Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Cloudy2024 on Robot Houuuuse!!!

3 days ago

I feel like one copy of Pithing Needle would be good

Cloudy2024 on Rigging the Heart of the …

3 days ago

Consider is great to play at your opponents end step, which will help Delver of Secrets  Flip and Galvanoth

GutterbonesMan on Grixis Impulse Engine

3 days ago

KermitWizard thank you! I’m pretty proud of this brew, might not be the most competitive but its mine and it’s fun to pilot

Femme_Fatale on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

3 days ago

Airbender still in preview season, they'll all be up eventually.

dwarqwe85 on Psychic Possession + Urza's Saga …

3 days ago

Clear! Thank you.

Urzas_Driving_Goggles on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

3 days ago

Missing card named "It'll Quench Ya!" from The Last Airbender set. I am hoping to put it into a pauper deck's sideboard.

Link- https://scryfall.com/card/tla/58/itll-quench-ya!

Joshy0610 on flipping the bird

3 days ago

joshua deck i got from DeckTechforDecks on youtube

Cloudy2024 on Darwin’s Dirty Onus

3 days ago

always love an eldrazi deck!

KermitWizard on Grixis Impulse Engine

3 days ago

This is awesome. A green version could use metamorphosis.

Cloudy2024 on Ghalta's Fury

3 days ago

such an annoying matchup! but love the deck

2000AD on His Dark Materials

3 days ago

Absolutely loving this old school conglomeration of cards into one deck! Nicely done!

Galbrush on 11.7% OF THE TIME, IT …

3 days ago

i love a deck with personality like this. a real all or nothing type deck

KongMing on Free Spell Tribal

3 days ago

Yeah, no screenshots, thought so.

BTW Fieldsweeper, do you know what the Casual tag means?

brushfe on Charlotte's Web

3 days ago

This is amazing haha oink oink!!

clayperce on Possible Free Dinosaurs?? Yes PLEASE

3 days ago

Also wanted to mention: I play in an ultra-budget playgroup (we aim for ~USD $25), and I spent a few minutes trying to pull together a Jodan Dinosaur deck. Here's what I came up with. It's DEFINITELY not optimal, but is perhaps an interesting starting point.

Also, there are a surprising number of Jodah Dino decks over on Moxfield ... you might want to check out these decks to see what other folks are trying.

clayperce on Possible Free Dinosaurs?? Yes PLEASE

3 days ago

Ok, to answer your question from earlier: IMO Jodan is a better Commander than Morophon, just because it only costs 4 mana to cast Jodan, vs 7 mana for Morophon. Said another way: In a perfect world with Jodan, you could ramp into him on Turn 3, and then start casting huge Dinosaurs on Turn 4. Where in a perfect world with Morophon, you could ramp into him on Turn 5 (maybe) or 6 (probably) and then start casting huge Dinosaurs the turn after.

2000AD on 93/94: White Weenie - "Clan …

3 days ago

Ah! Thank you for letting me know that, and thanks for dropping by!

mazeofish on 93/94: White Weenie - "Clan …

3 days ago

Tapped Out only recognizes Swedish Old School rules where Fallen Empire cards are not legal. That's why it says "not Old School Legal" But this is 100% Legit for EC Old School. White Weenie is always a blast to play and an affordable deck in the format.

Femme_Fatale on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

3 days ago

Galbrush: Those cards are not legal for standard, but are legal for draft. Note how the set is not EOE but EOS. EOS is effectively like, EOE's masterpieces set. Some products have a set where none of the cards are legal for standard play but can show up as reprints in a fancy showcase frame with art of the set's theme. They exist to upsell the pack to people looking to flip the contents.

DubMC on Kaalia's Air Force V.1

3 days ago

I strongly recommend Dragon Tempest and any other ways to give haste for Kaalia

Neotrup on Psychic Possession + Urza's Saga …

3 days ago

No. Saga's receive a lore counter as a turn based action at the start of the precombat main phase. The reminder text states after the draw step because it's shorter and reminder text doesn't need to be 100% accurate as long as it gets the correct point across.

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

3 days ago

Laromir, Malicious Healer

Legendary Creature - Devil Cleric

Whenever this creature would be dealt damage, it deals that much damage to you instead.

Other creatures have lifelink.

Whenever a player would gain life, they lose that much life instead.

5/8


Tainted Remedy, the deck. Repeat.

dwarqwe85 on Psychic Possession + Urza's Saga …

3 days ago

Does playing Psychic Possession and thus skipping the draw step make it possible to "keep" a saga at a certain level, because lore counters are not added?

Edgapuffle on Dwagons :D

3 days ago

I decided to take out Time Walk lol. Somehow forgot that that card is banned in commander when I put it in, and never bothered to take it out until now. The deck is now legal!

