At the helm of Chubbub's deck will be Elaine. Comments from that side will in in bold.
Low on land, but not a problem since I'm on the draw.
C plays Drowned Catacomb tapped and passes.
C draws Sulfur Falls . He plays it tapped and passes.
Not really the lands I was looking for.
C draws Dragonskull Summit . He plays Mountain and passes.
I see your Drownyard and I raise you a Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker in a few turns, hopefully.
There goes my white mana.
It kind of sucks to put Mystic Retrieval in the graveyard.
Other than Gideon, Sorin is the planeswalker I want out on the board the least.
C draws Devour Flesh . He does nothing and passes.
C draws Think Twice . He does nothing and passes.
E draws Lingering Souls
. She casts Jace, Memory Adept
, who uses his +1 ability. E draws Supreme Verdict
and C mills Dragonskull Summit
. E passes. End step, C casts Think Twice
and flashes it back. drawing Chromatic Lantern
and Nephalia Drownyard
E draws Lingering Souls and casts it, then flashes it back. She passes.
This might be really stupid, but I can't just let the staff sit there; I have to hope that he doesn't have Bolas.
E casts Lingering Souls . In response C casts Devour Flesh , and a spirit dies. Lingering Souls resolves and there are again 4 1/1 spirits. E attacks with the two older ones and hits. (E 18, C 18). She passes.
This means Sphinx's Revelation next turn, most likely, which means this is an excellent time to try and resolve a Bolas.
C draws Swamp and Watery Grave . He plays Swamp and casts Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker . Bolas blows up Detention Sphere and Staff of Nin returns. He passes. End step, E casts Sphinx's Revelation for 4, drawing Terminus , Glacial Fortress , Godless Shrine , Azorius Charm . (E 22, C 15).
E draws Isolated Chapel and plays it. She casts Azorius Charm and draws Godless Shrine . She casts Gideon, Champion of Justice , then flashes back Lingering Souls . She attacks Bolas with her four old 1/1s. The two staffs of nin destroy two of those; the other two hit (Bolas at 6). She passes.
C draws Murder , Gilded Lotus , Desolate Lighthouse . He plays Desolate Lighthouse . He casts Gilded Lotus , then Barter in Blood , killing two spirits. Bolas blows up Gideon, going to 9 counters. C passes.
E draws Psychic Strike and concedes.
Detention Sphere or scoop, probably.
E plays Godless Shrine tapped and passes.
C draws Mountain. He plays Swamp, casts Illness in the Ranks , and passes.
That actually kind of sucks, although not really right now.
I love Slaugher Games.
C draws Swamp. He plays Drowned Catacomb and passes.
I didn't know whether I should bring down the Snapcaster Mage here just to mess with his mana and make him spend time killing it. I thought it would be more valuable getting back something.
Maybe he doesn't have any sacrifice kill spells, otherwise he wouldn't counter Gideon.
Thought I'd find that in there. Need to get rid of those effects first; my deck doesn't like those. Next will be Tamiyo, then Pithing Needle .
Man, Slaughter Games feels awful when it gets cast on you.
Up next on the Slaughter list is Pithing Needle , then I'll just start going after Planeswalkers.
E draws Glacial Fortress and plays it. Sorin goes up to 5 counters. She passes.
At least he's tapped out.
E draws Augur of Bolas . She plays Nephalia Drownyard and casts the Augur, seeing Watery Grave , Nephalia Drownyard , and Gideon, Champion of Justice . She puts all of those on the bottom of the library. She puts Sorin to six counters, and passes.
Sorin is at least preventing Bolas from blowing anything but Sorin up on his first turn in.
This whole process is really horrifying.
E draws Azorius Charm . She plays Drowned Catacomb . She uses Sorin's -2 ability and gets the emblem. She uses Azorius Charm and draws Sorin, Lord of Innistrad . She attacks C with the Augur and hits. (E 23, C 18). She passes.
Where the hell is Jace?
This is a slight error; if she happened to draw the card I'm going to name with Slaughter Games , it will be a wasted play for her.
I can afford to do this now that all the really scary Planeswalkers are gone. Sorin is a non-entity with Illness in the Ranks out, and Gideon, Champion of Justice is just a creature, although a lot of my removal is gone.
E draws Sphinx's Revelation . She uses Sorin's -2 again, putting him to 2 counters. She attacks with Snapcaster and hits. (E 23, C 14). She passes.
She might have Psychic Strike , but she didn't have it last turn, and there are only two copies. I'll go for Bolas, I think.
C draws Chromatic Lantern . He taps out for Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker . Bolas steals Snapcaster Mage . C passes. End step, E casts Sphinx's Revelation for 5, drawing Hallowed Fountain , 2x Glacial Fortress , Watery Grave , and Godless Shrine .
