Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

wiedzmin on Pauper Boggarts

1 week ago

Good point. But Boggart Birth Rite can return Warren Weirding and Nameless Inversion, so it's more universal.

StarfireAlpha on Sandy Sapphire Juju

1 week ago

Here's a two years late answer (just getting back into Magic), but Sands of Time will prevent any permanents from phasing back in due to a lack of Untap phase. The deck aims to lock down the opponent and then win through Misers' Cage, Suq'Ata Firewalker, or, failing all of that, mill.

butter83 on Tappedout Phone App

1 week ago

Same here

PlushPotato on Tappedout Phone App

1 week ago

Im not sure if I missed something, but randomly yesterday my app stopped functioning and now will not let me login? Im not sure if this is the right spot for this so please correct me if I am wrong! Thanks!

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

1 week ago

Vivien, Beholding Bolas

Legendary Planeswalker - Vivien

+2 Dragon spells and Bolas spells you cast this turn cost less to cast.

+1 Target dragon you control deals damage equal to its power to any target.

-8 You get an emblem with "Whenever you activate an ability of a dragon or bolas permanent or whenever an ability of a dragon or bolas permanent you control triggers, you may copy that ability. You may choose new targets for the copy".

Vivien can be your commander.

4


Imagine a Vivien who, upon Skalla's destruction, didn't turn to hate towards Bolas, but instead started glorifying him. This is how she might be.


Repeat or wild.

Wormple12 on Card creation challenge

1 week ago

Endrek Sahr, Creator of Life

Legendary Creature - Human Wizard

Whenever a non-token creature dies, create a 1/1 black Thrull creature token.

Whenever a non-token creature would be put into a graveyard, you may sacrifice X Thrulls where X is the mana value of that creature. If you do, return that creature to the battlefield under it's owner's control.

3/3


A version of Endrek Sahr who would use his necromancy and flesh-sculpting for the good of the realm, mending the wounds of his allies at the last possible minute with the help of mindless thrulls.

Repeat!

capwner on That's "Treasure Hunter!"

1 week ago

How the h*ck did you know we were going to get final fantasy commanders 5 years ago

Scion of Primal Hunter on Pauper Boggarts

1 week ago

Your creatures' CMC is max 3, have you thought about using Unearth instead of Boggart Birth Rite?

skyland on Don't blink Abuelo

1 week ago

yeah i know... its the difference between my troll casual braket 0.1 decks and a good deck like yours, i just wanted to share my war barge/abuelo combo with a random stranger before i went to bed last night.

dudeanonymous on Don't blink Abuelo

1 week ago

While I appreciate the use of an obscure card like war barge, it does seem far too mana inefficient to use.

sirbar on How Did Dragonstorm Not Fit …

1 week ago

It honestly doesn't work with anything in standard to warrant a main set reprint. Stormscale Scion could just fit in a dragon deck and have the storm ability only be relevant in the late game while also being used in an actual "dragonstorm" deck. Dragonstorm could have been a cool special guests reprint, but I'm not surprised that it wasn't included into the main set.

legendofa on $1 Control EDH. One US …

1 week ago

rwn1971 I like the suggestion, I always had fun with Sleep, but it's right at the top of the budget curve. Let's see if I can fit it in somewhere.

rwn1971 on $1 Control EDH. One US …

1 week ago

Ooooh i love this deck. How about Sleep ?

ArantirTheDestroyer on The Mythical Go-Wide Voltron Deck

1 week ago

mtgApprentice21, just so you know, I have transitioned over to Moxfield for posting my decks online. Two reasons: 1, I do not believe Tappedout decks appear on EDHrec; and 2, I like their UI a lot better.

Most of my decks are not there, because I have actually disassembled many of them for redesigning, but if you want to see up-to-date versions of the decks I do have active currently, that's the place to look.

Here's my profile page there.

capwner on Pre-fire and 2015 Modern formats?

1 week ago

Just wanted to circle back and see if yeaGO had a chance to look at this.

Is there any possibility of having the prefire and 2015 formats added since both variants are somewhat played?

Murrow on Red Rum (Dredge)

1 week ago

jonjonhholt oh I like the idea of Oliphaunt and Dwarven Mine! I was wondering how else we could tinker with this deck! Sick, I shall experiment haha. And do you run less then 16 lands? I'll have to peak your list if you have it on here haha. And yeah I'd like to run a couple more dredgers, Golgari Brownscale is a pet card of mine, but am having trouble finding space, I could cut the Fiery Temper but I'm rather partial to them and having some removal so I'm not sure lol. Thanks for the suggestions! I've got some tinkerin to do now lol.

