Perhaps this thread can be closed, as to prevent further discussion on the matter? Because someone might not read your reply, Caerwyn and move to reply to StopShot - not out of violation of terms and policy, but just to be nice and friendly.

Closing the thread would prevent that accident from occuring.

Obsidian Titan

Creature - Giant

Whenever Obsidian Titan attacks, Put a blaze counter on target land without a blaze counter on it. For as long as that land has a blaze counter on it, it has "At the beginning of your upkeep, this land deals 1 damage to you." (The land continues to burn after Obsidian Titan has left the battlefield.)

3/4

I was given some positive feedback for my Goldfang, Voracious Conscriptor card the other day, (#22 of this page)

So your challenge is to make a simple commander who is built around a very specific archetype. In my case, it was Orzhov Death & Taxes

So my understanding is this:

An Elemental is a "living" creature, naturally made from the world around it such as fire, sand, wind, water, plant matter, carrion, etc. Its when (in our case) the Leylines breathe life into substance and form beings capable of thought and independence. These would NOT be considered "Artifact Creatures".

A Construct is wholly artificial, made with deep and rich magics and technology, usually made out of metal and stone. They can be truly autonomous or designed for specific commands and functions. These would be considered "Artifact Creatures"

Meanwhile a Golem is a religious craft, typically made out of clay or otherwise softer stone. It is usually created to guard areas, and responds directly toward its master. It will protect its area from anything it is told to consider a threat, making them prime guardians that can last for centuries. These COULD BE considered "Artifact Creatures", depending on their composition and more importantly HOW they were made; E.G. religious magics, or technology.

Ancient Golem

Creature - Golem

First strike, defender

As you cast Ancient Golem, you may pay up to less to cast it. If you do, it gains Suspend X where X is the amount of mana you reduced its casting cost by.

Ancient Golem enters the battlefield with X +1/+1 counters where X is the number of turns it was Suspended.

3/3

In other words, you could cast it for just and it would gain Suspend 5, then enter with five +1/+1 counters making it an 8/8, which would be ideal for longer games such as Draft, Two Headed Giant and Commander.

How about this; Let's see a Planeswalker with four loyalty abilities, focused around making different Elementals.

While we are on the topic, the Siege counters symbol  ^Flip could also be added.

So this will be a nice couple from Theros and Kaldheim.

Enchanting Storyteller

Creature - Human Cleric

Partners with Battle Singer (When this creature enters the battlefield, target player may put Battle Singer into their hand from their library, then shuffle.)

When Enchanting Storyteller enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a Saga. If you do, reveal it and put it into your hand, then shuffle.

1/2

Battle Singer

Creature - Human Bard Warrior

Partners with Enchanting Storyteller (When this creature enters the battlefield, target player may put Battle Singer into their hand from their library, then shuffle.)

, : You may put a lore counter on target Saga you control. If you do, activate it's next ability.

3/2

This would be a lovely pairing for Battlebond.

Make a Goat Hydra.

Brennan Lee Mulligan

Legendary Creature - Human Advisor Wizard

Vigilance, haste (Because he is extremely fast with his quips and very hard to catch off guard)

Whenever you scry, surveil or fateseal, the number of cards you look at is increased by 1.

, , choose one: Scry 3, Surveil 3 or Fateseal 3.

"The rise and fall of the Merovingian Dynasty and then behind that is like a cardboard book that says what noise a fox makes."

2/3

Lmao

Wild

Sakaizokan, Ravenous Colony

Legendary Creature - Insect Wall

Defender

When Sakaizokan enters the battlefield, create X 1/1 red insect creature tokens named Fire Ant. They have ": This creature deals 1 damage to any target."

Whenever you are attacked, Sakaizokan deals X damage divided as you choose among attacking creatures equal to the number of insects you control.

6/6

Dragonlair Spider, Hornet Queen, Hornet Nest, Ant Queen, Beacon of Creation, Carrion, Grist, the Hunger Tide, Amzu, Swarm's Hunger, Izoni, Thousand-Eyed, Living Hive, Broodhatch Nantuko, Nest of Scarabs, Xira, the Golden Sting

I mean are you kidding me? And this isn't even all of them, and not even all of the best ones in these colors. Not to mention all of the all of the black punishment effects, all of the red ETB damage effects or all of the green propagation effects.

Your challenge is to make another interesting Commander, and showcase several cards that would be in their deck starting precon deck.

Remember this is a precon deck, so cards should largely be between $1 and $3 each, with maybe two or three $10 max cards.

And if you look, yes I did adhere to my own rule with Beacon of Creation, Grist, the Hunger Tide and Amzu, Swarm's Hunger being the expensive ones in the list.

Range Rover

Creature - Plant Ranger (Rare)

Desertwalk

When Range Rover enters the battlefield, distribute a total number of +1/+1 and / or -1/-1 counters equal to the number of deserts in play among all creatures.

