alechodgin23 on Docta Yawgdaddy-CEDH
3 weeks ago
After playtesting, I'm considering removing Bloodchief Ascension / Mindcrank. Its a cheap combo but really hard to pull off in CEDH. I want so bad for this to be a bracket 5 combo, but I think it is strictly bracket 4.
Crl255 on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
Kindred Authority
Enchantment
When Kindred Authority enters the battlefield, choose a creature type.
Whenever a creature of the chosen type attacks, discover X, where X is its mana value.
Create a card that does something whenever it loses a time counter from suspend, or make a card that does something whenever it gains an age counter from cumulative upkeep.
KayneMarco on Preston, Magic Rabbit
3 weeks ago
Surprised I don’t see Ojer Taq, Deepest Foundation Flip or Exalted Sunborn in the deck.
moo1234 on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
Second Hand shop
Artifact
second hand shop untaps on each players untap step
: Creatures you control get +1/+0 until end of turn
: creatures you control get +0/+1 until end of turn
'we've got everything here anyone could want, let me know if you need a hand'
I guess it doesn't quite get the concept of having no hands but rather 1 hand.
create a card with cascade or discover
Tarzunga on Death from Above
3 weeks ago
TheoryCrafter thank you for your input. Glad you like what I came up with. Yeah those more expensive dragons I will leave for later, first I wanna test the deck and see if I really enjoy it and if it works as intended.
Sivitri I had in the first version but I'll still consider her for an "upgrade", same for Monestary Siege.
As for other dragons with ETBs, I may change a few depending on how the deck performs.
eldritchmachinepriestess on List of Bugs and Feature …
3 weeks ago
Okay after experimenting some more I think i figured it out. It affected that deck specifically because of how big its maybeboard is, more cards than just the 2 mentioned are affected and all the ones missing I could identify start with letters close to the end of the alphabet (examples i found were V, W and X).
So my assumption is the live editor stops loading the cards at some point to prevent loading too many images and it loads them alphabetically.
So its probably an intentional feature.
eldritchmachinepriestess on List of Bugs and Feature …
3 weeks ago
The cards Wooded Foothills and Zoyowa's Justice dont show up in the Live Editor.
On the deck page and the (text-based) Editor they show up normally and count towards the size of their respective category and the deck.
In the Live editor my deck size is missing 2 cards (same for their respective categories once sorted) and the cards simply dont exist in the deck, when adding them in via search they get added normally and when saving they do get properly added to the deck and show up normally (as additional copies) on the deck page and (text)editor but after closing and opening the Live Editor again they are once again completely missing there.
Pass44 on Raggadragga, the boss
3 weeks ago
Thanks for your input! Love the suggestions! I'll definitely look into them!
AJC312168 on Gonti, Lord of Bitches: Black …
3 weeks ago
Also, target the blue player with Gonti. Having a counterspell at your disposal in mono black is invaluable.
Asder on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
Precarious Performer
Creature - Human Bard
Flying
Precarious Performer enters the battlefield balanced on a non-hand part of the body. When it falls, sacrifice it.
3/3
Wasn't really sure what to do with this one, so I went literal.
Give it another go if you have a better idea, or create a card with cascade or discover
seshiro_of_the_orochi on Does Rayami, first of the …
3 weeks ago
Here's a ruling from scryfall:
Dour Port-Mage’s first ability triggers whenever one or more creatures you control go to any zone other than the graveyard from the battlefield. They could be returned to your hand, your library, or exiled, for example. (2024-07-26)
So yeah, that works. Nice catch!
seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
Perilous Flora
Enchantment
Whenever a player casts a spell, create a 0/1 green plant creature token for each spell that has been cast this turn.
Whenever a plant you control attacks or block, it gets +2/+1 until end of turn.
"Perilous? Those are just some stupid dandelions!"
- Rok, the Bravehearted, last words
Look ma, I did both ;D
Create a card that embodies the phrase "Look ma, no hands!"
alechodgin23 on Docta Yawgdaddy-CEDH
3 weeks ago
Profet93 Please give me some feedback and ask any questions. Description has been added. There may be other combos built into the synergy that I am missing as well. In test play, I have won as early as turn 3 so far.
Long_Con on Raggadragga the druid addict
3 weeks ago
Klauth, Unrivaled Ancient
is made for Raggadragga. Also, Selvala, Heart of the Wilds, Kami of Whispered Hopes, and Cradle Clearcutter are nice like Heronblade and Marwyn.
It's those scalable interactions I'm focusing on in Raggadragga Mana Saga deck, and I just realized that Wurmcalling goes infinite with those mana dorks! Now, to find something I can cut...
Long_Con on Raggadrazi
3 weeks ago
Ah, yes, I should qualify it in a couple of ways. First, I don't have a group to play with, I have one friend who mostly builds Tier 4 decks, and I have to tailor mine to be strong in the 1v1 matchup. Second, we both are cool with proxies; I don't have all these cards but I do have a laser printer. ;)
I see the benefit of the going wide in the attack with Sylvan Awakening - I have Liege of the Tangle in the Maybeboard for similar ideas, and I think if I ended up playing multiplayer, I would make a shift like this.
