Manabarbs

Legality

Format Legality
Tiny Leaders Legal
Noble Legal
Leviathan Legal
Magic Duels Legal
Canadian Highlander Legal
Vintage Legal
Modern Legal
Penny Dreadful Legal
Custom Legal
Vanguard Legal
Legacy Legal
Archenemy Legal
Planechase Legal
1v1 Commander Legal
Duel Commander Legal
Oathbreaker Legal
Unformat Legal
Casual Legal
Commander / EDH Legal

Printings View all

Set Rarity
2012 Core Set (M12) Rare
2010 Core Set (M10) Rare
Tenth Edition (10E) Rare
Classic Sixth Edition (6ED) Rare
Fifth Edition (5ED) Rare
Fourth Edition (4ED) Rare
4th Edition Foreign Black Border (4EDFBB) Rare
Revised Edition (3ED) Rare
Revised Foreign Black Border (3EDFBB) Rare
Unlimited Edition (2ED) Rare
Collector's Edition (CED) Rare
International Collector's Edition (CEI) Rare
Limited Edition Beta (LEB) Rare
Limited Edition Alpha (LEA) Rare

Combos Browse all

Manabarbs

Enchantment

Whenever a player taps a land for mana, Manabarbs deals 1 damage to that player.

Manabarbs Discussion

SynergyBuild on cEDH Boros (RW) needs more ...

3 weeks ago

Let me go through your points.

  1. xD What? cEDH doesn't make you win by turn 3? Most lists can't do that, midrange combo like Kess Turns and Yisan lists aim for turns 4-5ish and use a mix of removal and hate to stop faster opponents. Control/Stax decks from Control Zur, Blood Pod, or Derevi win much later, after locking out faster combo opponents with permission, removal, stax, and hate.

It is true you need to be affecting the board state in a heavy way by turn three, but you definitely do not need to win by then.

  1. Wrong, Boros does have efficient infinite combos that do not need to spend a long amount of time to physically go through each trigger, such as the popular cEDH Aurelia, the Warleader + Helm of the Host list, using a stax-core for the list, as well as an abundance of tutors, such as Steelshaper's Gift or Stoneforge Mystic to set up the combo.

Another popular competitive viable Boros combo was using Imperial Recruiter with Recruiter of the Guard , to fetch Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker , to copy the Recruiter of choice to fetch Combat Celebrant or Village Bell-Ringer to go infinite with Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker .

Point is, Boros always had good win conditions that went infinite and were effectively 1-card combos too, (Just need Helm + Commander or Recruiter+what it tutors for in deck) for what it is worth.

  1. Aurelia, being a strong combo-enabler also happens to remove the argument that prior to Feather, WotC only made bad commanders that only revolve around creature-beatdown strategies or dumb tribal shenanigans.

Gisela was often used in conjunction with effects like Manabarbs for a stax-lockdown deck, Firesong and Sunspeaker is a burn-lifegain deck, very spell-focused, Brion Stoutarm was a list based around sacrifice and recursion, with lifegain synergies to boot, etc.

After this you say that "BOROS HAS YET TO DO THAT", referring to non-combat commander support, again I look to Gisela, Firesong/Sunspeaker, and Brion.


Then you bring up that tier 1 lists always go off turn 3 and you can't be competitive without that, again, BS, Yisan, Teferi, and Sisay and tier 1 decks, of which two are stax-combo hybrids that often go the stax-y control route and Yisan is midrange-y, etc.

Then you go into the 5 things you want to do to get this deck where you want. I don't see why as Aurelia is a tier 3 cEDH list anyway, but who cares.

  1. All commander decks need to be 100 cards exactly anyway to be a commander deck, this is not specific to cEDH.

  2. No, many people build budgeted cEDH decks, but just like any competitive event for standard, modern, legacy, vintage, and pauper, playing a budgeted variant will lose you games. Also, many players to do accept the use of proxies, and in competitive EDH tournaments or side events and Grand Prix's, or now Magic Fests, you can be disqualified for using proxies.

