Disgraceful_Duckling Deckling

My name is Ducky or Charlotte. I dislike competitive MTG and I really like the level of casual MTG that's like, right below tournament play. I like optimizing really stupid nonsense.

I hate people who play blue. Mono-blue and blue-red are for bad people tbh. Blue-white and blue-green are usually fine, blue-black is iffy. Once you get into 3 colors I don't care what you do.

I'm broke af so I don't have a lot of decks/fancy cards. This Deck Has Had 3 Commanders still has weird proxies in it after 3.5 years of making it halfway decent.

I mainly play EDH, but whenever someone wants to play 60-card I have Sun Titan Shenanigans and one day I will get off my ass and actually build What does the Didgeridoo?.

For EDH I've got Iroas and my bad Daxos deck.

At some point if I ever have money I'm going to build all of the decks on here. It's gonna be a hot minute tho.

Please login to comment

Said on 5 Generals...

#1

PlutoniumWedding Thromok the Insatiable and Omnath are both technically valid. I don't have Thromok as a general because its effect is more conditional than the other 5, and I don't have Omnath as a general because the deck is not competitively tuned enough to deal with the massive hate it would draw every game. Plus I'd need more ramp in order to get him out as fast as the others, and that would require cutting important cards.

Solemn Simulacrum is in the deck. The others are cool tho. I hadn't considered Farhaven Elf because it's so overcosted for the stats, but that was before I really knew the themes of the deck so I should have taken another look at that.The addition of Conjurer's Closet and/or Boundless Realms are scary because they're non-creatures, but they are obviously powerful. I'll see about swapping those in. And Valakut is definitely worth putting in.

Sylvan Scrying does offer the benefit of having a land in my hand to drop when I have synergy/ensuring that I'll hit my land drops for another turn, but I don't know how I feel about an instant that doesn't have an inherent impact on the board and doesn't even cycle.

Thanks so much for the suggestions!

April 26, 2017 12:41 a.m.

Darksteel Ingot seems too slow and Fellwar Stone is going to produce colorless for you pretty often, since blue and green are pretty popular colors. Both are comparable to Mardu Banner. Also consider Chromatic Lantern, I consider it mandatory in 3+ color decks and most would agree that it's good.

Since the deck has Kaalia of the Vast and Master of Cruelties, not having Whispersilk Cloak or something similar (maybe Rogue's Passage?) seems like a mistake.

Swiftfoot Boots is another way to give Kaalia haste. Blade of Selves would be pretty bonkers in a deck with Kaalia, ntm the ETB effects on a lot of creatures. Strionic Resonator is another way to copy triggered abilities like Kaalia's.

If budget really isn't a concern, Damnation is another Wrath of God that you can cast in other colors.

Also, I think I've seen another Kaalia deck on here with this title.

April 25, 2017 5:39 p.m.

Said on 5 Generals...

#3

Lutachris23 lmao does he say another? I haven't looked at the card since I pulled him at prerelease and was just kinda remembering. I honestly like it better in general and for the deck that he can't buff himself.

Personally i love skullmulcher, but there are reasons besides preference to run it over those three: in the case of harmonize and elemental bond, it's a creature, which makes it a target for xenagod, and makes ruric-thar not punish me for playing it. in the case of regal force, it's 2cmc less and specifically only 1 green symbol, making it more accessible if I'm having a hard time with mana.

thanks for the suggestions, correction, and the upvote!

April 19, 2017 2:30 p.m.

Friends

Jagged_Ice

Followers

zcstover1Reon

Decks

Sun Titan Shenanigans

Legacy* Disgraceful_Duckling

SCORE: 3 | 10 COMMENTS | 894 VIEWS

This Deck Has Had 3 Commanders

Commander / EDH Disgraceful_Duckling

SCORE: 5 | 3 COMMENTS | 955 VIEWS | IN 1 FOLDER

EDH - Excitedly Destroying Helms

Commander / EDH Disgraceful_Duckling

SCORE: 1 | 160 VIEWS | IN 1 FOLDER

The Wall

Commander / EDH Disgraceful_Duckling

SCORE: 2 | 235 VIEWS

5 Generals

Commander / EDH* Disgraceful_Duckling

SCORE: 8 | 4 COMMENTS | 612 VIEWS | IN 2 FOLDERS

Finished Decks 10
Prototype Decks 3
Drafts 0
Playing since Theros
Points 70
Avg. deck rating 3.80
T/O Rank 3124
Helper Rank 384
Favorite formats Commander / EDH, Casual
Good Card Suggestions 23
Last activity 1 hour
Joined 3 years