can i Redirect One with Nothing?
Asked by Sismir 6 years ago
as the title ask i wonder if i can use Redirect on spells that say "you/your" or am I not a "target"?
Gidgetimer says... #2
Spells do not target uness they specifically use the word "target". Therefore you can not Redirect a spell like this. If another player were to gain control of the spell "you" would refer to them, but though you can Commandeer a spell, there is no Donate for spells so detrimental spells are not likely to be put under another player's control.
Neotrup says... Accepted answer #1
What you can do is cast One with Nothing and in response cast Redirect targeting One with Nothing. When Redirect resolves you will get to rechoose targets for One with Nothing, though it has no targets so that will be rather pointless. Then when One with Nothing resolves you will discard your hand. In short, you technically can, but it won't give you the result you want.
September 29, 2017 12:50 a.m.