Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

SefTheReject on Burnin' Down The House

1 week ago

Icbrgr thank you. When I can get them, swapping slickshot show-off in and soul-scar mage out.

sergiodelrio on Edge of Eternities Previews

1 week ago

The baloth dies to removal as weak as Shock... I agree that it appears strong tho, and certainly will actively demand an answer more often than not, since people will try to beef it up and/or protect it. Blocking it to death seems reasonable, too.

Coward_Token on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

1 week ago

Oh and for e.g. Ocelot Pride, the 1/1 token is using the 2/2 (leonin) art. Scryfall got all the different 1/1 art handy: link

Coward_Token on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

1 week ago

Closest thing is the MTGO one by David Martin: image link

Femme_Fatale on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

1 week ago

zelous666: if you can find one in real life that is printed by wotc and take a good quality picture of it that would be amazing.

Zetagen on Golbez deez nuts

1 week ago

That's fair enough.

TyloRen on Golbez deez nuts

1 week ago

Yes, this would absolutely be considered a bracket 4 deck. I usually just hit 3 as I start building a deck on tappedout so I can import them into tabletop sim fairly quickly when I've finished the list. I've updated it now, could probably do with a couple less gamechangers and make a more thoughtful sideboard to keep it within bracket 3.

Balaam__ on Rebecca “Don't Mess with Me” …

1 week ago

I miss the old sensibilities WotC had when commissioning/choosing the artwork for the cards. There was so much variety and the idea of everything feeling same-y wasn’t much of an issue. Now nearly everything has homogenized into ‘character in action stance/hero pose, midfield focus, cg magic marker aesthetic’ and it’s really unappealing.

Barnie22 on Rebecca “Don't Mess with Me” …

1 week ago

Thanks Balaam__ glad you enjoy the vision. I got into Magic because of the art so a deck for appreciating an artist was going to happen at some point with me.

moo1234 on Card creation challenge

1 week ago

Curse of the Witch Queen

Instant

Put a curse counter on up to 2 target creatures, (Creatures that are cursed have no abilities)

Then Serebela looked at me, and I forgot everything before this moment


Curse is my attempt to create an evergreen keyword

Next Challenge:

  • Attempt to create a new "evergreen" esque keyword, like haste, +1/+1 counters, vigilance

  • Make another card that curses creatures

Balaam__ on Rebecca “Don't Mess with Me” …

1 week ago

This is up there as one of the best looking decks in all of Magic from an artistic aesthetic point of view.

zelous666 on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

1 week ago

Missing a Spawn artifact creature token for Spawning Pit *list*.

CrazyDanPsycho on Brudiclad's Glorious Transmorgrification!

1 week ago

McDuckington: Those are great suggestions, thanks. I'm currently trying to compile my collection, and as soon as that's done, this is the first deck I plan on updating. I know I have a Helm of the Host, but I'm not sure about the other two. I will have to look into that. Again, thanks. :-)

McDuckington on Brudiclad's Glorious Transmorgrification!

1 week ago

Helm of the Host Quantum Misalignment Irenicus's Vile Duplication

Make a nonlegendary token of Brudiclad.

Turn all tokens into brudiclad

Now all your Brudiclads make more Brudiclads, which in turn make more Brudiclads.

jonjonhholt on Pauper Scam (with Wildfire)

1 week ago

this deck looks dope! theres a new card coming out in edge of eternity that could be a fun addition to the deck

edge of eternity card Show

Icaruskid on Alien Surge | The First …

1 week ago

Mortlocke Yeah they look great! The EoE set spoilers are also getting exciting!

Mortlocke on Alien Surge | The First …

1 week ago

Thanks for the +1 on my comment, 2 years later LOL. Have you seen the new art for Sliver Overlord? Or the Future Sight border for The First Sliver? I'm loving these new art treatments.

hallowvale on Cheap EP

1 week ago

Edited and ready for testing

DemonDragonJ on Death and Rebirth

1 week ago

I definitely shall put vernal fen into this deck, but what land should it replace? I could replace a basic land, with it, but I wish to ensure that this deck still has sufficient basic lands, in the case that I use this deck against an opponent who has cards that punish the usage of non-basic lands, so I likely shall replace another dual land, with that one.

DemonDragonJ on Edge of Eternities Previews

1 week ago

I am displeased at how this space opera set clashes so strongly with previous MTG sets, but I do appreciate how WotC is doing something so very different from any previous set, and many of the cards in this set are very awesome, indeed, and I am especially pleased that WotC is finally completing the cycle of dual lands from Battle for Zendikar (i.e., Prairie Stream, Canopy Vista, and so forth), as that cycle has been long overdue for being completed.

