Each player chooses a number of lands they control equal to the number of lands controlled by the player who controls the fewest, then sacrifices the rest. Players discard cards and sacrifice creatures the same way.

Latest Decks as Commander

Balance Discussion

TotesMcGoats on Wizzardrix (Kwain, Itinerant Meddler)

1 week ago

philesposito007 Oath of Lieges is best when it comes down early to accelerate the whole game faster. There's almost always going to be at least 1 green player whos casting some kind of land ramp spell early on, so once one player gets ahead and gets an extra land, then hits their land drop, now they're ahead of the NEXT person and so on. I like it because it helps balance the game without being... yknow Balance. Its not always going to do anything, but when everyone's drawing so many cards from you, people should be hitting land drops and if anyone pulls ahead, everyone else gets to take advantage from it. I also try to run as many basics as possible since we're only a 2 color deck anyway, duals just aren't very necessary and utility lands are way more important.

Jace's Archivist is a card that in my experience rarely survives a turn around the table, so I've stop playing it. Thassa's Oracle I'm still considering because I'm not sure if I want to make the deck geared more toward being fun and casual or toward actually winning.

wereotter on Mono White Ramp/Draw

1 month ago

I think white doesn't need to find a way to copy every other color with more ramp and draw. Colors need to be able to balance each other out, and rather than allow white to do the same thing, I think white should stick to its flavor of being the color that forces people to play "fair" magic.

To that end, I think Balance should be unbanned and we need more cards like it. Force that green-white deck that's been drawing its whole deck and putting down 4 lands per turn to be back on the same page as everyone else. I also think they need to expand this. Maybe a white enchantment that says something like "If a land would enter the battlefield, and it wasn't the first land that player played from their hand this turn, exile it instead" and one that say "Players can't draw more than one card per turn" Make these effects universal so decks containing white can't abuse cards like Collective Voyage or wheel effects.

Guerric on State of Mono-Colored Decks in …

3 months ago

metalflame and plakjekaas I'm not saying that white can't do strong things, it certainly can! When I've made white decks they've pulled off some epic wins, and the tutoring in white is underrated, which helps with those wins. And yes TriusMalarky, it does have good hate-bears effects, and those are stronger in mono-white because they aren't competing too much for space with other cards. That being said, the lack of synergistic and consistent card draw is a problem. Part of this is that they haven't settled on a direction for it. So a couple of cards will draw for equipment, two will draw for weenie creatures, one will draw for life gain, another when people attack you, but these strategies don't always work together without losing focus. I don't necessarily need a fat hand, but its hard to imagine that anyone enjoys doing nothing but top-decking each turn, and when you're always top-decking your don't have the options for dealing with what your opponents throw at you. In all honesty, Rhystic Study had no business ever being in blue since white is the death and taxes color, and they really should just start doing white effects like this to provide draw while being true to the color. And I agree, Peoyogon that Balance should be legal, and I personally am not adverse to using Armageddon if I am in a winning position in order to keep my opponents from making a come back while I'm ahead. Now, if they fixed card draw and made some good commanders, I think RNR_Gaming is right that white would still be 75% of the power-level of multi-colored deck in regular commander, but it at least wouldn't be so far behind the other color combinations!

Peoyogon on State of Mono-Colored Decks in …

3 months ago

I think the answer to this was already hinted at: it is really determined by what play experience lens you are looking through.

As mentioned above, CEDH finds plenty of power in mono decks; I can attest that jank fun is always widely available and equal in any color combination. It seems that the biggest discrepancy lies within the higher thresholds of 'casual' groups, where decks are powerful but also where some color's most powerful abilities are barred under social contracts. In my observation, this is where green and blue elements (prosocial or neutral-social effects like card draw and ramp) flourish because their foils (oftentimes found in red and white like MLD, hate effects, and hard-lock combos) are not able to punish and balance the table. Litterally. If Balance were legal and those type of effects more often run, I think that Mono White in particular would be a very strong color indeed - it's just not able to fill that role while also existing in the weird psudocompetive-but-still-casual world that many EDH players build around.

Epicurus on Card creation challenge

4 months ago

Felfnig of the Scales

Legendary Creature - Elder Dragon

Flying, Defender

At the beginning of your end step, the player who controls fewer lands than each other player draws a card. Repeat this process for creatures, artifacts, enchantments and planeswalkers.


I think I properly worded it such that if it's a tie for the lowest, nobody draws. So I don't think it is worth adding to the text.

I often wonder how many people realize that EDH stands for "Elder Dragon Highlander." The reason, of course, is that when the format was created, your "Commander" had to be an Elder Dragon. The format was hence expanded to make it more approachable. "Highlander" referring to the famous line "There can be only one" from the Highlander movies, signifying that you can only have one of each card in the deck. Highlander itself was a format well before EDH existed, so the verbiage was adopted in the latter.

Anyway, make another mono-colored Elder Dragon, any color other than white. If you want, consider this card as the beginning of a cycle of mono-colored Elder Dragons, and take it from here. They should each draw their inspiration from classic spells for their colors, the way this one somewhat is inspired by Balance (though not literally so).

If you feel so inspired, pass on the remaining colors of the cycle to the next challenge.

Or, of course, I was ninja'd. So ignore all of that I guess and do the challenge above. Damnit...

rdean14 on Card creation challenge

4 months ago

Roland "Rol" is bonded with Brin, but I'd like to make a card representing Rol before then. Rol is a giant pink raccoon, btw

Rol, Cunning Scavenger

Legendary Creature - Raccoon Beast (The only Raccoon in magic is silver bordered, but c'mon, it's fun!)


Whenever this creature mutates, each player with more cards in hand than you discards cards until they have the same number as you and you return that many cards from your graveyard to your hand.


The identity works with the blue caring about cards in hand and the black returns cards to hand, while the is based on white's Balance -type effects and Green's Regrowth -type ability.

I've made a 4-color () card representing the good fairies and Aurora in Princess Beauty, used MDFC to achieve the four colors a few days ago and another one here where I used Mutate to get four colors ().

I'd like to see another four-color legendary creature which uses some alternative casting cost or transforming ability to achieve four colors. not like the cards in the Tarkir block or in Jumpstart that use their triggered or activated ability to increase their color identity.

These color combinations remain:

Drcfan on Aggressive Angels Tribal

6 months ago

I don't see any point in the "Casual" Format. Just ignoring all rules of magic and add 4x Black Lotus + 4x Sol Ring and call it a day seems unreasonable for me. There is a reason cards like Balance , Sol Ring are banned straight down to Vintage. I don't see why anyone would play against and if, the casual format would win on Turn 1 or even Turn 0 with very high chance. I really do like Angels, thats why i build Angels Deck for 6 years now. But i would suggest to stick to at least one format. Maybe Commander or Modern would be something for You?

Load more