Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

lolofolo on Purphoros, Goblin Tribal

1 day ago

Infinites:

Kiki-Jiki and Zealous Conscripts (Infinite ETB) Grinning Ignus and Runaway Steam-Kin (Infinite ETB, Infinite Storm) Krenko Mob Boss, Skirk Prospector, Cloudstone Curio, and Goblin Chieftain/Goblin Warchief (Infinite ETB, Infinite Red Mana, Infinite Storm)

Sobrinho on Dryad of the Ilysian Grove …

1 day ago

If I have a Dryad of the Ilysian Grove in play, and after my first land drop, my opponent kill or exile her, I still have some how the extra land drop of her ability ?

Ender666666 on Small Update: New Formats, New …

1 day ago

Heya, it's just that it's a difference between 60 card and 100 card decks, so I'm not surprised no one uses it currently.

Commander_JAR on Chef Shimatsu's Famous "Blood Shimatsoup"

1 day ago

....what's the point of running Dragonstorm? Seriously, am I missing something? Or you just need some way to tutor for a treasure generator?

Femme_Fatale on Small Update: New Formats, New …

1 day ago

legendofa: I would actually like to remove Horde Magic entirely. No one uses it for its intended purpose and if it were a format it'd be hidden after a year.

Ender666666: I'll consider it but we've got exactly one deck for Brawl in the past 4 months so it isn't looking too popular.

As for all the hubs they should be there. If they are not then there are bugs.

BenTim on Goat Simulator - Ephara EDH

1 day ago

Am I dumb... or... like... where are the goats? I was promised goats...

Cozmosmash33 on #12 Crow Hogan: 2-2

1 day ago

MAIN STRATEGY: Get vehicles out early and often.

SUB STRATEGY: Turn all vehicles into creatures, swing for lethal.

Urkchar on Faldorn

1 day ago

Check this out: Savvy Trader

Urkchar on Ob Nixilis

1 day ago

Check this out: Volatile Fault

Also, consider Initiative

Urkchar on Anikthea

1 day ago

Check this out: Vessel of Nascency

Optimus_Prime_10 on Hazezon, Dune Altered Art Deck

1 day ago

You're a living God Emperor! Thanks for the effort 61 Billion times!!!! I shall show my table the Golden Path.

Formless0209 on FYNN-ISH HIM!!!

1 day ago

I know this is super late but... would any cards from newer sets be worth putting into this deck? Like Ankle Biter?

Formless0209 on Fynn, the Fangbearer

1 day ago

Kinda late but considering buying this... would Ankle Biter be worth putting in? What about other cards from newer sets?

austintayshus on My 3-headed baby girl

1 day ago

Thanks for the suggestions SaberTech! I like Trudge garden and Lathiel, i'll see if i can work them into the deck.

Profet93 on Eldrazi 2.0

1 day ago

Who is the commander?

LeMonado on Dawn of the First Day

1 day ago

EnderAsha I have all the artwork thoroughly backed up and I own it all in paper! Each artist is cited on the card (where possible, some have been lost to time).

If you want the files, add me on Discord (@lemonado) and I'll share them.

There are actually some pieces that aren't on here and I'm not at liberty to share. The literal best pieces of this art had to be procured on the condition that I do not share them online.

DreadKhan on Diabolic Revelation or Rune-Scarred Demon?

1 day ago

I have Diabolic Revelation in one deck atm, it's purpose in that deck is to generate card advantage, usually for the next turn. In that role I find the card quite satisfactory, and I wouldn't be as happy with a Rune-Scarred Demon because it doesn't generate card advantage the same way, and the body created probably wouldn't be impactful enough for the mana. I think if you have reanimation or flicker effects then the Demon will almost certainly play better. TBH I don't think either card is a 'good' card, but either can provide a high cost tutor effect (which is desirable in certain metas), one can provide significant card advantage while the other is stapled to a 6/6 flying body. If you ever find yourself wanting to cast Revelation where X < 3 I would cut it, Diabolic Tutor is actively clowned on, and Revelation is much worse Diabolic Tutor if X = 1. I think the nicest utility for the Demon is actually that you can use it as a blocker to hopefully last until your next turn (so you can win), casting Revelation will attract even more attention while providing no blockers.

IXALAN_Crazy on Small Update: New Formats, New …

1 day ago

Maybe also an Explorer hub would be good

Formless0209 on Magar the Horrible

1 day ago

Doesn't this kindof lack protection for Magar? Or is he normally less of a target compared to the creatures he is creating?