MLS91 on Deforestation Techniques

3 days ago

DreadKhan

Like in terms of my draw package in this deck, over time tannuk will draw more cards in all over time, deal more damage and cost 1 less overall, also if much rather winds of change turn1 then faithless looting. I cannot tell you how many times that has won me a game outright

MLS91 on Deforestation Techniques

3 days ago

DreadKhan

I swear by dakmoor salvage in rackdos, reanimation in rakdos is just to good and dredging your lands away to play through a crucible effect is just , one of the Liliana’s is a swamp tutor and lake of the dead when you get there but you wanna look mostly at rituals for “ramp” in rakdos colors

Zerethon on Hallway of Fiery Doom-Death

3 days ago

Two personal favorites of mine for Red prison fun, Price of Glory & Citadel of Pain

Since you have artifacts/treasures/powerbalance/etc you can cast without tapping lands to get around Glory & Pains drawbacks pretty easy if you want more to mess with control decks

Fieldsweeper on Free Spell Tribal

3 days ago

idk what you need to do to get booted from this site tbh, as tbh, I don't think he said anything BAD, just disagreed. but to the other guy, you don't need my screenshots, just run a sim on it, play it on xmage, I am soooooo sorry I didn't screen shot every single game, and most of them are gone by now, but I will show you. Just play the freaking deck, if you play it for REAL, and not some friendly allow 15 free mulligan bs, you will see how widely inconsistent it is at getting ANTTHING of any meat on the table until easily turn 6. since most of those lands are tapped, sure it has rocks, but again, turn 5 or 5 is if you are lucky to start doing anything. AND that is assuming ZERO interaction or pressure from opponents which you WILL have. ESP if you haven't done anythingKongMing of value by turn 5 lol.

there is even a tool on HERE that you can randomly draw 7 cards, just do that 100 times and see what you get, try on xmage, it's free, play against a bot etc. you CAN play it yourself before just blanket assuming anything one way OR the other.

Noobybro_ on K'rrik cedh

3 days ago

ahem

DubMC on Sanguinary Healing

3 days ago

Voice of the Blessed would be amazing. Looks fun!

MindBoogaloo on Need Tap/Tapped Creature Payoff Suggestions

3 days ago

@ FormOverFunction: That'd indeed be a good inclusion if I had some strong creatures in my deck. Atm, my single most powerful creature is a 4/5.

@ Bookrook Yes, something along the lines of Throne of the God-Pharao. Pls keep in mind that all permanents are required to have an activated ability (see Zirda's companion restriction).

DreadKhan on Deforestation Techniques

3 days ago

I've wondered if I Ghostfire Slice is better in Commander than people give it credit for, 4 damage is enough to swat a lot more key cards than Abrade or Bolt, and most decks run multi-coloured spells that are important (especially their actual Commanders!). The Devoid is a really nice upside too actually, solving Protection based solutions. I'd love to hear how if it works out!

Mostly curious, but have you ever thought about stuff like Wild Growth and/or Utopia Sprawl? It's hard to find a more cost effective ramp solution that doesn't involve artifacts. Only G for an extra pip, which could even be available the same turn (making it neutral later game), yet they also play well early (offering you ramp turn 1 more often), surviving most early wipes/interaction. I've gone so far as to sneak a Sprawl into a 5C deck, so far it's been fine, I imagine a 2C deck would find it more practical though!

I'm actually thinking of sneaking a Faithless Looting into a Rakdos list, as a way to help dig for lands, but I can't decide if the card disadvantage is tolerable. If you drew Looting early did it usually work out well?

yeaGO on List of Bugs and Feature …

3 days ago

Just been resetting them manually for now but thanks for the update.

Balaam__ on List of Bugs and Feature …

3 days ago

No cycles again. Unsure if the glitch persists or if the timing window for replenishment was adjusted, but they’d usually be refilled by now.

Cloudy2024 on Squat-drazi-tron

4 days ago

no, not the karns. But maybe some Ugin, the Ineffable

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

4 days ago

Kombolo, Champion of Ureni

Kombolo, Champion of Ureni

Okay but this deck would go so hard

Make a commander for a deck you absolutely need

Cloudy2024 on Retro Wizards (Grixis)

4 days ago

yeah, that is a really good point

Cloudy2024 on Blightning Skelemental

4 days ago

good point, but they usually have another creature out anyway, so Sheoldred's Edict is normally useless as well

MadScientist616 on Squat-drazi-tron

4 days ago

Cloudy2024 Would you say remove Devourer of Destiny and one of each planeswalker to make those two 4 each?

legendofa on Card creation challenge

4 days ago

Mana Shatter

Enchantment

Players can't play lands.

Pay 1 life for each degrade counter on Mana Shatter, sacrifice a nonland nontoken permanent: Put a degrade counter on Mana Shatter, then add one mana of any color for each life paid this way. Any player may activate this ability.


Create a Bear Spirit enchantment creature.

Asder on Card creation challenge

4 days ago

Senchal, Lurking Threat

Legendary Creature - Dinosaur

Menace, Skulk

Senchal enters with 3 Hexproof counters.

Whenever you cast a spell, remove a counter from Senchal.

4/2


His rival can defeat him, but only after he comes out of hiding.

Create a card that slowly degrades and gets worse

Femme_Fatale on PreDH Format Tag

4 days ago

yeaGO? The above report.