THALIA!

We have a creature heavy deck and Thalia, Guardian of Thraben is perfect against non creature heavy decks and a really good 1W creature with first strike.

Thalia, Guardian of Thraben for sure. Crushing Vines is a good card as well, but we really need as many decent, cheap creatures as we can get right now, and Thalia fills that niche perfectly.

I think Thalia is better for constructed than limited, but she still has value.

Crushing Vines is an underrated card, but there's a 50/50 shot it'll wheel.

Fling + Elder of Laurels could be impressive, but it requires many creatures and too much mana.

I still like Forge Devil. He's such a cuddly little guy.

I'll stop my contrarian ways and vote for Thalia, Guardian of Thraben this time. First strike with our pump spells makes for happy aggro antics. Her spell tax ability could bite us in the rump, but there's good odds it will hurt opponents more.

Take Thalia, Guardian of Thraben now. The pack is good enough that we'll see something we like the next time it comes around. Her first strike is her most valuable ability in limited, no doubt.

It's a shame Lingering Souls won't table. But Thalia, Guardian of Thraben is good beats. Take the first striker.

Thalia, Guardian of Thraben FTW

Thalia, Guardian of Thraben is a really nice find for us.

I think going over the top with evasion is going to be better even than a first striker... which is why my vote is for Lingering Souls even w/ out the ability to flash it back. Lots of flying little dorks can get very lethal very quickly.

That said if this was a draft where you keep what you open then i would be more interested in the money card and taking Thalia, Guardian of Thraben.

Looks like Thalia has overwhelming support. Moving along.