Sup, I'm Kai, I've celebrated 30 birth anniversaries, you can call me Barf if you want, it's a name I picked up from a TV show you've never heard of. Don't play too much Magic any more but I try to stay up to date with things and still tinker around with EDH decks and whatnot.

Favorite card: Song of the Dryads

About me: I'm a nerd, video games, board games, whatever, just like chillin' really. I wouldn't say I'm antisocial just don't talk to me. For real though, I kinda just like doing my own thing. My favorite video games are probably The Binding of Isaac and Minecraft or any kind of mindless grinding RPG like Fallout or Skyrim, love an open world. Favorite TTGs; Magic, Warhammer (blood for the Blood God literally as many bloodletters as I'm allowed,) and anything I can play solo. Lastly, I have a few smaller side hobbies; I can yo-yo pretty well, very very amateur speedcuber (22.6 seconds) and Dungeons and Dragons of course great player, better DM. That's about it really, message me if you want, I'm not the best at advice but I can probably talk about Elves in all formats or just High-End casual EDH.

I've been playing magic casually since I was 10 or 11. I took a hiatus when I was 13-14 when a "friend" stole my collection. I started up again super casually around the age of 16-17 playing Magic Duels on Xbox with a couple friends, until I was about 19 and I found a serious group willing to play competitively, we played modern for about 2 years until it became too repetitive and expensive to buy different decks. We slowly switched to commander for something more casual and fun until that group slowly moved on. I'm definitely the rules guru for our group and that has helped me learn a lot about the game. Now I just brew for the fun of it, been out of the game for so long and missed so much that I honestly know less than newer players.

Edit: Getting back into magic and seeing the state of newer players, I'd say I'm pretty well off lmao.

EDH: 5 color superfriends Super Duper Super Friends, Blackless goodstuff Welcome to the Circus of Value!

EDH: Blackless goodstuff Welcome to the Circus of Value!, WURG Doctors Doctor? Doctor Who?, Grixis Armies Army of Sauron

I've created a goal for myself I want to build (and eventually own) an EDH deck of every color combo from Colorless to WUBRG.

Hello, I'm Kai of the future, if you're reading this you're probably thinking "This is the 32 deck challenge you're just a copycat" and I would like you to know this has been my idea and posted here, long before some rando Youtuber dubbed it the 32 deck challenge.

Here's the list:

Colorless: Karn, Silver Golem Artifact tribal

Mono-White: Sram, Senior Edificer Equipment Voltron | You are Over-Encumbered

Mono-Blue: Talrand, Sky Summoner Creatureless spells | The Oprah Winfrey of Spells

Mono-Black: Ghoulcaller Gisa Zombie tribal

Mono-Red: Orthion, Hero of Lavabrink Jank

Mono-Green: Azusa, Lost but Seeking Rampy stompy | Big Dumb Idiots

Azorius: Either Grand Arbiter Augustin IV Stax

Dimir: Phenax, God of Deception Mill | huMILLiation

Rakdos: Juri, Master of the Revue Treasure

Gruul: Atarka, World Render Dragons

Selesnya: Bess, Soul Nourisher Tokens

Orzhov: Athreos, God of Passage Shadowborn Apostle

Izzet: Jhoira of the Ghitu Big spells

Golgari: Lathril, Blade of the Elves Elf tribal

Boros: Firesong and Sunspeaker or Rem Karolus, Stalwart Slayer Burn or Aurelia, the Law Above Goad

Simic: Aesi, Tyrant of Gyre Strait or Tatyova, Benthic Druid Landfall

Esper: Tivit, Seller of Secrets Voting

Grixis: Nekusar, the Mindrazer Groupslug

Jund: Kresh the Bloodbraided hidden commander Korvold, the Fae-Cursed King Sac

Naya: Bruse Tarl, Boorish Herder + Kamahl, Heart of Krosa Extra combat

Bant: Tuvasa the Sunlit Enchantress

Abzan: Bilbo, Birthday Celebrant Lifegain soul sister

Jeskai: Gavi, Nest Warden Cycling | Pentacycle

Sultai: Muldrotha, the Gravetide Graveyard

Mardu: Mr. House, President and CEO Dice

Temur: Averna, the Chaos Bloom Cascade

I actually don't care about 4 color decks



Ink-Treader: Aragorn, the Uniter legends tribal | Welcome to the Circus of Value! and Kynaios and Tiro of Meletis Grouphug

Witch-Maw: Atraxa, Grand Unifier Flicker


Wooburg: The Prismatic Bridge  Flip Creatureless planeswalker | Super-Duper Superfriends!

Please login to comment

indieinside Sorry it took me so long to get back to you, kinda read it, got busy, and forgot lol. Unfortunately though, I don't have a great answer for you, I haven't had the chance to play it yet. Getting cards for TCGplayer is like pulling healthy teeth from a conscious tigers mouth.

Goldfishing though, it plays like a politics deck, you don't get off to a very fast start, you'd likely need convince other players you're not a threat or threaten like you have some sort of answer in your hand to an attack, use your counterspells very conservatively, countering anything that wins the game for other people or anything that would destroy your field in the beginning. Then switch to an aggressive plan once there's two people at low life or it's a 1v1. That's my assessment just from goldfishing though plus, I'm also building with weird deck restrictions, so take my opinion on it with a grain of salt.

The deck would obviously be stronger if you don't build like an idiot like myself, cards like Consecrated Sphinx and other creatures make the deck much better. It's been pretty consistent in terms of land drops, card draw, and pumping out tokens.

February 24, 2024 5:56 a.m.

Said on If an attacking …...


Since all blocking, or attacking, creatures must assign combat damage equal to their power, unless it's zero,(510.1a) they will all do Damage to Rona, since all combat damage happens simultaneously(510.2) she won't die until all combat damage has been dealt and state based actions are checked.

Since the former was your answer, your final question isn't relevant but, to answer it anyway, you need to assign lethal damage to each creature before assigning damage to another.(510.1c)

February 15, 2024 1:14 p.m.

You would get a total of 3 cascades, each instance of cascade is it's own trigger therefore you can only copy one.

Edit: 702.85c "If a spell has multiple instances of cascade, each triggers separately."

February 15, 2024 12:23 p.m. Edited.


Commander / EDH - Casual, Modern - Elves, Commander / EDH - Theme/Gimmick

MTG Decks

Reptiles of the Atmosphere

Commander / EDH BarfQuackers



Commander / EDH* BarfQuackers


Rith, the Tokener

Commander / EDH BarfQuackers


You are Over-Encumbered | Equipment Voltron

Commander / EDH* BarfQuackers


Welcome to the Circus of Value!

Commander / EDH BarfQuackers


Super-Duper Superfriends!

Commander / EDH* BarfQuackers


Finished Decks 39
Prototype Decks 24
Drafts 0
Playing since Ninth Edition
Points 321
Avg. deck rating 15.75
T/O Rank 45
Helper Rank 144
Favorite formats Modern, Commander / EDH, Casual
Cards suggested / good suggestions 66 / 46
Cards Added/Fixed 1
Joined 9 years
MTGO Username Suiciidebring3r