few questions

Asked by Enditoren 9 years ago

1.can i exile a token that died with Scavenging Ooze ?tokens go to the graveyard and then they get exiled, but can i response?

2.can i enchant a god if i only have 4 devotion, but with the enchantment entering the battlefield i got my 5. one and the god is a creature(example: i got a Boros Reckoner and a Purphoros, God of the Forge . can i enchant purphoros with a Madcap Skills ?

3. if i have a Darkest Hour and all creatures are black, are they mono black or are they black in addition to its other colors?

4.if i have 2 Prophet of Kruphix on the battlefield and the trigger resolves of one of them to untap all my things, can i response to the other one and tapp everything to untap it again with the second one?

thx :)

Absinthman says... Accepted answer #1

  1. No. Tokens that leave the battlefield are not exiled, they cease to exist as a state based action. This is performed before anybody gets priority, and can't be responded to.

  2. No. When you cast the aura, you must choose a target for it. That target must be legal at the time of casting (so it must be a creature prior to casting the aura.

  3. Only black. If they were black in addition to their other colors, the card would have said so (see Painter's Servant ).

  4. It doesn't work, because Prophet of Kruphix 's ability is not a triggered one. It's a static ability which modifies the rules for your opponent's untap steps. You can also see the ruling on the Gatherer which says: 9/15/2013: Controlling more than one Prophet of Kruphix doesnt allow you to untap any creature or land more than once during a single untap step.
July 8, 2014 9:31 a.m.

Epochalyptik says... #2

Please ask questions separately. Don't create a compilation post.

1) First, tokens don't get exiled from the graveyard. When a token exists in a zone other than the battlefield, it ceases to exist as a state-based action. This is not the same as exile. State-based actions are performed before you receive priority to activate any abilities. Furthermore, Scavenging Ooze 's ability targets cards. Tokens are not cards.

2) No. Aura spells require a target while on the stack. They are the only permanent spells with targets. At the time you choose the target for the Aura, it is not yet on the battlefield; it's on the stack. You can't look forward into the game to see that the Aura would give you sufficient devotion after resolution; you need to choose a target that is legal at the time.

3) Whenever an effect says " is [color]," the specified object or objects become only that color. The effect would need to say " is [color] in addition to its other colors" in order for the specified object or objects to have multiple colors.

4) Prophet of Kruphix doesn't have any triggered abilities. It has a static ability that causes you to untap your permanents during each other player's untap step. You can't respond to anything.

July 8, 2014 9:32 a.m.

Gidgetimer says... #3

.

  1. No, if a token is any any zone except the battlefield it immediately ceases to exist. It isn't exiled, i just ceases to exist. and no player gets priority between it going to the graveyard and ceasing to exist.

  2. No, Auras have to target when they are cast. And when the aura is on the stack the god wouldn't be a creature.

  3. Monoblack

  4. Prophet of Kruphix has no triggered abilities. It has 2 static abilities that change the rules of the game. Multiple instances of "Untap all creatures and lands you control during each other player's untap step." are redundant.

July 8, 2014 9:33 a.m.

This discussion has been closed