Really? No Detention Sphere ?
E draws Isolated Chapel
. She plays it, puts Sorin to 3, and casts Azorius Charm
, drawing Dimir Charm
. She casts Dimir Charm
on her own library, putting Augur of Bolas
and Hallowed Fountain
into the graveyard, and Dimir Charm
E passes, discarding Glacial Fortress to get to 7.
E draws Dimir Charm . She casts it on her own library, milling Witchbane Orb and Drowned Catacomb , and putting Azorius Charm on top. She casts Sorin, Lord of Innistrad , puts him to 4, plays Watery Grave tapped, and passes.
E draws Azorius Charm . She casts it, drawing Detention Sphere . She casts Detention Sphere , but C casts Counterflux on it. E passes. End step, C uses Desolate Lighthouse , drawing Think Twice and discarding Swamp. He casts Think Twice , then flashes it back for Drowned Catacomb and Dreadbore .
C draws Chromatic Lantern . He plays Drowned Catacomb . Bolas blows up Nephalia Drownyard and goes to 11. E activates the drownyard in response, milling Staff of Nin , Dragonskull Summit , and Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker .
That's what I needed to mill. If I can just get a Detention Sphere out again, I'll actually not be doing bad at all.
E draws Gideon, Champion of Justice . She plays Godless Shrine tapped and casts Gideon. In response, C activates the lighthouse, drawing Staff of Nin and discarding Chromatic Lantern . E passes. End step, C drownyards, and E mills Hallowed Fountain , Watery Grave , Detention Sphere .
Well crap. I do still have Gideon, though.
Man, I am just getting dunked on, as we say at my card shop.
You need more counterspells, and not Psychic Strike . Put some Dissipate s in there, you won't regret it. Dimir Charm is not what you want in an Esper Control deck. Go with Dissipate . And throw some more Detention Sphere s in there too.
Bad draws for Esper, good draws for Bolas. Slaughter Games remains hilarious.
Would getting Sorin, Lord of Innistrad ready to use his ultimate have helped Elaine at all? Or would Caley just have blown up Sorin before that could happen? Basically, I would like to know why Elaine used Sorin's -2 instead of raising him to 6 loyalty.
Bolas would have to deal with Sorin first anyways, so going up to ult wouldn't make that much of a difference.
Bolas can just end Sorin without really having to try. It was a better play to use Sorin's emblem to buff her utility creatures. Caley sided out most of his creature removal, meaning a 4/1 Snapcaster Mage can jump in and dish out some pain if left unchecked.
That game was pretty much decided by unlucky draws. Bolas is a better built deck, but the esper build had a lot of answers and only found charms and land.
It really is gross if used correctly.
@KrazyCaley: I'm interested, did you look at the Esper decklist before you played your games? Casting Slaughter Games naming Nevermore isn't usually a move somebody would make blindly. Same goes for Pithing Needle.
@landgrafb - I did not see the decklist prior to playing, but I knew in advance it was Esper control. I often name Nevermore blind against Esper control because even though it's less common to include, it KILLS me when resolved.
Gideon, Champion of Justice just has no business being against Bolas. I sideboarded him in my deck Vigilantes Answer the Call, but only for creature heavy decks, Bolas has literally no creatures...
Ah. Forgot that the first Slaughter let you see the whole deck. It all makes sense now.
Do you just randomly select decks from T/O to play against?
Wish there hadn't been so much draw-fail, but still an interesting match.
I'd like to see Bolas go against a faster deck. Perhaps a Gruul or Naya Burning-Tree Emissary deck.
I put my naya humans deck forward to fight it out with Bolas. Human After All
@buffy - No, people post on my wall. There's a line, but post if you want to send forth a deck to battle. If you're on MTGO you can run your deck yourself!
@Aikola - See above.
@SupremeAlliesCommander - Big-time sucky draws for the Esper deck, I agree. Not exactly god draws for Bolas, but better than the other side for sure.
Honestly, I would have targeted Pithing Needle with Slaughter Games. Even in non-control decks, almost everyone runs one or two of them in the sideboard. It's a really safe bet. I guess you didn't want to risk Nevermore being in the deck, since you were up against white.
@Aikola - Mystic Retrieval has really been the surprise winner of this deck, and I will miss it badly when it rotates. In a control deck without wrath, you really have to get super-high efficiency out of the cards you DO have, and Mystic Retrieval, though slow, is INCREDIBLY efficient.
@TikiShades - Basically, yeah. Nevermore sucks for me because smart players can shut down my control tools with them. Nevermore naming Counterflux, for instance, hurts REAL BAD. I can deal with a Pithing Needle or two because I have several win conditions, but when another control deck can shut down my counterspells, that's sad times.