Pick Your Poison

Sorcery

Choose one —

• Each opponent sacrifices an artifact.
• Each opponent sacrifices an enchantment.
• Each opponent sacrifices a creature with flying.

Legality

Format	Legality
1v1 Commander	Legal
Alchemy	Legal
Arena	Legal
Block Constructed	Legal
Canadian Highlander	Legal
Casual	Legal
Commander / EDH	Legal
Commander: Rule 0	Legal
Custom	Legal
Duel Commander	Legal
Gladiator	Legal
Highlander	Legal
Historic	Legal
Historic Brawl	Legal
Legacy	Legal
Leviathan	Legal
Limited	Legal
Modern	Legal
Modern Beyond Horizons	Legal
Oathbreaker	Legal
Pauper	Legal
Pauper EDH	Legal
Pioneer	Legal
Planar Constructed	Legal
Pre-release	Legal
Standard	Legal
Standard Brawl	Legal
Tiny Leaders	Legal
Vintage	Legal

Discussion (18)

Femme_Fatale on JohnTDixon

2 months ago

All the playtest cards have (playtest) after their name because of WotC reusing these card names. Tax Taker (Playtest). You can blame MKM for this. Pick Your Poison Pick Your Poison (Playtest).

Femme_Fatale on MindBoogaloo

2 months ago

Blame MKM for Red Herring/Red Herring (Playtest) and Pick Your Poison/Pick Your Poison (Playtest).

I'll double check the synonyms on these on a later date so you won't have to add the playtest to them.

MadPilot on Oh, Rotty!

4 months ago

Pick Your Poison against Serra's Emissary

wallisface on How to deal with [[The One Ring]]

4 months ago

Collective Brutality can’t hit One Ring (i know it’s not on your list but you did mention it above).

In a lot of matchups Pick Your Poison is a viable option.

You might want a category for denying the fog effect. Stuff like Bonecrusher Giant has been seeing some play in decks that just want to push for damage.

I know you don’t want counterspells added, but its probably worth at least mentioning Consign to Memory as that card is being included in sooo many sideboards (and in pretty high quantities), and has become one of the default best answers.

Murrow on The Brood x Blade (Combo Core)

8 months ago

capwner

The One Ring is solid I just can't borrow against my mortgage again lmao. Otherwise I'd likely include it in more builds.

And yes! Boseiju would actually be smart. Each time I rebuild this deck I usually have at least a copy and totally brain farted. Thanks!

Also yes caverns feels really essential. And Pick Your Poison looks solid! Thanks for that suggest!

capwner on The Brood x Blade (Combo Core)

8 months ago

How about The One Ring as gas you can run in mono green?

Also a big fan of Boseiju and sideboard Pick Your Poison right now. Since you're mono green why not run 4 Boseiju mainboard, just to give a bit of play against Nadu, Necro, and Ruby?

I'd also say keep the Caverns since control is such a big part of the meta rn...

capwner on Viga-BOOM! (Primer + SB Guide)

8 months ago

How good are the Shifting Woodlands? Couldn't find much about them in your description, delirium seems a little unreliable, I'm guessing you have them sb to bring in against matchups that can reliably remove the titans? Also interested to hear your thoughts on matchups/general position of titan in the post-MH3 meta? Why do you think it dropped off so hard, does it just lose to Nadu/Necro/Ruby? Seems like you have a lot of play vs those decks with Boseiju. Pick Your Poison also seems really strong rn, killing Nadu with no trig, killing Ruby, Necro, Murktide, and The Ring as well (though instant speed better vs necro).

Taida on golgari something or another

11 months ago

The idea of the deck looks good, but it is torn between landfall and zombies, I would recommend going for either one, but maybe not both. For zombies I cannot help you, I barely play with them, but if you want, there is a fun combo using Putrid Goblin and Thran Vigil, then killing the goblin. This will make it come back without the -1/-1 counter from persist, so if you have a sac outlet, you have basically infinite etb effects (and any other bonus the sac outlet gets you). You could also use some Deadly Dispute, drawing you cards and getting the Gravecrawler on the graveyard.

For landfall, get some fetchlands. They double the number of triggers.

Also, you might need some interaction. I do not think Pick Your Poison is enough, and getting some instant speed removal might be nice