Crow_Umbra on Jund Aggro

1 hour ago

I had a few quick questions, since the triple commander listing caught my eye:

• Is this deck intended to run any of those three options as the commander, and you swap them in between games?

• Or is this more so a "Rule Zero" with your play group, where they allow you to have multiple commanders?

• If none of the above, is one of the three listed options intended to be the primary commander?

Mostly wondering since the three commanders are all pretty dissimilar from each other in terms of strategies, so if you're looking for feedback it might be hard to know which of those three you're mostly focusing on.

legendofa on Card creation challenge

1 hour ago

Playful Poppet

Artifact Creature - Toy

When Playful Poppet enters, each player creates a 0/1 colorless artifact Toy creature token.

At the beginning of each player's end step, if that player controls a Toy, they create a 0/1 colorless artifact Toy creature token.

0/1

Create a creature with coven (if you control three or more creatures with different powers, ...) and morbid (if a creatures died this turn, ...)

DemonDragonJ on Mind Over Matter

2 hours ago

I have replaced Cryptic Command with Disallow, which reduced the average converted mana cost of this deck from 3.79 to 3.77, because, as great as the command is, its casting cost is too strict, so it is better to replace it with a card that has a more lenient casting cost, and Disallow still very much matches the theme of this deck.

DemonDragonJ on Flux Channeler or Lulu, Stern …

2 hours ago

I have a copy of Flux Channeler in my Atraxa, Praetors' Voice EDH deck, but I am contemplating replacing that card with Lulu, Stern Guardian, because Lulu works as a mana sink and also has an additional ability that works well with that deck's theme. It is true that the channeler requires no additional investment of resources after she is summoned, but her ability has a restriction that I find to be annoying (as it prevents me from replacing Vedalken Orrery with High Fae Trickster), and I already have a copy of Inexorable Tide in that deck, so replacing the channeler would not be a major issue.

What does everyone else say, about this subject? Should I replace Flux Channeler with Lulu, or leave the channeler in my deck? I certainly am eager to hear your thoughts, on this matter!

DemonDragonJ on Is the Legendary Supertype More …

2 hours ago

wallisface, I must respectfully say that that solution does not seem to be necessary, since the current legend rule is not broken; if a card that depicts a named character is not so powerful that it would be broken if more than one copy was on the battlefield at a time, then why even make it legendary, at all? In my mind, WotC should make permanents legendary only if they are too powerful to have multiple copies on the battlefield, as that seems to be more appropriate, to me; Mark Rosewater himself has said that mechanics take precedence over flavor, so that indicates to me that a permanent should have the legendary supertype only if it has a mechanical reason to do so.

DemonDragonJ on Mana Rocks or Mana Dorks?

2 hours ago

SaberTech, these two decks of mine have a strong focus on placing +1/+1 counters on creatures, so would Kami of Whispered Hopes be a good match for either of them?

Parkerkeeton14 on Slight Mayhem

4 hours ago

this helped me build my first standard deck as a edh player

SufferFromEDHD on Captain Howler - Discard Scourge

9 hours ago

Oops... Scratch that Echo of Eons and make it Memory Jar!

WyrmWood on Meteor Mage // Dragons

13 hours ago

I played with someone on Spell Table. They explained that this deck could win much more often. This is the latest version... It's gained respect from the other players at the game shop.

christ4like2l0ve on Eowyn

13 hours ago

Super Cool deck