|Commander / EDH||Legal|
Printings View all
|2010 Core Set||Rare|
Combos Browse all
Creature — Elf Shaman
G, Tap: You may put a creature card from your hand onto the battlefield.
Price & Acquistion Set Price Alerts
|Have (10)||HydraOoze , ZombieFood , robbnoble , Sparky41 , moonmonster , CAPT.Shock , ibraJG84 , Big-Foot , switchkill65 , Wiggins|
|Want (4)||xpsychovampx , Lucan2000 , rakdos24 , brokendwarf|
Elvish Piper Discussion
5 days ago
6 days ago
Glissa, the Traitor, Surgical Extraction, Rishkar, Peema Renegade, Gyre Sage, Treasured Find, Golgari Charm, Vines of Vastwood, Shaman of the Pack, Collected Company, Armorcraft Judge, Champion of Lambholt, Maralen of the Mornsong, Gilt-Leaf Palace, Ezuri, Renegade Leader, Elvish Piper, Imperious Perfect, Immaculate Magistrate, Joraga Warcaller, Eternal Witness, Heroic Intervention, Putrefy, Abrupt Decay, Eyeblight Massacre, Smother, and Damnation are all cards you could consider as well.
6 days ago
@KeelHaul10 I do have a primer in the works but wanted to put the deck up to be seen until it is done. SO far this deck has functioned in two ways. Early game aggression with Concordant Crossroads and Elvish Piper shenanigans have won me matches. Heavy board presence as early as turn 3 and 4 has set me to being a target in my play group and thanks to Meren, the only time I dont come back from board wipes is when I am occasionally short on lands (I usually sit on 5 lands and 1 mana rock before winning "early game"). My late game answers speak for themselves but as for combos that I will wait to show in a fully written deck analysis.
1 week ago
I know I posted semi-recently, but I have a new list and want to start some more trades now that I am active again.
I am looking to get cards for a Progenitus Superfriends Deck. I have a bunch of random stuff to offer and am more interested in some cards listed below than others (i.e. I will prioritize Atraxa, certain walkers, and certain lands). I know in some cases it will be hard to make trades but it is worth a shot.
Cards wanted for Superfriends:
Ashiok, Nightmare Weaver
Chandra, Flamecaller (SDCC Version)
Gideon, Champion of Justice
Elspeth, Sun's Champion
Jace, Architect of Thought
Jace, Unraveler of Secrets (SDCC Version preferred)
Kaya, Ghost Assassin
Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker
Nissa, Vital Force
Nissa, Voice of Zendikar (SDCC version)
Ob Nixilis Reignited
Vraska the Unseen
Venser, the Sojourner
Cards of Note:
Force of Will
Loxodon Warhammer Russian
Serum Visions (Other version, not sure how to code)
Sarkhan the Mad
Scion of the Ur-Dragon
Other stuff, some unlisted
1 week ago
Brilliant Ultimatum and Seek the Horizon aren't very good cards, i think you would do just fine without them.
Currently, your deck is all powerful fatties, but it lacks a supporting shell around them: Cards that cheat creatures into play (Elvish Piper, Garruk, Caller of Beasts, Selvala's Stampede), cards that benefit from them (Rishkar's Expertise, Chandra's Ignition), cards that interact with the opposition (Austere Command, Cyclonic Rift, Ashen Rider) and cards that protect you from bad things (Swan Song, Stubborn Denial) seem like they would be helpful.
1 week ago
To be honest, as you have predicted, Elvish Piper is a pretty fragile way to cheap out some big Eldrazi.
Get rid of Vile Redeemer, Seeker of Skybreak (not Modern legal either), Hydra Broodmaster and Prowling Serpopard. More mana ramp could be used, Chord of Calling, Burning-Tree Emissary, Eternal Witness, and Birds of Paradise.
Hope some of that helps!
1 week ago
Made a ramp deck based on getting an eldrazi out by turn 4 with Elvish Piper. Tell me if this is viable with the hexproof stuff green seems to have. Magic newb here looking to be a scrub with this scrub deck. Thanks fam.
BTW - first completely original deck. No intentional plagiarism
1 week ago
I am particularly hard on this deck because I know the builder in person, and he has asked for some help. This is not a comment on a random deck tearing it a new one.
Samut, Voice of Dissent is not the easiest commander to build, because the deck is instantly torn between multiple possible play styles. She is strong enough to be a voltron commander, has the colors to be a general big-beast-beat-down commmander, and an ability that makes you want to play utility. Choosing what you want to focus on and sticking to it is going to be key in building her effectively.
