archenemy | Legal |
| Big Apple Highlander | Legal |
| Block Constructed | Legal |
| Canadian Highlander | Legal |
| Casual | Legal |
| Commander / EDH | Legal |
| Commander: Rule 0 | Legal |
| Custom | Legal |
| Duel Commander | Legal |
| Freeform | Legal |
| Highlander | Legal |
| Legacy | Legal |
| Leviathan | Legal |
| Limited | Legal |
| Oathbreaker | Legal |
| Oldschool 93/94 | Legal |
| Planar Constructed | Legal |
| Planechase | Legal |
| PreDH | Legal |
| Premodern | Legal |
| Quest Magic | Legal |
| Vanguard | Legal |
| Vintage | Legal |
Rules Q&A
Titania's Song
Enchantment
Each noncreature artifact loses all abilities and becomes an artifact creature with power and toughness each equal to its converted mana cost. If Titania's Song leaves the battlefield, this effect continues until end of turn.
Rhadamanthus on I have Titania's Song out, …
8 months ago
In both cases Sol Ring will be a 2/2 with its own abilities plus haste given by earthbending.
Normally when multiple effects would modify an object's characteristics, they get applied in timestamp order. But if one of the effects would impact what the other effect would do to the object or whether it would apply at all, then the other effect is said to be "dependent" on the first one, which is said to be "independent" of the second. The independent effect is always applied first, then the dependent one, if it even still applies. In this case, the fact that Titania's Song only affects noncreature artifacts makes it dependent on earthbending.
This one was tricky. I had a whole different response typed out before I realized right at the end what was really important.
bhst5019 on I have Titania's Song out, …
8 months ago
So Titania's Song, makes a non-creature artifact lose its abililty and makes it into a creature with a power and toughness equal to its mana cost. If I have it out with Toph, the First Metalbender and Sol Ring and proceed to cast another creature with earthbending 2 targeting the Sol Ring, what happens? Is the Sol Ring a 2/2 with no abilites? Or does it have its tap abilities and a 2/2?
If instead I cast the 2 cards in reverse order? I assume I have Toph, the First Metalbender out - Play the earthbender 2 targeting my sol ring then cast Titania's Song. I assume the Sol Ring would it be a 2/2 with its abilites.
Thanks
artcwolf22 on Share your hidden gems
1 year ago
I love older cards that still have niche relevance.
-
Order of the Sacred Torch is something I've always wanted to add to my Winota or Heliod cEDH. It's just so weird that it just counters any black spell.
-
Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth is my favorite weird combo. Yes, it gets consistency, but it can run in any deck and you can add Spreading Algae for land destruction like some do in Modern. And then there's weird cards that care about Swamps like Angry Mob and Kormus Bell.
-
Titania's Song was a weird stax piece I like in Mono Green. I've seen people shotgun to kill it because they want their artifacts and stuff.
-
For newer cards, Powerbalance is a new favorite of mine as it gets pseudo card advantage if most players are playing low numbers.
-
Banding is iffy. I'm a little on the fence about that banding thread in the comments, but I won't add to the fire.
Gleeock on Favorite EDH Cards
2 years ago
I will go lower power on these pets, but oddities as well.
Oath of Druids my baby! it can crap on control in great ways while making sure the game will have impactful play from many spots.
Descent into Avernus I write about this one all the time
Shiny Impetus I ramp away while not being the guy that removed my opponent's thing.. Also, lets that pain train keep on rolling
Any of the monarch courts
Titania's Song hilarious, kills treasures too.
Crescendo of War for the sake of aggression
Wand of Wonder it just randomly will get me out of a bind and makes my deck function unpredictably
I don't have much for pet creatures, I will have to look into that
Neotrup on Animation: Layers and Timestamps
2 years ago
Since both Titania's Song and March of the Machines specify noncreature artifact they are both dependent on eachother, forming a dependency loop that means they must be applied in timestamp order rather than dependency order. This means that whichever entered the battlefield first is the one that applies. In the first example March of the Machines does nothing since Sol Ring is already a 1/1 artifact creature with no abilities, but if it had entered first it would be a 1/1 artifact creature with ": Add ."
Starfield of Nyx does not turn itself into a creature since it says "other nonaura enchantements." However, assuming they control two Starfield of Nyx it would be a 0/2 creature with no abilities. This is because its ability starts to apply in layer 4 when it turns enchantments into creatures and doesn't lose its ability until layer 6 when Sudden Spoiling starts to apply. Once the ability starts in an earlier layer, it will continue to be applied in a higher layer, so in layer 7b Starfield of Nyx will give all enchantment creatures a base power and toughness, then that will be overwritten by Sudden Spoiling also in layer 7b due to having a later timestamp.
TehGrief on Animation: Layers and Timestamps
2 years ago
Player A controls a Sol Ring, player B casts Titania's Song; Player A's Sol Ring becomes a 1/1 artifact creature with no abilities.
If player A then casts a March of the Machines, since Titania's Song specifies non-creature artifact, does March of the Machines change the artifacts into creatures, causing them to retain their abilities?
What would happen if the reverse was true? Player A controls both Sol Ring and March of the Machines, then Player B casts Titania's Song?
Follow-up question.
If Player A controls Starfield of Nyx (meeting its condition, causing their enchantments to become creatures with power and toughness equal to their converted mana cost in addition to their other types), and Player B cast Sudden Spoiling (causing creatures to lose their abilities), what would the result be?
Would all enchantments controlled by Player A lose all abilities and become 0/2 creatures - or, since the Starfield of Nyx would lose its ability, they would remain enchantments with their innate abilities but not be creatures in addition to their other types?
FormOverFunction on The GingerBant Man!
3 years ago
Exactly. Generally I'm focused on destroying power stones with Xenic Poltergeist or wiping out all the treasures with Titania's Song. I thought I was going to be a hero and turn that knowledge around for good, but I’ve failed. Your deck looks like a blast though!!
eliakimras on
Sytphilis (give it to your opponents)
3 years ago
Hello! I went through your list looking for spots to upgrade, but I found almost none: congratulations, it is really optimized!
Still, I believe you might want to consider some of these cards to increase your engine:
Ramp: Cultivate and Llanowar Elves could be Starfield Mystic, Bear Umbra, Burgeoning or Exploration instead, to stick with the Enchantments theme.
Draw: Don't forget the other enchantresses (Satyr Enchanter, Verduran Enchantress). I would take out Hyena Umbra and Cartouche of Solidarity for them.
Tutors: Heliod's Pilgrim might be better than Moon-Blessed Cleric, since it puts the card in your hand.
Pillowfort: Raking Canopy is probably more effective to deflect fliers than Spider Umbra. Elephant Grass could take White Sun's Twilight's place, since the former does not blow your own field.
Evasion: You might want Unquestioned Authority for extra evasion. It might replace Aegis of the Gods. (In my experience, players' spells do not usually target other players.)
Hate pieces: Rest in Peace, Ground Seal, Solemnity, Authority of the Consuls, Blind Obedience are some cards you might want to include.
Win conditions:
- Since your deck punishes artifacts so heavily (Austere Command, Stony Silence, Titania's Song), I believe Helm of the Gods could be swapped out for Primal Order as a punisher for nonbasic landbases. (Against my decks, it would be doing all the damage.)
- Michiko's Reign of Truth Flip, Katilda, Dawnhart Martyr Flip and Hallowed Haunting might be good finishers for your deck.