And thanks btw

jonjonhholt on Red Rum (Dredge)

1 week ago

DragonMaster420, just to tag on as someone who has played a lot of this deck, i dont even run the Conduit Pylons. I get the desire to hard cast cards like snacker but adding the necessary support for that reduces the decks consistency, which is one of its strong suits imo. The deck is actually really good at getting in chip damage with Masked Meower, Molten Gatekeeper, etc so usually you dont need to deal all 20 with the giant but I think you would be surprised how easy it is to get 20 creatures in the gy with stinkweed imp. Also I would say <5% of games I actually run into scenarios where I want to be hard-casting the black cards in the deck. And if you look at the versions of red dredge that are going 5-0 in mtgo pauper leagues they are almost all mono-red

Murrow i like this list, personally I enjoy running 5-6 dredge cards, obviously nothing comes close to Stinkweed Imp but Golgari Brownscale gives you some lifegain where as Greater Mossdog gives you an extra dredge compared to the brownscale. Also, I like running 4 Oliphaunt in place of some of the mountains for a higher creature count to help Lotleth Giant hit harder. Plus you can sneak in a single copy of Dwarven Mine thats tutorable with the Oliphaunt for an extra body to sac to Dread Return but that definitely isnt vital

tie95 on Hugs for All

1 week ago

谢谢你,我很喜欢这套卡组

DopeyTheCat on Ulalek, Fused Atrocity Upgraded

1 week ago

Thanks for the suggestions GAMEBOY1234! I'll look into adding these cards!

clayperce on List of Bugs and Feature …

1 week ago

Femme_Fatale -
Ummmm, because I didn't know it existed, lol!

Mox Diamond P
Cool!

I just might be blind, but I looked for and did not see it on the Formatting tips page. Could we maybe add it, in the Tagging Cards section?

Thank you for the tip, and cheers!

Femme_Fatale on List of Bugs and Feature …

1 week ago

clayperce why not use the existing proxy flag? Mox Diamond P.

Murrow on Red Rum (Dredge)

1 week ago

DragonMaster420 I didn't invent this deck. It's an established archetype in the pauper format. Just look up mono red dredge in pauper and you'll see. There are plenty of YouTube videos. And yes I've played the deck it's quite effective.

And there are other variants of the deck. Hell I've built plenty of versions. But I like the simplicity of the mono red version.

magwaaf on How Did Dragonstorm Not Fit …

1 week ago

They remember all the havoc I wreaked on standard magic back in the day with that card so they didn't want to reprint it again

DreadKhan on Phyrexian Nightmare

1 week ago

Whenever I see a deck like this I can't help but feel like (especially since you are on Underground Seas anyways) Dark Ritual would feel really good, if you want something to cut to test a couple out I'd pull Trickbind in a second, sticking a Turn 1 Dreadnaught sometimes is a LOT better than sticking one turn 3, so much so that it'd be worth a mulligan to try and hit Illusionary Mask and Dreadnaught with a Dark Ritual.

This looks more interesting to play than Modern Death Shadow family lists ever were!

DragonMaster420 on Red Rum (Dredge)

1 week ago

have you actually tested this? you're being awful condescending about a combo that isn't winning you the game. it's unlikely the giant deals 20 damage with it's etb all at once, and i just don't see you being able to sacrifice 6 total creatures to Dread Return it a 2nd time. all i'm suggesting is that you add some dual lands.

Rhadamanthus on Do I keep it?

1 week ago

Bobby654: An answer to your question has been up for a while. Since there don't seem to be any follow-ups or corrections that need to be made, I marked it as the "Accepted answer" so this topic can move out of the list of unanswered questions. In the future you can take care of this yourself using the "Mark as Answer" button on the response that you feel is the most helpful answer to your question.

I try to avoid selecting my own responses when I do this, but in this case it was the only option.

Rhadamanthus on Does Shabraz trigger when phased …

1 week ago

Sqeeze: An answer to your question has been up for a while. Since there don't seem to be any follow-ups or corrections that need to be made, I marked it as the "Accepted answer" so this topic can move out of the list of unanswered questions. In the future you can take care of this yourself using the "Mark as Answer" button on the response that you feel is the most helpful answer to your question.

I try to avoid selecting my own responses when I do this, but in this case it was the only option.

skyland on Don't blink Abuelo

1 week ago

And here I am spending 10 mana to kill things with War Barge

clayperce on Goth Girl Tribal

1 week ago

If you ever do a Golgari version: Belbe, Corrupted Observer

Cheers!

jaggers on Lucy, Best Waifu

1 week ago

removed Elesh Norn MOM because it does not work the way you would want it to

Removed Thalia (the noncreature costs 1 more) because of synergy. It worker against me. More synergy for producing tokens needed instead.

Just proxy t-pro and smothering

Murrow on Red Rum (Dredge)

1 week ago

DragonMaster420 lmfao okay buddy