Waking Nightmare

Enchantment - Aura curse

Enchant Player

Whenever you play a land or cast a spell, lose 2 life. Whenever you draw a card except for the first time each turn, lose 2 life.

If you have cast at least two spells this turn, you may roll a 6 sided die. If you roll a 1-4, nothing happens. If you roll a 5-6, transform Waking Nightmare and return it to the battlefield under your control.

False Reality

You cannot play more than one spell each turn.

Whenever a creature you control would attack an opponent, that creature attacks a random player instead. If four or more creatures you control attack, you may transform False Reality.

"They told me the nightmare was over, they told me I was awake over, and over, and over again - But I knew I was still asleep, still trapped."

So I have chronic nightmares, and all I could think about was what it is like to be trapped in a nightmare when your (near sentiently evil) nightmare constantly tries to convince you you are awake. The regular nightmare is so much less scary than the nightmare of order that tries to convince you you are awake.

Create a mono white nightmare card.

Imo, if every color had access to counterspells, the game would stall more frequently and be a more boring/less active game. Mark Rosewater talks a lot about why they utilize the color pie, and aside from themes and mechanics one of the driving ideas is to keep the game fun and engaging. If every color did everything, the game itself would be less fun and engaging, and I'd argue deckbuilding would be the same. I also really liked what FormOverFunction said - not every color may have word for word counterspells but each color has its own access to counterplay, removal, etc.

Ashmkiz, Giver of Form

Legendary Creature - Angel Ooze Elemental

Flying

You may have Ashmkiz, Giver of Forms enter the battlefield as a copy of any target creature except it has Ashmkiz's other abilities.

Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield, you gain one life.

: Populate. Activate this ability only once each turn.

3/3

"Ashmkiz is a child of the leylines, they are pure life and pure mana. Around them, the world is as transient as Ashmkiz itself."

If anyone has been here for a while and is seeing my umpteenth version of a bant populate commander, I'm sorry but I will never stop lol. The blue in their color identity operates as a clone but it also gives you much more power/flexibility when using cards like Cackling Counterpart which make token copies of your own creatures. I want a commander like this so bad but I don't think WOTC will ever give me one ):

Continue the challenge

Ulexies, Mage of Bounty

Legendary Creature - Aven Druid

Flying

At the beginning of combat each turn, you may give target creature Myriad until end of turn.

Whenever a creature token you control deals combat damage to a player, draw a card.

2/3

I want a Bant Myriad commander so bad! Continue the challenge or Wildcard

Crow_Umbra I haven't had a chance to playtest Wake the Dead yet but I have always wanted to find a good home for Inkshield so I'll have to test it and see how it plays, great suggestions as always.

Afterlife Insurance and Ophiomancer are at the top of my switch in list, as of now I'm on the side of extra fodder because the decks needs a lot to work. Your Gorgussy deck was also great inspo for some exciting group drain triggers!

Crow_Umbra Only deck I've made recently that I have also really enjoyed playing. Always love your sagely feedback :3

Charismatic Conqueror, Market Gnome, Warren Soultrader, and Nezumi Linkbreaker might be good fits.

Any thoughts on Pawn of Ulamog?

Trace of Samhaina

Legendary Creature- Elemental Avatar Dragon

Trample

Whenever a creature you control deals combat damage to a player, you may search your library for a basic land card and put it onto the battlefield tapped.

3/3

"Samhaina lives on in the forests, fecund and voracious."

Continue the cycle

Brineborn Cutthroat

Creature - Merfolk Wizard Assassin

Flash

When Brineborne Cutthroat enters the battlefield pit a flood counter on ttarget nonbasic land. That land is a basic island.

When you cast a spell during an opponent's turn, creatures you control gain Islandwalk until end of turn.

2/3

"Drowning is a local term for a Merfolk attack"

Repeat!

Hi all, I know Brenard replaces power and toughness when turning a creature into a token, so a / PT creature for example becomes a 1/1 but what about Tarmogoyf? Since it says plus is this ability still in effect?

Sapphire Fae

Enchantment

When this enchantment enters the battlefield, two target creatures gain flying until end of turn.

If you have drawn three or more cards during your turn, Sapphire Fae becomes a 2/2 Faerie creature with flying until end of turn.

"When will people learn a trinket is never just a trinket around here?"

A blue 5mv Enchantment uncommon it is then! Continue the rolling challenge or make another studio ghibli themed card.

Yubaba, Mistress of the Bathhouse

Legendary Creature - Spirit Warlock

Flying

Give a New Name - When another creature enters the battlefield under an opponent's control, you may exile it. If you do, that player creates a 2/2 white Worker creature token with "when this creature leaves the battlefield, it's controller draws a card.", Then, exile all other Worker creatures created by Yubaba, Mistress of the Bathhouse.

Whenever a creature an opponent controls is exiled, create a tapped treasure token.

3/4

Oooooo boy thank you for this prompt! I was instantly inspired to make Yubaba into a MTG card. She's such a unique character, I really enjoyed translating her role in the film into these two abilities, and figring out how to get them to interact. Most fun card I have created in a while.

Make another Studio Ghibli inspired card!