aholder7 Deckspert

Rakdos, just here to enjoy the show

Please login to comment

Said on Red voltron...

#1

I wouldn't really call this burn. It's closer to a voltron style deck. Have you considered Kiln Fiend?

May 17, 2017 8:26 p.m.

Said on 4 and 5 ......

#2

you have a decklist we can look at? there might be a few more niche cards that might work depending on what type of deck you are running. i mean as it stands right now i can't think of many 4 drops that are better than Phyrexian Obliterator. It would also be useful to know why you don't want that card. is it the price tag? if so i wouldn't suggest Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet even though that would probably be one of my first suggestions otherwise. is the reason the 4 black mana symbols? ie you are playing several utility lands like Ghost Quarter and etc that make it hard to get 4 black?

May 15, 2017 10:03 a.m.

Said on How much damage ......

#3

I think at 5 it would find a spot in a good number of lists, but 6 would cement it as an auto-include in every list.

I know some people have pointed out blood hand and firecraft but those aren't really played in more recent lists as far as i've seen mostly because cards like Atarka's Command are better at what they do. theres also cards like Boros Charm that just do 4 damage and are cheaper.

The other thing is that these cards did something else as well as do 4 damage. assuming this card only did damage i'd imagine it would have to more than 4 to make up for being worse than these cards.

May 11, 2017 3 a.m.

Said on Token Convoke...

#4

you have 58 cards and 5 Scatter the Seeds so the deck is currently illegal. that needs to be fixed first.

ill go down the list for your cards

starting with creatures

Elvish Mystic: this card is good at ramping you to high cost cards, however the only cards you have that are high cost, already have convoke so this card basically is a 1 mana 1/1 with no effect.

Essence Warden: pretty good card in a token based deck. theres also Soul Warden and Soul's Attendant if you want more of this effect.

Midnight Guard: i mean unless your abusing it's untap effect such as attempting to cast multiple convoke spells a turn, this card is pretty underwhelming. I don't think you will be casting multiple convoke spells per turn due to the fact that they are all so expensive.

Nest Invader: 2 mana 2/2 for 2 is considered a sort of standard/base. this card is that with a free 0/1 which can be sacced for mana. this is pretty good. One thing i will note is that you cannot tap the token for convoke and sac it for mana for a convoke spell. However that's not the end of the world.

Seraph of the Masses: this card is a hopefully going to be a big angel that you can get out relatively cheap. if you have 5 tokens and 5 mana this thing can come down as a 6/6 flyer by tapping 2 guys. that not a terrible deal. however i think it would be more effective to make all of your tokens bigger threats with cards like Intangible Virtue. 5 2/2s can be much scarier than a 6/6. one reason for this is because there are lots of options for cheap removal. Terminate, Path to Exile, Doom Blade etc. are all methods of getting rid of your 6/6 that are cheap and often played. these do not work as well when you have multiple threats.

Siege Wurm: See above.

Sunblade Elf: At first I did not like the card but i'm starting to like it more and more as I look at the rest of your list. I think this card is fine for now since its a 2 mana 2/2 most of early game and it can pump the team late game which is great since you will likely have a lot of tokens.

on to instants

Might of the Masses: this card is itself a good card for this deck but pump spells in general tend to be weaker than you'd expect. That's because of instant speed removal. people can cast Lightning Bolt in response to the spell to kill the creature you are targeting which means you will be getting 2 for 1'd as you lost a creature and a spell to their 1 spell. now that's not to say that this card is bad. I just wanted to make you aware that it's power is a bit more fragile than you might first expect. it is stronger in my opinion than Seraph of the Masses since it is so much cheaper and demands an answer from your opponent immediately instead of seraph which waits around for a turn before attacking and usually requires you to tap several of your creatures.

Raise the Alarm: this is a good card for any token deck. Gather the Townsfolk and Servo Exhibition are decent in their own right as well.

Scatter the Seeds: yeah you want 5 in your deck. sadly you cannot play 5 in your deck. its a token maker card that can put down more tokens to replace the ones you tapped. so you really don't even care if you had to tap 3 creatures to play this.