Godoyzera on Agatha Activations

1 day ago

Hey man! I have a Agtha deck too, and Im having trouble making the deck smooth. May I suggest Cascading Cataracts, so you can correct the mana color to activate abilities and Champion's Helm.

I'd also like to know if you think the amount of draw and ramp you are running is good enough in your opinion

zapyourtumor on B/R Deathtouch Destruction

1 day ago

Sudden Spoiling and Hero's Downfall are not playable modern cards, the removal has to be more efficient than that. Staple BR removal options would be 3-4 Lightning Bolt 2-4 Fatal Push 1-2 Molten Collapse 0-1 Angrath's Rampage. I'd also cut the Blightning.

Vampire of the Dire Moon kinda boring generic 1 drop. I assume Tinybones, the Pickpocket is way out of your budget, the cards not super great in here anyways.

Hooded Blightfang is honestly not the best card but I mean if you're playing deathtouch tribal then you should probably play it. Also interesting you chose BR because most deathtouch decks I see are BG and use Fynn, the Fangbearer. Green also gives you some better 1 drop deathtouchers like Gnarlwood Dryad and Narnam Renegade, and also a 2 drop Chevill, Bane of Monsters. Also 3 drop Glissa Sunslayer.

Zoyowa Lava-Tongue 2 drop deathtoucher. Nighthawk Scavenger 3 drop.

dillonja on DougY's Fblthp Cheerios

1 day ago

I have this in my Jank folder, though it's 100% entire possible that there's operator error in play

PhotogenicParasympathetic on Card creation challenge

1 day ago

A Show in Three Acts

Enchantment - Saga (rare)

Chapter 1 - You may sacrifice a creature. If you do, create a 1/1 Goblin with a Young Hero Role attached to it. Each opponent creates a 1/1 Goblin, then you attach a Wicked role to it.

Chapter 2 - You may sacrifice a creature that does not have a role attached to it. If you do, create three blood tokens.

Chapter 3 - Return each creature in your graveyard to the battlefield. Whenever a creature card sacrificed by this saga returns to the battlefield in this way, destroy target permanent an opponent controls.


Make a multicolored card using the Spree mechanic.

Rhadamanthus on Master of Cruelties and interactions

1 day ago

Yes, it still triggers. The declare blockers step of combat only gets skipped if there were no creatures declared as attackers or put onto the battlefield attacking. Otherwise, it always happens, even if it is impossible for any blockers to be declared. If Master of Cruelties is attacking then there will definitely be a declare blockers step and its last ability will trigger if it doesn't get blocked.

Samuel_Antao_Amazonas on Small Update: New Formats, New …

1 day ago

Attractions, Battles, Undercity, Stickers...

yeaGO on Skip Validiation/Adding cards that don't …

1 day ago

We would like to be more timely, what kinds of delays have you been seeing that you want this feature back?

xcontla on Master of Cruelties and interactions

1 day ago

I have some questions with this card in some specific times.

I understand that the ability triggers in the declare blockers step.

  1. If Master of Cruelties gains skulk, Does his ability still trigger? ("... opponent life becomes 1").
  2. If I equipped some artifact that made Master of Cruelties unblockable, Does his ability still trigger? ("... opponent life becomes 1").
  3. If the opponent doesn't have creatures in the battlefield, Does his ability still trigger? ("... opponent life becomes 1").

Thank you.

AurorasDawn on Jank Sheep Tokens

1 day ago

No suggestions since I'm not an expert on sheeps but imo, fun & unique casual decks like this are what MtG is all about.

SaberTech on My 3-headed baby girl

1 day ago

A card that I would recommend for a deck like this is Trudge Garden since the tokens it produces trigger the lifegain from your commander or other Soul Warden type creatures, giving you another potential activation. You could very quickly build up a large board state over a few turns.

Lathiel, the Bounteous Dawn might also be worth considering. Since its ability triggers at the end of opponents' turns too, having Soul Warden and other similar cards on the board means that Lathiel will also grow your creatures in response to all the creatures your opponents play. Lathiel combines really well with Spike Feeder to gain you increasing amounts of life at the end of each person's turn. I don't know if you are purposefully avoiding using infinite combos though, so it should be noted that Spike Feeder combos with Heliod, Sun-Crowned to gain you infinite life.

Wittyinator on Skip Validiation/Adding cards that don't …

1 day ago

Hi there,

As spoilers get released, I like to try and add cards to current deck lists in TappedOut that don't exist yet in TappedOut's database of cards. But I know, in the past, I used to be able to select the "Skip Validation" option to add the card regardless.