3/3

So if you control 5 Deserts and your opponent has 2 Deserts you could distribute up to seven +1/+1 or seven -1/-1 counters as you see fit, or any mix in-between such as three +1/+1 and four -1/-1

So you know how in Modern Horizons 3 we are returning to the realm of flipwalkers? Legendary creatures who transform back into Planeswalkers?

Make one for Nahiri.

SAM SPINES

I LOVE IT HAHA

Peer into the Void

Legendary Enchantment

Whenever you Cascade for the first time each turn, you may instead cast a card that that costs up to mana more.

I sat, looking into the void, the void looked back. Suddenly, I heard a familiar voice. “Don't go back to sleep."

Quote is from Here. It isn't my cup of tea in terms of writing or story telling, but it had a nice quote I could borrow from for the purposes of the card.

So by making it cost MV7, it triggers Zhulodok, Void Gorger.

Basically what this means is, if you cast an Ulamog's Crusher, instead of being able to Cascade into something MV 7 or less, you could cast another MV 8, or even an MV 9 card such as Void Winnower.

The catch is that this only works on the first instance of Cascade each turn.

So now that Outlaws of Thunder Junction have introduced us to the whimsy of Cactusfolk, make their first Planeswalker.

Changed his name;

Honestly I am not a big fan of this AI artwork, but I love how he's got Orzhova armor and is before a citadel so I'll take it.

markbeloit your first ability actually has a name :) it's called Fateseal n

Goldtooth, Voracious Conscriptor

Legendary Creature - Dragon Advisor

Flying

Whenever an opponent casts a spell, you create a treasure tokens unless they pay or 3 life.

"There are only two certainties in life; Death and Taxes." - Goldtooth

4/4

Okay, so Orzhov is definitely NOT known for its Dragons. Which, now that I think of it, seems like a glaring oversight? I mean Dragons hoard wealth? Sooo...??

Anyway, your challenge is to take another guild and make a legendary creature that the guild is definitely not known for housing or supporting.

For example, you could do a Simic Zombie or a Rakdos Angel.

Garmand the Assimilator

Legendary Creature - Demon Zombie Shaman

Flying

Zombies you control get +1/+1

Whenever another nontoken creature dies, its controller may exile it. If they don't, return it to the battlefield under a random players control. It becomes a black Zombie in addition to its other types.

5/5

So you could wrath the field, exile everything you control, gain a bunch of goodies, wrath it again, exile everything you control, gain a bunch of goodies, wrath it again, exile everything you control, gain a bunch of goodies... Lol

Great challenge, so let's repeat!!

Munitions

Token Artifact - Munitions

, , sacrifice this artifact: Munitions deals X damage to any target.

Thoughts?

Masterball

Legendary Artifact

, , sacrifice Masterball: Gain control of target nonhuman creature.

Lol again

griffstick, may I ask why you tagged those two cards?

Sacrificial Lamb

Sorcery

As an additional cost to cast this spell, sacrifice a legendary creature.

Draw two cards.

Would be great in Commander if you can nab someone else's such as with an Act of Treason or if someone enchants your creature with like a Darksteel Mutation or something

Wild

Wrenn and Eight

Legendary Planeswalker - Wrenn

Retrace (You may cast this card from your graveyard by discarding a land in addition to paying its mana cost.)

If you cast Wrenn and Eight from your graveyard, it enters the battlefield with two additional loyalty counters.

-1 Each player sacrifices a land

-3 Destroy up to one target artifact, battle, creature, land, enchantment, Planeswalker and token you don't control.

-5 Sacrifice any number of lands you control. Destroy up to that many target permanents. They can't be regenerated.

4

Okay so you know how we have cards such as Daryl, Hunter of Walkers and then their non-universes beyond versions like Hansk, Slayer Zealot?

Your challenge is both super simple and incredibly difficult.

Take a character from any work of fiction you like, find a legendary creature who could reasonably be that card and swap its name only.

In other words, turn an existing MTG legend into a Universes Beyond counterpart.

Liliana, Corpse Bride

Legendary Planeswalker - Liliana

Dredge 6

+1 Search your library for a card, put that card into your graveyard, then shuffle your library.

-4 Create a tapped 2/2 black Zombie creature token for each instant and sorcery card in your graveyard.

-8 Create thirteen tapped 2/2 black Zombie creature tokens.

4

Following this design, create another Planeswalker where all of their abilities are just instant / sorcery spells. Don't forget to tag the instant or sorcery.

If you want to make an emblem for something such as Doubling Season you can, as their ultimate. The rest of their abilities must be instant or sorceries though.

(Speaking of which, yes I modified her so that she works in tandem with Doubling Season for some pure Golgari hate lol)