Similarly with Kozilek, right off the bat, the "two target players" is diminished in my circumstance, but again, I see the go-wide strategy as strong in the multiplayer. I playtested your deck, and I was impressed at the (colorless) mana available quite early, it rivalled the heavy mana-dork ratio in my own deck!
ArmchairRuler on Does Rayami, first of the …
3 weeks ago
From what I understand Rayami, First of the Fallen has an ability that works as a replacement effect that when a creature dies, it gets exiled instead. Would this allow cards like Dour Port-Mage to trigger and draw me a card when a creature is exiled from my board to her effect?
Evil25Illusion on Locthwain Nightmares
3 weeks ago
Since you're CMC/MV is currently 2.23 (at the time of this comment), you're not running enough lands. Since your Mono-Black Midrange (Control-Aggro is another term for "Midrange) Deck is edging closer to a CMC/MV cost of 2.25, you need to be running at least 24 lands to play on curve. And arguably, you should try running 7-8 fetches. With typical Decks running a generic build/strategy like this, especially, in my experience, having 8 fetch lands present is more common than 7, I'd say. But this doesn't apply all the time. So, in case you're in doubt, 75% I'd run 8 fetch lands in a 24-land Deck, and 25% of the time I'd run 7 fetch lands in a 24-land Deck. Same rule applies (usually, but not always) in a Deck with CMC/MV of approximately 2.00, which is right around 23 lands. But in this case, you'd want to run from 6-7 fetches, with 75% of the time being 7 fetch lands, and 25% of the time being 6 fetch lands. For the record, though, I wouldn't put any fetches into a Mono-Green Stompy Deck, though.
Overall, though, if I'm being honest, the conceptualization is great. In my view, you typically want cards that have their abilities applied right away more than ones that just sit there and do nothing. So, I'd suggest 4 copies of "Gatekeeper of Malakir" over 2 copies. The next card, "Gifted Aetherborn", depending, I'd suggest that 2 or 3 copies would be good, but probably 3 seems more comfortable. Also, "Liliana of the Veil" can be an interesting take, I'd say 2-4 copies of that. But you might only actually want to run 2 or 3 copies instead, because "Liliana of the Veil" can seem more excessive than she needs to be. I think "Castle Locthwain" should always be at 4 copies, especially in purely black builds like this. Having too few seemingly doesn't nothing. Anyway, these suggestions are not set in stone, but in my experience, you don't want to be overflown with cards that do too little and underwhelmed by cards that can shake-up your opponent.
DarkKiridon on Raggadrazi
3 weeks ago
Long_Con Yours looks great! (and pricey!). Klauth looks fun to try whenever I obtain a copy but yes, mine is built around eldrazi spawns/scions in mind and I like to rotate cards in and out on occasion with my decks but I would be willing to try Regal Force
Sylvan Awakening is sweet tech with Raggadragga. They will be 4/4s instead of 2/2s and you will (most likely) get a free attack in with no worries (most of the time) from them being indestructible. They will also untap from Raggadragga and be able to block anything for a full turn cycle.
Kozilek, the Broken Reality is good in here. Buff up those spawns/scions a bit more and I'm also a fan of Glaring Fleshraker with Skittering Invasion
One card I think you should give a try is Hideous Taskmaster. I don't need to explain why haha.
TheoryCrafter on Death from Above
3 weeks ago
You've built this deck about how I'd do it. Using the omens and the adventures for early game control and card advantage, dragons with etb triggers to concentrate on instants and sorceries that give you card advantage, and an alternate win card to end any stalemates.
With the Exception of the mana rocks, Ancient Brass Dragon, Ancient Silver Dragon and Transcendent Dragon, the only cards I'd add from your maybeboard are Sivitri, Dragon Master and Monsatery Siege. Anything beyond these should be more dragons with etb and attack triggers.
You did a good job. May you draw well!
Saturn999 on Mardu skeletons
3 weeks ago
Cool deck! Really like the synergies. Do we like Flare of Malice over Bitter Triumph? Granted malice is essentially free. Also I know there is no room in the deck but any play testing with Kroxa, Titan of Death's Hunger?
Profet93 on Docta Yawgdaddy-CEDH
3 weeks ago
Be sure to tag me when you have finished the description. Would love to know your budget and meta considerations as well
Asder on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
Caged Battle-Moose
Creature - Elk
Ward - Caged Battle-Moose fights a creature you control.
Caged Battle-Moose can't attack or block.
Whenever a creature enters the battlefield, any player may pay . If they do, Caged Battle-Moose fights that creature.
6/6
Want to play creatures again? Defeat The Moose first.
Create a card that goes in a mono green storm deck or a mono green stax deck
Tsukimi on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
Ixmtl, Wandering Den Mother
Creature - Sliver Kithkin Shapeshifter
Each creature you control is a Sliver in addition to its other types.
Whenever one or more creatures you control deal damage to a player, you and that player each draw a card.
3/3
"I am a child of two hives, both lost to me. To build my own I must teach my children to be different."
