Holier than thou
Legacy
SCORE: 6 | 12 COMMENTS | 1625 VIEWS | IN 3 FOLDERS
Streamlined —Aug. 27, 2018
I've made additions and explanations have been reflected in the main deck deceptions. I haven't seen any new cards since Tarkir block, so while searching for new Commander spells I came across Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim. I also have an urge to replace a few things to throw in Dark Supplicant + Scion of Darkness to be spiteful.
Thank you very much. I used to play this deck around getting the Scion in play. I haven't played casual vintage in a long time and was excited when I discovered disciple of grislebrand . Other cards I want for the deck are Enlightened Tutor and Marsh Flats. The side board is pretty random.
November 13, 2014 12:38 p.m.
You're welcome, glad I could help. It really good and I hope everything goes well.
November 13, 2014 12:43 p.m.
Hi Se7enfoot... Thanks for your comment on my B/W Clerics deck.
I have several suggestions for your deck, but before I present to you let me first address your comment.
Although your deck is B/W like the one you commented on, they meant to be different. Yours is a hybrid between life-gain deck and an aggro deck. Mine is meant to be exclusively aggro.
I have a hybrid life-gain aggro cleric deck, white the Daru Spiritualist and Shuko combo, but it is mono-white - have a look : http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/protection-clerics/?cb=1532856807.
Now, about my suggestions:
-
I noticed that you only have four one-mana creatures, coincidentally the Dark Supplicant only. That means that you'll never be able to have Scion of Darkness in the second turn. I would advise to add four one-mana clerics, like Mother of Runes or Soul Warden.
-
I don't see the use of Mikaeus, the Lunarch in a sacrificial deck. Instead, the sacrifices would acvtivate the morbid ability of Skirsdag High Priest. I would advise them instead. Plus, they are cheaper. In a way...
-
The Doomed Necromancer is nice, especially if you want to bring back again a Dark Supplicant and invoke another Scion of Darkness. But if you only have a Scion of Darkness, it is of no use. Put two Scion of Darkness, and one less Doomed Necromancer. Notice that the cost of the Scion of Darkness cycling ability is the same as Doomed Necromancer... so if you ever do not need the Scion in hand, just cycle it...
-
21 lands are not enough lands. I accept minimum 23 lands in a deck, but 24 seems the most adequate. Now, you have 21 lands, where one of them (Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth) gives no mana whatsoever. So, effectively, you have 20 lands. I would replace Urborg with two more useful lands.
-
I think Dark Deal is a dangerous option. It seams like the cards you may have in hand are useless. Why not a Hymn to Tourach instead?
July 29, 2018 8:11 a.m.
@venturub thank you for the constructive comments. Some of my decks have strayed from the overall theme. I once felt that having singleton inclusions of powerful/useful cards would make a difference in some decks, but those cause a player to remove copies of much needed cards. I have made some significant changes while researching the Gatherer database and those changes are now implemented.
August 17, 2018 2:02 p.m.
@Se7enfoot I understand but, Woh, you made a lot of changes in your deck. For the better, although no more Scion of Darkness!
I still have three suggestions:
1) Instead of Lightning Greaves, Shaman en-Kor. Why? Three reasons. Firstly, the casting cost is the same, that is 2. Secondly, Shaman en-Kor ability can be activated as an instant (also during the turn of your opppnent) whereas Lightning Greaves can only be equiped as a sorcery (during your turn only). Thus, if you activate the Shaman ability to boost a cleric toughness with Daru Spiritualist it can serve a defense guy against big monsters, before you sacrifice it for big life. One common mistake, is to think that the Shaman en-Kor ability can not be activated unless it receives damage. That it is not the truth: the Shaman can target a cleric, regardless of whether it received damage: "You can use this ability as much as you want prior to damage being dealt" - . Also, the shaman can redirect damage to itself: "It can redirect damage to itself". Third reason: the Shaman is a Cleric, unlike the Lightning Greaves.
2) Starlit Sanctum instead of Disciple of Griselbrand. Why? Disciple of Griselbrand costs 3 in order for you to use the ability: 2 to cast the creature, plus 1 to use its ability. Starlit Sanctum costs 1. Plus, Starlit Sanctum lets you choose between gaining life or taking life from your opponent, thus complementing the damage of Cabal Archon.
3) You should add one more Test of Endurance. Why? If yours gets destroyed, you will get no second chance to use it again. The more so when you have no Devoted Caretaker or Eight-and-a-Half-Tails in your deck to protect it.
August 17, 2018 7:17 p.m.
Ah, check my Defense Clerics deck : https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/defense-clerics/. Be sure to read well the description. :)
August 17, 2018 7:32 p.m.
I'm going to find copies of Shaman en-Kor, that's a great suggestion. The instant speed ability versus sorcery speed ability is superior and keys the financial cost down.
luisserpa says... #1
I used to have a deck with the same combo, it's very cool and simple to get. A card that could work well is Worthy Cause or Shuko. +1
November 13, 2014 11:02 a.m.