Fa'adiyah Seer questions.
Asked by BruhYouFarted 3 years ago
If I activate Fa'adiyah Seer's ability with Abundance on the battlefield, could I activate Abundance naming Land to guarantee the draw, or is it considered a different card and the "reveal clause" doesn't activate? If we do the Abundance thing again but I choose Non-Land, will I always have to discard that card? What happens when I use the Fa'adiyah Seer to dredge a Stinkweed Imp? Do I dredge it and then immediately discard it?
BruhYouFarted says... #2
So if I choose Non-Land with Abundance, I can keep the card without revealing/discarding it?
May 3, 2022 9:04 p.m.
You reveal it for Abundance to confirm that it's a nonland, but you don't reveal it for Fa'adiyah Seer, nor do you discard it.
May 3, 2022 9:32 p.m.
Sorry yes, you do have to reveal from Abundance, but that's because it's the replacement effect of Abundance that's making you reveal what you're putting into your hand. The Seer doesn't make you reveal anything if the draw gets replaced.
Yesterday says... Accepted answer #1
From gatherer: "If the draw is replaced by another effect, none of the rest of Fa'adiyah Seer's ability applies, even if the draw is replaced by another draw (such as with Enduring Renewal)."
You just get the replacement effect. No need or opportunity to reveal or discard the card that you put into your hand this way.
May 3, 2022 8:30 p.m.