  3. That is not a rule of cEDH, while it isn't a bad suggestion, it is not necessary for the vast majority of faster combo decks, that only need to protect their combo, or for stax decks with hate that can stop threats before they are cast, or stop them from being cast, well before having a removal or counterspell up is necessary.

  4. I would suggest the old Helm of Obedience / Rest in Peace combo for the deck or a Kiki-Jiki package to play with. Running Rest in Peace as graveyard hate is often useful enough to warrant inclusion in any cEDH white list not aiming on using the graveyard for itself, and this list shouldn't so recursion based.

  5. Wrong, not that Boros has great effects, it does, but the arrogance in saying that nobody knows them is astounding to me xD.

After this you make it sound like there is a mob of cEDH players who say Boros is "forbidden". I have only heard that word said in cEDH as a reference to Forbidden Orchard xD.

Then you complain about infinite creature combos stopping you from having fun, and claim Azathoth from the Lovecraftian pantheon is the most powerful media character (must never have heard of SCP-3812), and ramble on about inane things.


Then you actually go crazy. Not about Boros, not about anything else mtg related, you literally claim you are "The only person willing to help on Earth." No joke, read it. Lunatic.

Starts quoting some BS after that, and immediately goes into talking about cuts for the list. Actually, this concerns me for BMHKain's mental health. This is some deeply disturbing stuff.

Then goes into quoting something about Tokyo, and apologizes for having some of the really weird stuff throughout.


Okay, wtf was that. You start by going on some factually incorrect assumptions about cEDH, then all Boros commanders, then all Boros combos, then on basic EDH rules like having 100 cards... then you go off the deep end, and ask about cutting cards.

hkhssweiss on hkhssweiss

3 weeks ago

Yo MLGSavageBoy, you can make it work it won't be the greatest of decks, but with Zozu you can make it more of a group hate type of deck that punishes people. Cards like Stranglehold , Manabarbs , War's Toll , Ankh of Mishra . Oh and don't forget about Blood Moon as well! I can see it working adding in a sub theme of lifegain but yeah go for it!

mrfab13 on Tap those lands

1 month ago

if you want full jank Oblivion Ring a Manabarbs then cast Worldfire and eventually draw a Memnite

Odysseus_97 on The Political Palace of Paliano

1 month ago

DrukenReaps: Ooh, that looks like a deck i need to give a good look :) Very nice suggestions, some of them might get a home here. What are your experiences with the cards: Luminarch Ascension & Bloodchief Ascension ?

How much does Manabarbs punish you compared to your opponents?

Interesting thoughts about Polluted Bonds , i think i will add it, and then after some playtesting make my decision :)

Thank you so much for the feedback.

DrukenReaps on The Political Palace of Paliano

1 month ago

Wow, seems like you want to do a deck very similar to my own. I focused pretty hard on pillowfort and punishment. Please take a look at the deck itself, Divine Decree, but I'll list some of my all stars. Hope it helps.

Pillows- Ajani Steadfast , Glacial Chasm , Kazuul, Tyrant of the Cliffs , Luminarch Ascension , Solitary Confinement

Bleeders- Bloodchief Ascension , Manabarbs , Sorin Markov , Tainted Remedy

I don't think I suggested any you already have but my bad if I did. I will also say I played Zo-Zu the Punisher for awhile but found it highly underwhelming as a card in the 99 any time it came into the game after turn 6 or so and too aggressive if it came out early... I suspect Polluted Bonds will end up the same way unless you are up against landfall decks.

frosthammer_eden on Nicapirate

2 months ago

Since this isn't a commander deck don't be afraid to put more that one or two of the same card into your deck. You could definitely take out certain cards that don't fit your deck at all or have no purpose such as Manabarbs and Chromatic Lantern

Load more

Manabarbs occurrence in decks from the last year

Commander / EDH:

All decks: 0.01%

Red: 0.16%

Rakdos: 0.2%