Sprout Swarm: this card is very powerful even if it seems week. you can pay for the "Buyback" cost with convoke. it's also an instant so you can do it at the end of your opponent's turn. so if you have a bit of mana and a few tokens, its not unreasonable to make 2 tokens at the end of your opponents turn for essentially free, then do it again every turn. for that reason i think you should have 4 of these.

lets do sorceries next

Launch the Fleet: this card is good and bad. its good because it can allow you to make several tokens at a 1 to 1 ratio which is pretty good. however this card has some downsides. its limited not only by the number of creatures you control but the number of creatures you are willing to attack with. you will often times want to hold back your stuff until you have enough tokens to get around most of their defenders or perhaps they have a few strong attackers on their side and you really want to have some defends held back. so this card won't always let you make any tokens regardless of how much mana you have. so this card is fickle and a bit unpredictable which is bad in a card. tl:dr its complicated and im not certain if you want it or not.

Nissa's Expedition: this card is good to help you get some mana out, however to pay for it you either need mana (and if you need to cast this we can assume you don't have that) or you need tokens, however if you need to cast this you probably don't have that many tokens, therefore you may need to tap all of your defender in order to cast this which leaves you wide open without giving you that great of a pay off.

Overwhelm: this card seems like a dream come true. a card that pumps all of you little guys and can be cast for cheaper with all your little guys. seems like the perfect combination right? the problem is that at 7 mana you NEED to tap several dudes to cast this, and for each token you tap to pay for this, that makes the spell that much worse since it's power comes from the number of attacking creatures you have. this card is a trap in my opinion.

Triplicate Spirits: Scatter the Seeds but with flying. see Scatter the Seeds for my opinion on this card.

enchantment time

Sigil of the Nayan Gods: this is basically Might of the Masses but sticks around longer. the problem is that this card is not an instant. masses could be cast after blockers were declared and you would be threatening to deal massive damage if your opponent didn't do something right then and there. this card has to be put on a creature before combat. now they just make sure to block it. it also suffers the same problem that masses did. your opponent can play a simple kill spell and all your set up is wasted. cycling is a nice addition but does not make up for the fragility of the card.

Spirit Bonds: this card sadly does not trigger when a token comes in, which means that it's useless for half the cards you play. you also have to pay mana to get more tokens. which means you have to pay a total of 4 mana for 2 tokens which is a lot worse than just playing Raise the Alarm.

maybe board

Hornet Queen: too expensive for what it does.

Whisperer of the Wilds: 2 mana Elvish Mystic that needs some set up to become a slightly cheaper Greenweaver Druid. i'd suggest passing on this one.

May 10, 2017 7:03 p.m.

Said on How to overcome ......

#5

Leyline of Sanctity is a great card for decks that play white.

there's also things like Loxodon Smiter and Wilt-Leaf Liege. (technically you could put this in any color but it does get a bit worse)

red has Ignorant Bliss but that's not super amazing. Guerrilla Tactics is a fun addition.

black can run discard to grab their discard. or maybe some madness cards. i don't exactly know what the best option is.

May 6, 2017 4:02 a.m.

Said on Who bids more? ......

#6

Hey I like the deck. Have you considered other choice cards such as Vexing Devil and Browbeat.

It's not explicitly bidding by your opponent is now gambling on what they think will be more damage. These cards or the other effects they have?

May 5, 2017 3:28 p.m.

Decks

enter here for life

Modern aholder7

SCORE: 5 | 5 COMMENTS | 815 VIEWS | IN 1 FOLDER

Good Bye Land

Modern aholder7

SCORE: 11 | 41 COMMENTS | 4483 VIEWS | IN 9 FOLDERS

Death at sorcery speed

Modern aholder7

SCORE: 1 | 4 COMMENTS | 345 VIEWS | IN 1 FOLDER

how do you keep rebuilding yourself?

Modern aholder7

SCORE: 4 | 2 COMMENTS | 436 VIEWS | IN 3 FOLDERS

here, gone, back and now on fire.

Standard aholder7

SCORE: 3 | 813 VIEWS | IN 3 FOLDERS

Legion of Steel

Modern* aholder7

SCORE: 1 | 409 VIEWS | IN 2 FOLDERS

Get Kede-Rekt

Modern aholder7

SCORE: 11 | 16 COMMENTS | 1144 VIEWS | IN 9 FOLDERS

Salt Sisters

Modern aholder7

SCORE: 96 | 160 COMMENTS | 10429 VIEWS | IN 66 FOLDERS

Finished Decks 30
Prototype Decks 5
Drafts 0
Playing since Magic 2013
Avg. deck rating 15.55
T/O Rank 642
Helper Rank None yet
Favorite formats Modern, Limited
Good Card Suggestions 40
Venues Jesters Gallery
Last activity 1 week
Joined 3 years