Im curious how you feel about dusk urchins in the deck for the card draw? it keeps getting -1/-1 and would come back, also a good thing to sac if you get a -1/-1 on it.

jgross18: Only works if Mikaeus is already in play, and if Mikaeus is already in play you hopefully have better things to do than a blocker that doesn't die!

12 votes in a day, what happened?

Either way, I want it to keep on happening more often!

I have decided to make a new version of this deck in between $100-200 since that may actually be relevant for people to use as deckbuilding inspiration. I will warn you ahead of time though, the decklist above us here has seen extensive playtesting to get into the form it is today (Probably like half the deck has been swapped out from the original), while the deck(s) I am making now are just "first editions" of how I would try to make my deck IF I were to upgrade it, so I won't be playtesting it and it won't be perfect!

Maybe one with "no budget" just to show you how it would look if I made it with zero restrictions (Would probably be at $2000 or so then.)

Well done. Claps hands +1

Can't wait to see it

Could someone please explain to me how cards like Pith Driller make infinite combo's with mikaeus and a sac outlet.

Clipster: Pith Driller puts the -1/-1 counter on itself, and since +1/+1 counters and -1/-1 counters nullify each other, he is left without any counters and can trigger undying again.

Ok thank you, I was just wondering if the counters cancelled out which it seems they do. Awesome deck btw +1

Pentavus seems like a good fit for this deck

Really awesome deck!I have a budget infi combo deck that's Modern instead of EDH, but here it is.Abzan Good Stuff by Zookyzook

How do you feel about Curse of Death's Hold? It shuts down aggro and tokens...

What cards would you remove from the original deck for Necropotence, Contamination, Blood Artist, Liliana of the Dark Realms, Life's Finale, and Engineered Plague? Also, would you add Falkenrath Noble in addition to Blood Artist?

Wow what a deck I love edh but the only decks I could afford were the store bought ones I built this deck but added grinding station and alter of dementia from the maybe bored going to my first edh tourney soon! Ty so much!

Great deck, however just so you know while yeah the +1/+1 and -1/-1 counters will cancel each other on your creatures, for the undying check it does still have a +1/+1 counter on it so undying will not trigger.

From the rulings on Undying: Undying relies on the last known information about the permanent just before it was put into a graveyard. If that permanent had a +1/+1 counter on it, then receives enough -1/-1 counters for it to be put into a graveyard due to having 0 toughness or lethal damage marked on it, it won't return to the battlefield despite the state-based action of +1/+1 counters and -1/-1 counters "cancelling each other out". As the permanent last existed on the battlefield, it had a +1/+1 counter on it, so undying will not trigger.

I'm surprised to not see some of the more basic tutors here. Such as Diabolic Tutor, Diabolic Revelation, or even Diabolic Intent because of it's sac outlet.

Legendary_Jack: 121.3. If a permanent has both a +1/+1 counter and a -1/-1 counter on it, N +1/+1 and N -1/-1 countersare removed from it as a state-based action, where N is the smaller of the number of +1/+1 and -1/-1counters on it.

So it does work since the +1/+1 counters are removed from the creature as a state based action before undying has a chance to trigger.

Magic: The Gathering Comprehensive Rules

fenriskiba Yeah I knew about that, I just checked with a judge I know and we're both right, but I was mistaken in that if the -1/-1 counters cause the death of something with Undying and a +1/+1 counter on it in the same instance as they're applied (e.g. Black Sun's Zenith) then it will not return because all state based actions are checked at once and it will still have a +1/+1 counter on it at that point, so yeah sorry my bad.

DaitokujiAmnael: Diabolic Tutor is in the deck! The other two I don't run due to mana cost (Diabolic Revelation) and pricing (Diabolic Intent at $7).

Most "generic" tutors are really expensive!

Hey im not sure if anyone still reads these comments, but i was actually looking into this commander and this looks like an amazing budget build(this is so perfect for me, thank you for posting!) I have a few of the upgrade cards, and i was wondering what cards i should take out for these?Cabal CoffersLiliana of the dark realmsperilous vaultblack sun's zeniththran dynamogilded lotusunderworld connectionsbeseech the queendecree of painsadistic sacramentdiabolic revelationincreasing ambitionswiftfoot bootsThanks for any and all help guys! I am new to the commander format and wanted to get into mono black and this looks like a ton of fun! Also, sorry if my formatting for the comment is not correct, i am new to this website! Thanks y'all!

@Sleazebag I would definitely try Retribution of the Ancients. It costs only one mana to remove all your undying counters. Even if you don't have that much mana you always can use one or 2 mana to get a few sac + come into play abilities. This card rocks with undying!

666 votes...

So evil. So dark.

Sorry about my last comment guys! The format went weird. Would someone please advise me on those cards?

Buwalda: I'm currently working on a new deck with some improvements and suggestions, it's a WIP and I've been busy lately (and now it's vacation) but it will come around soon.

On another note, lots of people have asked the same questions, I recommend you look through the comment history (All the "reset discussion updates") and look for others who got advice!

Thanks man! If i posted a decklist with my own changes, could you look at it and see if it would be good? I'm very new to EDH and i would love some assistance!

Buwalda: That's easily doable!