One big problem at the moment is that your deck seems to lack focus. It has some generally good cards, like the Exert creatures, who were practically made to work with Samut, but then it has cards like Elvish Piper and Yisan Chord, while having very few creatures of particular use or great value to cheat out. (How often do you think this deck will have two high cmc creatures in hand to make use of Elvish Piper and Samut in one turn?)
Your creature choices suggest you run a big creature deck, yet you have 3 spells that copy instants and sorceries, with nothing in the deck that needs copying. You run Quicksilver Amulet, any only one creature of cmc 8 or greater. Your deck sifts through its creatures, but very few of them do anything, and a number of them reverse their effects when they leave the battlefield.
What you need to do is focus on how you want to win, not what you want to do or what would go well with your commander. Once you have the focus on that, you can find the cards in that vein that will have synergy with your commander.
There are a lot of cards in this deck that just don't need to be here. Maybe they are around from an earlier deck direction that didn't pan out, maybe some other reason, but as it is, they are generally of less value than many other cards could be.
Soul Warden and Essence Warden. This is not a particularly creature heavy deck. You currently have 30, and little to no token production. These cards do not have tap abilities, and so have no synergy with your commander, and your deck as a whole doesn't require a lot of life to function. It's two card slots for minimal life gain, which is a function separate from the deck as a whole.
Ranger of Eos. This card is strictly dedicated to fetching the two above-mentioned cards. It does not have a verity of targets, it does not benefit from untapping. It does not have significant combat value, and ultimately little value to the deck as a whole.
Banisher Priest and Fiend Hunter. These are just weak removal spells. They only target creatures, and they only temporarily remove them. They don't interact with Samut, and they can't be used for combat purposes since they return the exiled cards upon death. They also grant your opponents a stronger board state post-wipe.
Reiterate, Reverberate, and Increasing Vengeance. This is not an instant/sorcery deck. This is not a control deck. Sure, these are good for controlling blue decks, but again, not a control deck. If you want to go that direction, you have to dedicate more resources to it, otherwise, you're spreading yourself too thin and overall weakening your deck. Remember, you need to be building towards your win condition, your endgame, otherwise you end up with a deck that can delay someone else's, but without a goal of its own. (Which is essentially what this deck seems to do)
The Primordals. Not bad cards, but not that great. Not particularly on theme with the deck. Their abilities have situational uses, so they are cards that you hold in hand until needed, not cards that you cheat in early. They don't benefit from your commander's ability, nor do they contribute to her combat capabilities. They have ok bodies, but as far as big creatures are concerned, there are far better for the cost. Molten Primordial especially, since your current build isn't a rush deck, and you don't have many sac effects, his one-time swing won't be particularly game changing.
Viridian Shaman. Why? It's half a Naturalize on a weak body for more mana. I could see this in an Animar deck, where casting creatures gains you additional benefits, but this deck gains nothing from weak bodies. He neither contributes to Samut, nor does he benefit from her ability. This card is actually a prime example of why this deck doesn't work. "Too much for too little." Card slots dedicated to minor contro/removal aspects, with no advancement towards your own victory.
I'm gonna stop there. A lot of cards don't work in this deck, and as you said, this deck doesn't work. I'm not trying to be mean, I know I'm coming down hard, but hopefully these examples emphasize the core of what's wrong with this deck. I'd suggest a redesign towards a more focused approach with your end game in mind.
Better tap abilities should be included if you want to make the most of your commander's utility ability. Cards like Mother of Runes, Mangara of Corondor, and Intrepid Hero have abilities that are easy to reuse and will actually gain you value to use multiple times in a turn.
If you want to continue the cheating in mentality, big creatures that actually pose a threat, and/or empower your commander should be included. Stonehoof Chieftain is a perfect example of the cards you should be looking for for this style. By itself it's an 8/8 Indestructible with Trample. That's a threat, hard to remove. Instant boardstate. Additionally, however, it gives Indestructible and Trample to your commander, (as well as any other attacking creatures), advancing you towards a commander damage win.
Elesh Norn, Grand Cenobite buffs your commander, the rest of your field, and is a soft wipe to your opponents. And the buff synergizes well with your commander's Double Strike.
Avacyn, Angel of Hope is a fantastic cheat in. That said, you're in green. I prefer ramp to cheating in creatures as it is. But I will not deny the potential of tapping Elvish Piper twice, so long as you have useful cards to put in with her.
My point is that you need to find things that serve an ongoing purpose to your boardstate. If you're going big creatures, find some that work together, as well as stand alone. Think of them in conjunction to your commander, and ask what value they will have together, continuing, and towards the end of the game. During a match, you are always pushing towards the win. During deckbuilding, that same mentality should be applied.