I know that I frequently as this question when WotC prints new creatures, but how is frenzied baloth remotely balanced? That creature is simply too powerful for a mere 2 mana, in my mind, so I hope that other users here agree with me, on that subject.

DemonDragonJ on How Are Black, White, and …

1 week ago

Mark Rosewater has commented on this matter, here, as well, and his response seems to agree with what everyone else here has said.

MTGBurgeoning on Scion of the Ur-Dragon: Every. …

1 week ago

YES!! I was not overreacting when I profusely stated numerous times during the last UP & UP video for this deck is that for anyone who has a Scion build or is building Scion, Colossal Grave-Reaver is unequivocally and hands-down the #1 card to add.

Andramalech on Eight-and-a-Half Swords

1 week ago

A bit rough around the edges, but hey.. this functions! You have the cast of equipment-focused White permanents, and the deck lovingly reflects a tale of caring for Eight-and-a-Half-Tails, who happens to be a favorite of mine as well. Cheers! +1

Skyhi on theres bugs in your skin …

1 week ago

To be added : Horizon Explorer

Optimator on Moocifer Rising

1 week ago

Instead of the middling sacrifice package, you could run some of the Stuffy Doll cards. Might be more synergistic.

Brash Taunter

Barbed Servitor -- draws cards

Crow_Umbra on Edge of Eternities Previews

1 week ago

Very excited for Umbral Collar Zealot for my Aristocrat leaning Party decks. Looks like the Monoists will be providing plenty of Clerics and Wizards for those decks to consider.

Loving the art for this set so far. Excited to see what else is in store.

Andramalech on Scion of the Ur-Dragon: Every. …

1 week ago

MTGBurgeoning oh dude that dragon is BONKERS! I have a Teval. Arbiter of Virtue deck that uses him as a main-cast star, as well as a The Necrobloom deck where it's even MORE popular!

MTGBurgeoning on Scion of the Ur-Dragon: Every. …

1 week ago

Thank you so much! I really appreciate your kind words. Truly. As for Drakuseth, many moons have passed since he received Scion love. It's all about Colossal Grave-Reaver now. 100%.

Coward_Token on Edge of Eternities Previews

1 week ago

Umbral Collar Zealot: Zahur, Glory's Past was in the last set and his activated ability has already been power crept

Evendo Brushrazer: the flavor text is incredibly

Planetary Annihilation: Fair mass land destruction. Makes my Ghalta, Primal Hunger -> Traverse the Outlands combo sad tho

Andramalech on Scion of the Ur-Dragon: Every. …

1 week ago

MTGBurgeoning I wouldn't recommend engaging with ShadowMasterNL as they seem to be committed to providing next to no value in conversations on lists, and almost all of their commentary I've seen is negatively framed, regardless of the concept.

That aside, I really love this idea, and am equally fascinated with your Drakuseth, Maw of Flames obsession. So many good dragons to use! +1 because I sat aside my suspension of disbelief and didn't need to pick a fight where there wasn't one. <3

thijmnesoy on Shadow wizard money gang

1 week ago

pretty cool idea of making a deck around a DnD campaign

legendofa on Does this Aura modify the …

1 week ago

The base power and toughness are the numbers printed on the card, so Destiny Spinner has a base power of 2. Mammoth Umbra gives +3/+3, so it raises Spinner's power to 5. Since its current power 5 is greater than its base power 2, if it deals combat damage to a player, Kutzil, Malamet Exemplar's ability will trigger and you'll draw a card.

DMBobbyC on Exponential Damage - Lightning, Army …

1 week ago

Thank you! I didn't even notice, meant to have Alchemist's Talent instead for some ramp and a big burn when I throw out a super boosted Fling or X cost spell. Probably could use a little more interaction and not just straight damage though. I'll take a look and see if Soul Partition can find a spot in there.

Ricochet_9000 on Does this Aura modify the …

1 week ago

I have Destiny Spinner enchanted with Mammoth Umbra, it dealt combat to my opponent. Does this interaction trigger my Kutzil, Malamet Exemplar ability to draw a card?

sergiodelrio on Edge of Eternities Previews

1 week ago

That Cosmogoyf will see a ban in Modern imho. It's just another Hogaak, and you can't even un-exile stuff realistically.

Set looks fun and cards are more on the strong side without going over the top, I believe.

Might be wrong on both statements, but we'll see.

magwaaf on Why Has WotC Changed the …

1 week ago

So I'm just going to let you know I only read the headline.

The answer is instant gratification

It makes the players feel better and get more excited when they show new shit especially if it's really good