Create a mythic rare moose card
Saturn999 on There's a Fungus Among us
3 weeks ago
This looks like a fun and interesting deck to play.
FauxFaux on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
Captain O'Tter, Grizzled Constable
Legendary Creature - Otter Detective
Haste
Whenever ~ attacks, Suspect target creature, then Investigate.
, Sacrifice any number of Clue Tokens: Exile target creature with mana value X or less, where X is the number of Clue tokens sacrificed this way. Put that many time counters on it. If it doesn’t have Suspend, it gains Suspend.
At the beginning of each end step, if a creature entered the battlefield under an opponent’s control this turn, investigate, then tap up to one target creature that entered the battlefield this turn.
3/4
"Every day, these vigilantes make trouble...And I'm only a few days from retirement...can't they give me a break?"
Wild!
Reaxetion on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
The Mourning Honk
Legendary Creature - Goose Hydra Hero
Flying, Haste
The Mourning Honk enters with X +1/+1 counters on it.
Whenever The Mourning Honk attacks, the defending player creates X blood tokens where X is half The Mourning Honk's Power rounded down.
Whenever an opponent sacrifices an artifact or creature, you may put a +1/+1 counter on The Mourning Honk. If you do, discard a card, then draw a card.
1/1
"Revenge for her lost gaggle lead her to vengeance. The abundance of evil made her a vigilante." -Captain O Tter
I got a bit silly on this one, but you gave me the chance to have Goose related lore (my favorite animal). Make a card for Captain O Tter. Your choice on another super hero otter or a law enforcement officer dealing with this rat and bird vigilante chaos.
TheoryCrafter on Ajani and his pride
3 weeks ago
Because you have two copies of Ajani, Strength of the Pride(which creates Ajani Pridemate tokens) and a full set of Resourceful Defense(which has both a triggered and an activated ability), my recommendation would be to remove one of each and add two more copies of Oketra's Monument. Either that or replace some of them them with Shrine of Loyal Legions since you have only 14 creature spells to trigger Oketra with.
Have you considered The Birth of Meletis? While it may not have the staying power of Ajani's Mantra or the flavor, it will help to make sure you have a supply of Plains and some life triggers.
Also, I would recommend changing the tab from Standard to Legacy or Vintage since many of your cards are not Standard Legal
I hope this helps. Thank you for reading me out. Happy Hunting!
moo1234 on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
Ratman, saviour of the sewers
Legendary Creature - Rat hero
Vigilance deathtouch flash
when ~ enters the battlefield other rats you control gain deathtouch and indestructible until end of turn
"Sometimes the truth isn't good enough, sometimes people deserve more, cheese for example"-ratman
1/2
make another animal based superhero
TheoryCrafter on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
Huntress Wizard
Creature- Human Wizard
Prowess
: Search target opponent's library for a creature and put it on the battlefield. Then ~ fights that creature. You can activate this once per turn and only before your combat phase.
1/3
Ninja'd! Do above.
TheoryCrafter on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
Huntress Wizard
Creature- Human Wizard
Prowess
: Search target opponent's library for a creature and put it on the battlefield. Then ~ fights that creature. You can activate this once per turn and only before your combat phase.
1/3
Ninja'd! Do above.
seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
Huntress Wizard
Creature - Archer Wizard
Haste, Reach, Deathtouch
: For each archer you control that blocks or is blocked by one or more creatures, choose target creature blocking or blocked by that creature. Huntress Wizard deals 1 damage to each creature chosen this way.
3/3
Create a rat.
ViscountVonSausageRoll on White Reanimator, Angels
3 weeks ago
I know you mentioned that the deck is budget in your comment, but I still can't help but mentioned Emeria, the Sky Ruin
Long_Con on Raggadragga, the boss
3 weeks ago
Nice deck, I have a Raggadragga deck as well!
I have found that Last March of the Ents and Nissa's Revelation are extremely good when you have Ragga and a scalable mana dork like Marwyn out. Especially Last March, as it can look at the mana dork's recently +7 toughness and draw cards off that. Then you hit a couple of 7+CMC cards and combo off, ending with a +28/+28 mana dork with trample and a battlefield of beauties!
Raggadragga Mana Saga if you'd like to check mine out. I'm focused on the ideal mana dorks, and comboing up 7CMC cards with scalable dorks like Heronblade Elite, along with card draw (like Regal Force) and the baddest threats.
Long_Con on Raggadrazi
3 weeks ago
I have a Raggadragga deck as well, just out here looking for ways to tighten it up! What do you think are your strongest cards/combos?
Raggadragga Mana Saga if you'd like to check mine out. I'm focused on the ideal mana dorks, and comboing up 7CMC cards with scalable dorks like Heronblade Elite, along with card draw (like Regal Force). I find it goes off very reliably, ending up with a turn 5 battlefield with Summon: Bahamut, Klauth, Unrivaled Ancient, and Blightsteel Colossus all lined up... or worse!
chrisiver on 8-CRACK BURN
3 weeks ago
It is almost identical to the typical boros builds. Atarka's command replaces boros charm in this build, and the sideboard has to have some different options. This version is definitely burn's best chance against boros energy, and blink which runs Phlage.