The card just appears as text and has no linkage to a card existing in whatever backend database is used. But it was a nice feature just to add cards that I know I want to add to a deck when it releases, and didn't want to forget about.

However, that functionality doesn't seem to work anymore? If I add a card that does not yet exist, and select the "Skip validation" option, it does not appear.

Just wondering if I'm doing something incorrectly, or if this could be a feature added to the deck building process?

Thanks

EnderAsha on Dawn of the First Day

1 day ago

I just came across this deck and I must say I'm absolutely blown away. I know it's a big ask but if someone wanted to print a recreation of this through mpc, is the artwork available for sharing? So much love went into this I wouldn't ever change anything just play it as is for the beautiful artwork. Thanks in advance!

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

1 day ago

Bomb Juggler

Creature - Goblin (Rare)

When Bomb Juggler enters the battlefield, flip three coins. For each heads put a bomb counter on it.

At the beginning of your upkeep, put a bomb counter on Bomb Juggler.

Whenever Bomb Juggler attacks, blocks or becomes the target of a spell or activated ability, sacrifice it. When you do, it deals X damage divided among any number of targets where X is the number of bomb counters on it.

2/2


It's a bait card. This lands on the battlefield and your opponent is forced to remove it quickly so it doesn't "GET OUT OF HAND" lolololll


So we all know of Rakdos as the truly sinister and evil cult of magic, but on Ravnica they are the entertainers.

Make another "entertainment" card from The Cult of Rakdos

Fux2209 on B/R Deathtouch Destruction

1 day ago

Thanks wallisface for your answer

I know, just 3 cards with 1 CMC isnt that good... I once had more creatures with 1 mana, but I needed these spots for Varragoth, Bloodsky Sire and Isareth the Awakener, cause they make me more stabel I guess...

Also I have 0 creatures that cost more than 3 mana, so with the 19 mana I have most of the time enough lands... Still I know thers some space for improvements... Next I will buy some double lands and things like that to be more consistent

that_dude33 on Small Update: New Formats, New …

1 day ago

Need a Gates hub!

AThiccNacho on A sliver of gold

1 day ago

Any particular reason Homing Sliver isn't there? Being able to slivercycle is quite nice. You can search for overlord, manaweft or even crib swap (it doesn't specify creature, only sliver CARD).

I think it homogenizes the gameplay a bit, but can be much needed if you're locked into a position with no immediate answers.

Dormant Sliver is also pretty nice but you won't be able to attack, but if you get gemhide/manaweft out, you can start populating the board while drawing cards, then sacrifice them with Basal Sliver, Cautery Sliver (not idea since it costs ) or Necrotic Sliver. Might not be ideal with morophon as your commander as it's easier to tutor with Overlord.

Overall, classic sliver deck!

chilln797 on Knight of the living dead …

1 day ago

-1 foulmire, +1 smitten swordsman -1 gray merchant, +1 skemfar shadowsage -1 phyrexian rager, +1 insatiable avarice

Ender666666 on Small Update: New Formats, New …

1 day ago

Could we differentiate Standard Brawl and Historic Brawl?

Rhadamanthus on Blitz of the Thunder-Raptor targeting …

2 days ago

Bblackboltt: An answer to your question has been up for a while. Since there don't seem to be any follow-ups or corrections that need to be made, I marked it as the "Accepted answer" so this topic can move out of the list of unanswered questions. In the future you can take care of this yourself using the "Mark as Answer" button on the response that you feel is the most helpful answer to your question.

Rhadamanthus on If a Enchantment with counters …

2 days ago

danielgonmar: You need to use double square brackets around the card's name to make the link work - Nine Lives, Resourceful Defense

To answer your question, since Resourceful Defense only moves counters between things you control, the same player has to control both Nine Lives and the Defense in order to use the Defense to move counters off of Nine Lives. If they're controlled by different players, which might be the situation in the original question where things are being moved around with Harmless Offering, then it won't work.

Also, it's much better to post a new question as its own topic rather than respond to a very old one. With the way this site works, adding a new post to a Rules Q&A discussion doesn't move the topic to the top of the list. This topic is about 4 years old, so the only reason I was aware of your comment is because the site auto-subscribed me for notifications on this topic after I originally posted in it. If you had happened to post in a topic where the only people involved in the discussion were no longer active users then no one would have seen your question.

itsbuzzi on Break out

2 days ago

I'm long off Jeggy, I feel like he doesn't help as much as the 15th SB slot. The restriction doesn't come into play very often but when it does I just drop Jeggy all together.